Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

30th July 1927, Page: 12, Column: 1

Coal Cleaning

At Edinburgh a joint conference of the Society of Chemical Industry (Fuel Section), the Institution of Gas Engineers, and the Coke Oven Managers' Association, had under discussion a variety of papers on the cleaning of coal.

Choice of Process.

In their paper on "A Comparison of Processes for the Cleaning of Coal," Drs. W. R. Chapman and R. V. Wheeler arrived at the conclusion that there can be no one coal-cleaning process that is universally the best. Each type of process is, no doubt, better than all the others under some particular set of conditions, but no process yet devised can be regarded as the most suitable for the cleaning of all coals under all conditions. Apart from considerations regarding the character of the coal (and associated mineral matter) to be treated, the choice of a cleaning process will depend upon such matters as : the desirability of a wet or a dry process ; the ultimate use to which the coal is to be put; and the space, building, and accessory plant already available. The choice will, however, depend primarily on the nature of the coal. In this respect guidance is given by (a) a series of screening analyses of the raw coal; and (b) a series of float-and-sink tests on sized samples of the raw coal in a number of liquids of different specific gravities. Screening analyses will indicate the extent to which the distribution and sizes of the raw coal varies from time to time. Float-and-sink tests will indicate the uniformity or otherwise of the raw coal. Both sets of determinations considered together will suggest, for example, whether a process that functions accurately with a regular feed is more desirable than one that is less accurate in its performance, but can meet fluctuating conditions more readily.

The Chemist's Job.

Discussing the above paper, Dr. Lessing said it was still maintained that most of the British coals were not only holding their own with foreign coals, but were in most cases superior. Where, however, they had been lacking in late years was in their preparation for the market, and particularly in the extraction of the mineral matters they contained when mined, and mined under the more modern methods of mining. There was one point on which he would like to sound a warning, and that was on the question of the economic limit of ash contents. It was a very usual phrase used in connection with coal-cleaning operations, and it was a fact that to-day collieries had to try and work to the economic limit, not use too much coal, and just clean their coal to the extent which the buyer absolutely insisted on. It was their duty to go a little ahead of economic practice. To-day it was mainly the foreigner who insisted on low ash contents, and it was the export trade that had to work practically to the bidding of the foreign buyer. There was no reason why the home consumer should be satisfied with any less cleanliness in the raw material than the foreign buyer was. In regard to the processes, Hittinger's law was a horse that had been flogged or ridden to death. It was a very convenient mathematical expression where they did not quite know what was going to happen, but he doubted whether any existing process could be explained by it, or whether, by using that formula, one could base definite results on it. One problem to which Dr. Chapman referred was the slurry problem, which was identical with the dust problem in dry cleaning. That was one of the great problems to be faced. At the same time, he had to consider that this very dust was the material which they needed to-day and which they ought to extract from the coal. In conclusion, he said it was to-day the chemist's and physicist's job to devise means for improving the raw material and not allow the miner simply to dig out the raw material from the earth and allow it to be consumed in the state in which it was procured from Nature and with a material which did not belong to it.

The Vital Point.

The paper by Mr. C. W. H. Holmes, on "Notes on the Cleaning of Coal with Special Reference to Pneumatic Separation," dealt principally with the process between the stages in which they found it and at which they left it at the moment. With regard to the question of dust, they had investigated the question of cyclones in the last few years, and had not adopted them; they had adopted bag filters at present, and were in touch with the University of Manchester, in connection with the textile side of this problem. Mr. Holmes thought he could say they had made very considerable strides in the collection of dust in the last six months. They were also now considering an entirely new process for dust collection. With respect to the question of wet coal, they had had a lot of experience of experimental work in connection with it, but they had not been able to get down to a definite statement as to how much wet coal they had to have before it had an influence on the process. If they could screen the coal they could clean it, but every particular case must be treated on its own merits. The question of treating unsized coal by pneumatic separation was a remarkably difficult one, so difficult, indeed, that he had no hope himself that it would be done commercially. There was one thing and one thing only that was the alpha and omega of coal cleaning — it must stand or fall on pounds, shillings and pence — and usually pence in these hard times. But that was a very, very vital point that was sometimes lost sight of. He thought that in pneumatic separation they had just as much chance of dealing with a fluctuating load as they had in any other coal cleaning process. In the case of extreme fluctuations it might be necessary, purely as an insurance, to circulate a larger proportion of middles, because there was rather a division between the true middle product of the coal and what they called middlings. It might be necessary to circulate rather more in order to provide an insurance against the path of reference widening out and getting into the clean coal.

Froth Flotation.

Another paper was by Mr. W. Guider, on "Froth Flotation applied to a Baum Washer." The author pointed out, in connection with a plant under discussion, that the advantages accruing from the froth flotation plant have entirely justified its installation. A well-washed slack of 6 per cent. ash, he said, is obtained with unfailing regularity. The slack is black in colour, and no lumps form in the mass on drying. The beneficial effect on the washer water is equally marked, contamination on the surface of the larger sizes being eliminated. A constant stream of fine dirt and clay is discharged from the washer, carrying with it only a negligible amount of fine coal, which represents a loss of approximately 0.1 per cent. on the dry feed to the washer. It is now unnecessary to withdraw sludge periodically from the settling tank, and it has never been run off since the froth flotation plant was introduced. The additional coal recovered with a throughput of 3,000 tons per week is estimated at about 30 tons over that period. On the other hand, the system is subject to disadvantages ; the froth is delivered from the froth flotation plant in a very wet condition, containing about 50 per cent. of water, and is perfectly liquid. This is the major disadvantage associated with this process.

Preparing Coal for Market.

The paper on "The Preparation of Coal for the Market" was in the hands of Mr. F. S. Sinnatt, assistant director, Fuel Research Board. In the course of his paper he said the preparation of the coal for the market may be defined as the process by which natural products, more or less impure, are converted into products more suitable for commercial utilisation. The process embraces sizing ; purification by dry or wet processes ; blending ; disposal of the waste products and effluents. The sequence in which the above are carried out varies with the general scheme of purification in operation. In view of the work of Lessing and Cobb the process may in the future include the treatment of coal with chemical substances to influence its behaviour on carbonisation or combustion. Prochaska ("Coal Washing," 1921, McGraw-Hill Book Co.) in an examination of the principles underlying the purification of coal, states that the following maxims may be considered as established in connection with the subjects : (1) The preparation of coal shall, by cleaning of the raw material and the production of suitable and Well-screened sizes, secure a maximum price per ton of output. (2) To arrive at this result three points must be kept in view : (a) the highest possible purity of coal; (b) smallest possible loss of coal; (c) small cost of production. It is not possible to accept (2a) without modification. It must be recognised that the preparation of grades of coal is frequently not confined to purification solely, but is designed to provide coals possessing definite properties.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Chapman, W. R.      
Guider, W.      
Holmes, C. W. H.      
Lessing, Rudolf, Dr.      Whos Who Page
Prochaska, —      
Sinnatt, Frank Sturdy      Whos Who Page
Wheeler, Richard Vernon      Whos Who Page


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print