21st April 1928, Page: 312, Column: 2
Coal Mine Ventilation*
By H. I. Smith.
Booster and Auxiliary Fans.
The technical and safety Press have devoted much space in support of or in
opposition to the use of booster and auxiliary fans in coal mines. An auxiliary
fan is a fan installed to divert a part of the air-current passing a given
point for the purpose of ventilating some particular place or places, while
allowing the remainder of the air-current to pass by.
The fundamentals of mine ventilation on which I think there is general
agreement are as follows :—
(1) Booster fans will re-circulate air if there are any leaky stoppings,
overcasts or doors between the intake and return airways on the suction side of
the fan or if there is loose construction in the fan housing.
(2) Where air is re-circulated there is an undesirable decrease in the
percentage of oxygen and an increase in the percentage of methane in the
ventilating current. The former reduces the amount of work which men and
animals can perform, and the latter is a hazard to the lives of the men in the
mine.
(3) Auxiliary fans will re-circulate air when the volume of air passing through
the entry is not in excess of that passing through the auxiliary fan, and they
may re-circulate air when the current is in excess of that passing through the
fan. Auxiliary fans will always re-circulate air when the fan is inbye the last
open crosscut.
(4) Booster and auxiliary fans are not desirable as regards either economical
operation or safety when used to offset the defects of leaky stoppings and
doors, or as a substitute for properly maintained air-courses.
(5) Booster and auxiliary fans driven by electricity have ignited gas and have
caused mine fires and gas explosions, resulting in loss of life and property.
(6) In the event of a mine fire, a booster fan may interfere seriously with or
may aid in getting the fire under control,
(7) Wherever ventilation is dependent upon a booster fan if at the time of an
explosion the fan cannot be operated by reason of being wrecked or the power
being cut off, it seriously retards the recovery of the mine and greatly adds
to the hazards of the rescue crew and of any survivors of the explosion.
The points on which there may be differences of opinion are :—
(1) Whether booster fans and auxiliary fans can be so placed and equipped with
explosion-proof motors that there will be no danger of gas ignition by the
motor or by static electricity from the belt or fan.
(2) Whether storage battery power, compressed air, or some form of power other
than line electricity can be used safely.
(3) Whether booster fans can be so protected that the possibility of mine fires
is eliminated.
(4) Whether underground fans can be so equipped as to be proof against
conditions that might interfere with continuous operation to the same degree as
outside fans.
(5) Whether the use of automatic starters on underground fans can be considered
a safe practice.
(6) Whether the same protective devices can be applied to underground fans that
are required by law on surface fans, such as offsetting the fan from the line
of an explosion force, the use of explosion-relief doors and of a recording
pressure gauge, and in case of stoppage or slowing down the flashing of a light
or sounding of a gong at some point where there is a constant attendant, as in
the engine room.
Booster fans in coal mines in the United States are, in my opinion, a direct
hazard and too often a sign of weakness in the system of ventilation. This
weakness may be due to a change in plans whereby a mining operation may be
extended several times the distance originally contemplated, without the
retention of sufficient pillars in which the additional entries required for
proper ventilation may be driven, or it may be due to a day-to-day method of
mining in which the aim is to keep down the daily cost regardless of future air
requirements.
The use of auxiliary fans may be inspired by false economy, by operating plans
which increase distances between breakthrough, or by a failure of the
ventilating system from leaky stoppings and clogged air-courses. My
observations have been that the responsibility for the installation of booster
fans and in many mines of auxiliary fans lies in leaky doors, stoppings, and
overcasts ; in the use of too many doors in lieu of overcasts and the
substitution of canvas, board or gob for concrete stoppings in crosscuts ; and
in restricted air-courses and air-courses closed or partly closed by falls of
roof or by heaving bottom. The cost of correcting these conditions may be
greater than the cost of installing a booster fan, but loss of mine safety
incurred by failure to correct them is too high a price to pay.
Booster fans may also be installed on the initiative of the company or on
instructions from the mine inspector to increase the amount of air or where an
increase in air circulation is so urgent that time will not permit the cleaning
of the air-courses and the building of tight stoppings. Where air splits are of
unequal length booster fans may be installed on the split of the greater
resistance in lieu of building up the resistance on the shorter split by means
of a regulator.
Another condition which is rare in the United States but may occur in Nova
Scotia and Great Britain is that of coal so thin and air-courses so long that
with tight stoppings and clean air-courses the resistance is so great that the
air cannot be forced through in sufficient quantities at ordinary pressure to
keep the oxygen above 20 per cent. and the percentage of methane below an
amount that can be detected with a miner's safety-lamp. Under such
circumstances the driving of additional entries or the enlargement of the
air-courses by brushing the roof will greatly extend the time before the
installation of booster fans must be considered. The additional entries should
be driven and the roof brushed as the entries advance, rather than waiting
until the demand is acute and the cost of doing all the work at one time looks
prohibitive.
It is freely admitted that the ventilation of coal mines should be continuous
except during necessary fan repairs and that, should the fans be stopped even
for only a short period, all employees should be withdrawn from the mine.
Outside fans for ventilating coal mines are equipped with many commendable
devices to give a warning by light or sound when the fan speed or air pressure
has been reduced below a prescribed minimum. Devices are used to give warning
when the bearings of the fan reach a certain temperature. Surface fans are
offset from the line of a possible explosion and are equipped with
explosion-relief doors.
