|
24th March 1928, Page: 279, Column: 2 Cwm Colliery DisasterThe causes and circumstances attending the explosion that occurred at the Marine Colliery, Cwm, Monmouthshire, on 1st March, 1927, and by which 52 lives were lost, are the subject of a report (Cmd. 3048, H.M. Stationery Office, is. 3d. net) by Mr. Henry Walker, C.B.E., H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines. From the general conclusions we cull the following :— "I am of opinion that the explosion originated in the C face or 'heading-up' place, and that the compressed air blower, having regard to its position, was insufficient to dilute and render harmless inflammable gas coming from the fall when the work of recovering the conveyor engine buried by the fall was in progress. I consider that an explosive mixture of firedamp and air existed in the C face and at the face of the C level, that this explosive mixture was ignited either by stones falling on stones already fallen or by the bare glowing filament of the missing electric lamp, and that the area of the explosion was increased and its violence magnified by the presence of coal dust." Regarding the method of sampling dust in the Black Vein district, the Inspector states that one sample was taken from the roof in January, but lost, and three were taken in February from the roof, sides and floor of different sections. "Such sampling could not give any idea of the character of the dust mixture on the floor of the haulage. Having regard to the known danger from coal dust (apart altogether from the requirements of the general regulations) it is amazing that such a method of sampling was being carried on. Workmen witnesses had alleged at the inquiry that when falls occurred on the faces the firemen were in the habit of not taking their flame safety-lamps into the places being driven to rewin those faces. "The inference I was intended to draw was that in these 'heading-up' places firedamp was always present. The workmen, however, had no means of knowing whether firedamp was in fact present or not, as they used electric lamps, and the allegations were denied by the firemen concerned. Mr. Gay (certificated manager) said he had discussions with the representatives of the workmen in reference to the use by the men of different types of lamps, with the result that it was agreed that no man should have both an electric and a flame lamp, but that he could have whichever of the two he preferred. In view of this statement, which was not challenged, it seems to me that if the workmen in the Black Vein had been anxious to have a check on the firemen before the explosion they had the means at hand and could have availed themselves of it." After discussing the recommendations of the Miner's Lamp Committee as to the use of flame safety-lamps for testing for inflammable and noxious gases, Mr. Walker adds :— "I should be in entire agreement with these recommendations if I were convinced that the workmen would make use of flame safety-lamps for testing for firedamp, but until I am convinced I feel that the possibility of accident is greater with flame safety-lamps than it is with electric lamps. The only alternative when electric lamps are used generally is to rely on the fireman, and in such case his district should be small ; and this is what was done here." The gobs behind the A and B faces were not completely packed, which resulted in firedamp being contained in them, so much so that Mr. Gay considered that the explosion was the result of firedamp which came in part from the A gob. "That the conveyor trays frequently rubbed against props, setting up sufficient heat to cause a smell as of sticks being dried in an oven, was one of the few matters upon which all the witnesses from the colliery agreed. That this cause of heat is a danger is proved by an occurrence in a longwall conveyor face at Orgreave Colliery, Yorkshire, in May, 1923, when brattice hanging on the face side of a row of props alongside a conveyor was set on fire by the conveyor rubbing against one of the props in the row. With ordinary care such a danger can easily be avoided. The teams of rescue men do not appear to have been used for the purpose of rescue. It was soon evident that there was but one road open for exploration — namely, the return airway from the Old Coal workings, and had rescue men been employed to explore by way of that road it is possible that some more of the men who took refuge between the doors on the main east level might have been brought out alive."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||