27th August 1927, Page: 42, Column: 1
Undersea Coal Mining*
Inundation Dominating Hazard.
The June Bulletin of the Canadian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy contains a
paper by Mr. Francis W. Gray on "Mining Coal under the Sea in Nova
Scotia : With Notes on Comparable Undersea Coal Mining Operations
Elsewhere." This paper was submitted for discussion at the 35th annual
meeting of the Mining Society of Nova Scotia, held in June, and it will also be
presented at the Sydney meeting of the Empire Mining and Metallurgical Congress
on September 9th. With maps, plans, sketches, and photographs the paper is a
volume in itself, containing a mass of information enriching the literature on
undersea mining.
In his introduction the Author mentions that 25 per cent. of the present output
of Canadian coal, and 55 per cent. of the Nova Scotia output, comes from under
the sea. A summary is given of the extent of coal production from under the sea
in various quarters of the world, the annual amounts in round figures being :
Great Britain, 6,600,000 tons ; Canada, 3,900,000 tons ; Australia, 200,000
tons ; Chile, 1,200,000 tons ; and Japan, 1,500,000 tons. These figures give a
total of 13,400,000 tons, of which the British Empire is responsible for
10,700,000 tons.
Most of the Canadian undersea coal comes from Nova Scotia, and Dr. W. A. Bell,
of the Geological Survey of Canada, is responsible for the view that
the coal deposits in Nova Scotia were laid down in river valleys and
flood-plain lakes (not necessarily connected), and that the sediments in the
various coal basins were not synchronously laid down. The Cape Breton Island
coalfields are predominantly submarine, only the fringes of the several basins
remaining above sea-level. In several instances the apexes of the basins
outcrop at the shore-line, with insufficient strata-cover to permit entrance by
mining in some of the coal seams. Seams probably exist with outcroppings
entirely under the sea.
Sydney Coalfield Characteristics.
Discussing the characteristics of the Sydney coalfield, the Author says this
field, originally one continuous deposit, is divided by folds of the strata,
running parallel to each other, into three main synclinal basins, with a
general dip of the measures seawards, except as modified along the folds. The
folds are not severe, and there is reason to surmise that they diminish in size
as they proceed seawards. A unique feature of the Sydney coalfield is the
regular uninterrupted seaward inclination of the measures and the included
coal-seams, and the general absence of disturbances of the measures, except the
changes of contour levels by the anticlinal folds and the shallow synclines
lying in between.
Up-to-date the submarine workings have been a more or less unplanned extension
of land workings, proceeding, as was necessary, from known conditions to
entirely unknown conditions. All the factors that are implied in the term
"workability" of the coal — quality, thickness, roof
conditions, and so on — are unknowable in undersea mining until proved by
actual workings, and this procession from land operations to submarine mining
has been, in the nature of things, gradual, and admittedly tentative. While the
dominating hazard of undersea mining is the possibility of inundation from the
sea, the really limiting factor is the cost of carrying ventilation currents,
materials, and motive power, for long distances underground ; and the
complementary difficulty of transporting coal to the surface, all consequent
upon the limitation of accessibility to points on land which become more remote
as the working faces drive seawards. The transport of men to and from the
working faces within a statutory working-day, with sufficient allowance of
productive labour period over and above the period occupied in walking and
riding to the faces, is also a limiting factor.
It is evident, therefore, that the fullest use must be made of the entrances at
the shore. The shafts must be large enough to admit the ultimate volume of air
required for ventilation, and the main-airways underground must correspond in
amplitude. As the recoverable tonnage seawards is necessarily available in some
instances through one shore-locality only, and may represent as high as 200
years of potential production from one set of openings, the factors of
amplitude and permanence in all equipment for ventilation, power-transmission,
and underground transportation, assume an importance much greater than in land
mining, calling for an entirely novel set of standards.
The Author, in 1916, forecast that the limitation of coal-mining seawards in
the Sydney field by cost of production would operate before any probable
physical limitations or actual engineering difficulties of depth and remoteness
from the land openings. This limitation by production costs is already well in
sight in instances where the mine entrances, airways, and haulage passages, are
conditioned by being the result of gradual seaward extension of land
collieries. In several of these instances the continual seaward advance of
workings has necessitated heavy expenditure in re-conditioning of main
haulage-roads and in enlargement ot airways. Such betterments, while serving to
prolong the period of profitable extraction through existing openings and
thereby securing maximum use of present investments in mine development and
equipment, will not permit economic winning of coal beyond a distance from
shore that cannot at this time be accurately gauged, because so much will
depend on thickness and quality of the coal-seams, and the depth of overburden.
Mining under somewhat similar conditions, as at Whitehaven, has proceeded up to
4 miles from shore, and in the upper seams of the Sydney field it may similarly
be extended from existing openings. For the winning of coal beyond this as yet
undemonstrated limit, new methods of access will doubtless be evolved.
A summarization of the conditions indicates that undersea mining in the Sydney
field calls for observation study, and research in several specialised branches
of mining science, namely :—
(a) The local conditions of coal deposition, which requires, as a preliminary,
study of the pre-Carboniferous floor of deposition, a subject that in turn
calls for research into the conditions that delimited the basins wherein the
coal-bearing rocks were laid down, and calls for a specialist in tectonic
geology applied to the coalfield of Eastern Canada whose services have not yet
been developed.
Questions of quality and economic availability of coal, allied to geological
structure of the coalfields, are a part of this general problem.
(b) The development of technicians of high-grade ability, for co-operation with
practical coal-miners, in the unique problems of earth movements consequent
upon coal-mining; of transportation, ventilation, and transmission of
motive-power, that will accompany the development of what may eventually prove
to be the classic instance of undersea coal-mining, both in regard to depth of
strata-cover and seaward extension of mine-workings.
There have been a number of attempts to estimate the coal content of the
submarine area of the Sydney coalfield. It may be stated that the existence of
a substantial reserve of recoverable coal is at this date more definitely
established than at any previous date, and there is now sufficient coal
virtually proved by existing workings to maintain the present rate of
production for 200 years. As there is no ascertainable knowledge of the unmined
seaward-coal, except that obtained by actual advance of workings, it is not
possible to make a more accurate estimate than to state the balance of
probability is that the coal-seams extend as far seawards as it will be
possible to mine them.
Where the mining of one seam only under the sea is in question, or possibly two
seams, the ideal method of extraction is entire removal of the coal by the
longwall method, with careful packing of the waste; but use of this method is
only possible where roof and floor conditions favour longwall, in seams of
suitable thickness, and where packing material is available.
The order in which superimposed seams should be worked is a matter that has
been much debated in regard to ordinary practice in land mining, but it is a
point of especial importance in undersea mining. The writer believes that if
statement of a broad rule is possible in undersea operations, seams should be
worked in descending order, and this was the order in which the seams were
developed under the sea in the Glace Bay area from Tablehead.
The importance of the effect of order of extraction upon the future of the
Sydney field is very large, because in the centre of the field there is 40 feet
of coal included within a strata column of less than 1,000 feet. Six of these
seams should be workable now or at some future date.
Methods of Extraction.
The pillar-and-room method of extraction has always been preferred in Nova
Scotia. This has been the case because thick clean seams were for many years
mined to crop openings at shallow depths, and the traditional method has
survived, being to-day employed to win thinner seams at much greater depths,
conditions under which there is good reason to believe longwall extraction
would give better results. The writer believes that longwall mining in the
Sydney field has failed to progress as it has done in other fields because of
conservatism and unfamiliarity of local miners with the method, and through
insufficient numbers of miners trained to longwall work locally available, and
not to any inherent inapplicability of the method to local conditions.
In discussing the merits of the longwall method as applied to local conditions,
Mr. J. J. McDougall states that — "while the longwall system
is usually adopted in these seams, it is also found to be advantageous in thick
seams where the overbearing strata is so heavy that the maintenance of roadways
in rooms, and the extraction of pillars, add materially to the cost of
production."
The President of our Society in 1921 stated :
"Experience in pillar drawing proves conclusively that under such
conditions as obtain in Princess Colliery, with a cover of 1,000 feet or over
and a roof of the nature so far found, some method must be adopted whereby
pillars can be removed simultaneously with the advance of the workings."
This is precisely the condition that will be encountered in every seam worked
at depth in the submarine area. The conditions are in fact that partial
extraction of a coal seam has under these circumstances become impracticable,
and all or none of the seam must be extracted. As longwall achieves an equal
subsidence (if there is ignored for purposes of this argument the vertical
extent of subsidence), whereas under the conditions in question the leaving of
pillars causes an unequal subsidence, longwall extraction would seem not only
preferable but without alternative.
The persistently regular and comparatively gentle undersea dip of the coal
seams in the Sydney field over a proved shore-frontage of 30 miles, and the
general absence of disturbance of the strata, are conditions favouring undersea
mining to an extent and over a period of time that will probably exceed all
similar coal-mining operations elsewhere. From experience so far gained in this
field, it seems probable that depth of cover and consequent roof-pressure will
prove a factor more limiting than distance from shore. The engineers of the
operating companies have adopted 2,400 feet of vertical strata-cover as the
limit of undersea extraction for purposes of reserve-tonnage calculations, but
it is believed this limit will be exceeded. A depth of 2,300 feet has been
attained in undersea mining at Inverness Colliery; and at Springhill Mines, in
a land area, a depth of 3,000 feet has been reached. In both instances,
however, great difficulties from roof pressure are being met with.
Undersea Mining at Home.
In the concluding portion of his paper Mr. Gray passes in review
submarine coal mining elsewhere than in Nova Scotia, with references to British
Columbia, Great Britain, Australia, Chile, Japan, and Spain. He mentions that
the Cumberland coalfield extends along the southern shore of Solway Firth for
15 miles, approximately from Maryport to St. Bee's head. The Whitehaven
collieries are in many respects the most interesting example of undersea
coal-mining practice. Coal has been worked under the sea at Whitehaven since
the 17th century, and it is believed was the first instance of the practice. At
Whitehaven, also, workings have been extended further under the sea than
elsewhere. It was in the neighbourhood of Whitehaven, at Flimby, close to
Workington, in 1834, that the sea broke into the workings of the Lady and
Isabella pits and drowned 36 men and boys.
