25th February 1928, Page: 242, Column: 1
Coke As Household Fuel
Summary of report by Mr. R. E. Gilmore and others in
"Investigations of Fuels and Fuel Testing, 1925," issued by the Mines
Branch, Department of Mines, Canada :—
(1) A total of 30 typical cokes comprising 20 samples of by-product coke, seven
of gas coke, and three samples of foundry coke were examined for the main
purpose of determining their comparative qualities as household fuels. In
addition to the usual proximate analyses, special chemical analyses were made
and attention paid to their comparative general characteristics.
(2) Proximate analyses along with the determination of the calorific values
were carried out on all the samples, followed by ultimate analyses on 16
representative cokes. The fusibility of ash and apparent density determinations
were made on most of the samples in addition to which their general
characteristics in respect to appearance, size, apparent density, and
comparative handling qualities were examined and reported, the latter tests
being applied to differentiate between the gas cokes made in retort and the
by-product cokes made in ovens.
(3) The ash contents varied from 6½ to 13 per cent., the average of 18 of
the by-product cokes being roughly 7½ per cent., which, in comparison with
anthracite, is not materially higher than the ash content of Welsh anthracite
and only a little over half that of the higher-ash Pennsylvania anthracites on
the market.
(4) The calorific values of the cokes with one exception varied from slightly
under 12,000 to nearly 13,500 B.T.U. per lb. on the as-received basis, with an
average of 18 of the lower-ash cokes of roughly 13,000 B.T.U. The calorific
values on the dry, ash-free basis varied from slightly under 14,000 to nearly
14,500, the average being 14,200. From this latter value, knowing the dry-basis
ash content, the calorific value of a given coke may be calculated to within
plus or minus 200 B.T.U. or so.
(5) The relation of the ash contents of the cokes examined to their respective
calorific values, in comparison with this relation for anthracites, is
discussed. A coke must have 2 per cent. less ash along with 2 per cent. less
moisture to equal the average Pennsylvania anthracite in respect to calorific
value. In this connection the cokes showed up to advantage in that the average
ash of 28 domestic cokes was 4½ per cent. lower than the average ash for
the anthracite just referred to.
(6) In respect to ash fusibility, most of the cokes tested came in Class 2,
viz., with ashes of medium fusibility — 2,200 to 2,600 deg. Fah. Four of
the gas cokes and one by-product coke were in Class 1, i.e., above 2,600 deg.
Fah., in the same class as Pennsylvania anthracite, while four of the (Besco)
by-product cokes were in Class 3, viz., below 2,200 deg. Fah. The ash content
of these latter cokes, however, was sufficiently low to assure non-clinkering
burning qualities at ordinary rates of burning.
(7) Screen analyses using standard laboratory screens showed considerable
non-uniformity in the cokes with the same size designation. The importance of
the stove size for coke to correspond roughly with that for anthracite was
stressed and the selection of standard screen sizes most suitable in the
laboratory for the dividing lines, between the egg, stove, nut and pea sizes is
discussed.
(8) The results of chemical analyses failed to distinguish between the gas
cokes and by-product cokes in general, and between the cokes of different
structures and densities in these two classes. The use of a standard
tumbling-test method in conjunction with a modified shatter test did, however,
serve to differentiate between a gas coke and a by-product coke having similar
apparent densities.
(9) For the shatter test on the domestic sizes 20-lb. samples of 1- to 2-in.
lumps were dropped four times according to the usual practice for foundry coke,
the amounts remaining on ¾-in., ½-in. and 35-mesh screens indicating
the comparative friability of the different cokes tested. This test is
suggested for showing the comparative handling qualities of the different kinds
of coke.
(10) Three different formulae for calculating the calorific value from the
ultimate analyses were tried and a choice indicated. The use of 14,220 B.T.U.
per lb., the heat of combustion of graphite (crystallised) carbon, instead of
14,540 for amorphous carbon, was found to give results that checked the
determined calorific values quite closely. For seven samples where the
calculated value checked the determined to within 50 B.T.U., the calorific
values on the dry, ash-free basis varied from about 14,000 to nearly 14,500
B.T.U. per lb. This variation, as was expected, was found to bear a definite
relation to the hydrogen content in the dry coke, which in turn varied directly
with the volatile matter. Knowing the volatile matter content of the dry coke,
therefore, a dry, ash-free value may be assumed from which the calorific value
of a given coke, the ash and moisture content of which is known, may be
calculated to give values correct within practical limits.
(11) The use of the temperatures up to 950 deg. C. for the ash determination of
cokes, as recommended by the American Society for Testing Materials, in
preference to 700 to 750 deg. C, as recommended for coals is criticised. The
ash results in the proximate analyses of ten representative cokes using a
maximum temperature of 950 deg. C. were consistently lower than those at 700 to
750 deg. C, whereas the ash results in the ultimate analyses of the same cokes
were consistently higher than at the proximate analyses lower range just
mentioned. The possible errors in the volatile matter determinations due to
oxidation or combustion of the (fixed) carbon, as well as moisture changes in
the pulverised laboratory samples, are also discussed.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Gilmore, R. E. | | | |