|
25th February 1928, Page: 244, Column: 1 Mining Electrical ResearchFrom the Mines Department we recently received copies of the Safety in Mines Research Board Paper No. 38 (H.M. Stationery Office, 1s. 6d. net), and Paper No. 39 (H.M. Stationery Office, 9d. net). The papers deal with experimental work carried out by Mr. G. Allsop and Dr. R. V. Wheeler, No. 38 relating to the Pressures Produced on Blowing Electric Fuse Links, and No. 39 to the Pressures Produced by Electric Ares in Closed Vessels. Paper No. 38 is in three parts, the first relating to the experiments with direct current, the second recording the alternating current experiments, and the third those on the blowing of fuses in an explosive mixture of methane and air. The Authors explain that a fusible cut-out is the most common form of protection against circuit overloads for low-power and low-voltage supplies of electricity. In mining practice, such fuse links are installed within flameproof enclosures which either are capable of withstanding the pressure developed on explosion of the most inflammable mixture of firedamp and air, or are so constructed that release of pressure is effected without allowing the passage of the flame of the explosion to the external atmosphere. When a fuse link is blown within a closed vessel containing an explosive mixture of firedamp and air, pressure may be developed additional to that due to the firedamp explosion, owing to the energy liberated on blowing the fuse link. The object of the work described in the paper has been to measure the maximum value of any such pressure under different conditions, more particularly as regards the magnitude and character (i.e., direct or alternating) of the current interrupted on the blowing of the fuse link. The method of experiment was, briefly, to blow the fuse link within a closed vessel of known volume to which a continuously recording pressure-gauge was attached. The majority of the experiments were made with fuse links of tinned copper, as these are most commonly employed, the chief variables of which the effects were studied being the volume of the fuse-box and the gauge of wire. Comparative experiments were made with fuse links of zinc and of tin. The effect of placing the fuse-box (and the fuse link within it) vertically or horizontally was also studied. In their general summary the Authors say that "in interpreting the results from a practical standpoint, the limitations imposed by the small amount of power employed must be borne in mind, as much heavier currents than those used for most of the tests are liable to flow when a cut-out operates in service. "A comparison of the results obtained in the many series of parallel experiments with alternating and direct currents shows that fuse links used as protection on alternating-current systems do not give rise to such high pressures when blown as do fuse links of the same capacity on direct-current circuits. "The alternating-current arc formed on the fusion of the wire is much less stable than the direct-current arc. This is due to the reversal of potential every half cycle. The conducting path has to be maintained during the period over which the voltage is below the arcing potential, failing which the arc is not re-formed. "It appears that the mechanical pressure accompanying transient arcs in closed vessels such as are produced when fuse links are blown, is almost entirely due to metal vapour. The magnitude of the pressure varies directly with the energy released during arcing. Any means of reducing the energy of the arc therefore automatically reduces the pressure developed. For this reason, very small fuse-boxes, having relatively large cooling surfaces, are effective in reducing the pressure that a blown fuse can give, as are also cartridge fuses. From a practical standpoint, however, reduction of the volume of the fuse-box is probably unsuitable for semi-enclosed cut-outs, as it might lead to 'failure' of the cut-out by arcing to the case, when a heavy overload occurred. "Tin fuse links yielded lower pressures than copper under all conditions of experiment, and zinc fuse links lower pressures than tin. The arcing with tin and zinc fuse links is not so severe as with copper because the former metals melt and run at low temperatures compared with that at which copper melts. "When a fuse link is blown in an explosive mixture of methane and air, the burning of the gas tends to reduce the period of arcing (over the range of power used in the experiments — i.e., 210 volts d.c. and currents up to 180 amps.). It also appears that ignition of the gas does not start until the fuse link has been melted and arcing has commenced, so that compression of the gas before ignition cannot occur in the true sense, though if the rate of rise of pressure due to the blowing of the fuse link is much greater than that due to the explosive mixture, some effect due to this cause may be possible. In the present tests the time taken by the pressure due to the blowing of the fuse link to reach its maximum was greater (0.2 to 0.67 sec.) than that taken by the explosive mixture (0.09 sec), and no effects due to initial compression were observed. It follows from this difference in the rates of pressure rise that the maximum pressures observed were not the sum of the pressures due separately to the fuse link and the gas explosion. "The tests further showed that the rate of rise of pressure due to the blowing of the fuse link increases with increasing blowing current, and, to study the effect of a more rapid rate of pressure rise due to this cause, an extension of the tests using currents up to about 10,000 amps, is under consideration." Referring now to paper No. 39 on electric arcs in closed vessels, Messrs. Allsop and Wheeler in their introduction say that flameproof casings for mining electrical apparatus are often provided with some form of pressure-release, such as gaps at flanged joints, through which the flame of no explosive mixture of firedamp and air is capable of passing. In most instances such devices afford only a partial release of pressure, whilst sometimes the casing is purposely constructed with as tight joints as possible (in an endeavour to render them dust-tight) and no form of pressure release is fitted. Apart from the pressure produced by the explosion of any firedamp-air mixture that may exist within the casing, it is possible that high pressures may arise due to arcing, during switching operations or through the blowing of fusible cut-outs. It is therefore important to know the probable magnitude of any pressure that may be produced in this way, and the conditions under which its production is most likely. This report deals with the pressures due to electric arcs formed between metallic electrodes. It is conceivable that any such development of pressure might be either momentary, in the form of a pressure-wave created by an exceedingly rapid change in the density of the medium in which the arc is struck, or sustained through the continuous heating of that medium. The effect of the suddenly applied pressure of a wave may be more destructive than that of a pressure of the same magnitude applied comparatively slowly. Previously published work on this subject is scanty and indefinite. The production of a pressure-wave when a disruptive discharge, e.g., a spark from an induction-coil, is passed in air was demonstrated by Topler in 1867. A disruptive discharge occurs when the potential difference between two electrodes is sufficient to cause disruption of the dielectric between them. A sustained arc does not necessarily follow a disruptive discharge. Arcing under oil causes "cracking" of the liquid hydrocarbons, with the production of hydrogen and gaseous hydrocarbons which, mingling with the air above the oil, form inflammable mixtures. The ignition of such mixtures would cause a high pressure within the enclosure of oil-immersed switch-gear. Apart from this, the phenomena of arcing in air and under oil appear to have much in common. The following conclusions can be drawn from the experiments :— (1) With direct current up to 200 amps, and voltages up to 250, no detectable pressure-wave was set up on arcing in a 1½-inch diameter cylinder, as determined both by a delicate manometer and by the Schlieren method of photography. With direct current of 1,350 amps, at 575 volts no pressure wave was detected by a manometer situated 6 inches from the arc. The Schlieren method was not tried. The pressure developed by arcing within an air-filled switch casing appears to be due to the heating effect of the arc and is mainly caused by the vaporisation of metal. In the tests made, the pressure appears to be dependent on the total watt-seconds of arc energy but the exact relationship, cannot be determined from the data available. (2) Up to the limit of power used in these experiments (1,350 amps, at 575 volts) no dangerous pressure will be produced in apparatus by arcs, provided an adequate circuit-breaker is in the system. If the arcing be prolonged owing to failure of the circuit-breaker to operate, dangerous pressures may be produced. A ¾-inch arc holding for about half a second gave rise to a pressure of nearly 140 ft. per square inch. (3) With the same power and the same voltages, it is clear that arcing in alternating current circuits is much less severe than in direct current systems. Any danger due to pressure as the result of arcing is in consequence much less with alternating than with direct current.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||