|
19th May 1928, Page: 340, Column: 1 Conversion From Steam To Electricity*By L. H. Forster, Assoc.I.M.E. Main pumping is a very important operation in the working of any colliery, and at Clara Vale Colliery two shafts, each 14 feet diameter finished, are sunk to the Brockwell Seam, at a depth of 398 feet and passing through the Three Quarter Seam at 327 feet depth. The main or downcast shaft is used solely for coal drawing, whilst the pumping or upcast shaft contains the whole of the plant, such as water delivery pipes, steam range, electrical cables, etc. It is also fitted for drawing coals, its capacity for this being much increased since the conversion from steam to electrical pumping. The seams dip southward from the shaft at an inclination of 1½ inches per yard into a synclinal trough, the axis of which runs east and west. The lowest point reached is approximately 30 feet below the shaft inset after which the seams rise southward. This geological feature tends to simplify the drainage of the area worked by these pits, as an underlevel drift originally driven in connection with the old steam plant connects the Five Quarter Seam with the Three Quarter Seam, which is 30 feet vertically below in the shaft, and at which level the old and new plants could obtain the bulk of their water. In the year 1892 a Hathorn Davy compound differential beam pump (at that time the last word in pumping) was installed to deal with the water feeders from the Three Quarter Seam level at a depth of 327 feet. At a later period, when the sinking was continued to the Brockwell Seam, a tail bucket set was installed and worked from the existing spears to deal with the feeders from the sump below the Brockwell Seam to the Three Quarter level, a depth of about 96 feet, the bucket being 18" diameter and 10' stroke. Certain difficulties were experienced with this method due to the feeders at the Brockwell level not being sufficient to keep the main spears in constant operation, with the result that quantities of water had to be returned from the Three Quarter level to the sump of the tail set. Ultimately this tail set was abandoned and a separate steam unit was installed to deal with this small feeder. In the year 1895, a standby pump to the above was installed at the Three Quarter level inset. This unit was considered solely as a standby unit, and was only used in case of emergency or when the beam pump needed overhauling and the necessary time taken for packing of rams, etc., therefore, a condensing unit was considered unnecessary. Electrification. — Due to natural progress and changes the electrification of the colliery as a whole began to take shape during the early part of the year 1920, and after careful consideration it was considered that the change over from steam pumping to electrical pumping must be the first question to tackle. This question demanded careful thought in selecting the level at which the pumps should be placed, whether at the Three Quarter level or the Brockwell, which is approximately 96 feet below. In the first place, whether the position selected was at the Three Quarter or Brockwell level, a complete new engine room was necessary. The result of calculations, together with the fact that if any sudden inrush of water took place above the capacity of the pumps the lower level could be "drowned out," decided the question that the Three Quarter level must be the main pumping level together with the main electrical power distribution point. Ram Versus Turbine Pumps. — There was no difficulty in deciding the type of pumps to be installed, because even eight years ago ram pumps to deal with the large feeders at the Three Quarter level were out of the question compared with turbine pumps. Owing to the limited standage and the seasonal changes in the feeders which varied between the extremes of 1,800 and 1,200 gallons per minute during the year, it was necessary to consider very carefully the question of the size and number of units to be installed. During the life of the steam plant this question was one of no concern, as under normal conditions the pump rams could be regulated to suit the incoming feeders, and it was not until any stoppage occurred that a standage of any size was thought to be worth the expense. However, with turbine pumps the regulation of the output to suit the incoming feeders is not an economical procedure, although this can be done by closing the delivery valve, thus creating an artificial head. The operating efficiency of a turbine pump will vary considerably with the speed, the quantity and the head under which the pump is working. As the provision of extensive standage was not practicable it was decided to adopt the following arrangement of three units of pumping No. 1 Pump. — Three-stage turbine pump made by Messrs. E. N. Mackley and Company, capable of delivering 1,300 gallons of water per minute against a manometric head of 368 feet, running at 1,170 r.p.m., suction 12' diameter, delivery 10" diameter, driven by a 220 h.p. 3-phase 2,750-volt A.C., 40 cycle, totally enclosed motor of the slip-ring type through a flexible coupling of the pin type with leather washers. The end thrust is hydraulically balanced by means of a balance piston, an easy method of adjusting this piston until the wear is sufficient to warrant machining. All bearings are of the self-lubricating type with split rings; by removing the end-covers of each pump the whole interior can be withdrawn or inspected without interfering with either suction or delivery pipes. No. 2 Pump. — This is an exact duplicate of No. 1 Pump in all detail and accessories, and one is considered a standby to the other. In normal working both pumps are left to the discretion of the pumpman to choose which he should run, on condition that each, as far as possible, gets an equal share of the work. No. 3 Pump. — Five-stage turbine pump by Messrs. E. N. Mackley and Co., delivering 500 gallons of water per minute against a manometric head of 368 feet, running at 1,170 r.p.m., suction 8" diameter, delivery 7" diameter, driven by an 80 H.P., 3-phase, 2,750 volt, A.C. 40 cycle, totally enclosed motor of the slip-ring type, through a flexible coupling of the pin type with leather washers. This pump was intended as a sort of helper up to overcome the great disadvantage of a small standage. During parts of the pumping time it was anticipated that the incoming feeders would be in excess of the capacity of either Nos. 1 or 2 units, and to deal with this extra water it was intended to run this unit, say for a few hours at a time, so as to maintain the water in the sump at a more constant level. This arrangement has worked exactly as intended it should do during