21st April 1928, Page: 309, Column: 1
Coal-Mine Fires In U.S.
Coal mines cannot be altogether freed from the fire hazard, but, by observing
proper precautions, this hazard can be so minimised that there will be little
danger of fires disastrous to life and property, as pointed out by Messrs.
G. S. Rice, J. W. Paul and M. W. Von Bernewitz, in
Bulletin 229 of the United States Bureau of Mines. Important factors in the
constitution of the coal mine fire hazard are that the mineral mined is
combustible ; in many mines there is inflow of inflammable gas from the coal
measures ; wooden timbering is necessary to support the roof ; doors and
brattices to afford ventilation are present; and more or less inflammable or
explosive substances, such as explosives, oils, and electric insulation, are in
use. Fires in coal mines have a variety of causes, some of which would hardly
be credited if the facts were not on record. Mine fires are dangerous to fight;
they generate asphyxiating gases and in gassy mines they may cause explosions.
To extinguish a mine fire, to prevent its spreading, or to seal it is a task
that demands care and skill. As a contribution to the study of the prevention
and limitation of coal-mine fires, the Bureau of Mines bulletin reviews the
essential details of reports on fifty-nine serious fires in different coal
mines in the United States. In all, these fifty-nine coal-mine fires caused
great damage to property and killed nearly 400 men. Fires have occurred in all
kinds of coal mines from anthracite to lignite and in non-gassy as well as
gassy mines.
Some coals when mined are subject to spontaneous firing, but this is not an
index of relative liability to disastrous fires, for such fires have occurred
at anthracite mines which are not subject to spontaneous fires. The factors
involved in mine fires are so numerous — they include different sources
of ignition present, the presence of methane, the arrangement of the mine and
its equipment, and, most of all the degree of discipline maintained and the
mine organisation employed — that no generalisation as to relative
hazards can be made to apply to a specific mine. The relative liability of a
mine changes from year to year, with changes in mining development and mining
equipment. For example, twenty-five years ago only a few mines used closed or
safety-lamps and no permissible explosives were available, consequently open
lights and black powder were almost the only cause of mine fires, except
spontaneous fires. At that time electricity was little used ; now its use is
almost universal in coal mines in the States, and it has become one of the
important causes of ignition. More gas (methane) is being encountered as mines
go deeper and are worked more intensively. On the other hand, permissible
electric miners' lamps and permissible electric machinery have been widely
introduced, better ventilation and panel systems of working have been adopted,
safety measures generally have become popular, and the development of highly
efficient oxygen breathing apparatus and gas masks — effective aids in
fire lighting — has been accompanied by systematic organisation of
fire-fighting and recovery crews. Thus it will be seen that although in recent
years natural hazards and some additional sources of ignition have tended to
increase the possibility of mine fires originating, other factors have tended
to lessen the number of fires. The Bureau of Mines believes that to-day the
relative order of igniting agencies in the causation of U.S. underground fires
is as follows : (1) Open lights igniting methane. (2) Black blasting powder and
dynamite igniting gas or coal. (3) Electric sparks from non-permissible motors
igniting methane. (4) Electric shorts from power lines or trolley lines
igniting timber or coal. (5) Spontaneous gob-fires. (6) Fires caused by
explosions of gas or coal dust. (7) Frictional heating of bearings igniting
wood or oily material. (8) Flames or burning brands from surface fires.
As being of primary importance in preventing serious fires the following
measures are proposed by the Authors of the Bulletin, beginning at the surface
: Use incombustible material for buildings near mines and especially avoid the
use of wood in shaft and fan structures. Use incombustible material for shaft
linings, the lining of shaft bottoms, and the entrances to slopes and drifts.
If wood is used, install emergency steel fire doors or trap-doors which can be
closed from outside the mine from a suitable distance by wire or cables or
other mechanical means. Main pump rooms, transformer and motor rooms, stables,
and places where oil is stored should have incombustible linings and be
provided with steel or concrete doors which can be closed from outside. Main
supply electric cables should be armoured and where feasible placed in a
channel cut in the floor and sealed over. Other electric lines should be
installed so as not to be in contact with wood, brattice cloth, or walls.
Approved junction boxes and switches should be used instead of twisting or
hooking wires together. Overcasts, door frames in main haulageways, stoppings
in cross-cuts of main entries, and permanent seals of fire areas and of
abandoned or unused parts of mines should be made of incombustible material.
Emergency fire doors at divisional points and panel entrances would be, under
some conditions, of great value in controlling a fire.
Necessary equipment for fire fighting includes ample water supply on the
surface ; water lines about the mine buildings and extending into and through
the mine with frequent taps and hose and nozzle ; also portable fire
extinguishers, stored at strategic and divisional points in the mine, and fire
buckets. Besides small hand apparatus, well-equipped mines now have chemical
extinguishers mounted on trucks. These have large tanks filled with water. The
pressure of carbon dioxide gas, generated by the action of sulphuric acid on
sodium bicarbonate, expels the water and carbon dioxide through a hose. Main
fans should always be on the surface and should be "reversible."
Booster fans should be used rarely, and then only to meet special needs. The
Bureau of Mines believes that auxiliary fans should not be used as a substitute
for the regular coursing of air-currents. Supplies of brattice cloth and
matched boards for emergency stoppings should be kept in special stations or
refuge rooms at strategic points. Rock dust, kept in barrels or sacks, is an
efficient aid in fighting a fire at the start. Telephone lines from the surface
to all strategic points and underground cabins are invaluable for giving
warning and for transmitting instructions. Gas detectors, carbon monoxide
detectors, and gas-analysis apparatus are important aids in ascertaining danger
and in the control of ventilation.
As most mine fires are caused by carelessness, education and discipline of mine
employees will do much to prevent them. Matches, patent igniters, and smoking
tobacco should not be permitted in mines. The most intelligent men should be
grouped into fire-fighting crews. Drills should be held periodically, at least
monthly, in different parts of the mine, and should cover different kinds of
fires, and different places of origin. Skeleton maps for use in fighting fires
should be prepared. They should show the position of pumps, water sumps, water
lines, and taps, the direction of ventilating currents, all control doors and
regulators, and all entrances and exits. These maps should be fastened up at
various points and especially in underground offices or cabins. The direction
of escapeways should be shown by standard enamelled signs. Direction charts of
what to do in case of fire should be framed behind glass and placed at shaft
bottoms and all principal underground stations.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bernewitz, M. W. Von | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |
| Paul, J. W. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |
| Rice, G. S. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |