14th November 1927
Durham Colliery Wages
Owners' Concession
Present Rates Through The Winter
(From Our Labour Correspondent.)
It is virtually certain that a new wages agreement will be negotiated in Durham without a stoppage of work. The colliery owners have agreed that the rates of wages laid down in the 12 months' agreement which was concluded after the national stoppage last
year shall continue in force throughout the winter. The steps of which they had given notice, with a view to applying to the county Wages Board for a revision of the subsistence wage and of the minimum percentage addition to basis rates, are postponed
for two months and if variations in the rates are ultimately allowed they will not take effect until March.
The miners' leaders recognize the value of these concessions, and are therefore urging acceptance of the modification of the agreement for which the owners have asked. This modification will not of itself vary wage rates, but it will enable either party
to the agreement to make application to the Wages Board for an alteration of the minimum percentages. An application to the Wages Board for an alteration of the subsistence wage can be made under the agreement as it stands, but no such application is to
be made until time has shown whether the winter trade will put the industry in a better position. A very slight advance of prices was shown by the September ascertainment, but, even so, the average cost of raising a ton of Durham coal was 13s. 0½d.
and the pithead price was only 12s. 1½d., involving a loss of 11d. a ton. The trading loss for the month was £136,000. In August the loss was 1s. 3¼d. a ton, and in July it was a fraction more. The last ascertainment showed a
"deficiency" of £2,185,000. The deficiency represents the share of the proceeds of the industry due to the owners which has not been kept by them because the receipts were insufficient to meet the wages bill. In Durham the subsistence
wage for low-paid workers is 6s. 8½d. a day, and the average daily wage has recently been 9s.
The Negotiations.
An account of the negotiations with the colliery owners was given on Saturday to the County Mining Federation Board — a body representing the four unions of miners, cokemen, mechanics, and enginemen. It was recalled that in the first place the
owners asked for a reduction of the subsistence wage and the county percentage, but suggested at the same time that it would not be necessary to terminate last year's agreement if the unions would consent to the introduction of a clause (known as the
Northumberland clause) entitling the signatories to bring the amount of the minimum percentage before the Wages Board. If the unions would not consent to such a clause, the agreement would have to be terminated. The leaders told Saturday's conference
that in the absence of an agreement there would be no safeguard at all for wages or other conditions of employment.
In the earliest stage of the negotiations the men's representatives asked the owners to postpone their demands. They submitted that the volume of trade, particularly the export trade, had been fairly well maintained ; that there had been an increase in
the percentage earned by the industry in September "for the first time during the year," and that, moreover, "having suffered all the hardships imposed by the general depression of trade common to all the coalfields of Great Britain, yet
we are the first to be singled out for a reduction in our standard of life." An earnest appeal was made for the withdrawal of the claim for a reduction of the subsistence wage. "We pointed out that if the economic readjustment of the industry
depended upon the reduction in the wages of those low-paid men, who are already struggling to maintain a very low standard of life, then we must be in a very bad way."
The counter-proposal of the union representatives was that wages should remain unchanged until the end of April ; that the march ascertainment of the proceeds of the industry should govern wages in May, and that any new agreement, whether reached in
direct negotiations or as the result of an appeal to the Wages Board, should also become operative in May. "We pointed out" (the negotiators reported) "that prices must have reached the rock bottom, and the time suggested would afford an
opportunity of observing any development in the conditions of trade. We put the question directly to them that if we were prepared to strongly recommend our members to include the Northumberland clause in our agreement, were they prepared to accept any
or all of the proposals we had submitted."
Owners' Final Proposal.
Following upon this the owners made their final proposal :—
"Subject to the parties agreeing to an amendment of the existing agreement to provider that on the application of either party, the district board, or, failing agreement, its chairman, shall be entitled to review the minimum percentage addition to
basis rates, the will agree not to make application for a revision of the minimum percentage prior to January 15, 1928, and the decision of the board, or its chairman, shall take effect as from March 1, 1928.
"On this proposal being accepted by both parties, the owners will also agree not to make application for a revision of the subsistence wage before January 15, 1928, and that any alteration in its amount shall come into operation on March 1, 1928.
The report of the negotiators went on to say that to leave a large county like Durham without an agreement authorizing conditions of work was unthinkable. "Therefore we are driven to the conclusion that the only course open to us is to urge you to
authorize us to accept the owners' request and include the Northumberland clause in our agreement. . . . We feel sure you will appreciate our efforts in extending the present agreement for two months beyond the normal period. This means a great deal to a
county like ours, and if, inevitably, we are driven to the Chairman of the Board, we have no more to fear from an independent mind than from the owners of the county."
"Almost unanimously" the Federation Board accepted the recommendation. The delegates, who numbered over 400, will convene special branch meetings at which the members of the unions will vote on the proposals, and the figures will be returnable
on December 1.
In a statement made after the meeting Mr. J. Robson, president of the Durham Miners Association, said :— "It was clear that the delegates realized the gravity of the position. I feel confident that the county will appreciate the
advantage of the owners' postponing their application of the modification of the agreement for a further two months. To the lower-paid men, more especially, it will give the assurance that no alteration will take place in their wages at least until
March. I have not the slightest hesitation in recommending acceptance. Everything points to a settlement. At any rate, there will be no stoppage of the collieries in Durham."
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Robson, J. | | | |