2nd June 1928, Page: 359, Column: 1
Canadian Fuel Policy
Canada has a fuel problem and many of her citizens have a fuel policy. It may
not be complete in its present state, but that does not deter them from
discussing it. Another paper as evidenced in the bulletin has recently been
submitted at the Quebec meeting of the Canadian Institute of Mining and
Metallurgy, by the Deputy (Nova Scotia) of Public Works and Mines, Norman McKenzie,
on the subject "A National Fuel Policy for Canada." He
indicates that there has been a slowly growing consciousness that the nation
should take some steps to "increase the consumption of its own fuel
throughout the great length and narrow breadth of its settled country."
The anomaly of the occurrence of coal in Canada is that the centre of the
country, which is its most populous section, is without any coal seams. Nor are
any large deposits found in going westward until the Rocky Mountains are almost
reached. Eastward the surf of the Atlantic is almost stepped into before coal
is found. Canada unquestionably has enormous deposits of coal, but as stated in
regions lying at great distances from the centres of densest population. The
middle of Canada is largely supplied from coalfields which lie not far south in
the United States, and struggle as they may, the eastern and western operators
in Canada cannot overcome the tremendous difficulties of cheap production and
expensive transportation to enable them to penetrate very far into the central
market. What must be done to enable Canadians to exploit to the full their own
great coal resources and thus add an enormous amount to their national income,
is now being asked by people, their motive being to use and develop the natural
wealth in their own country. Mr. McKenzie says the problem is national,
not sectional, and he hopes for such an extension of the use of their own fuel
as will stabilise their present provisions for production and increase the
consumption of their own coal by fifty per cent.
Looking at the problem as it concerns Nova Scotia, Mr. McKenzie says
this area in a few years will contain the most extensive submarine workings in
the world. The mines are all gaseous, and the most elaborate provisions must be
made against the hazard of explosions of gas or dust. Some of the mines have
workings below 1,200 feet, and there are the burdens of maintenance under these
conditions in haulage, pumping, ventilation, support and other services. Under
these drawbacks it is frankly admitted that cheap coal could not be expected at
the pit mouth, compared with the favoured mines in the United States which
enter the deposit by a tunnel, win all their coal to the rise, find no gas to
contend with and have no problem of auxiliary haulage and pumping. The
advantage that is enjoyed by Nova Scotia, however, is that the mines are for
the most part located at tidewater. The St. Lawrence river reaching towards the
middle of the continent furnishes an opportunity to transport the coal in large
vessels as far as Montreal, and thus Nova Scotia coal may be carried a thousand
miles on water as cheaply per ton as the Ohio or Indiana coal may be moved by
rail from the mine to the State border. Unfortunately the river freezes up
during the period when the demand for coal is greatest, but Mr. McKenzie
says that if the dealers and industries in central Canada were willing to stack
coal in the autumn against winter requirements, they could do so with perfect
safety and provide a wider production of Nova Scotia coal. He is unwilling in a
general way to concede that this coal is not of as good quality as the soft
coal from the States.
A point made by Mr. McKenzie is that there is very little flexible
market, as in farming, nor any floating population of workers. Almost all of
the miners are native born or immigrants from Great Britain. They are of a
specially high order of ability and intelligence, as is required of men who
work under the difficult conditions that obtain. Men who have not worked
underground cannot be trained for this occupation in a short time, and skilled
coal miners are not well adapted for other vocations. The Nova Scotian fields
are far distant from any other like area, and there is practically no migration
to and from the mines. This means that if the market for the coal could be
increased fifty per cent. and the production spread more equally throughout the
year, Nova Scotia would be relieved from one of its chief economic disabilities
as a part of the Dominion. This is the national aspect of the problem as Mr.
McKenzie sees it, and the remedies which he believes could primarily help
the industry in Nova Scotia, and consequently the rest of Canada, would involve
a rearrangement of duties on United States coal, also the renewal of Federal
subvention to assist in the movement by railway of Canadian coal, together with
Dominion grants to aid in the establishment of plants to produce coke from
Canadian coals.
The Author says that if a national policy were developed to increase production
by 50 per cent. and stabilise operations so that a fair measure of winter
employment were assured, there is no doubt that lower mining costs would be
secured and the use of the coal would be pushed much further westward. He is
not in favour of measures that would cause the people in a certain area that
will long continue to use coal from the States to pay more for that coal than
necessary, in order that another area, in which coal is produced, could enjoy
prosperity at their expense. He believes a national policy should employ
national revenues, so that those provinces which are economically handicapped
in exploiting the natural resources should be placed in such a fair condition
as will increase the prosperity of the nation as a whole.
Mr. McKenzie concludes his paper in the following terms :
"We are moving out of an era of mental conceptions of economics in which
we were limited by bugaboos of high wages, overproduction, financial cycles,
etc. We know that high wages are not a necessary attendant factor in high costs
; in fact the reverse has been proved true under ideal conditions. We know that
it is not a desirable thing in a nation to have unemployment, or a section of
the people with low standards of living. If some people are not producers they
cannot be consumers. If they do not earn money they cannot buy. Just how these
factors interact or how far production, leisure, and desires for acquisition,
may be developed and satisfied, we do not yet know. We are sure that, in order
to develop its natural resources in and for the best interests of the nation as
a whole, a nation should in some cases undertake policies that may not seem to
be justified on the basis of strict economy. We are confident that the whole
Dominion cannot prosper as a nation if some of its natural industries and some
of its provinces are suffering while most of the others prosper. It is on this
basis that I make my strongest plea for your consideration and helpful action.
Nothing truer or more helpful has ever been written than the Apostle Paul has
written in First Corinthians. May I commend Chapter XII. to you, if you have
not read it recently ? May I close by quoting three verses :
'And the eye cannot say unto the hand, I have no need of thee ; nor again the
head to the feet, I have no need of you.
'That there should be no schism in the body, but that the members should have
the same care one for another.
'And whenever one member suffer, all the members suffer with it, or one member
be honoured, all the members rejoice with it.'"
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| McKenzie, Norman | | | |