Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

22nd December 1927

Haig Pit Explosion

Opening Of Inquest

Impressive Funerals Of Victims

Rescue Party's Dramatic Story.

The inquest on the three of the four victims of the explosion in Haig Pit, Whitehaven, James Knox, James Bateman Fitzsimmons, and William Bradley — was opened on Thursday at the Court House, Whitehaven. With Mr. H. Gibson as foreman, the following jury was empanelled: Messrs. J. Kerr, T. K. Langstaff, F. Cussons, J. H. Cant, G. W. Moss, C. B. Dalzell, J. Graham, C. Moore, and I. Browne.

There were present Mr. W. Loudon, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. H. C. Hanlon, miners agent; Mr. J. Tyson, Cumberland Colliery Officials Association; Mr. H. W. Walker, chairman; Mr. W. H. Johnson, general manager; Mr. R. Steel, agent and works manager; and Mr. J. Hope Brown, representing the Whitehaven Colliery Company.

At the outset, the Coroner, Mr. D. J. Mason, expressed to all concerned in this matter the great regret they felt that this explosion had taken place and extended to the relatives of these poor men their very sincere sympathy.

Mr. Hope Brown said the directors and members of the Company desired to express their sincere regret that this explosion had happened and to convey to the members of the families of the men who had been killed their very sincere sympathy and their regret that men who had been faithful servants, some of them for many years, should have met their deaths in this unfortunate way.

Mr. Hanlon and Mr. Tyson also associated their members with the vote of sympathy.

Mr. Gibson, on behalf of the jury, extended their deepest sympathy to those who had been bereaved by this unfortunate accident.

The Coroner stated that one body had not been recovered, and he was taking the directions of the Home Office in regard to that case. He added that he only proposed to take evidence of identification this afternoon and then adjourn the inquest.

Formal evidence of identification was then given by Robert Knox, miner, 30 Old Arrowthwaite, brother of James Knox; John Bradley, 9 Quay Street, son of William Bradley; and Joseph Broatch, drifter, the Back Ginns, brother-in-law of James Bateman Fitzsimmons.

In reply to the Coroner, Mr. Hope Brown said it was quite impossible to remove the stopping in the pit within a month.

In adjourning the inquest to January 20th next, the Coroner said even then he did not think it would be possible to proceed with the inquest, but they might be able to fix a definite date.

Deputy Chief Inspector's Visit.

Mr. Wynne, Deputy Chief Inspector from the Mines Department, London, and Mr. Greenland Davies, the Divisional Inspector, descended Haig pit on Thursday, and made an inspection.

Mr. Cape's Sympathy.

Mr. H. C. Hanlon, on Wednesday, received the following telegram from Mr. Tom Cape, M.P.: Regret to hear about explosion. Raising question in House this afternoon for information. Express my sympathy relatives; letter following.

Writing to Mr. Hanlon from London, on Wednesday, Mr. Tom Richardson says :—

"I felt I must write you a brief note to say how deeply I feel for the loved ones of those comrades who have lost their lives in a calling that has never received from the mine owners, the Government or the community, the consideration the miners and their dependents should have had. Kindly convey to the relatives and friends of the deceased my sincere sympathy.

The following letters of sympathy were read at a meeting of the Whitehaven Lodges on Tuesday :—

From the General Council of the Trades Union Congress; Dear Mr. Cape, — I am very sorry indeed to see by this morning's papers that an accident has occurred at the Haig Pit and that four of our fellow workers have been killed. I shall be glad if you will kindly convey to their wives and families an expression of my sincere condolence with them in their sad bereavement. In the unfortunate circumstance one can only feel relieved that this accident, bad as it is, is not serious as the one in 1922. — Walter W. Citrons, general secretary.

From the Yorkshire Mine Workers' Association; Denaby Main Branch :— Mr. H. Hanlon: Dear Sir, — I am desired by the members of the above to convey through you our sympathy and condolence with the relatives of the men who lost their lives in the present explosion. May I also tender on behalf of myself and family our sympathy with the bereaved? — Yours sincerely, A. Roberts, secretary.

