24th March 1928, Page: 273, Column: 1
Electrical Coal-Cutting Problems
Dangers Discussed and Safety Measures Explained
The last meeting for this session of the Past and Present Mining Students'
Association was held at the Wigan and District Mining and Technical College on
Friday, 8th March. The advertised lecturer for the evening was the well-known
machine-mining expert, Mr. G. M. Gullick, and his subject was to have
been "Coal-cutting." Mr. Gullick, however, was unable to be
present on account of illness, and Mr. R. M. Chalmers, B.Sc.(Glas.),
contributed a lecture and demonstrations on "Dangers associated with
electrical coal-cutting and the measures adopted to ensure safe
operation."
After recounting the development of machine mining and particularly the
development of electrically driven machines, attention was drawn to the
progress made during the past ten years. In that time the percentage of
machine-got coal to hand-got coal had doubled, and now over 20 per cent. was
thus obtained, or as much as 60 millions out of a total of 250 million tons.
So far as machines were concerned, the chain machine seemed to be that which
was adaptable to the greatest range of conditions, as during the past ten years
there had been a six-fold increase in the number of this type employed, whilst
only a 70 per cent. increase in the number of bar machines was to be noted, and
the disc machine, the general favourite of 15 years ago, showed no increase in
number. The last-mentioned machine seemed to be falling into disfavour, but
conditions would continue to arise which would call for the disc machine, it
being that which would successfully undercut in hard holing with reasonable
maintenance costs.
The development of the use of electrical power in machine mining was such that
we must of necessity be reminded of the associated dangers. Mining electrical
equipment now showed much improvement on former years. Coal-cutting motors were
more liberally rated and improved trailing cables and gate-end boxes were
obtainable, yet although safe electrical systems may be installed there was no
form of power which when neglected and uncared for could kick back so hard. A
thorough knowledge of electrical dangers was required of all concerned, and
sound maintenance of plant was essential.
What were the dangers ? There was danger of shock, and the danger of fires and
explosions. So far as safety from shock was concerned, this could only be
obtained by maintenance of a sound earthing system, provision of suitable
mechanical and electrical interlocks, non-interference with plant by
unauthorised persons, and careful and intelligent handling of plant by the
authorised persons so appointed in writing by the manager.
Risk of ignition of firedamp was most serious, as such might result in
explosion, the devastating effects of which were widespread, often reaching to
the most remote parts of the mine. All but the very weakest of electrical
sparks were capable of igniting firedamp, and this was most effectively
demonstrated. Overheated conductors were also dangerous in this respect, this
too being shown experimentally.
Conductors, either in cables or in motor windings, might easily become
overheated if they were worked for lengthy periods much above their rated
capacity. Fuses become overheated before they finally rupture and throw off
heated particles of the fuse wire. Sparking is always obtained in the operation
of plant, in opening switches, especially when the circuit, being broken,
embodies a strong magnetic field. A heavy trailing arc was then shown on the
opening of a switch, and the same arc was obtained when the circuit was broken
by withdrawing a plug. The reprehensible practice of withdrawing live plugs
connecting trailing cables to coal-cutting machines was strongly condemned.
If dangers of this kind were to be avoided no "open sparking" should
be allowed to occur. The old idea of enclosing parts, which were liable to give
sparking, in gas-tight cases was wrong. It was impossible to manufacture
gas-tight enclosures. If gas could diffuse through porous pots as demonstrated
or through bricks, it could not be prevented from passing into electrical
apparatus through between flanges and through between bushes and operating
spindles even without the "breathing" of the apparatus.
Electrical apparatus liable to give sparking should be enclosed in
"flameproof" enclosure, the term flameproof implying that the
enclosure should be capable of withstanding the internal pressure set up by
explosion resulting from the ignition of gas within it, and also the ability to
prevent the passage of flame from within the enclosure to the outside
atmosphere.
It was well known that mixtures of firedamp and air between the limits of 6 per
cent. and 14 per cent. firedamp were explosive. If enclosures were to be
flameproof they should successfully withstand the pressure set up by the most
explosive mixture. The most explosive mixture, that which would set up the
highest pressure, was 10 per cent. firedamp — 90 per cent. air, and when
this was exploded in a sealed enclosure a maximum pressure of 102 lb. per
square inch was set up. The size of the enclosure also influenced the pressure
set up, and this was demonstrated, but 102 lb. per square inch was the maximum.
Flameproof apparatus would therefore require to be made to withstand at least
800 lb. per square inch if an adequate factor of safety was to be given. This
would mean that such enclosure would be massive and difficult to handle, but
the provision of vented flanges, flanges with a small gap between them,
considerably reduced the pressure. If a gap of 1/50th of an inch were left the
maximum pressure developed would not be more than 40 lb. per square inch, and
the enclosure could be made much less massive. Would the gap allow the passage
of flame to the outside atmosphere ? It was then demonstrated that large gaps
would allow the passage of flame, but if the gaps were of suitable dimensions
and 1 or 1½-inch wide flanges provided, the latter would successfully cool
the flame to below the ignition point of the gas and prevent the passage of
flame. The safety of this construction was then adequately demonstrated.
A New Electrical Firedamp Alarm.
Mining electrical apparatus would thus be made to give safe operation even in
mines to which Rule 132 applies, that is in minds where firedamp is liable to
be present in such quantities as to be indicative of danger. These rules (the
general regulations governing the use of electricity in mines) however, require
that the pressure should be cut off all electrical apparatus when the
percentage of firedamp reaches 1¼ per cent. The difficulty was the
detection of this percentage of gas, but after undergoing severe Mines
Department tests, a new firedamp alarm is about to be used for this purpose.
This is the Ringrose firedamp alarm, which depends for its action on the
diminution of volume produced when firedamp is burned. Firedamp present in the
air of the mine diffuses through a porous pot quicker than the air can get out
of it, and an increased pressure would be set up. A glowing filament within the
pot, however, burns up the firedamp, and this produces a diminished pressure
which, through the operation of a specially designed bellows, causes the
closing of a local circuit and the illumination of a red danger bulb. Safety in
the use of electricity for coal-cutting purposes could thus be obtained, but
sound maintenance of plant was essential.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Chalmers, R. M. | | | |
| Gullick, G. M. | | | |