If recording and safety devices of the type mentioned are of value on outside
fans they are even more essential on underground fans. To date, however, I have
failed to observe any underground fan offset so as to prevent its injury in the
event of an explosion, although G. S. Rice has shown me a sketch of such
an arrangement at a mine in Nova Scotia. Unless underground fans are
continuously operated and are equipped with the same warning and safety devices
as outside fans, they should be condemned as vigorously as one would condemn a
surface fan under such circumstances.
Records indicate that by reason of intermittent operation, booster fans have
moved bodies of gas to some distant point, where they have been ignited. This
hazard is greater than that involved in practice, universally condemned, of
moving gas by brushing with a coat, shovel or water spray. It is apparent that
in places containing small amounts of methane at the face the methane
percentage gradually increases after the air-current is cut off, and even after
the current is re-established there is a continued increase in methane at the
face for a period of time. In view of this continued increase and the fact that
methane may be moved in an explosive body for long distances from the point
where it may accumulate, the use of automatic starters on underground fans is
decidedly dangerous. Intermittent supervision of underground fans is likewise
dangerous.
Twelve years ago my attention was first drawn to re-circulation. I made a test
on a booster fan and found that in the return there was but 13,000 cubic feet
of air while at the booster fan there was 29,250 cubic feet. Measurements were
then made of the air on the haulage entry opposite the fan, showing 29,200
cubic feet of air. The loss of 16,200 cubic feet of air occurred within a
distance of 2,000 feet and indicated approximately 500 cubic feet per stopping
and door. There was more than 0.5 per cent. of methane in the air. In my report
attention was called to the possibility of igniting the gas by static
electricity, even though a protected motor may have been used to drive the fan.
The static electricity is credited with accumulating on the blades of a booster
fan driven by compressed air.
A small fan set on the surface at a certain coal mine was used to ventilate a
shaft before underground connections had been made to the air shaft. The shaft
was divided by a wooden partition, and as it was found that the air-current was
too sluggish to keep the mine clear of methane a second or booster fan was set
at the bottom of the shaft to increase the circulation. The additional fan did
not help much in ridding the development entries of gas, and after checking up
carefully with an anemometer it was found that although some 10,000 cu. ft. of
air was being handled by the first fan and a similar amount by the fan at the
shaft bottom there was no movement half-way down the shaft, or at least
insufficient movement to turn the anemometer. Investigation showed that the air
handled by the top fan was leaking out before it reached the bottom of the
shaft and that the air handled by the bottom fan was being pulled through the
brattice boards and re-circulated. The use of a large canvas tubing connected
directly to the top fan resulted in providing more fresh air than the top and
booster fan combined had been furnishing, and accordingly the booster fan was
eliminated.
If consulting mining engineers were called on more generally to solve
ventilating problems the cost of many booster and auxiliary fans, as well as
many surface fans, would be saved, and better ventilation would result.
To illustrate an acute danger in the use of booster fans, I would quote
Daniel Harrington, who observed a case where workers receiving air
passing through a canvas tubing had difficulty in keeping their carbide lights
burning. Matches would not burn at the fan, yet 50 feet outside the fan a match
would burn brightly, thus indicating the extent to which the booster fan failed
to draw on fresh air but 50 feet away. Mr. Harrington has also shown me
a long list of fires and explosions resulting from booster fans, including one
where an ordinary office fan used to clear entries of gas resulted in
casualties and others involving longwall mining where men have been burned by
the ignition of gas at the fan motor.
There are places such as in underground pump stations, hoist rooms and
electrical stations where the use of auxiliary fans and canvas tubing in place
of line brattices appears to be appropriate, temporarily at least, but power is
always uncertain at the face, and when a fan stops even for a short time there
is no way in which the main fan can take care of the gas accumulations. In some
mines the power goes off so often that a fireboss cannot withdraw all the men
and make an examination every time it happens. When the main fan stops, the
men, including those at the face as well as those at the shaft bottom, are
withdrawn, and it is of course particularly important to withdraw those in the
more dangerous parts of the mine should there be any interruption of the
ventilation from any cause.
One way to eliminate the dangers of booster and auxiliary fans is to eliminate
the necessity for them by getting a large percentage of the air from the main
fan to the face with a minimum of power. This can be done in a number of ways,
such as sinking shafts in advance territory, or erecting all stoppings and
overcasts of concrete and eliminating doors. I was instrumental in bringing
about the adoption, in several mines opened up in Indiana in 1917 and 1918, of
a plan having in view more economical ventilation. This plan provides for two
pairs of main entries with a solid pillar of coal between the two pairs. One
pair is used for intake air and one pair for return air ; the solid pillar is
to be cut only at the cross entries. The same scheme has been more recently
followed in large mining operations in Illinois.
The demand for auxiliary fans or blowers can also be greatly reduced by driving
more entries, building more concrete stoppings, and using fewer doors. The aim
in ventilation should be to get to the last crosscut 90 per cent. of the fresh
air handled by the surface fan, or nine times the amount to be found in some
mines.
Before any surface, booster, or auxiliary fans are installed in or at a coal
mine, fan houses and airways should be examined and it should be found out
whether the appropriation should be made for a fan or for changes in the mine.
If there is not a ventilation man in the organisation, advice should certainly
be bought from a consulting engineer familiar with up-to-date coal mining
ventilation who can point out the spots in the mine that are below par.
* From paper read before the American Institute of Mining and Metallurgical
Engineers.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Harrington, Daniel | | | |
| Rice, G. S. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |
| Smith, H. I. | | | |