|
15th December 1927 Youth Crushed By TubThe circumstances attending the tragedy in William Pit, Whitehaven, early on Thursday morning, in which a 16 years-old Whitehaven haulage hand, Joseph William Carson, was killed, were inquired into yesterday. There was a jury, of which Mr. Askew was the foreman. Mr. W. Loudon, H.M. Inspector of Mines. Mr. R. Steel, representing the Whitehaven Colliery Company, and Mr. H. C. Hanlon, representing the Whitehaven Miners' Lodge, were also present. Richard Routledge Carson, 3, The Close, shifthand identified the body as that of his son. Mr. R. H. Garside produced a plan of the place where the boy was found. Mr. A. B. Dawson, manager of William Pit, said deceased was on the night shift, and the accident happened at 2-50 a.m. The lad had to meet the full setts coming out on the rope and knock them off the rope as they came to the pit bottom. The setts were travelling at about three miles an hour. The usual procedure in landing a sett was to knock off the fore end bogey some time before it reached the standing sett and then to proceed to the hinder end and allow the sett to run until it met the standing sett and then knock off the back bogey. In this case the fore end clutch bogey had not been knocked off. They could tell that because the catch had not been released. It appeared that Carson had had some difficulty in knocking off the bogey, or that he was not aware that the sett he was on was so near the standing sett. If he had been in difficulty he could have stopped that rope signalling. Working Alone. The foreman: Was there anyone with him? — No, not at that time. Part of his work is sending away setts and he had assist then. Mr. Hanlon: You said he could have stopped the rope. Is it not probable that the lad was fast over the bogey and could not be signalled? — No, the position of his lamp suggests that he was not in difficulty. Your opinion is different from mine. You are only assuming how this happened. My theory of this accident is that Carson, in attempting to knock off this sett, caught his foot in the wheels of the bogey, and this flung him to the floor under the bogey. Before he knew where he was he was under the full sett and the other tubs got on top of him. Mr. Dawson: If he was caught he must have been caught somewhere near the standing sett so near for him to have seen the standing bogey and to have stopped the rope. Mr. Hanlon: The point I am pressing is that this man had difficulty in stopping the rope. If he was in difficulty the nearest point where he could get assistance was about 600 yards away. There ought to be someone with him. Richard Trainor, 105, Bransty Road, onsetter, said that about 3-30 a.m. the haulage engineman called him up and he went to the place of the accident. The full sett had got into the standing sett, and the boy was dead. He was crushed between the fore end bogey and the first tub. John Tyson, 1, Countess Terrace, Bransty, haulage engine driver, said about 2-50 a.m. he was running the rope when he got three signals which meant slow the rope down. He did so and ran the rope about 30 or 40 yards and then felt a bump. The signal to stop was one. There was no doubt it was a three signal and not three ones. When he felt the bump he knew something was wrong, stopped the rope and telephoned to the charge man at the junction. Harry Cowin, haulage hand, also gave evidence. No Cause For Criticism. The Coroner said it was quite clear that the boy had died by being crushed between the clutch bogey and a full tub, but as to how it happened, that was a matter of pure speculation. There was no evidence which involved anyone with anything which would give reason for criticism. The only point he noticed that had been mentioned was that the nearest man was working a long way from Carson. That was not very important. After a short retirement, the Foreman announced that the jury agreed that it was a case of accidental death, but they wished to draw the attention of the people concerned that if a youth of that age had to do such work by himself he ought to have better means of communication. The distance from him to the next man was too far.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||