Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

10th March 1928, Page: 260, Column: 1

Miners' Nystagmus

By Dr. R. J. Perring*.

The middle third of the nineteenth century saw numerous references in medical literature to a new disease occurring in miners, whose eyes, to quote one observer, "from swelling of the lids appear small, are intolerant of light, and many, after a few years trial, are obliged, by reason of the injury which their health has sustained, and especially by weakness of their eyes, to leave the mine. The passage of the intervening years has seen the birth of many theories as to its cause. To mention some of the more prominent, the view of Snell in 1875 should be mentioned that the disease is due to the constrained position at work combined with upward direction of vision; that of Needen who added to this, lack of light; of Nisel, who conceded these factors, but added the crystalline fracture of the coal. The Oxford Opthalmological Congress and the findings of the Miners' Nystagmus Committee are unanimous us to defective illumination being the chief cause.

No information as to its prevalence is available prior to 1907, when nystagmus was added to the Workmen's Compensation Act, hut since that year the number of cases receiving compensation has steadily risen. A marked increase in the number of cases notified occurred on the alteration of the original definition. For example: in 1908, the number of cases was 386, and the cost £13,000. In 1920, the number was 2,865, and the cost £343,000. The average output per man per annum fell from 334 tons to 235 tons in this interval. (Miners' nystagmus became an economic problem of considerable magnitude). It is obvious what a serious economic loss the disease is: To the worker the transition from the happy independence of an active bread-winning existence to a life dependent on weekly compensation entailing the loss of home comforts. To the Coal Company and to the State comes the pecuniary loss due to compensation — the loss of the best workmen — with its consequent decrease in coal output, which is reflected in an increased cost of production of commodities in other industries.

The types of cases met with may he roughly divided into two classes: first, the latent in which oscillation is present (though the miner is unaware of this) and there is no disability; second, the manifest. This group could be sub-divided according to the severity of the disease, e.g., the slight case where but little incapacity is present, the ordinary where the man can do work on the bank but is obliged to give up underground work, and that group of unfortunates where complete incapacity is present.

One of the most characteristic signs of the disease is the failure of what is known as the "dark adaptation" sense. Its invariable constancy would provide much room for speculation as to bow far any innate deficiency of this dark adaptation sense might predispose to the disease. All of you are aware of the helplessness experienced on first leaving daylight and entering a cinema. The stairs are not where they ought to be — the rows of seats are a confused blur. In a few moments, however, the ball becomes lighter, dark objects appear out of the shadows and take form — one can almost see the pattern on the carpet. This is the nominal functioning of the dark adaptation sense. The same condition of affairs obtains down the pit, and a severe case of nystagmus may even have to be led to the coal-face by his companions. Once there, he may work to the satisfaction of the officials.

Loss of sight, headache and dizziness form a triad of symptoms rarely absent.

From the mass of data at one's disposal, one fact is pro-eminent, and that is that 81.5 per cent. of cases are coal face workers. All classes of underground workers are affected, and it is not confined to the coal-getter. Among 2,000 cases it was found that 1,731 were from colliers and timbermen — both cases of workers whose work was of a definitely skilled nature — workers who were compelled to use their eyes for the satisfactory carrying out of their job. The light at the coal face was notoriously bad. Was there then any relationship between these two factors? The connection between the two seems to lead through a maze of apparently contradictory evidence. The incidence is low in Scotland, and in the naked light districts of the Forest of Dean and of Somerset. In North Staffordshire, Yorkshire, and Cumberland where safety-lamps are the rule, it is high. In America, where either naked lights or electric cap lamps prevail, the disease is almost unknown, while the safety-lamp districts of France, Germany and Belgium show a relatively high case rate. Of the 2,000 eases mentioned 1,951 had worked with safety-lamps almost entirely; 35 with candles and safety-lamps, and 14 with candles alone. This would suggest that the relatively poor illumination of the safety-lamp was more detrimental to the eyes than the illumination of the candle.

Illumination at the coal face, however, is dependent on several factors. There is the candle-power of the source of illumination. There is the distance from the face at which the light must be placed, for "the intensity of illumination" varies inversely with the square of the distance from the source of light.

Thirdly, there is the surface brightness of the surrounding objects, which, by the nature of things, is particularly small. There is the ventilation of the area. The poorer the ventilation the smaller the percentage of oxygen in the surrounding atmosphere, and consequently the poorer light emitted from the lamp or candle. The damper the air the less brightly will a lamp burn, while a dust-laden atmosphere absorbs more light than a clear one.

From the figures given, it appears obvious that the safety-lamp has some connection with the underlying cause. The necessity for the use of safety-lamps is the presence of firedamp, or to give it its more scientific name, " methane." Has this abnormality anything to do with the disease? The possibility must, at any rate, be considered. Professor Haldane, physiologist and chemist of the highest rank, has answered our question with an emphatic "no." All physiological effects of the inhalation of firedamp go, as far as is known, to show that it acts like the nitrogen of the air, merely as a diluent, and that any effects produced from its respiration are due to a dilution of the oxygen by the firedamp. In proof of this, he personally inhaled a mixture of 80 per cent. pure methane and 20 per cent. oxygen, and observed nothing abnormal. A mouse subjected to the same conditions for a considerable period was unharmed. Any dilution of the atmospheric oxygen and excess of carbon dioxide can be definitely excluded, as these are greater in the nystagmus-free naked light pits than in the infected safety-lamp pits.

The other gaseous abnormality we must consider is carbon monoxide, produced by the slow oxidation of the coal at atmospheric pressure. Again, as far as is known, like nitrogen or firedamp, it acts merely as adiluent. Carbon monoxide poisoning is a fairly common clinical entity, e.g., in ordinary coal gas poisoning most of the trouble is caused by the power that the carbon monoxide has of combining with the oxygen-bearing blood pigment haemoglobin to form a relatively stable compound known as carboxy-haemoglobin. This, of course, reduces the oxygen-carrying capacity of the blood-the tissues are starved of the oxygen essential for their existence and they succumb.

Professor Haldane placed two warm blooded animals in pure oxygen at two atmospheres pressure and then forced in carbon monoxide until the pressure was raised by another atmosphere, This gas has an even greater affinity for haemoglobin than has oxygen, so that the blood of these animals was completely saturated with carbon monoxide, but with the enormous pressure of oxygen present the animals could still carry on unharmed. One interesting fact should be mentioned, and that is that some cases of acute carbon monoxide poisoning produce mental symptoms and a lateral nystagmus — a condition which must not be confused with the rotatory nystagmus of miners. We may therefore definitely conclude, I think, that abnormal atmospheric conditions have no direct bearing on the subject.

No discussion on the casual factor of any disease would be complete without some reference to that very popular beverage, alcohol. Alcoholic drinks in their many forms have been blamed in the past for the production of most troubles, and miners' nystagmus has not escaped. In this country since 1914 the low alcohol content of beer (I mention beer in particular, as it is undoubtedly the most popular drink) and its comparative dearness have led to a diminished consumption-the nystagmus rate during this period has not fallen ; rather has it increased. It is unlikely (I should think) that alcohol has anything more than a secondary effect on the production of nystagmus. As is usual, of course, other things being equal, the alcoholic fares worse than his more sober brother.

The question of heredity predisposition to the disease is interesting, although the figures at our disposal show no obvious influence. Of course, in mining communities, the sons as a rule follow their fathers' occupation and cases in the same family would occur according to the law of averages.

Dr. A. H. Pooley, an Ophthalmic Specialist and Member of the Nystagmus Committee, has done a considerable amount of work with a view to determining the presence or absence of any relationship between visual acuity and miners' nystagmus. He concluded that there is no such relationship ; that defective vision does not predispose to the disease nor is the duration of incapacity protracted on that account. Miners with nystagmus are as a rule more comfortable when wearing spectacles which correct their error of reflection. His figures show that the standard of visual acuity among miners is somewhat lower than that of men in other occupations — the percentage of miners with a high degree of myopia (i.e., short-sightedness) is 5, compared with 1.3 in ordinary workmen.