Another letter received by Mr. Cape, through Major A. Scoular, reads :— Dear Major Scoular and Mr. Cape, — I have been greatly shocked to read in to-day's paper of the explosion and fire at Haig Pit, Whitehaven, and am grieved at the sad loss of life. I would like to add my expression of sincere sympathy with the bereaved relatives of the four dead men. — Believe me to be yours very truly (Sir) W. J. Collins, neutral chairman of the Old Conciliation and Minimum Wage Board.

The Funerals.

Impressive Services.

There were marked demonstrations of public sympathy on Sunday, at the funerals of three of the four victims of the Whitehaven Haig Pit disaster last week. The first funeral was that of William Bradley - was at 1.30 p.m. and the last that of James Knox at 3 p.m.; and by that time two or three thousand sympathisers had congregated at the cemetery, necessitating the attendance of a staff of police, under the supervision of Supt. Melville.

There were many particularly pathetic scenes as each of the corteges passed through the Ginns district, the centre of many miners' homes.

Each funeral service was attended by a large crowd, and among those who were present at all three services were: Mr. T. Cape, M.P., general secretary of the Cumberland Miners' Association; Mr. H. C. Hanlon, Whitehaven miners' agent; Mr. J. Tyson, secretary of the Cumberland Colliery Officials Association; Mr. W. W. Morgan (manager of Haig Pit) and Mr. R. Fell (under-manager); Mr. C. W. Whinfield (manager of Ladysmith); and the four Whitehaven pit delegates: Mr. W. Thompson (Haig), Mr. J. A. Fearon (Wellington), Mr. J. McAllister (Ladysmith), and Mr. T. Brannon (William). Old associates and workmates of the deceased, some of whom took part in the rescue operation, acted as pall bearers.

The Church Services.

The funeral service for William Bradley, of Mitchell's Court, Irish Street, was conducted in St. Begh's Church, Coach Road, by the Rev. L. S. Cave, O.S.B. (Parish priest), who also conducted the ceremony at the graveside. There was a very large attendance in the church.

The service over the body of James Bateman Fitzsimmons, of Back Ginns, was held on the Colliery Mission, which could not accommodate the hundreds of people who attended. The hymn, "Peace, Perfect Peace" was sung and lessons were read by Mr. J. Davidson (of the Town Mission), and Mr. J. T. Cooper (secretary to the Colliery Mission), who also conducted the graveside service. Previous to the service the coffin was carried from the deceased's home, a short distance away to the Mission.

The Rev. F. K. Fell, vicar of Holy Trinity Church, who lost a son in the Haig Pit disaster of 1922, conducted the funeral services of James Knox, Mountain View.

Wreaths were sent to all three funerals by Mrs. Herbert Walker, Lingmell, and by the colliery officials. Following are the complete lists of wreaths:

For William Bradley: Mrs. Bradley; son and daughter; Mrs. O'Neil and family, and grandson Robert; Mrs. Crawford and daughter; son and daughter-in-law; Con and Eliza and family; son and daughter and family; John and Catherine; Mr. and Mrs. Kenmare and family; Mr. and Mrs. W. Lewis and customers; Mrs. Herbert Walker; colliery officials.

For James B. Fitzsimmons: Wife and daughter; Brother and sister-in-law and family; Brother and sister-in-law John and Polly; sister and family, Parton; Jennie, Annie and Maggie; Mrs. Elizabeth Reay and her sister; Mr. and Mrs. Huddart (Arrowthwaite); Mr. and Mrs. Alex Broach; Mr. and Mrs. H. McKenzie (Sandhills Lane); Mrs. Herbert Walker; colliery officials.

For James Knox Maggie and family; Bell, George, Agnes and family; Robert and Polly (Arrowthwaite); Roby and Elsie; Maggie and George (Arrowthwaite); Mrs. Beaumont, Margaret and Neta; Old friends at Raven Hill; Lowther Castle, Scotch Street; Mr. and Mrs. McLean and family; F. Davey; Mr. and Mrs. J. Riley; Railway Terrace; all at Egremont; Mrs. Herbert Walker; colliery officials.

