Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

14th January 1928, Page: 196, Column: 1

Problem Of Underground Haulage Accidents

By A. M. Bryan, B.Sc, H.M.I.M.

[A summary of the first section of Mr. Bryan's paper before the Associates and Students' Section of the North of England Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers was given on page 178. Excerpts are appended from the concluding portion of the paper dealing with the causes of accidents, with a few suggestions for their elimination.]

Derailment. — The main causes of derailment are, bad permanent way, irregularly driven and badly maintained roadways, which make neither for safety nor efficiency. Many of the troubles are traceable to the light section rails so commonly used. Heavy section rails do not cost anything extra in upkeep after they are once bought; they do not bend so readily, and the advantages generally are very great indeed. Other points that merit attention are, the cleanliness and straightness of roadways, especially near the face ; the design of the tub and gauge of the rails with special regard to the stability of moving tubs ; the slow speed of haulage ; larger radius and properly laid curves ; more uniform grading of roadways ; the elimination of spragging, or where this is not practicable, reducing the necessity for this operation to a minimum by making the gradients as uniform and regular as possible ; proper maintenance of permanent way, and more frequent examination of tubs to reveal defects.

Crushed Between Tubs and Obstructions. — The obvious remedy for reducing the number of accidents from this cause is to get rid of the obstructions as far as is practicable and possible. The nature or cause of the obstruction varies. In some cases the defect lies in the smallness of the roadway itself, and can only be remedied by making larger roadways. This is largely an economic question, but I am convinced that there are many cases where the additional initial outlay in providing and maintaining a larger roadway would be more than repaid by the extra output obtained. In other cases the defect lies in the lack of uniformity either in the cross-section of the roadway or in the setting of artificial supports to the roof and sides. It is not an easy matter to preserve a regular cross-section in face roadways subject to heavy earth movements unless, perhaps, arched steel girders are used, but it is a fairly simple matter to see that supports are set in a regular and systematic manner, and to see that they are replaced as soon as necessary. Special care should be taken, especially on horse haulage roads where persons are permitted to ride on the limbers and in places where tubs are coupled and uncoupled or spragged, to maintain a safe clearance between the tubs and roof and sides, and to avoid as far as possible those sudden diminutions below the safe clearance which are the cause of so many of the accidents. It is also necessary to maintain a good width of road at all parts of a roadway where it is known that the driver must pass the set. This question of the size of roadway and uniformity of setting of supports depends largely on the method of working and system of support adopted. The best avenue to the solution of this aspect of the problem is by the adoption of a method of working which results in decreasing the number of loading points to a minimum and by using arched steel girders for the support of the roadways.

Contact with Moving Ropes. — The number of accidents in this group is higher than might be expected. These accidents were extremely varied in character. Points that merit attention are (1) the maintenance of straight roadways, thus avoiding curves and sheaves ; (2) the reduction of junctions to a minimum by the more intensive working of certain districts ; (3) the use of devices for making mechanical haulages and landings or sidings far more automatic in their working and so reducing the personnel and man-handling of tubs ; (4) the elimination of unnecessary slack rope ; and (5) the prohibition of persons travelling on haulage roads when ropes are in motion, or, better still, the provision of separate travelling roads altogether.

Uncertainty of Ponies. — Under this heading are included accidents due to ponies starting, stopping and crossing out when not expected, and to ponies stumbling, bolting or kicking. The most obvious remedy for this class of accident is the elimination of ponies wherever possible by the substitution of carefully planned mechanical haulage ; but since this is not always a practicable and economic solution, strict attention must be given to the proper training of ponies before and when commencing work underground, and to the proper training of the persons responsible for their handling. More attention might with advantage be given to the even condition of the floor between the rails to prevent the ponies from having to jerk so much.

Slow Moving Tubs Colliding. — The number of accidents arising from this cause points to inefficient control of tubs in shaft-sidings, landings and flats. The question of control of tubs in such places should receive more attention than it usually gets. There is far too much human interference or man-handling in this simple operation, which, in a great many cases could easily be done, and ought to be done, by a carefully planned combination of effective grading of the roadway and automatic tub stop-blocks or retarders, with or without power release according to circumstances, which can be operated from a position of safety clear of the moving tubs. Many accidents occurred to young boys when coupling or uncoupling tubs. Very often they are never instructed in the right way to do this simple job.

