14th January 1928, Page: 193, Column: 1
Nitrate Of Ammonia And Safety Explosives*
By Wm. Cullen, L.L.D., M.Inst.M.M., M.I.Chem.E.
In view of the visit to Gathurst I have thought it wise to make my remarks
explanatory at what you are likely to see there but at the same time in view of
the large number of firemen present, I propose to deal with some practical
points in connection with the use of explosives. The explosives made at
Gathurst have as their principal raw material, nitrate of ammonia, a body to
which I referred somewhat fully on a previous occasion, but much has happened
since then, and if you are to obtain a general grasp of the situation it will
be necessary for me to say a little about what chemists call the
"fixation" of atmospheric nitrogen. Our atmosphere as you know,
contains roughly 79% of nitrogen and 21% oxygen. We all know the functions of
oxygen, but when I was a young man at college and for very many years
thereafter, we were told and accepted it as a fact that nitrogen was one of the
most recalcitrant elements. Broadly speaking, it combined with no other element
and it was not very clear that it had any particular function at all. On the
other hand, we did know that it was most essential in the combined form, for
growing crops and for vegetation generally. Indeed Sir Wm. Crookes in an
address to the British Association about 30 years ago gave a very gloomy
picture of the future of mankind, for he predicted that there would not be
enough nitrogen in the world to support its increasing population. At that time
the only known sources of supply were the nitrate of soda deposits of Chile and
the by-product ammonia from the gas works and coke ovens. However, early in the
present century it was discovered that when air was passed rapidly through the
electric arc, the nitrogen of the air combined with the oxygen, producing
nitrous oxide, which ultimately through oxidation becomes nitric acid. It was
only a further step to combine this with a base to form a nitrate, and many of
these suggested themselves. Shortly afterwards it was found that when nitrogen
was pumped into molten carbide of calcium, the raw material for the production
of acetylene, a body called "Cyanarnide" was formed. This was found
to be quite a good fertiliser, because when sprinkled on the soil ammonia was
evolved in a form which plants could assimilate. Moreover Cyanarnide when
decomposed by steam or hot water produced large quantities of ammonia, and so
this recalcitrant nitrogen seemed to be tamed at last and made amenable to
man's necessities. It may be said at this stage that the Cyanarnide process
survives to this day, and is a very big industry where power is cheap, but the
arc process is gradually dying.
Shortly before the Great War the scientific world were made aware of a great
discovery by a German chemist named Haber who by means of suitable
catalyst had managed to make nitrogen combine with hydrogen. True high
pressures and temperatures were necessary, but all the difficulties were
overcame and the Haber process to-day in one form or other is responsible for
about 80% of the synthetically fixed nitrogen produced throughout the world.
Munitions and industrial explosives consumed quite a small proportion of the
world's nitrogen, and the nitrate of ammonia forms an exceedingly small
proportion of that, but it is comforting to know that it is now made in this
country at Billingham near Stockton-on-Tees, where a huge plant has been
erected. The process employed at these works is a modification of the Haber
process, and the necessary hydrogen and nitrogen are obtained very cheaply from
water gas and producer gas, which in turn are produced from coke and steam. The
raw materials are therefore very cheap, but the plant required for the series
of operations up to the stage of the production of ammonia calls for a very
heavy capital outlay, so high indeed, that only firms like Imperial Chemical
Industries which have large capital resources could ever undertake the work.
Time does not permit my explaining these various processes which, however, are
very simple from the chemical point of view, but ammonia when passed over
metallic platinum, a catalyst, with air forms nitric acid, so it is easy now to
see how nitrate of ammonia is produced from part of the very air which We
breathe. This I consider the most remarkable chemical romance of the present
century.
Now nitrate of ammonia, the formula of which is (NH4)NO3,
is a very remarkable body. If we could explode it by itself — which is
very difficult — it would give the following gaseous products:
The H2O naturally condenses to water, so that of the permanent gases
amounting to 1½ volumes 33% are oxygen, and when we have to build up an
explosive, having regard to the nature of the gases produced on detonation,
this oxygen excess comes in very handy, for we can also look upon the nitrate
of ammonia as an oxidant. By itself it is, however, no use as an explosive. It
is too insensitive, so it has to be combined with other bodies, generally of
the nitro order, the combination forming a most useful group of
"permitted" and "non-permitted" explosives ; but in order
to cool the flame for the former class, certain other bodies such as common
salt, borax, etc., are added. Nitrate of ammonia, however, from the
"permitted" point of view, starts with the great advantage of
producing very cool gases. Then again the velocity of detonation can be
regulated by methods which are well known to manufacturers, but which have no
particular interest for you.
I want to say a few words about another chemical romance which I hope will be
of interest to those users of explosives present, be they students, firemen,
managers, or even sellers of explosives. In every one of my previous lectures
here. I have mentioned the danger of handling frozen nitro-glycerine
explosives, for as you all know most explosives which contain nitroglycerine
freeze in an ordinary English winter. In this state they are very insensitive
to detonation, but extremely sensitive to friction, and if the records of
accidents are examined, it will be found that the careless handling of frozen
explosives has been responsible for many fatal accidents in the past. Of
course, if warming pans or thawing houses are employed with discrimination,
there need be no danger from this cause, but the fact that there was the
potential risk undoubtedly militated against the use of nitro-glycerine
explosives in cold countries. All this, however, will soon be a thing of the
past, for to-day there is a choice of two substitutes for the ordinary
glycerine C3H3(OH)5, viz., polymerised
glycerine and glycol C2H4(O)H2. Now frankly,
we do not know very much about polymerised glycerine chemically, but we do know
this, that if several molecules are grouped together and one or more molecules
of water (H2O) abstracted, we get a larger molecule of a polymerised
body which has all the properties of glycerine, but which on being nitrated
does not readily freeze. Indeed, one can say positively that it cannot be
frozen at the very lowest temperature we are ever likely to experience here or
elsewhere. That is in itself a remarkable discovery, but it is to glycol that
we look for the romance. Wherever oil is obtained from the bowels of the earth,
there is always an accompaniment of gas which is largely composed of ethane
(C2H6). When this gas is cracked, in much the same way as
mineral oil is cracked to produce petrol, another gas called ethylene is
produced (C2H4) and only two OH radicles are required to
make this into glycol. This, however, is a long and complicated process which I
have no time to describe, but the glycol has all the properties of glycerine ;
it nitrates just like it, and the final product di-nitro-glycol
C2H4(NO3)2 behaves in all respects
just like ordinary nitro-glycerine, except that it does not freeze. The trade
names of "Arctic," or "Polar" explosive, therefore,
indicate that it contains a proportion of either polymerised nitro-glycerine or
di-nitro-glycol, neither of which freeze at ordinary winter temperatures.
Nitroglycerine was and still is, largely used for shooting oil wells, and it is
rather a remarkable thing to think that the gas evolved from these oil wells
can be made into a most effective explosive for inducing the production of
still more oil.
All the foregoing processes involve the use of nitrogen in some form or other,
and I have already indicated how nitric acid to-day is made from ammonia, but
before leaving the subject of fixation altogether the following figure may be
of interest. The world's consumption of fixed nitrogen to-day is 1,300,000
tons, and until 1914 certainly 90% of this came from Chili. To-day more than
one-half of this is produced synthetically and the annual increase is very
large. It is therefore easy to understand that the Chili saltpetre industry has
rather a poor outlook.
A most important point for the miner to bear in mind always was that the gases
produced by practically all explosives in the absence of the best ventilation
were suspect, not in the sense that they might produce fumes which were
unpleasant to inhale, for that seldom happened to-day, but that they nearly
always produced carbon monoxide. The aim of all manufacturers is to so build up
an explosive that there is enough oxygen available to completely burn up all
the carbon to CO2, which is a harmless gas, but this was not always
possible. Broadly speaking nearly all explosives produce carbon monoxide (CO),
some more and some less. Now your teachers have all impressed upon you that,
inasmuch as carbon monoxide has neither taste or smell, you never know you are
breathing it until you collapse. It is not, however, so generally realised that
0.2 % in an atmosphere is very dangerous, particularly if work is being done.
It is, therefore, very necessary that there should not be an early return to
the face in a heading where biggish charges might be used. I could recount some
of my own early experience in carrying out experiments on these lines twenty
years ago when safety helmets were actually dangerous to use, but that would be
a story by itself, and it only remains for me to say that the regulation which
deals with this particular subject is more than justified.
I know perfectly well that, on a previous occasion I have said a good deal
about the position of the detonator, but much experimental evidence to
re-inforce my views has been produced within recent years. I am pleased also to
know that I have converted quite a number to my views, and they tell me that I
am fully justified in all that I have said. I hold that the correct position
for the detonator is in the centre of the primer cartridge, the closed end
pointing to the bottom of the hole and the open end to the mouth of the hole.
It can be taken as a fact that the closed end is the active end, i.e., it does
the actual work of detonating. Moreover, it is important to have it in the
centre of the cartridge, and with powdery explosives this can only be attained
by tieing with string. I know only too well that this is seldom if ever done,
and that the regulations are silent on the point, but it does not alter the
fact that it should be done. The general practice is to put the detonator in
the second or third cartridge, but the slides which I have shown you prove
conclusively that this is wrong from every point of view and can only introduce
new dangers, for if, as I have stated, the closed end of the detonator is
active, then the other cartridges which may be above the open end have little
or no chance of detonating. Indeed they may even be thrown out into the roadway
and get among the coal. I fully believe, indeed, that this practice of placing
the detonator in the wrong place is very largely responsible for the cartridges
which are occasionally found among coal.
Now we are apt to exaggerate the number of accidents from handling explosives.
They are in reality not numerous, but many accidents are indirectly caused by
explosives, mostly the result of either carelessness or bad judgment, which is,
of course, another name for ignorance. It is a remarkable thing that in the
manufacture of explosive where there is obviously a great deal of handling,
accidents are of the rarest occurrence. When you visit Gathurst please,
therefore, note the careful way in which all the operations are carried out and
the scrupulous attention which is paid to cleanliness. The following
"permitted" explosives are made there, viz,, Roburite, Belhte,
Gathurst Powder, and Negro Powder — the last an excellent coal-getter.
The "non-permitteds" are Ammonial Blasting Abelite and a new
explosive called "Super Abelite," which has given very fine results
on the field. Practically all these contain T.N.T., but the permitteds have
also the cooling agents which have been referred to. Naturally there are other
ingredients added for specific purposes, but it would take too long to mention
them.
The lecture was illustrated by numerous slides, and in the course of the
discussion one of the speakers in seconding the vote of thanks told his
experiences when he started work at a quarry with an old hand who had been
blasting all his life. He impressed on him that the only safe and right place
to place the detonator was in the position so clearly demonstrated by Dr.
Cullen. Various other speakers also referred to this point, and the general
concensus of articulate opinion was that the point had been proved up to the
hilt.
* Summary of a lecture delivered at the December meeting of the Past and
Present Mining Students' Association in the Wigan Meeting and Technical
College. On the day following the lecture nearly 300 members paid a visit of
inspection to the works of Roburite and Ammonal Ltd., at Gathurst.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Crookes, William, Sir | | | |
| Cullen, William | | | |
| Haber, — | | Chemist | |