|
21st April 1928, Page: 314, Column: 1 Pumping Layout And Practice[The subject of a paper by Messrs. Harold T. Collinswood and H. Wilfred Ritchie, of the Harland Engineering Co., Ltd., prepared to be read before the March meeting of the Leigh Municipal College Mining Association, was "Notes on Pumping Layout and Practice." Some excerpts are appended.] The development of the turbine centrifugal pump to its present pitch of simplicity and reliability is without doubt due in great measure to an endeavour to meet one of the most serious problems which face the mining engineer — the flooding of underground workings. The aim of the authors was to indicate some of the points which, if they do not receive due attention, may give rise to trouble and disappointment. As to the first stage in the installation of a pumping set, to ensure the minimum of correspondence it is well that every endeavour be made to give all the necessary information, particularly with regard to the proposed pipe-work. In mining work, the situation often demands awkward arrangements, which may affect the performance adversely if not taken into account in the initial stages. Every pump set before despatch is tested to full capacity to ensure that it is in every respect up to specification and entirely capable of the duty. If when the pump is installed, the desired results are not obtained, the first step is obviously to find in what way the running conditions are different from those on test. In nine cases out of ten the answer is found in Unsuitable Pipe-work, and it is no exaggeration to say that out of these nine, Suction Troubles are responsible for eight. As regards the total suction lift, the turbine pump suffers from the same disability as all other forms, in being limited to a theoretical maximum of 34 feet of water — the height of the water barometer at sea level. This figure suffers a reduction of one foot per 1,000 feet above sea level. In addition the head absorbed in the friction of the strainer, foot valve, and suction piping, must-be allowed for. In short, the maximum static lift should not exceed 15 to 18 feet. If the water dealt with is warm, even this figure is impracticable on account of the increased vapour pressure. Probably one of the best known principles of hydraulics is the law of stream line or non-sinuous flow, upon which practically all calculations on flow are based. Despite this, however, it is very common to observe a pump connected to its suction pipe by a sharp right angle elbow, which must produce anything but a stream line effect. This too, in face of the fact that the conditions at the suction of the pump are most sensitive in relation to the efficiency. It is most desirable that a fairly long length, say, 8 to 10 diameters of straight pipe, should be connected to the suction flange before a bend is introduced. In the case of a suction main otherwise satisfactory, the most frequent cause of trouble is air leakage. The design of practically all turbine pumps is such that the shaft gland at the suction end is under suction pressure and it is thus subject to air leakage. This is obviated by fitting a pipe from the delivery side of the first stage to a space in the middle of the gland packing. In order that this pipe should be fully effective, it ought to have a cross-section equal to twice the area of the clearance between the shaft and the sleeve in which it runs. In the event of a new sealing-pipe having to be fitted on site, care should be taken that it is of ample area. Air leakage into the suction main itself is often very difficult to trace. It may be detected by allowing the pressure of the delivery column to come on to the suction pipe by means of a bye-pass on the reflux valve, or by actually looking for leakage while the pump is running by means of a naked candle flame — a method usually impossible under modern mining regulations. It is poor policy to utilise old and worn piping for the suction main, and if priming is to be effected by a byepass from the rising main, the suction piping must be capable of withstanding the full delivery pressure. The use of a sluice valve on the suction side is really most undesirable, and in cases in which such a valve is fitted, e.g., boiler feed pumps, it should not be used for throttling but should be kept fully open while the pump is working. The foot valve is a unit in the suction system which ought to receive considerable attention. The strainer should have perforations equivalent to at least twice the area of the valve inlet, in order to reduce friction to a minimum, and to provide against partial choking. In priming a pump, a water-tight foot valve is of course essential, whether the pump be charged from a separate supply by means of the tundish, or by a byepass from the rising main. Where necessary, a small air pump may be installed to exhaust the suction pipe of air. The delivery piping, while far less prone to trouble, should be carefully selected. If too small a pipe is fitted, the head lost in the friction will be excessive, and will necessitate a higher pressure at the pump. At the other extreme, the use of large diameter piping may be prohibitive. In addition, allowance must be made for additional pipe-friction as growth and incrustation take place. It is necessary to work out two or three alternatives, taking the cost of the pumping plant and of the piping in conjunction with any other factors. With a long delivery pipe, trouble is sometimes experienced from water-hammer. Protection can be obtained by fitting a relief valve at the danger points. The reflux valve should generally be fitted on the side of the sluice valve remote from the pump, in order that both pump and sluice valve may be protected from a bad surge, since reflux valves are nowadays quite reliable. If for any cause, such as the failure of the power supply, a bearing seizure, or even the sudden closing of a valve, the column of water is suddenly brought to rest, the kinetic energy stored in the moving column is suddenly