5th November 1927, Page: 124, Column: 1
Compressed Air In Cool Mines*
By Marc Piard.
In a cool mine, tapping high-pressure lines through reducing valves lowers the
temperature beyond remedy. It is the writer's suggestion that, for low-pressure
work, low-pressure air should be generated in a compressor installed
underground adjacent to the work, and that the jacket-water of the compressor
should be utilised for re-heating purposes. Such a system of compressed air
distribution, designed especially for service in cool mines, is described in
the following notes.
The suggested system includes a three-wire pole line from the sub-station to
the opening nearest to the working face, with a cable connection extending to
the latter from the openings ; an electrical centrifugal unit; a reservoir
excavated in the ground ; and a distribution line, re-heated by jacket-water.
As regards the reservoir, it may be pointed out that in many mines there are
blind or abandoned tunnels that could be used for the purpose.
The centrifugal type of compressed air machine is a comparatively new
departure, and it was formerly considered that such a machine, operating at
less than 1,000 kilowatts per unit, would be commercially impracticable. At the
present time, however, these machines are being built in Europe for as little
as 400 kilowatts per unit, and as much as 110 lb. per square inch pressure.
One advantage which these centrifugal machines have over other types is that
they may be driven by plain induction motors, without the help of special
starters — a consideration of the first importance where the electrical
regulations are severe.
A compressor which is to operate a hoist and several conveyors, loading
machines, and air picks, will require as much as 400 kilowatts ; and yet such a
machine is so compact — the overall size approximates only 10 by 5 by 5
feet — that it can be easily moved from point to point, as the working
face progresses or retreats.
In a mine whose air and ground temperatures are respectively 40 deg. F. and 50
deg. F., the air engines work at 25 deg. F., this being the practical minimum
quoted by the makers. In the reservoir, then, the air is cooled to a minimum
temperature of 50 deg. F. (the ground temperature), and in the process of
cooling it loses part of its moisture. The actual amount of moisture thus lost
will depend on the size of the reservoir. The larger this is, the drier will
the air become, and at the same time the peaks that the comparatively small
plant is able to take care of will be correspondingly higher.
The level section of the distribution is re-heated by jacket-water in a trough.
As some of the connections are exposed to the cool mine atmosphere, the
temperature of this re-heated air may be as low as 70 deg. F. when it reaches
the engines.
Compared with this, the air from a reducing valve on a high-pressure line would
reach the engine with a temperature not exceeding 40 deg. F. — a
difference, in favour of the low-pressure system, of at least 30 degrees.
The relative performance of the two systems at the point of use can be
estimated both for full-pressure work and for expansion work. The full-pressure
work for a given weight of air at a given pressure is proportional to the
absolute temperature of the air. For the high-pressure and low-pressure lines,
absolute temperatures would be 530 deg. and 500 deg. respectively, showing an
economy, in favour of the latter, of 6 per cent. on full-pressure work alone.
On expansion work, the advantage would be much greater.
When re-heating is negligible at the point of use, the mechanical energy given
out by expansion is equal and opposite in sign, to the loss of internal energy
in the expanded fluid, i.e., under such conditions there is, irrespective of
pressure, a constant output of mechanical energy equivalent to the constant
internal loss of 0.1689 B.T.U. per lb. of air per deg. F.
The drop in temperature for the air tapped by reducing valves is 15 degrees.
The proposed drop of 45 degrees being three times as great, the expansion work
also would be three times as great — or an economy of 66 per cent.
This result is borne out by a test made by the writer 14 years ago in a cool
Alberta mine. Comparison of the performance of locomotives working expansively
in this mine, where the atmosphere had a temperature of 40 deg. F., with that
of similar locomotives in a European mine, where the average temperature in the
haulage road was 70 deg. F., showed that the ratio of air consumption per ton
mile in the two mines was nearly 3:1.
It follows from this that, in a district where one-half of the air power is
used expansively, the general economy at the point of use alone would
approximate 40 per cent.
Air picks working expansively are desirable, but to give the required blow they
would have to be unduly bulky. Air engines on hoisting, conveying, and loading
machinery are designed for partial expansion.
The system here proposed would be particularly advantageous in electrified
mines in which the compressed air requirements at working faces far from the
sub-station are subject to rapid change, since, in addition to the economy at
the point of use (as explained above), it would result in a large saving due to
the transmission being electrical instead of pneumatic. Electrical transmission
over a distance of two miles should have an efficiency of at least 90 per cent.
As a result of having large reserves of compressed air stored in the ground,
the practically uniform supply of alternative current will find a steady
average load, and machinery which is used intermittently will not have to work
on irregular fluctuating pressure, or be compelled to stand idle while waiting
for pressure. Storage of energy is thus provided at low cost, even in
comparison with electrical energy.
It has not been considered necessary in this paper to stress the advantages of
re-heating. These are fully set forth in the textbooks. It will be sufficient
to state that heat, as a booster df compressed air, has an industrial
efficiency of 80 per cent., which is twice the efficiency of the best types of
internal combustion engines.
The use of compressed air in mines is growing very rapidly, with the
introduction of a great variety of mechanical tools and machines which are
proving of great aid to the miner. Its increased employment in the coal-mining
industry is to be commended and encouraged, not only on the score of economy
but also in order that eventually it may entirely displace the use of
explosives and other poisonous substances in the mining of coal.
* From Transactions of the Canadian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy and of
the Mining Society of Nova Scotia. Read at RocKy Mountain Branch Meeting.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Piard, Marc | | | |