|
17th December 1927, Page: 161, Column: 1 Points From The Inspectors' ReportsShaft AccidentsMr. Henry Walker, C.B.E., in his report as Chief Inspector of Mines, says that whilst injuries due to overwinds at the top of shafts are provided for to some extent by the use of detaching hooks and automatic contrivances to bring winding engines to a standstill should the cages be raised beyond a certain point, very little attempt has been made in this country to minimise the shock resulting from a descending cage being bumped on the shaft bottom. Accidents occur from time to time due to this cause, and he considers that some steps should be taken to provide a remedy. The Inspector further says the automatic contrivances flow installed to prevent overwinding do not fulfil that requirement if they do not prevent a cage being bumped hard on the shaft bottom. The impact on the shaft bottom would be much lessened if, when winding persons, the automatic contrivances attached to the winding engines were so arranged that the speed of winding when the cages were nearing the end of the wind were reduced to a very slow rate, this question, he says, must be settled either by some such device or the provision of some means by which in the event of an overwind a cage may be brought gradually to rest below the lowest mouthing in the shaft. It may be, he adds, that a solution will be found, when electric power becomes cheap and available throughout the country, by replacing steam by electricity for winding persons. Discussing a fatal accident to a rope splicer at the pit bottom Which occurred at a Durham colliery, Mr. T. Greenland Davies, the Northern Division Inspector, says it appears to have been the custom to raise the cage a few fathoms in the shaft when it was not required, and this had been done about twenty minutes before the accident by the onsetter giving the engineman what was locally known as an "all clear" signal, which apparently did not require a further signal from the onsetter should the engineman require to move the cage. As a shift of men was expected to ascend the shaft about the time of the accident the engineman lowered the cage without any warning. Mr. Davies concludes by saying that the practice of moving cages without proper and definite signals from the banksmen and onsetters is exceedingly dangerous. The Yorkshire Inspector, Mr. H. M. Hudspeth, devotes more than the usual space to an accident which might have had very serious consequences, as a result of which he strongly expresses the opinion that winding enginemen should not change during the period allotted for winding men. He adds that the occurrence illustrates the known inadequacy of most overwind preventers, as used, to control the winding engine in such a way as to avoid dangerously high speeds near the end of the wind. In other words, the permissible "banking" speed was too high. Such devices should be adjusted to operate at less speeds. Mr. Hudspeth points out that the potentialities of danger resulting from overwinding are so great as to demand close attention and consideration. When riding men, it is his opinion that a longer retardation is necessary towards the end of the wind than is usually allowed for by overwind controllers. In the North Midland Division in 1926 there were five fatal accidents in shafts, two due to breach of rules and two to failure to exercise ordinary care, whilst all the non-fatal accidents might nave been avoided had reasonable precautions been taken. Having made a statement to this effect, Mines Inspector J. R. Felton submits some shaft accident pointers as follows: "It is not a difficult matter where caging is done at mid-insets to make the gate operate a lever in the engine house showing whether the gate is open or closed; the engineman then does not move the cage from the inset until he sees the gate closed, an arrangement which increases safety." To be effective overwinding apparatus should be made not merely to come into operation at two or three fixed points, but to follow a pre-determined curve providing for a definite retardation beyond a fixed point in the wind. The usual steam governors are not sensitive enough to control at slow speeds, and the provision of an auxiliary attachment to secure effective speed control during the end of the wind is of great importance." "Injuries in overwinding accidents almost invariably arise from the bumping of the downgoing cage on the bottom. Most of the accidents might be prevented by leaving the sump open (and, of course, free from water) so that the cage would be free to proceed below the 'hanging on' level in the event of an overwind. The sump for a short distance could be left clear, below which converging receivers or 'squeezers' might be fixed to prevent the cage going too far. 'Keps' might be provided at the inset or 'hanging on' level for coal winding, and fastened back for men riding." An accident is discussed by Mr. H. A. Abbott in his report for the Midland and Southern Division in the following terms: "A full tub was being put into the cage by the onsetter, when it left the rails. Deceased entered the cage and was assisting to re-rail the tub when, without a signal from the pit bottom, the cage was raised and he, when attempting to get off the cage, was fatally crushed between it and the runner-bearers in the shaft. There were two mechanical means of signalling in the shaft, one actuating a gong in the engine house and the other a plate rapper. The gong was in general use and the rapper was a stand-by. About half an hour before the accident occurred the gong signalling line was out of order, and the engineman notified the shaftsman, who, acting on his own initiative while the manager was underground, took steps to effect repairs, and requested the onsetter by note to use the spare or rapper signal in the meantime. Whilst making the repairs, the shaftsman, when tightening the line to make connection, gave the signal "one" on the gong, and the engine-man responded to it, with fatal result. Repairs of this character should not have been done during working hours."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||