|
25th August 1927 Fall Of RoofKills Cleator Moor MinerAn Unexpected FaultAn inquest conducted by Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, Coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, was held at Cleator Moor on Saturday, concerning the death of Daniel O'Neill (66), an iron ore miner of Queen Street, Cleator Moor. The Coroner had the assistance of a jury, of which Mr. J. Murphy was foreman. O'Neill was terribly crushed by a fall of roof in Lord Leconfield's York iron ore mine, Cleator Moor, on Friday morning, and his death was instantaneous. In the course of the evidence, witnesses testified to the method of roof examination previous to the fall being the best and could not describe any better system. Mr. W. Loudon (H.M. Inspector of Mines) admitted he did not know of any better examination. Mr. Lightfoot, (Messers. Saul and Lightfoot, Carlisle) appeared on behalf of the Company, and Mr. T. Gavan Duffy represented the relatives. Matthew O'Neill, coal hewer, 30 Bowthorn Road, Cleator Moor, who gave evidence of identification, said his father was a widower and had been an iron ore miner all his life, knowing his work very well. James Spowart, iron ore miner, 47 Crossfield Road, Cleator Moor, said he was working with O'Neill and a young man called Edward Graffin at York pit after descending at 6 o'clock in the morning. Witness accompanied by Graffin, examined the place of the accident as soon as he went down and found everything apparently safe. Witness had a long bar and he would have been about nine feet from the roof. Heard A Thud "I heard a thud," witness continued, "and shouted down, Danny O'Neill, but got me no answer. I ran down to see what I could find and saw some ground had fallen. And he was lying underneath one of the pieces. I shouted to some more men working nearby and they helped me to roll the lump off him." The lump weighed about one hundred weight and witness thought it had fallen 29 or 30 feet with great force. He thought deceased must have been in a stooping position and that the lump hit him in the back. Replying to the Coroner witness said he examined the roof from which the piece of stone came down, from a ledge and not from the ground. It was a very good roof. It did not need timbering because it was too high, and it did not look as if it required it. The question of timbering the roof was left to miners. If they had thought the roof was dangerous they would have taken it down. After the fall he examined the stone and found it had come off a "slip." It was quite sound and solid. Stones with slape backs were very hard to detect sometimes. The Coroner: By tapping this stone, would it have been impossible to find if it had a slape back? Witness: Not always; sometimes you can. Might Happen At Any Time Answering further questions by the Coroner, witness said Mr. Nixon, the overman had also examined the placed before the accident, and he left instructions about the roof that they had to be careful and look over it well. In the opinion of witness such an accident could happen at any place at any time. By Mr. Loudon: He made the examination from the ladder and ledge. The stick would always indicate a hollow sound when the stone was hollow. It was eleven or twelve feet long. Mr. Loudon: How far was the roof above your head from where you were standing on the ledge? — Witness: Almost a ten foot. Could you use a solid iron rod from the ledge you were standing on to the height of the roof? — Yes. Fifteen or sixteen feet long? — No But you will need that in some parts of the roof? — I quite agree it's impossible for a man to stand on a ladder and hold a fifteen feet rod. By the Coroner: The roof was three or four feet from his head. The Coroner: The Inspector is wanting to see whether in fact you did examine the roof at the place where this stone came from, he is asking you as to how far this ledge is from the roof and the length of the pole, so I don't think your explanation is very satisfactory yet. Witness: With the pole we have with an iron spike I could reach it thoroughly from the ledge. How long is this pole? — Ten to twelve feet long. And you are five feet nine inches in height? — Yes. You think you examined it satisfactorily yesterday morning? — Yes By Mr. Lightfoot: The fall came away near where he was standing on the ledge. It was perfectly easy for him to examine the place because it was within his reach. If there had not been any ledge he would have stood the ladder against the pillar. He might have been underneath the place himself. A High Roof By Mr. Duffy: The reason why the roof was not touched was because he did not think it necessary. The roof was too high. If the roof was unsafe the question of being too high would not have prevented something being done in the way of prevention? — No. It is no excuse for being a bad roof? — It was a very good roof. And that is the reason it was not timbered; you regarded the roof apparently safe? — Yes. The Coroner: You were going to work underneath this roof yourself and were satisfied to work under it yourself? — Yes. Thomas Nixon, overman at York pit of 22 Crossfield Road, Cleator Moor, gave corroborative evidence, and said he would not have had any hesitation in working underneath it. They paid special attention to it because it was high. O'Neill was a practical man. He had been with the firm for 30 years in that and other pits, and was a faithful old servant. Mr. Loudon: Is that the only method of examination that could be taken? — Yes. How do you reach a roof in a place 30 or 35 feet wide? It is not satisfactory to assume a roof is sound simply because it is cleaned. Cannot we introduce some other method of examination? I am quite aware of the fact that Cleator Moor has had a very good record. I understand it is fifty years since there was an accident. There is nothing in your mind? — Witness: No. We can climb ladders and get to any place. The Best Method. The fact that after such careful examination this thing takes place goes to show it is not giving satisfactory results. Probably it is the best that can be done? — I think we have the best method. We could not work in a better way than that. Mr. Loudon said he could not suggest any better method. He agreed they could reach with a pole but could not get the sound out of it. He pointed out certain thicknesses and the dividing line between hollow sound and none. He thought every part of a roof should be examined where a man was working or passing. A lamp would not show a bad stone. (To witness): You did not examine the whole of the roof? — As far as it wants examining. Witness agreed with Mr. Lightfoot that there would not be the same noise from a thin stone, as that from a thick stone, and that it did not follow when a noise came from thin stone it was a faulty roof. It was a 34 feet Wellstone roof. The fact of there not being an accident at Cleator Moor for fifty years spoke for the method carried out in that mine. Dr. Eaton said he went to the pit and examined the body. There were several wounds on the head, his chest was crushed, ribs fractured, pelvis fractured, both thighs fractured, and left leg between knee and ankle fractured. He must have been killed instantly. In his remarks to the jury the Coroner said he did not know whether they thought the roof had been properly examined. One had always found evidence to the affect that the roof had been properly examined and that in the case of stones having slapped backs they were always difficult to detect; and that such a stone was likely to come away in a good many cases. The roof is tapped and sounded, there is no indication of anything wrong, but it does not come away. There are no indications whatever, but in many instances falls of roof occur. It happened not only in the case of roofs 30 feet high, but in cases of small roofs. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidentally killed by a fall of roof." On behalf of the Company, Mr. Lightfoot said deceased was an old and faithful servant who had been in their employ for 30 years. Their loss was very much regretted. Sympathy was extended to the relatives, the officials associating themselves with Mr. Lightfoot's remarks.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||