A Plucky Rescue Party.

Scenes Following The Explosion.

With the disclosure of the names of the four men who dashed from Wellington pit to the rescue of the survivors of the Haig Pit explosion is unfolded one of the most dramatic and pluckiest episodes on Whitehaven's mining history.

The story told by William Douglas, of Bransty, an old Whitehaven Athletic footballer, leads up to the rescue operations. Douglas, a charge hand, was sitting in the brake engine house with nine youths when the explosion occurred, about 150 yards away. The blast whistled past the engine house, which was penetrated by fumes so thick and suffocating that although the electric lights were still alight it was impossible to see a foot ahead. I told the lads to wrap their mufflers round their mouths and dash out bye", continued Douglas. They were plucky youngsters; there was not a murmur as they did as I told them, but we had not got 30 yards up the brow before we all collapsed and became practically unconscious. How long we lay I don't know, but when the air resumed its normal course a youth named Winthorpe and myself recovered, and after struggling to our feet, we started turning over the lads, some of whom were lying on their faces. We had got some to their feet and sent them tottering out when three rescuers from Wellington pit, Alf Casson, Hugh McGlennon, and Pat. McFarland, came along, followed by Tom Birkett. Casson had to put his lamp to my face before he knew it was me. They started assisting the lads and then asked me to try and get the surface on the telephone, but although I could hear them, they could not hear me.

"McGlennon then asked me where Jolly's drift was and I went down with them to within ten yards of the Rope Road where we found the electric cable on the ground, and I was asked to go back and cut the switch off. The first man I met going back was Jack Graham, the overman, and he cut off the switch. Then with Kitchin and Winthorpe I came out bye, the last three to come up belonging to the back shift.

"Those four Wellington pit men were a brave lot to come as they did with only an oil lamp among them," concluded Douglas.

Lying With Faces In The Dust.

The experiences of the rescuers makes a gripping narrative. The reversal of the air first warned the men in Wellington that something was wrong, and, taking an oil lamp, Casson, McGlennon, and McFarland set off to investigate, fearing a fall. As they went along the air grew thicker and fouler, so that they could hardly see one another. Then when going down Saltom Brow they saw a flicker of light and two lads came struggling along like drunken men. The gave them drinks of water, and, then, making progress, found more lads, some trying to walk, others leaning against the side moaning and others lying on their faces in the dust.

"One of these we met," said Casson in an interview with a "News" representative," was Douglas. He was gassed like the rest of them, but urged us to try and get two deputies who were further in. We left McFarland to attend to them and went further on to find the last two boys, lying face downwards in the dust. One, Turnbull, I think it was, was very ill and I thought he would not recover. We attended to them and left them with Douglas before going on.

Attempts To Telephone Fail.

"At the engine house we found the telephone bell ringing, but we could not get an answer. Just then Douglas came struggling in, and he also tried to speak to the surface, but failed. Some little distance further on we found the cable on the ground and asked Douglas to cut it off. Although practically exhausted, off he went, and that was the last we saw that night of one of the gamest men I have met in a pit.

"At this point we were joined by Tom Birkett and at Rope Road bottom found a number of wrecked tubs. At that time we did not know Knox was there, so we pressed on for about another 150 yards. Failing to see anyone, we marked our initials on a board and returned to try another passage. Then we were met by several Haig pit men who said the likeliest place to find Knox was at the Rope Road and there, on top of the tubs, with his sleeve caught on a nail, we found his body.

"With the arrival of Jack Graham, the overman, and Pat McFarland, we decided to again enter the Development District and had got perhaps 30 yards when there was another waft of wind, just like a small explosion, and we ran out to the wrecked tubs. On the air again taking its normal course were returned and found that McGlennon and two other men, one named Moore, had found the body of Fitzsimmons about five yards beyond where we had stopped on our first tour.

"At that time no one had mentioned or seemed to know about Bradley and Horrocks being in the pit, and just about spent ourselves, we helped to bring out the bodies. On getting to the surface I first learned that Bradley was down the pit and had word telephoned down."

Tom Birkett, who was awarded The King Edward bronze medal for rescue work in Wellington pit in 1910, told a similar story to the related by Casson, except that he was threequarters of a mile further in Wellington pit than the other three and had to make his way along alone. He said the manager and under-manger arrived and took charge of the operations soon after the bodies had been recovered and when the outbreak of fire was expected.

The names and addresses of the rescue party are :— Tom Birkett, shifthand, New houses; Alfred Casson, compressor man, Kells; Hugh McGlennon, shifthand, Buttermere Avenue, and Patrick McFarland, Hill Top Road, Arrowthwaite.

Question Of Resuming Work.

About 1,500 men employed at that pit and the adjoining Wellington mine - which is connected with Haig have been thrown out of work, and on Tuesday the question of resuming work in Wellington was discussed by representatives of the men and the Colliery Company. Previously a meeting of the Haig and Wellington pit men was held in the Market Hall, Mr. Tom Cape, M.P., the general secretary of the Cumberland Miners' Association, being present. Later, Mr. Cape, Mr. H. C. Hanlon, the Whitehaven miners' agent, and delegates met colliery directors and the management, and a report will be submitted to the men on Friday morning. It is not likely, however, that there will be any resumption of work in Wellington pit this week.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Birkett, Tom    Miner  
Bradley, John      Son
Bradley, William   65 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Brannon, T.    Pit Delegate  
Broatch, Joseph    Drifter  Brother in Law
Brown, J. Hope    Solicitor  
Browne, I.    Juror  
Cant, J. H.    Juror  
Cape, Tom    M.P.  Whos Who Page
Casson, Alfred    Compressor Man  
Cave, L. S., Rev.      
Citrons, Walter W.      
Collins, W. J.      
Cooper, J. T.      
Cussons, F.    Juror  
Dalzell, C. B.    Juror  
Davidson, J.      
Davies, Thomas Greenland    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Douglas, William    Charge Hand  
Fearon, J. A.    Pit Delegate  
Fell, F. K., Rev.      
Fitzsimmons, James Bateman   58 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Gibson, H.    Jury Foreman  
Graham, J.    Juror  
Graham, Jack    Overman  
Hanlon, H. C.    Miners' Agent  
Horrocks, —    Miner  
Johnson, W. H.    General Manager  
Kerr, J.    Juror  
Knox, James   67 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Knox, Robert    Miner  Brother
Langstaff, T. K.    Juror  
Loudon, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Mason, D. J.    Coroner  Whos Who Page
McAllister, J.    Pit Delegate  
McFarland, Pat    Miner  
McGlennon, Hugh    Shifthand  
Melville, —    Police Supt.  
Moore, —    Miner  
Moore, C.    Juror  
Morgan, W. W.    Manager  
Moss, G. W.    Juror  
Richardson, Tom      
Roberts, A.      
Scoular, Alexander Carlaw, Major      Whos Who Page
Steel, R.    Works Manager  
Thompson, W.    Pit Delegate  
Turnbull, —    Miner  
Tyson, J.      
Walker, H. W.      
Walker, Herbert, Mrs.      
Whinfield, C. W.    Manager  
Wynne, Frederick Horton    H.M. Deputy Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Haig Colliery  Haig Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
12 Dec 1927  Haig Pit Explosion, Four Lives Lost, Rescuers Battle With Fire (Whitehaven News)
15 Dec 1927  Explosion in a Coal Mine, Four Men Killed at Whitehaven (The Times)
15 Dec 1927  Haig Pit Explosion (Whitehaven News)
22 Dec 1927  Haig Pit Explosion, Opening Of Inquest, Impressive Funerals Of Victims (Whitehaven News)
22 Dec 1927  Haig Pit Rescue Party (Whitehaven News)
22 Dec 1927  Into The Unknown (Whitehaven News)
31 Dec 1927  News and Notes (The Science and Art of Mining)
19 Jan 1928  Haig Pit, Inquest Resumed, Timbermen Asked To Stay Behind (Whitehaven News)
09 Feb 1928  Workings Still Closed, Colliery Solicitor's Statement (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for Haig
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print