Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

24th March 1928, Page: 276, Column: 1

Accidents From The Use Of Explosives*

By William B. Brown, H.M.I.M.

The dangers attendant upon the firing of shots underground have been recognised since the very earliest times, when blasting by means of gunpowder and straws was the system in vogue. In those early days accidents were common and explosions arising from shot-firing not an infrequent occurrence. Research work has been extensively carried out in this and other countries where mining is in progress, to introduce explosives which are relatively safe for use underground. Without tracing in detail the evolution of the "Permitted Explosive" as we know it to-day, I would add that in the year 1925 some 53,000,000 shots were fired in British Mines, with only one fatal ignition of firedamp and coal dust resulting in two deaths, and one non-fatal ignition resulting in injuries to three persons. This is a wonderful tribute to the painstaking efforts of our research workers, and to the competency and carefulness of our shot-firers.

In the Northern Division there are both naked light and safety-lamp mines, both of which are extensively legislated for in the Explosives in Coal Mines Order. In the face of such comprehensive rules for the safety of the persons engaged in the firing of shots and the handling of explosives, the number of accidents reported is almost incredible. It is true that one can be wise after an event, but the melancholy fact about accidents due to the use of explosives, is the recurrence, year by year, of the same type of accident whereby lives are thrown away and injuries sustained representing, in the aggregate, a serious loss of man power.

Figures culled from the reports of the Divisional Inspector in the Northern Division show that, in the five-year period 1922-26, there were 28 separate fatal accidents causing 29 deaths, and 467 separate non-fatal accidents injuring 512 persons. In the period 1919-1924 inclusive there were 28 fatal accidents of which 25 or 89 per cent. were the result of breaches of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order; there were also 543 non-fatal accidents of which 453 or 83 per cent. were due to breaches of the E.C.M.O.

It will be generally admitted that such a position leaves much to be desired and steps have been taken by some Colliery Companies to bring forcibly to the notice of their workmen the requirements of the Explosives in Coal Mines Order. One method adopted is to present to the hewer, in his pay tin, a Safety First Pamphlet, reminding him of his duties and the dangers which follow noncompliance with the regulations designed for his safety. Another method adopted is to display prominent notices on the heapstead warning men to take every care when using and handling explosives. The chief cause of accidents due to the use of explosives are :— (a) Unramming miss-fired shots ; (b) returning before waiting the statutory period ; (c) open lights coming in contact with powder ; (d) shots fired before persons had taken shelter; (e) failing to take proper shelter ; (f) drilling into miss-fired shots ; (g) tampering with squibs ; (h) no warning given by persons firing the shots ; (i) failing to take shelter when ordered to do so.

(a) Unramming Miss-fired Shots. — Irrespective of the method of firing the shot, the E.C.M.O. lays down certain rules, contained in Section 3, clauses a-i inclusive.

It would appear that the time involved in carrying out these requirements is a possible reason why workmen and officials, on occasion, fail to comply with them and commence to remove the stemming in order to place a second detonator in the original charge. It cannot be too strongly emphasised that a detonator will explode on being struck by a drill or other tool. Not only is it illegal to unram a miss-fired shot, it is extremely dangerous and attended by very grave risks, as illustrated by the following case : A deputy had charged and attempted to fire a bottom canch shot containing 16 oz. of gelignite, fired by fuse and detonator. The shot failed to go off when lit up. According to the story told by the survivors, no person approached the shot for a period of one and a half hours, after which the deputy, accompanied by two stone-men, went to inspect the place. It was alleged that the shot exploded as they were approaching the face of the canch. The deputy was killed outright and the stonemen seriously injured. Investigation at the scene of the accident revealed a 4 feet drill, lying in line with the hole, but 10 feet away, badly bent and blackened for a distance of 2 feet from the cutting end. Near the drill was found a cartridge of gelignite, lacerated at one end. A copper scraper and a wooden beater were found nearer the mouth of the hole, while at the mouth itself, there was a drill key found which is ordinarily used for the purpose of releasing and extricating the drill when boring. On the floor, close beside the drill key, a candlestick was found.

(b) Returning to the Shot Before Waiting the Statutory Period. — The waiting period has already been referred to. The majority of accidents under this heading occur in naked light mines. The cause is not difficult to find. In a word the accidents are due to the fact that the men firing their own shots do not always carry a watch. Attempts are made to measure the passing of time by guessing ; this method, to say the least of it, is very dangerous. The largest number of this type of accident occur where squibs are used, in which case the waiting period is 10 minutes. At a colliery in Northumberland where this type of accident had occurred too frequently, the manager posted the following notice.

"Avoidable Shot-firing Accidents."

"Accidents to coal hewers in the Yard Seam are still frequently occurring and I am very much concerned about it. In my considered opinion the cause is due to men going back upon their shot too soon. It cannot be too widely known that 10 minutes must elapse between lighting a squib and going back to it. If your shot does not go off, I suggest that you should then start slowly counting aloud up to 300 before going back to your shot. ; It will be much more sensible doing this than counting blue marks on your face in hospital. Remember that the only people in the world who can prevent these avoidable accidents are yourselves. As sensible men I trust you will endeavour to do so."

One could have wished that such an arresting notice had recommended the use of a watch instead of "slowly counting aloud up to 300."

(c) Open Lights Coming in Contact with Powder. — The Fourth schedule stipulates that "no person while charging a shothole or handling any explosives not contained in a securely closed case or canister shall smoke or allow any naked light to be within a distance of 4 feet of the shothole or explosive." In the years under review, namely, 1919 to 1924, no less than four fatal accidents and eighty-two non-fatal accidents were reported under this heading. On investigating these cases it is usually found that the candle or other open light has fallen from the coal face to the floor where the hewer had placed the whole of the charge preparatory to charging the hole. In such cases the canister is generally left alongside the man's clothes, a distance back from the face. Or again, the hewer fetches in a charge of three or four cartridges of powder from the canister and is carrying the candle and a portion of the charge in the same hand. The remedy for this type of accident is compliance with E.C.M.O., 1 (b) which states that explosives shall be "kept until about to be used for the charging of a shothole in a secure case or canister." It is therefore the duty of the person firing the shot to take the canister to the place where the hole is to be charged. The cartridges should be removed singly and the lid closed after each operation. He should also ensure that there is no naked light within a distance of 4 feet, measured laterally, of the shothole or explosive being handled. There are cases where the manager and workmen at naked light mines have agreed to prohibit smoking underground, the object being to eliminate the possibility of accidents to workmen whilst engaged in the firing of shots, or handling explosives, from accidental ignition by a burning pipe or cigarette.

(d) Shots Fired before Persons have taken Proper Shelter. — The E.C.M.O., 2 (e) states "the person firing the shot shall, before doing so, see that all persons in the vicinity have taken proper shelter and he shall also take suitable steps to prevent any person approaching the shot. He shall also himself take proper shelter." Where shots are fired electrically authorised persons only are allowed to fire the shots, and it is provided in 2 (h) of the E.C.M.O. that "the authorised person shall not use, for the purpose of firing the shots, a cable which is less than 20 yards in length."

In naked light mines where shots are fired by means of squibs or fuse, it is imperative that no time be lost in taking shelter after lighting up the shot as the rate of burning of a squib is about 75 seconds and fuse 90 seconds per yard. The person firing the shot should give a clear warning and receive a satisfactory answer from all persons whose safety is involved before the candle is applied to the squib or fuse.

Where shots are fired electrically it is the duty of the appointed shot-firer to see that all persons have taken proper shelter before he connects the cable to the firing apparatus. A careful official will make a point of seeing that all other persons are sheltering on the outbye side of the place where he himself is under cover.

(e) Failing to Take Proper Shelter. — From 1919 to 1924, three persons were killed and 105 injured through failing to take proper shelter. Mr. T. Greenland Davies, commenting on this in his report for 1924, states : "One of the most prevalent types of accident is that due to persons failing to take proper shelter, and in almost every case the injured person thought he was quite out of harm's way. A careful analysis of this type of accident reveals the fallacious views held by many shotfirers and workmen. Some fondly imagine that if they are more than 20 yards from the shot to be fired — especially if it is a lightly charged one — no matter whether they are in line with it or not, they are quite safe. Others believe that if they are out of sight, or line of the shot, say by getting behind some tub or other obstruction, by getting into a refuge hole, by getting behind a canvas door, or by getting a very little round a corner of another roadway, they are perfectly safe. They overlook, or forget, that a small piece of debris can be projected with considerable force for a long distance — far more than 20 yards — by even a very light shot, and can easily be deflected round corners into apparently sheltered places by rebounding, or ricocheting off some prop, or other obstruction in its path."

It is important, in naked light mines, that the person firing a shot should make sure that there are no obstructions blocking his path to safety. In addition to seeing that there are no tubs, heaps of coal or stones over which he might stumble, he should also place an additional lighted candle in some convenient place to expedite his movements after lighting the squib or fuse as the case may be.

(f) Drilling into Miss-fired Shots. — The requirements of the E.C.M.O., regarding miss-fired shots are very clear and if carried out in detail, would eliminate all accidents under this heading. Not least in importance is the requirement that there shall be marked upon the roof the direction of the original hole. Too often this is overlooked or regarded as trifling and no mark is placed on the roof. Occasionally it is found that the men rely on the recess in the roof in which the stand type of machine is set when drilling the hole to give the direction or line of the hole. This method may lead to an accident. The direction of the hole should in all cases be placed on the roof, or where the shot is near the foot of the seam, on the floor, before the hole is charged. It cannot be too strongly impressed upon all who have to use explosives requiring a detonator that there is need for great care to be exercised when drilling a relief hole.