converted into a pressure or impulsive force, sometimes of many tons. The destructive effect of such a surge is often very severe, and in addition, in the case of a long horizontal pipe, a periodic sway of the whole pipe may occur. This is due, in (say) the case of a valve closing, to the following. The water next the closed valve is suddenly brought to rest and its pressure rises. This wave of pressure travels to the open end of the pipe. Here, since there is a difference in pressure between the water and the atmosphere, the water will flow out. A wave of velocity will now travel back along the pipe to the valve, and these alternate waves of pressure and velocity in turn set up sway. The effect is sometimes accentuated by the opening and closing of the nonreturn valve. In this connection, in shutting down, the sluice valve should always be closed, before the motor is tripped out, so that the water column is gradually brought to rest. By this means, the shock caused by the sudden closing of the reflux valve is avoided. One of the most interesting and useful facts relative to the centrifugal pump, is that for any given speed of rotation the maximum pressure which can be developed is a definite and fixed figure. The characteristic of a centrifugal pump is the curve of head developed drawn to a base of quantity delivered. In a typical curve, at zero delivery, a certain head is developed. As the delivery increases there is a gradual and slight rise in pressure up to a maximum figure, and the curve thereafter falls more rapidly. The efficiency curve, when plotted, gives the optimum normal duty at the point where the head is approximately 90 per cent. of the maximum possible. Since the product of delivery and head, when divided by the efficiency, is a measure of the water-horse-power, the B.H.P. curve is easily plotted. From this latter curve a very interesting fact arises. Whereas the power taken with the valve closed is only 35 per cent. of the normal full load, the maximum overload which can come on the motor is only 15 per cent. since the power curve begins to fall away beyond this point. Thus, while no excessive or dangerous pressure can be developed, neither is there any danger of serious overload. One important point arises where induction motor drive is installed. The speed of such a motor, as is well known, varies appreciably with the load, the percentage variation being known as the "slip." The head developed by a centrifugal pump varies as the square of the speed, and consequently the effect of the "slip" is to accentuate the downward drop of the characteristic. It will be realised therefore, that it is most important that both pump and motor should be designed with special reference to each other, and that care is taken that the "net characteristic" of both pump and motor is suitable for the duty. A type of pump which is of great interest to the mining engineer is the sinking or unwatering set. For this purpose the pump and motor are rigidly attached to a framework of girder construction fitted with a pulley by which the unit may be lowered into the shaft. The motor is of the drip proof type or may be totally enclosed. For large powers high tension windings are usually fitted. Since the pump is hanging vertically special thrust arrangements are necessary. In the case of sinking pumps dealing with gritty water no balance disc is used, all the thrust being taken on a Michel bearing. Dewatering pumps dealing with comparatively clean water are fitted with a balance disc in conjunction with a special floating coupling which is arranged to take the thrust at starting until the pump pressure builds up and the balance disc becomes operative. To facilitate dismantling and assembly in the vertical position, the stages are generally bolted together by small bolts in suitable lugs, in addition to the girder bolts. In the case of a sinking pump, the head at which the pump begins to operate, is very much less than the final head. This difficulty is overcome by building the pump with the full number of stages ; but at first one or two of the final stages are replaced by "dummy" chambers. As the dewatering progresses, these stages can be replaced, the pump thus operating with maximum efficiency all the time, with a corresponding economy in power. In the case of a sinking pump installed at Betteshanger Colliery, Kent, satisfactory working was obtained even when dealing with water containing up to 33 per cent. of Kent green sand. With regard to borehole pumps there are really two classes. Those for use in boreholes, where the diameter is somewhat restricted, are of special design in order to keep the overall diameter low, while in the case of deep wells where more room is available, they are of more standard type. So far as the arrangement of the piping and shafting is concerned, there is practically no difference between the two. There are many other applications of the centrifugal pump, all governed by the same principles. In the case of pumps for washery duty, the difficulty is to prevent excessive wear of the internal parts. The design of such a pump involves the prevention of eddies, and the passages are made as simple as possible, so that with low water velocity the abrasive action of the material being handled is reduced to a minimum. The material used for the casing, etc., is carefully selected, chilled or white iron. For condenser extraction duty, the chief difficulties lie in the prevention of air leakage, and in the method of getting the water efficiently under control in the eye of the impeller. As the duty is usually fairly small, a single entry pump of the overhung type without balance holes in the boss is adopted. With this arrangement, there is only one gland, and this is under delivery pressure. In the case of larger volumes, two impellers may be placed in one casing, arranged with the suction eyes facing each other. In this way end thrust is eliminated and both glands are under pressure.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||