Those who have seen numbers of cases of miners' nystagmus have invariably been struck by the abnormal mental condition exhibited by quite a large percentage of them, a mental condition made up of unnatural anxieties, forebodings, depression and unpleasant dreams — a syndrome whose exact relationship to the disease in question it is not easy to define — a collection of symptoms in every way comparable to that exhibited by the shell-shocked soldier. I mention this condition as it will be found in most of those cases where the disability has been protracted for a period exceeding twelve months. With the nystagmic miner being unable to fix objects properly, to strike with his pick the piece of coal aimed at, his confidence wanes, a sense of danger prevails, and suitable ground for the production of a psycho-neurosis develops. That fear is the underlying factor is shown by the terrifying nature of his dreams, for it is a well-known fact that emotions repressed in the waking state find expression when mental control is removed in sleep. It would seem that in a proportion of cases, this psycho-neurosis is consequent on the nystagmus. Unfortunately this class of case is not clearly defined, for all types of workers are liable to nervous breakdowns. Where do the symptoms of nystagmus disappear and those of psycho-neurosis begin? It is impossible to give a definite answer. Each case has to be judged on its own merits and judgment given accordingly.

The conclusion of the Nystagmus Committee is that the cause of the disease is defective illumination, and the facts on which this conclusion is based are given. It seems to me that one cannot ignore these facts. For the most part, they are hard to gainsay, though one cannot be dogmatic, as there are the cases which have been aggravated from a passive to an active stage by improved lighting. A possible explanation is that the glare of an electric lamp acting on an oculo motor apparatus already distressed by long periods of work and in bad lighting conditions becomes the proverbial straw to break the camel's back.

According to some observers, there are cases which have developed nystagmus, although they have not been exposed to poor illumination, e.g., workers on the bank. I can offer no explanation of these. They are, doubtless, rare, but they seem to establish that defective illumination is not the only cause of the disease.

As regards preventive measures, Haldane and Llewellyn in an address before the Institution of Mining Engineers, say: The lamp-room installation should be regarded as primary machinery and as much care spent on the purchase of a suitable lamp as on a large turbine engine. The head lamp-man should be highly paid and have had a special training in the repair and maintenance of all kinds of lamps. The attendants should be capable men. Each lamp should be periodically tested against a standard lamp or candle and set aside if it falls below a certain reading. Workmen should be encouraged to report any defect of their lamps. Every effort should be made to help men get their sight. The pit bottom and roads should be whitewashed as far in-bye as possible and made easy for travelling. Every miner should carry a piece of tin or cardboard and place it at the back of his lamp to prevent the light causing inconvenience to 'those following. This rule should be made absolute and fines imposed for its breach."

The provision of suitable work has an important influence on the recovery rate of sufferers. Men allowed to remain idle rapidly deteriorate in morale — one has to look no further than those who for long periods have been in receipt of unemployment benefit.

There is a popular, but quite erroneous, belief that cases of nystagmus may ultimately become blind, Nystagmus has never been known to cause blindness.

In conclusion, as to what nystagmus is, its origin, its cure, it is impossible to speak with certainty, as medical science and the researches of many earnest thinkers have not proved anything conclusively. We can only speak in terms of what is probable, and the conclusions to which one is driven are (1) That nystagmus is primarily associated with defective illumination, and that its prevention is in the hands of the colliery management, and (2) that the cure depends on finding the sufferer congenial occupation, and in this connection bringing a healthy influence to bear on the sufferer's psychology.


* From paper prepared by Dr. Perring, before the February meeting of the Associates and Students Section of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Haldane, John Scott, Professor      Whos Who Page
Llewellyn, —      
Needen, —      
Nisel, —      
Perring, R. J., Dr.      
Pooley, A. H., Dr.      
Snell, —      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print