25th February 1928, Page: 252, Column: 1
Safety And Health In Mining
By Sir Robert N. Kotze.
[In his presidential address before the Chemical, Metallurgical and Mining
Society of South Africa, Sir Robert N. Kotze, late Government Mining
Engineer of the Union, surveyed the history in South Africa of legislation
intended to secure safety and health in mining operations. The address is given
in full in the Journal of the Society, from which some general remarks are
reproduced.]
Mining is in all parts of the world recognised as a dangerous occupation and
certain branches of it are also unhealthy. Part of the danger is inherent. We
have to deal with natural forces which are difficult to control under
circumstances where ignorance or negligence means loss of life or limb. The
only way to stop accidents completely in mining and the only way to eliminate
entirely such diseases as miners' phthisis, is to stop mining. If one looks at
the probable history and development of mining, there was a time no doubt when
all mining was individual. In the beginning the miner owned bis mine and worked
it himself. This stage could, however, hardly ever have carried mining beyond
the stage of small surface workings. As soon as underground operations became
necessary the ownership must have vested in chiefs or men of means, who had
slaves, paid servants and artisans and other resources at their disposal, and
this stage gradually merged into the conditions we have to-day. When the
individual worked his mine with his own hands only, any risks he ran were his
own concern and he did as he liked. But as soon as the owner began to use the
labour of others, an entirely different situation arose. Even if the owner
shared the risk by continuing to work in the mine himself, he also exposed the
lives of others to danger. If these others were free men, one might say tbey
could please themselves whether they undertook the work and ran the risk. If
the pay was high they were no doubt prepared to run great risks. But the case
of slaves and prisoners was different. They had no choice and were compelled to
face dangers to swell the profits of the owner. The injustice of this was
apparently felt at an early date, and a public conscience sometimes intervened
long before there was any code of mining law. Thus we read of a mine owner
being punished in Athens because he allowed insufficient support in his mine.
He no doubt was too keen on turning all his ore into profit and would not allow
any of it to remain as pillars.
The present codes of mining laws in civilised countries are of quite recent
growth and do not go back more than 100 years. They are largely a result of the
solicitude for the welfare and for the just treatment of the nation's workers
which has been one of the principal effects of modern democratic government,
even although the lead for the reform may have been directly given by
individuals belonging to the enlightened classes. Thus, in England, the first
safety mining code was the law of 1842. In the year before Lord Shaftesbury
had succeeded in securing the appointment of a Royal
Commission, whose report exposed the appalling conditions under which the mine
workers of Great Britain worked. The public conscience was aroused and the law
of 1842 at once brought about a great improvement. Prior to that date the coal
mines were worked under conditions which entailed enormous physical suffering
and moral degradation on the mine workers, many of whom were children of tender
age and women, working under conditions which to us to-day appear almost
incredibly unhealthy, dangerous and loathsome. One reads of cases of little
children under ten years of age sitting for hours in dark and noisome places,
waiting to open the ventilation door for the miner, who now and then came along
with his loaded truck of coal and whose voice and candle no doubt made a
welcome change for the little mite to the company of the rats in the dark. Let
us be thankful that we do not live in those times.
It might be said that the law of supply and demand sufficiently regulates the
question whether the conditions of the miner are good or not. If the pay and
the conditions are satisfactory men will take to mining, and if they are not,
men will adopt other occupations. But in practice it is not so. In the past it
has been found that many men are compelled by circumstances over which they
have no control, by their lack of opportunity, and by their ignorance of other
courses to adopt, to find employment which is badly paid or which is unsafe. In
all civilised states therefore the State has stepped in and made the conditions
more tolerable. It has even taken action in such a matter as compensation for
accidents and occupational disease. Here, particularly, it might be deemed that
the pay or wages should in itself suffice to enable the worker, not only to
meet his expenses, but also to insure against accident or disease. In practice,
however, it has been found that only the most highly paid classes of employees,
such as managers and higher officials, insured, while the workman, owing partly
to improvidence and partly to lack of means, neglected to do so. The State has
therefore intervened and compelled the employer to effect the insurance. There
is no doubt that if the employees were given the choice whether they would take
the money spent by the employer on insurance and compensation as an addition to
wages or leave it to be devoted to insurance, they would prefer to have it
added to their wages, but, fortunately for them and for everybody else, the
State does not permit the choice.
Finally, I may refer to the fundamental question whether an occupation which
unavoidably leads to loss of life should be permitted or not. In all
occupations involving the use of great natural forces or contact therewith, or
the employment of great artificial forces, such as those developed in
machinery, life will continue to be lost, even with the utmost precautions
against accidents. It may be asked why such occupations should not be
prohibited, since apparently they are merely carried on for providing profit
and, to put it bluntly, there can be no ethical justification for buying the
life of even a single individual with untold millions. But this view only
presents one aspect of the question. There are certain occupations that must be
carried on even though they cost lives. Mining for the indispensable minerals
is one of them. I need not now labour the point that civilisation is impossible
without metals, that indeed the greater portion of the human race would perish
of starvation if the supply of metals was completely cut off, since we cannot
perform most of the ordinary breadwinning operations without the use of metals,
and any large decrease in the food supply of the world must inevitably result
in a smaller population. As the metals have to be won, it is therefore
necessary that the dangerous occupation of winning them must continue. To put
it tersely, a few individuals have to perish to enable the many to live. This
is said in no spirit of callousness, but as a broad economic truth. It is
perhaps particularly striking in the case of the fishing industry, which
annually enacts its toll of life, but which directly furnishes a considerable
portion of the human race with food. No one would I think venture to suggest
that fishing should be prohibited because some fishermen are unavoidably
drowned every year.
But there is another even more vital issue at stake. To illustrate it, I may
take our principal branch of mining industry, the production of gold on the
Rand. Although gold serves a useful purpose in the world, and is indeed for the
moment indispensable, it cannot be maintained that the world could not have
done without it. Some substitute might conceivably have taken its place which
could have been won without the risks of life involved in gold mining. Let us,
for argument's sake, therefore grant that the gold which we are producing at
the cost of many lives annually is a nonessential element in the social
structure. Surely, it may be claimed, there is no justification for allowing it
to be won at the cost of human life. But the fact remains that the rest of the
human race is prepared to pay to the people who produce the gold the
wherewithal in food and other goods to provide life and the amenities of life
to a very large portion of its population. It was estimated by the Low Grade
Mines Commission of 1920 that the gold of the Rand furnished directly and
indirectly the means of livelihood for a quarter of a million white people and
a million natives in South Africa. To maintain this position about one person
per two thousand of these million and a quarter persons has annually to
sacrifice his life. Is this sacrifice too great ? I leave it to you and to the
community to give the final answer ; but my own view is that we have no reason
to be ashamed of the position we have attained. We certainly fall short of the
standard attained in the most enlightened European countries, but our accident
death-rate is better than it is in the United States and Australia, in spite of
the fact that 90 per cent. of our mine workers are ignorant natives only just
emerging from a state of barbarism. The recognition of the crude fact that some
have to die in order that the rest of us may live should only stimulate our
efforts to make mining safer and more healthy, so as to minimise the
unavoidable sacrifice.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Kotze, Robert N., Sir | | President | |
| Shaftesbury, —, Lord | | | |