8th October 1927, Page: 85, Column: 1
Dust Explosions
The practice of rock-dusting bituminous coal mines, as a means of preventing
and limiting disastrous coal dust explosions, has undoubtedly saved the lives
of hundreds of American coal miners within the past two years, although the
practice is not generally compulsory, and is, therefore, by no means
universally followed in the United States. The partial rock-dusting of mines,
or rock-dusting by improper or inadequate methods, however, provides no
assurance of safety, and rock-dusting may be worse than useless if it is not
done adequately and systematically, Director Scott Turner, of the U.S.
Bureau of Mines, declares. Merely perfunctory scattering of rock-dust or
sporadic rock-dusting at long intervals, or the rock-dusting of only a few main
haulage ways, may result in an unwarranted sense of security. To provide
adequate assurance against deadly mine explosions, all accessible open areas
should be thoroughly rock-dusted, including haulage entries, air courses,
rooms, cross cuts and pillar regions ; and the rock-dusting should be
replenished from time to time so as to hold the incombustible content of the
rib, roof and floor dusts at all times over 65 per cent.
The unfortunate occurrence of several disastrous explosions in bituminous coal
mines in the States within the past few months makes it an opportune time to
review just what the practice Of rock-dusting has accomplished towards
preventing such explosions, Mr. Turner proceeds to say. It is now
approximately two years since the rock-dusting method has been tried more or
less extensively in a considerable number of coal mines of the United States.
For the past ten years, rock-dusting has been required in the gassy and dusty
coal mines in France ; and no explosion disasters have occurred in the French
mines during this period. In Great Britain, rock-dusting has been required by
law since January 1st, 1921, in all but naturally wet mines, and since 1924 it
has been required in all coal mines except the anthracite mines. Although many
localised minor explosions of gas have occurred in face workings, no major
explosions have occurred in rock-dusted mines in Great Britain since January
1st, 1921, except in the case of a recent explosion in South Wales, in which a
strong gas explosion destroyed the ventilating currents.
In the bituminous mines of the United States from January 1st, 1926, to May
1st, 1927, there were 16 major explosion disasters, in each of which more than
five men were killed. Two other incipient explosions in rock-dusted mines
killed four men and one man, respectively. In all these explosions, 438 men
were killed. Eight of the mines were rock-dusted, at least in the vicinity of
the origin of the explosions of gas or coal dust; and this rock-dust, by
extinguishing the flames, localised, or aided in localising, the explosions.
Fifty-seven were killed by these incipient explosions, but 1,892 other men who
were exposed to the liability of death, escaped. According to the testimony of
State mine inspectors, of mine operators, and of Bureau of Mines investigators,
it is probable that a large proportion of these men would have been killed had
it not been for rock-dusting. Two other explosions, occurring in partly or
imperfectly rock-dusted mines, killed 131 men out of 173 who were in the mines.
If rock-dusting is not efficiently done and maintained up to an approved
standard, in parallel air passages as well as haulageways, it is not effective.
During the same period, January 1st, 1926, to May 1st, 1927, eight explosions
occurred in non-rock-dusted mines, killing 244 men out of 761 in the mines. It
seems clear that, from an explosion-risk standpoint, partly or imperfectly
rock-dusted mines class with non-rock-dusted mines. On this basis, there have
been, since January 1st, 1926, ten major explosions in partly rock-dusted and
non-rock-dusted mines in contrast with seven explosions of a limited character
in rock-dusted mines. In the former, 555 men out of 934, or 60 per cent. of the
men in the mines, escaped, Whereas in the rock-dusted mines, 2,078 out of
2,135, or 97 per cent. of the men in the mines at the time of the explosion,
escaped death. These figures clearly show the merit of rock-dusting. The method
will not prevent local gas explosions, but if properly done and maintained,
there can be no doubt of its success in preventing great wide-sweeping
coal-dust explosions that destroy numerous lives and a vast amount of property.
The cost of rock-dusting is comparable with accident insurance premiums, apart
from the humanitarian and psychological value in saving life and improving
morale in coal mining.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Turner, Scott | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |