10th March 1928, Page: 266, Column: 1
Miners' Welfare Fund
Report for 1927
General Survey of Fund.
The Sixth Annual Report of the Miners' Welfare Committee (1s. 6d. net., H.M.
Stationery Office), has now been published. The Report deals with the
administration of the Miners' Welfare Fund during the year 1927, and includes
as a supplement the First Report of the Selection Committee appointed to
administer the Miners' Welfare National Scholarship Scheme. During 1927 the
Miners' Welfare Committee made 702 allocations from the Fund, to the total
amount of £1,090,734. Of this total £938,673 was allocated for
local schemes on the recommendations of the District Welfare Committees,
largely for recreation and sports grounds, institutes and halls, swimming
baths, hospitals, convalescent homes and ambulance services. Some of the more
noteworthy of these projects are briefly described. The Committee also describe
in detail the developments during the year in connection with research and
education, which accounted for the bulk of the remaining £152,061. The
Report concludes with a section on the progress made by the Committee in
carrying out their duties under the Mining Industry Act, 1926, in relation to
the provision of pithead baths. The Appendices to the Report include the usual
statistical tables and financial statements, with photographs, plans and
descriptive matter illustrating points of special interest. The Report of the
Scholarship Selection Committee contains a detailed account of the measures
taken to examine the unexpectedly large number of applications received for the
first scholarships to be awarded under the scheme, and gives full statistical
tables relating to such matters as the numbers, ages, aims and qualifications
of the applicants, accompanied by very interesting commentaries. Eleven
scholarships were awarded as a result of the competition.
The Scholarship Scheme.
In a general reference to the scholarship scheme it is recalled that the Scheme
was extensively advertised and 2,259 applications were received, of which 1,209
were from candidates who were themselves workers in or about coal mines, and
the remainder from the children of such workers. Over a hundred of the former
proved to be already qualified to enter on university degree courses, nearly
another hundred were taking a qualifying examination, during the year with
reasonable prospects of success, and over a hundred more had acquired such a
degree of education that, so far as the Selection Committee were able to judge
from the evidence before them, they would have had little difficulty in passing
one of the qualifying tests for persons of mature years which are now held by
practically all the British universities. There were therefore over three
hundred working miner candidates whose applications demanded serious
consideration, and this without taking into account some of the younger ones
who were not old enough, to be eligible for a mature matriculation test but who
had comparatively recently attended a secondary school and might, with some
further part-time instruction, have been able to pass a normal university
entrance examination. These figures are very gratifying and the existence of so
large a number of miners who have attained an advanced stage of education, but
most of whom have little or no prospect of being able to carry it to the
university stage is sufficient in itself amply to justify the setting up of the
scheme. The number of candidates among those who applied as children of miners
who had already qualified to enter on degree courses was over 500.
There was no district which did not provide a candidate, but South Wales and
Monmouthshire provided an exceptionally large number of both "A"
(working miner) and "B" (children of miner) classes, even having
regard to the proportion of the mining, population of the country living in
that coalfield.
As regards the degree courses which the applicants desired to follow and the
careers they aimed at, a considerable proportion of the miner candidates wished
to study subjects connected with mining industry as inspectors of mines, mining
engineers, or colliery managers, but only about 1 per cent. of the
"B" candidates had this object in view, more than half of them
wishing to become teachers in secondary schools.
After a process of careful scrutiny of every individual case, which, in view of
the number of applications, was a long and difficult task, the Selection
Committee selected 59 applicants to attend in London for a personal interview,
the candidates chosen being from 13 different districts, and eventually 11
scholarships were awarded. Two of these were for the University of Oxford, two
for Armstrong College (University of Durham), and one each for the Universities
of Cambridge, Birmingham, London, and Sheffield, and the University Colleges at
Aberystwyth, Bangor and Cardiff. Four of the successful candidates came from
South Wales and Monmouth, two from Durham, and one each from Lanark, North
Derby, North Wales, Nottingham, and South Yorkshire.
Special Grants for Education.
The Committee have, from time to time, received applications from individuals
for special grants to enable them to complete their higher education, and they
decided to devote a sum not exceeding £500 a year to the purpose of
giving some assistance to young miners, or children of miners, who, as a result
of great sacrifice, had managed to enter on a promising university career, but
found themselves without the means to complete it. Six special grants to the
amount of £320 were made during the year; all but two of the recipients
had been competitors for Miners' Welfare Scholarships and were recommended by
the Selection Committee of the Scholarship Scheme.
It has been the experience of the Selection Committee that there are numerous
instances of such hard cases and the suggestion that district welfare
committees might well consider supplementing the provision made by themselves
setting aside a small annual sum from their district funds to be devoted to
such cases as the Selection Committee recommended has already been adopted in
some districts. It is probable that nearly all the young people concerned will
be candidates under the scholarship scheme and that their circumstances will
thus come under close review. It is not proposed that the special grants shall
be regarded as consolation prizes to those who just fail to win the major
awards, but that they shall be determined mainly by the personal need of the
prospective recipients.
District Proportions.
In a reference to the proportion of candidates from each district in relation
to persons employed, South Wales, the Lanark group of counties, Northumberland
and North Wales, are cited as showing up most prominently. The proportion from
South Wales was exceptional, due, the Committee is inclined to think, rather to
the facilities for university education than to the exceptional merit of the
instruction in that district. They say it seems probable that the comparative
ease with which entry on degree courses in the University of Wales may be
effected stimulates the students in that country, both adult and juvenile, to
aim at a university career, and this, combined with the cheapness of a
university training there, results in an exceptional number of undergraduates
who are miners or the children of miners, compared with the numbers in England
or even in Scotland, where costs are also small but entrance is more difficult,
it may be observed that the necessity for taking a language other than English
at a matriculation examination, which so often proves a stumbling block to the
English or Scottish working class student, is less of an obstacle in Wales,
where the language taken may be Welsh. Some of the districts provided fewer
candidates than might have been expected from the size of their coal-mining
populations. Lancashire and Cheshire sent only half their proportionate number,
and Derbyshire (excluding South Derby) only one-third. In both cases the
deficit was almost equally divided between the "A" and "B"
candidates. Nottingham and Warwick also supplied less than one-half their
shares on a mining population basis, and South and West Yorkshire considerably
less than theirs. On a superficial view it might be supposed that the number of
candidates from a district reflected the condition of education there, but the
committee hesitate to accept that explanation seeing among the districts
sending fewest candidates in proportion to their mining populations, were some
of the most progressive in the matter of education. It is worthy of note,
however, that all the districts which sent an exceptionally large number of
candidates happen to he amongst those where unemployment is particularly great,
and also that the number of "A" candidates from each district was
more or less in inverse ratio to the degree of organisation of mining education
there.
The number of candidates with ambitions to follow what used to be known as
"the learned professions" was very small, only 12 desiring to become
doctors, five ministers of religion, and two lawyers. One candidate aspired to
become a Member of Parliament, while two wished to be captains of ships. The
great majority of the candidates desiring to take economics aimed at becoming
adult education workers. The fact that no less than 498 wished to qualify as
mining engineers, while the majority of the 178 who wished for degrees in other
branches of engineering and the 146 who merely specified the degree of B.Sc. as
their objective, were also proposing to remain in the industry, indicates that
there are still a very large number of workers who have faith in the future of
coal-mining in this country.
Interesting Personal Letters.
The personal letters of the candidates were found by the Committee to be
exceedingly interesting and provided very valuable evidence for and against the
candidates' applications. The average standard of those written by
"A" candidates was much higher than that of those from "B"
candidates, the former having, of course, the advantage generally speaking, of
wider fields of experience and more definitely formed characters. Examining the
report more closely, the following notes of the Committee on the personal
letters may be of more than passing interest:
Even from a purely literary point of view there were several really good
descriptions of scenery and of village or town surroundings, and many
candidates showed a genuine sense of humour. Certain points particularly
impressed the Committee by the frequency with which they came across them. The
first was the appreciation shown by the candidates of the sacrifices made by
their parents to provide them with an education, and the anxiety on the part of
their parents to do so. Again and again such expressions were met as "I
know that my father and mother have gone short of a good many things they
needed in order that I might get a good education," and among the aims and
aspirations of the candidates a foremost place was usually given to
"repaying my parents for all they have done for me." One girl's
particular ambition was to get her father out of the pit and settle him in a
little farm of his own. The Committee unfortunately found many instances of
parents who had saved money for their children to go to a secondary school or
even (in Wales) a university, and had been obliged to use all or part of the
savings to keep their home going during the long stoppage. There was one case,
however, where a miner who had only been employed for 12 months in the last 21
years, was actually paying for his son's university education..
Obstacles Surmounted.
The second point that particularly impressed the Committee was the very
difficult conditions under which many miners and their children have to study,
and the keenness for instruction which is shown by the way in which these
obstacles are surmounted. In Scotland particularly, it is no uncommon thing for
a university undergraduate to travel backwards and forwards twenty miles a day
or more, and to be obliged to do his study at home in the single living room of
the apartment where his family lives in company with half-a-dozen or more
younger brothers and sisters. Some applicants stated that they worked on the
night shift and attended whole-time courses by day. Others mentioned the
difficulty they had in concentrating after a hard day's work in the pit, often
finding themselves falling asleep over their books. Others, again, who could
not attend classes because they clashed with their hours of work studied
privately or took correspondence lessons. Some, too, had succeeded in winning
scholarships for day courses at various institutions which they were unable to
take up owing to the necessity for supporting dependents. There were cases
where the writer stated that he had been the family wage-earner at thirteen or
fourteen years of age, his father being dead and his mother unable to work,
with possibly several younger children in the household. The success that is
achieved by so many of those who work under these handicaps is highly
creditable to them.
Another point mentioned in connection with the personal letters: is the wide
and varied reading which many of the applicants appear to have done. One man
actually stated that he himself possessed some 1,000 volumes and another that
he had read 288 books from the local library in one year. The nature of the
books in these two cases was not, however, specified. It may be of interest to
mention that at the personal interviews, when candidates were asked What
authors they read for relaxation, it appeared that Scott and
Dickens have still a large number of readers in the coalfields and the
modern writers whose names were most frequently mentioned were H. G. Wells
and Bernard Shaw.
Safety in Mines.
The purely social and recreational side of the Miners' Welfare Fund, in its
earlier years and according to the evidence presented to the ordinary onlooker,
may have seemed to absorb an undue amount of the energy of the central
committee as well as the district committees, but plans were being discussed
and developed in committee ensuing the widest interpretation of the section Of
the Mining Industry Act constituting the Fund for "purposes connected with
the social well-being, recreation and conditions of living of workers in or
about coal mines and with mining education and research." The health and
safety of the worker as well as his educational advancement are matters to
which from a very practical standpoint more attention is being devoted. Much of
the work may not as yet have passed the foundation stage, but there may be
sufficient evidence to show that, as the funds increase with the extension of
the levy, the rank and file of the pits will secure advantages and benefits
undreamt of a decade or so ago.
It may be instanced that the fund admitted of a mining education conference
being held at Buxton last year, three important results of which were (a) the
formation of a fully representative national body of mining organisers and
full-time teachers ; (b) a resolution recommending that assistance be given
from the district funds to help necessitous part-time students ; (c) the
drafting of proposals for amending the regulations governing examinations
leading to certificates of competency under the Coal Mines Act.
The opening of the research station at Buxton was another important event.
Arrangements are being made so that workers in the industry may have an
opportunity of becoming more closely acquainted with the methods and results of
the research work being undertaken. According to proposals, summaries will be
issued, written in simple language, of the reports issued by the Research
Board, and these summaries will be circulated to all local welfare committees.
Then again the Buxton research station is open to periodical visits of
representative parties of mine workers when demonstrations are given, affording
an opportunity for friendly discussion and intercourse between the research
workers and mine workers.
Another method finding favour whereby general interest in the work may be
encouraged, takes the form of popular lectures in which the more important
results will be simply explained and illustrated with experiments or lantern
slides. In connection with this the co-operation of the education authorities
has been sought in order that the services of organisers and teachers may be
available. Already in Lancashire steps have been taken to put this suggestion
into practical operation, and members of the staff of the Wigan Mining College
have been giving experimental demonstrations in schools and institutes at
Abram, Ashton-in-Makerfield, Hindley, Orrell, and Pemberton. The demonstrations
took the form of a series of graded experiments, with the result that the
interest of the audience was maintained throughout the evening, and questions
were asked relating to various points, leading to some of the experiments being
repeated to emphasise their importance. At all the halls large attendances were
reported, and there is much satisfaction at the degree of success attending the
effort. The enthusiasm of the men was most marked by their attendance on one or
two of the evenings notwithstanding the unpropitious weather. The first series
of experiments was given last month and dealt with "Mine Gases,"
special reference being made to firedamp and flame safety-lamp. The second
series, advertised to commence on 1st March, was on "The Use of
Electricity in Mines," the experiments indicating the dangers likely to
arise and how those dangers are surmounted. Managers and men, together with the
Secretaries of the Local Education Authorities and Headmasters of the Schools,
are to be congratulated upon their co-operative measures ensuring the
encouraging results that have accrued. The lecturers themselves felt fully
repaid for their efforts to make the demonstrations popular by inquiries from
men at the meetings who wanted to know "When are you coming back
again."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Dickens, Charles | | Author | |
| Scott, Walter | | Author | |
| Shaw, Bernard | | Author | |
| Wells, H. G. | | Author | |