Stumbling. — The number of accidents due to persons stumbling clearly shows how important it is to maintain the floors of all roadways along which persons have to work or pass free from obstructions. The travelling ways at the side of haulage roads where persons are allowed to travel when sets are in motion merit special care. At one Durham colliery the travelling way at the side of the main endless-rope haulage plane is maintained at about 3 feet wide and is paved almost throughout.

Runaways. — So long as tubs run on gradients there will always be a danger of tubs running away sooner or later, and effective measures should be taken to guard against this danger before accidents occur. If persons are allowed to travel on inclined roads when tubs are in motion, they ought to be protected against runaways, and protection should always be provided against such a danger at or near places where haulage attendants have to work. For ascending tubs a good measure of protection is always afforded by the use of back-stays, and on ways used for ascending tubs only, protection can easily be afforded by the adoption of any of the well-known methods such as runaway switches, or stop-blocks, which allow the free passage of the ascending tubs but de-rail or stop descending tubs. Protection against descending tubs merits more attention than it receives at present. Where the haulage speeds are reasonably constant and low — and high speeds are seldom advisable — this can readily be achieved by the use of runaway tub catches of the rocking lever type, placed in the middle of the way, which operate only when the normal tub speed is largely exceeded. Perhaps the most common source of runaways is the failure to provide or use efficient protection at the tops of gravity inclines, whether worked by single rope or endless rope or chain, and at the dip end of flats, landings or sidings. It should be remembered that in all such places safety cannot be assured unless two effective stop-blocks — or other appliances serving the same purpose — are used, one in advance of the other and interlocked so that when one is "off" or "open" the other is "on" or "closed" to the passage of tubs, thus effectively guarding the incline at all times.

Caught by Moving Tubs when Travelling. — The accidents under this head are generally due to persons either failing to make use of the refuge holes available on haulage roads or travelling along haulage roads where travelling is prohibited because such roads afford more comfort and a shorter journey. The remedy lies chiefly in the hands of the workmen themselves. At the same time more attention could be paid to the provision of separate travelling roads, or, where this is not practicable, to the fixing of definite travelling times when the haulage is not in motion, and to stricter discipline to ensure that the system adopted is carried out.

Illegal Riding. — Here again, the remedy for the prevention of this type of accident lies mainly with the workmen themselves, It should not be forgotten that bad walking roads are conducive to illegal riding.

Failure of Ropes, Chains or Sockets. — When full consideration is given to the amount of mechanical haulage in use and to the enormous quantities of coal hauled, the number of accidents due to the failure of ropes, chains or sockets is remarkably small. The main security against such failures lies in the right choice and dimensioning of the materials, sound workmanship and installation, and proper supervision and maintenance. Even if every care is exercised, accidents will still happen, but it should not be forgotten that their consequences need not be so serious if travelling on haulage roads is reduced to the absolute minimum.

Caught by Offtakes Winch-Handle. — Accidents of this type usually occur because the offtakes lad, who has lifted the "pawl" to pay out slack rope, forgets to replace it in position when pulling in rope. To obviate interference with the "pawl" and prevent such accidents a few collieries have adopted a type of offtakes winch which is fitted with a clutch on the drum shaft, and having a "pawl" which is always in position.

Before concluding, there are a few other matters to which I would briefly direct your attention. The first is the need for better illumination at junctions and in all places where tubs are coupled or uncoupled, either by the provision of sufficient and good artificial fixed lights (pneumatic electric lamps are convenient for this purpose in mines where compressed air only is available), and/or, where such is not practicable, by whitewashing the roof and sides. This latter practice could with advantage be extended to all parts of the roadway where any definite operation connected with haulage is performed, such as the spragging of tub wheels, or the withdrawal of sprags. Another is the advisability of providing haulage workers with the most convenient, efficient, and certain form of light possible. In safety-lamp mines this may be done by providing them with electric hand or cap lamps. Other points are the necessity for a greater interchange of ideas among mining men by more frequent visits to other collieries or coalfields, and the need for a better system of broadcasting particulars of the various simple inventions, contrivances or arrangements which succeed in promoting safety, and which are so often peculiar to one colliery or colliery district.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bryan, Andrew Meikle    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
17 Dec 1927  News and Notes (The Science and Art of Mining)
31 Dec 1927  Problem Of Underground Haulage Accidents (The Science and Art of Mining)
14 Jan 1928  Problem Of Underground Haulage Accidents (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print