the last five years. In fact, this unit has become as essential to the working of the colliery as any other unit. As to why three-stage pumps were selected for the 1,300-gallon units and a five-stage pump for the 500-gallon unit, although all three pumps have to deal with the same head, on several occasions I have been asked this question by visitors. In the first place this selection is not made by the user, but is decided upon by the maker for the following brief reasons: If the head against which a centrifugal pump has to work is such that the speed is excessive, or the quantity is so small compared with the head that the width of the passages is too small to obtain a reasonable efficiency, then two or more impellers must be used working in series. In order to obtain high efficiency the width of the impeller at the outlet must never be less than 01 time the radius of the tip of the impeller. In the design of centrifugal pumps, one formula states that the width of the impeller required at the outlet varies directly as the quantity and inversely as the peripheral velocity of the fluid for a given pump. Also we know that the head to which a centrifugal pump will deliver depends on r 2, where r is the peripheral velocity of the fluid at the discharge of the impeller. Now if we apply these fundamentals to our particular question we can show the rudiments of the calculation in this case. We have a 3-stage pump delivering to the same head as a 5-stage pump, therefore 3C = 5C, when C and C are the circumferences of the tip of the impeller of the respective pumps. But C = 2ϖR, therefore 3R = 5r. Now we will assume that the 3-stage pump has an impeller radius of 5", and that to obtain a high efficiency the ratio b²/R = 0.1, then the width of the impeller in this case would be 0.5 inch, therefore, in the case of the 500-gallon pump a much less width of the impeller is necessary; therefore, if the same diametered impeller was used the ratio width : radius would be much less than 0.1, which would result in a very low efficiency. The object then is to arrange a suitable number of impellers of a suitable diameter so that the ratio is not less than 0.1, that is, the width of the impeller to be 1/10 the radius of the tip of the impeller. Great care should be taken when ascertaining the head against which the pumps should work as it is most important that the manufacturer should be in possession of accurate figures, otherwise the pumps will not come up to expectations as regards the duty required, or to work at a maximum efficiency. Pipe Arrangements. — All three pumps deliver into one common delivery pipe of 12" diameter, and each unit is provided with a sluice valve and reflux valve, both fitted with by-passes for the priming of each unit separately. The existing 12" diameter cast-iron delivery pipe on the Evans Duplex steam pump is utilised for the delivery of the electrical units, and is so arranged that either the electrical plant or the steam plant can deliver separately through the same pipe. Suction Pumps. — Each unit is provided with an independent suction, all taking their water from a common well, and each provided with a strum and foot-valve which are essential fittings on turbine pumps. All suction pipes, together with the additional pipes to connect the electrical plant to the existing 12" diameter cast-iron pipes, are loose flanged steel tubes, made to the British Engineering Standards Association Specification. Treatment of Pipes to Prevent Dampness. — It was found that a fair amount of condensation took place on these pipes, both on the suction and delivery due to the warm air coming in contact with them causing a considerable amount of dampness. To overcome this trouble, all steel pipes were coated with one coat of varnish, and before it was allowed to dry a covering of small pieces of cork was applied; this stuck to the varnish and remained firmly fixed by this process. It is claimed that these pipes will outlast the life of the pumps. Treatment of Cement to Prevent Dust. — In all engine houses, where electrical machines are in use, and where any part of the floor or other construction is of cement, special care has to be taken to prevent the cement dust from causing trouble. This is best accomplished by the treatment of the parts in the following manner: After the cement is properly set and fairly dry, brush the surface clean, and apply with a brush one coat of "Kewato" solution, made by the Indestructible Paint Co., Ltd. This process prevents any sign of dust from the cement work and so reduces the troubles from dust to a minimum. Electrical Power Supply. — Seeing that the Three Quarter level had been decided upon as the main pumping level, together with the main electrical distribution point, the principle of duplicating essential items was also carried out with the power supply to this point. The surface sub-station received power from the County of Durham Electric Power Distribution Company at 6,000 volts pressure; this is transformed by their two 800 K.V.A. transformers and supplied to our bus-bars in the sub-station at a normal pressure of 2,750 volts. We receive 3-phase alternating current at 40 cycles, the neutral of the 2,750 volt side being earthed in the sub-station. The Supply Company undertake to maintain a duplicate supply to our terminals in the sub-station at a normal pressure of 2,750 volts, for which they are responsible, and all apparatus connected therewith. From our terminals, i.e., where the supply is given to us, we take over all responsibility. Duplicate Supply. — A duplicate supply is maintained by means of a "ring" system around four of the Stella Coal Company's pits. This colliery is supplied by two cables tapped off the "ring." By this means it will be seen that we have a duplicate supply from the whole of the Supply Company's System. Underground Feeder. — The installation provides for all distribution at 2,750 volts; two shaft cables are installed, one down each shaft, so that in case of shaft accident or damage to either cable, the whole of the work can be maintained by the other cable. The main distribution board is fixed at the Three Quarter level and is fed by both shaft feeders, which are normally working in parallel, each cable (paper-lead double wire armoured) is capable of transmitting 850 h.p., making a total of 1,700 h.p. available at the Three Quarter seam level. * From a paper on "Notes on the conversion of main pumping from steam to electricity with special reference to the plant installed at Messrs. The Stella Coal Company's Clara Vale Pit," read on 28th April before the Associates and Students' Section of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||