The general dip of the strata in the Whitehaven district is seawards. A system
of faults, some upthrows and some downthrows, crosses the measures. In a
distance of slightly under four miles, proceeding from shore, the sum of the
several downthrows is 438 feet, Which is offset by upthrows totalling 330 feet.
The effect of the faults so far met with in the seaward advance of the workings
has been to increase by over 100 feet the gain in depth of cover resulting from
the inclination of the seams. The depth of the sea is fairly constant, being
from 80 to 100 feet over the sea-area likely to be coal-bearing, a depth which
is maintained at 3½ miles from shore. The sea-floor, which is very flat,
consists of sticky clay and sand, forming an excellent seal over the underlying
rocks. The measures contain a number of underclays which also act as seals. At
Whitehaven the seams dip seawards about 4 degrees. Workings have extended four
miles under the sea from high-water mark, depth of cover being at this point
1,400 feet with 100 feet of water. Both longwall and pillar-and-room extraction
are employed. Generally speaking longwall is practised in seams up to 5 feet in
thickness, and pillar-and-room in seams exceeding this thickness. The thinnest
seam worked at Whitehaven is 2 feet 3 inches in thickness, and the thickest 15
feet.
Four superimposed seams have been worked under the sea. The order of extraction
has at Whitehaven, as elsewhere, depended upon the quality of the seams, the
best seam being first worked. At no time have superimposed workings proceeded
simultaneously in more than two seams, and it has been demonstrated that
simultaneous working of two seams is bad practice and liable to set up
"creep." Under present practice, where more than one seam is worked,
not more than one seam is worked at the same time over a given area.
The coalfield of Durham and Northumberland is an irregular basin having a
synclinal axis aligned north and south. The seams, in Northumberland, dip
eastward under the sea, and, in Durham, are concealed along the coast by
Permian rocks. Along the coast of North Durham and Northumberland, the dips
going north change from a very slight eastward-dip under the sea to an
inclination of 1 in 10.3 (5½ degrees) and then to a rising inclination of
1 in 120. In Durham, the general dip of the seam is seawards. The average
inclination of seams followed under the sea is 1 in 16, gradually flattening
out to about 1 in 85. The field has a shore frontage of 46 miles, extending
northwards from a point just north of Hartlepool. The earliest undersea
workings appear to have commenced at North Seaton colliery, in Northumberland,
in 1872, and there appears to have been a general development of submarine
mining about 1899 in south Durham.
The coalfield of the Lothians is connected with the Fifeshire coalfield under
the firth of Forth. From the Fifeshire shore to that of Haddington and
Edinburgh shires is nineteen miles, and of the continuity of the coal-seams
across this distance there is no reasonable doubt. The whole series of
coal-bearing strata is present, and 130 square miles of coal-bearing measures
are contained in a synclinal basin, having its axis north and south, with the
seams outcropping under the firth on either side of this axis. The axis of the
basin swings towards the Fifeshire shore and there is a large portion of the
basin where the lower seams are at a depth exceeding 4,000 feet. The field is
extensively worked from the Fifeshire shore.
It is anticipated (vide Mr. Richard Kirkby) that at a future date the
Fifeshire collieries will mine a distance of possibly eight miles from shore,
and that the Lothian collieries will extend a similar distance. It is probable
that mining operations will extend to the depth limit of mining along the
slopes of the syncline, but will not be able to win the coal lying in the
bottom of the basin. The depth of the syncline is greater on the Fifeshire
shore than on the Lothian shore, and while a portion of the upper series of
seams only will be mineable from the Fifeshire side, it will be possible to
mine the Upper, Middle and Limestone seams from the opposite shore. The depth
of water under the firth is mostly under 120 feet, and so far as known the
sea-floor is covered with a thick deposit of stiff boulder-clay, a combination
favourable to undersea mining.
The recently developed coalfield of Kent is believed to have a seaward
extension under the straits of Dover along a shore frontage of some 20 miles,
the probable workable limit of the extension being placed, for the estimating
purposes of the Royal Commission, at four miles distant from and paralleling
the shoreline. The Kent coalfield has only just passed the pioneering stage of
development, and the working of the undersea extension is a matter for the
future. The coalfield is a concealed one, and the undersea extension is unique,
inasmuch as the coal seams are at a considerable depth at the shore-line and
entirely concealed by younger rocks. The existence of the Kent field, which had
been presumed by Godwin Austen as far back as 1855, was actually proved
by a borehole at the foot of the Shakespeare cliff at Dover, where the Coal
Measures were met at a depth of 1,157 feet from the surface.
Other probable undersea coal-areas are those under Swansea and Carmarthen bays,
being extensions of the South Wales coalfield, estimated together at 20 square
miles. No mining has been attempted in either area.
* Excerpts from paper by Mr. F. Gray, President, Mining Society of Nova
Scotia.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Austen, Godwin | | | |
| Bell, W. A., Dr. | | | |
| Gray, Francis W. | | | |
| Kirkby, Richard | | | |
| McDougall, J. J. | | | |