|
3rd December 1927, Page: 152, Column: 1 Points From The Inspectors' ReportsSteel SupportsAs indicated in the last issue of The Science and Art of Mining several of the Mines Inspectors in their 1926 Reports comment on the use of steel supports, not only from the safety point of view, but also from that of economy. In his annual report Mr. H. Walker, C.B.E., devotes some space to this question. He says it is difficult to understand why steel supports have not been made use of generally. Considerable experience has been gained of the benefits to be derived from the use of such supports, but the information has not been disseminated. It is quite understandable that with competition existing in an industry, methods from which economies are derived at individual collieries are naturally not published broadcast, but when viewed from the point of view of safeguarding life, the Inspector says the question is raised to a higher plane. With this aspect in view, he expresses the hope that owners and managers will give the whole question their most earnest and serious attention. If actual trials of steel supports were undertaken in every mine in the country and carried out fairly and with goodwill the Chief Inspector is certain that the results would show that such supports are preferable to timber supports, and that with their adoption not only will the number of accidents from falls be diminished, but also considerable economies in working costs be realised. Following the course adopted in other sketches, the views expressed by the Inspectors will be set forth separately so that there can be no confusion regarding the experience in one district as compared with another. Scotland Division. The problem has evidently been very carefully examined by Mr. J. Masterton, the Scottish Divisional Inspector. He devotes nearly three pages of his report to the discussion, and as regards steel arches his view is that they have certainly come to stay. Where they have been given a trial they have proved their superiority over the older types of supports, and in many instances where there had been difficulty in maintaining a road the arches have been a complete success. He quotes Mr. J. A. Grove, one of his sub-inspectors, as saying "One result of the coal stoppage was the giving of silent demonstrations, in almost every mine, of the efficiency and economy of steel arches." In this sentence efficiency embraces safety, and Mr. Masterton emphasises that one great advantage from the point of view of everybody is the security from the danger of falls from roof and sides. He then gives some of the claims for steel arches, such as : "On main roads which have to last for long periods, the additional expense of lining the spaces between the arches with bricks or concrete is usually amply repaid. Concrete being more homogeneous gives a stronger support, but it becomes a disadvantage when the arches have to be withdrawn on abandonment of the roads. The lining prevents weathering and flaking of the sides, so that the roads are cleaner. The problem of dealing with coal dust is simplified, as there are no ledges on which coal dust can rest, and there are no accessible cavities where firedamp can accumulate, and the danger of Are is eliminated. The arches and brick and concrete are, of course, immune from the deleterious effects of the atmosphere and fungi." When steel arches are used in unsettled ground near long-wall faces, the Inspector says that wood lagging, to permit settling of the roof, is usually an advantage, and adds that "with a little experience, the arches, whether on main or subsidiary roads, can be quickly set and there is little or no additional expense for the labour of brushing, since the roof (although higher) does not require so much time and labour to be given to it to square in the sides, as is the case when timber or walls and horizontal girders are used." Another statement made is that "where horizontal roof supports have been used, each rebrushing creates considerable disturbance of the adjacent strata and there are large and dangerous falls to be met and dealt with. But on roads secured by steel arches the strata have been found to be very little broken up and very little rubbish is produced if and when re-brushing becomes needful." Mr. Masterton further says : "On the score of economy alone, steel arches have much in their favour even in inbye workings in unsettled ground. The extra initial cost of the steel itself is often repaid the first year by the saving of back brushings, and in some instances, taken over periods of a few years, for which I have seen figures, the costs of road brushings and maintenance alone have been nearly halved. This is remarkable when it is remembered that a higher standard of road, with more efficient transport facilities, has been maintained all the time. When the road is abandoned, the arches can be withdrawn with comparative safety." Discussing steel props, Mr. Masterton says : As with roads lined with steel arches, so it was with working faces supported by steel props during the coal stoppage; the working faces so supported were in almost every case found to be standing open as they were left and ready to be occupied again. In one of the largest Lothian collieries where some of the workings are at a depth of 2,500 feet, and all the working faces and roads are supported by steel, the only persons employed underground from May to November were a few overmen who adjusted a prop here and another there on the working faces. The miners, Mr. Masterton adds, "walked into the colliery workings as into a factory, and the full staff of over 1,200 men underground was producing full output within three days, a feat unparalleled in Britain, I should think, for a mine of such size and such depth. The report indicates that consideration of the roof and floor conditions has to take the place of custom and rule-of-thumb in the minds of the colliery officials who adopt steel supports, and Mr. Masterton then says : "The propping and strapping — for steel straps should with few exceptions accompany propping — must be regulated to have the roof breaking off readily behind the back row of props and falling to a sufficient height in the waste. If the roof tends to fall too freely, this can be adjusted by making the continuous stone packs — built from already fallen material — broader and with the addition of occasional wood pillars ; on the other hand, if the roof does not fall readily enough, the distance between the back row of props and the face may require to be lessened in order to reduce the time interval between the setting and withdrawal of the props to a minimum to avoid over-pressure, and leaving the waste as empty as possible of everything except the stone packs reduced in width, while at the same time keeping the actual working zone along the face safe and keyed tight by the props." Northern Division. In the Northern Division also the coal stoppage appears to have afforded an opportunity to test the superiority of steel over timber for the support of roof and sides, and Mr. T. Greenland Davies, in his report, says — "In general, I think it can be definitely stated that at collieries where steel arched girders were used, excellent results were obtained and managers were very sorry that greater lengths of roadway had not been supported in this manner." It is pointed out that "in workings in the same seam, under similar conditions, the faces were maintained in much better condition by steel supports than by timber. Where the floor was soft, heaving took place in both cases, but height was made more easily and safely on the faces where steel supports were used, than on the faces where timber supports were used, many of the latter supports being broken. On roadways subjected to earth movements, steel arches maintained the section very much better than timber supports or steel bars or girders supported by end wooden props." The management of one colliery in this Division figure out the cost of excavation for and the setting of steel arches at about double that required for timber setting, but the arches are invaluable in reducing the cost in maintaining the roadways, and they consider the life of steel arches is considerably more than four times that of timber supports. At another colliery the cost of erecting the arches is about three times that of erecting timber sets, but the manager says the arches have been standing three years, and a canch would have had to be taken through at least three times, with complete renewal of the timber, if timber supports had been used. The report informs that "the arches are perfectly intact, and it is safe to say they will save still further canch work." Referring again to the first-mentioned colliery, the report says : "In one part of a roadway where there is a length of 200 yards so much affected by the working of the seam above that it was found to be almost impossible to keep it open with timber settings, although 20 men were constantly employed on it, the length is now supported with steel arches 9 feet in diameter, which have been standing for over two years without attention, and with the exception of a few occasional repairs to a heaving floor, there has been no expense in maintaining the roadway. It is estimated that on this road alone, after allowing 8 of the 20 men being still employed in extending the steel arching, there has been a saving of almost sixpence per ton on an output of 500 tons per day." Yorkshire and North Midland Divisions. In his report as Inspector of the Yorkshire Division, Mr. H. M. Hudspeth says the stoppage disclosed the advantages of steel arches as road supports ; roads so supported stood so well that more are sure to be used. In the words of one under-manager, "the behaviour of the steel arching had been a lesson, and their use will certainly be extended." Mr. Hudspeth expresses the view that it needs no argument to show that by using steel arches, a road shape is attained which is more conducive to withstanding pressure and subsequent movement than when the usual "props and girders" are used. Although his opinion is that practically no form of artificial support can resist the pressure due to true subsidence at great depths, he holds that what might be correctly termed the "flow" of the ground can be arrested at an earlier stage by a method of support which more nearly approximates to the natural shape the road itself would assume in the absence of support. Referring to the use of steel props of the adjustable type, and steel arches, the North Midland Divisional Inspector, Mr. J. R. Felton, says the experience of the stoppage showed that workings and roads thus supported stood better and required less attention than those supported by timber. Lancashire and North Wales Division. Mr. A. D. Nicholson, the Divisional Inspector in Lancashire and North Wales, finds that only at about ten collieries has any attempt been made to support the roof of roadways by means of steel arching. The results varied. Some were satisfactory; others, after about twelve months' trial, ended in the old method of timbering being reverted to. The Inspector says : "Possibly, in some cases, the unsatisfactory results were due to using sections which were too light, and not building them close enough. In other cases, the extra movement of the strata, due to many seams in close proximity being concurrently worked over the same area, would militate against satisfactory results being obtained. It was also found that unless the ground was fairly well settled, this method of support was not a success. There are, however, many mines in Lancashire and North Wales where the use of steel arching on permanent roads would be found satisfactory, and more economical in the long run, and it seems desirable that further experiments should be made in this direction. The use of steel props at the face has as yet been tried on even a smaller scale than steel arches, and there does not appear to be any reason why they should not be used with the same advantage as in other coalfields." Cardiff and Newport and Swansea Divisions. In his general remarks, Mr. J. Macleod Carey, the Cardiff and Newport Division Inspector, says "the more general elimination of heavy timber sets on the roadways and their substitution by steel arches, to the great gain of the underground conditions, leads one to hope that the large amount of timber used, and wasted, at the face may in its turn be displaced by steel props of a design suitable to the conditions of this coalfield." The Inspector is aware of a certain prejudice on the part of some of the workmen, as well as some of the officials, to the withdrawal of timber at the working faces, due, he cannot help feeling, to the inadequacy of the packing of the gobs. This, he says, is understandable, and then adds : "Where there is an open space the feeling of security is greater when substantial props are placed under the roof. How much greater will be the sense of security when, instead of timber, the roof is supported with well-built substantial packing ? Then, and only then, can practically the whole of the timbers be withdrawn and so allow the roof to subside gently on to the packs. In collieries where this has been the practice in the past the effect is felt along the roadways right back to the shaft, in the reduction of repair work necessary to maintenance. Further assistance is given in this direction by the use of many miles of the steel arch, some mines having as many as 15 to 20 miles of roadways supported in this manner. I do not know of any mining district where the conditions require such constant attention to repairs and reopening as South Wales, where the large number of thick seams, lying so close together at great depth, cause, during the working of them, very heavy squeezes to occur, which are constantly and relentlessly closing in the roadways. The steel arch has practically solved this problem, and, as an instance, a colliery in Monmouthshire, where 23 miles of steel arches are in use along the main roads, was able, after a seven months' stoppage, to haul coal from the faces along all its haulages on the day the colliery was restarted." Brief reference may be made to the Swansea Division report, in which Mr. W. J. Charlton points out the great superiority of steel rings to timber supports. He says many colliery managers are thankful to-day that they had adopted this mode of support some time before the long coal stoppage. They have found that roads so supported suffered less, to a marked degree, than those supported by timber, and they were able to get up their coal output much more quickly than they could otherwise have done. Midland and Southern Divison. The report of Mr. H. A. Abbott, who has charge of this Division, contains the following remarks : The year under review has been very adversely affected by the prolonged stoppage of the coal mines, extending from the 1st May over the summer and autumn. Fortunately, the safety men remained at work, and thereby the mines were very largely preserved in a condition ready to absorb large numbers of miners on the termination of the dispute. In this respect, where steel arches for the support of roadways were used, they amply proved their superiority over ordinary timber supports. Although first cost is two to three times that of timber, they are more economical in the long run, provide a greater degree of safety, and, by diminishing to a large extent heavy falls of ground on the roadways, they prevent the resultant disorganisation of parts, and sometimes whole districts, of the mine.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||