(g) Tampering with Squibs. — The E.C.M.O., Part 1, clause 2 (f) (c) states "no person shall shorten, bend or untwist the slow match or touch, or light it except at the extreme outer end, or in any other way expedite its burning." It should be borne in mind that the slow match is the safety provision and is so designed to allow the person lighting the squib to retreat to a position of safety before the squib explodes, emitting a shower of sparks along the hole to the charge. Hence to break off a portion of the slow match or touch is to hurry or expedite the blast with the result that the shot is fired before the person has taken shelter. Squibs should not be carried in candle boxes except in a separate compartment as there is an obvious danger of the squibs becoming damaged or bruised. Nor is it a safe or sensible practice for the hewer to carry the squib behind his ear for half an hour before the shot is fired. Apart from the very real danger of igniting the squib inadvertently at the candle or other naked light, there is the equally grave danger of the slow match or touch becoming damaged to the extent that the shot may fire prematurely. Like the explosive, the squib ought not to be removed from the box or case until it is to be inserted into the shothole.

(h) No Warning Given by Persons Firing the Shots. — It is clearly the duty of the person firing the shot to see that all persons in the vicinity have taken shelter and also to warn others whose safety is jeopardised. This applies particularly in bord and pillar workings where there is the danger of shots blowing through into an adjoining place. Under these circumstances it is not enough to depend upon rappings to convey the fact that a shot is about to be fired, the warning must be verbal, definite and distinct. The messenger should see that the persons whose safety is affected have withdrawn before he returns to where the shot is to be fired. Under this heading are classified the accidents to persons who inadvertently approach shots along unfenced or unguarded roadways. This ought not to be, as it is an easy matter to fence off approaches to a shot which is not guarded by some person on sentry.

(i) Failing to Take Shelter when Ordered to do so. — Accidents of this kind are not due to a refusal on the part, of the persons concerned to take shelter, but rather to the peculiar interpretation of the term "shelter." This results in refuge being sought behind tubs, canvas sheets or wooden doors too near the shot. Safety lies only in retiring to a safe distance from the shothole, making use of corners and barricades as previously described. In these cases, as in many others, the examine set by the official in charge is infectious.

(j) Handling and Carrying Explosives. — Much has already been said on this subject, but a word on the question of the term "secure case or canister" will not be out of place. The secure case or canister cannot, and does not, include tins of all shapes and sizes, many of which have been punctured in order that the rope by which the tin is carried may be fastened to the tin. Managers should not countenance the use of anything other than secure canisters with external lugs to accommodate the rope or strap used for carrying the canister, and also a closely fitting lid with a good overlap. Although not specifically required by the E.C.M.O. it would be all to the good if canisters were kept locked, the key to be in the possession of the owner of the box throughout his working shift.

Sundries. — An accident which pointed strongly to a second charge being placed in the same hole occurred at a naked light mine, the particulars being as follows : Two hewers, working "marrows," but in separate places, were hewing on a longwall face. During the course of the shift the younger and less experienced man attempted to fire a shot which was placed in the solid. The shot did no useful work, but blew out the stemming. The more experienced hewer, on hearing of the blown-out shot, volunteered to change places remarking that he would attend to the shot. He appears to have been in the act of placing a cartridge of powder in the shothole when it exploded at a point about one foot from the mouth of the hole displacing the coal. The hewer was caught and severely injured by the fragments projected by the shot and died from his injuries shortly afterwards. As only a short time elapsed between the shot blowing out and the second charge being inserted, it would appear that the shothole retained sufficient heat to explode the second charge of powder.

Clause 3 (h) of Part 1 of the E.C.M.O., reads as follows : "Should the miss-fired shot not be dislodged by the second shot, further holes must be drilled and the same precautions taken as aforesaid," that is to say, additional relief holes must be drilled, 12 inches or more away from, and parallel with, the original hole until the miss-fired shot is dislodged.

Some accidents appear to be the outcome of sheer forgetfulness on the part of those entrusted with the safety of others. Here is a case in point. A deputy had charged a shothole in the bottom canch and ran out his cable down the gateway, the hewer preceding him. Shelter was taken about 60 yards from the shothole. As the deputy was about to couple up the cable to the exploder, the hewer remembered he had left his pay note in his waistcoat pocket, and that the waistcoat was hanging on the packwall close to the shothole. He asked the deputy's permission to fetch the waistcoat, which was granted. When the hewer had gone up the gateway, two other workmen arrived on the scene and took up a conversation with the deputy. This evidently caused a mental lapse on the part of the deputy as he fired the shot without waiting for the return of the hewer, who, as a matter of fact, was standing beside the hole at the time it was fired. He sustained injuries to the arms and legs, which, luckily, were not serious.

While it must be recognised that shot-firing is an operation attended by dangers, it must also be admitted that the number of avoidable or preventable accidents is out of all proportion to the unavoidable ones. It is most desirable that a reduction be brought about, and the only way to do this is by the whole hearted co-operation of all concerned, employer, official and employee.

* From some notes prepared for the 17th March meeting of the Associates and Students' Section of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brown, William Bertram    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Davies, Thomas Greenland    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print