|
30th July 1927, Page: 6, Column: 1 Mining SubsidenceFinal Report of CommissionThe Second and Final Report of the Royal Commission on Mining Subsidence (Cmd. 2899, price 1s. 3d. net, H.M. Stationery Office) has now been issued. The inquiry has been concerned almost exclusively with coal mining and its effect upon the stability of the surface. While some surface subsidence as a result of coal mining is justifiable, its extent is not quantifiable, and cannot be accurately predicted even when all the conditions are tolerably well ascertained. Moreover, the Commissioners say, whilst subsidence is admittedly inevitable, damage due to that subsidence is by no means a necessary consequence. By precautions not normally prohibitive in cost the effects of subsidence upon surface buildings can now be minimised. Some of the existing damage might have been obviated had greater foresight in construction been exercised. In many cases the remedy of the surface owner in respect of surface subsidence is adequate. The three main principles of law which govern the position are (1) That the law both of England and Scotland recognises and protects a property in unsevered minerals as complete as the property it recognises and protects in land itself. (2) That where the surface and subjacent and adjacent strata are in separate ownerships the surface in its natural state is entitled to support. (3) That landowners have an unfettered right to make such stipulations as they please When they grant out the surface and the minerals separately. The Commission are not prepared to make any recommendations as to compensation in the case of property of local authorities and public utility companies in respect of sewers, water gas or electricity mains, tramway lines, and the like ; similarly as regards the case of existing houses and other buildings to whomsoever these may belong. They are of opinion, however, that the right given to other persons under Part I. of the Mines (Working Facilities and Support) Act, 1923, to prohibit and restrict the working of minerals should be extended to local authorities and statutory undertakings to which the code applies. It is also recommended that private owners or occupiers of existing houses of an annual value not exceeding £40 who have no right of support or right to compensation, subject to certain conditions, shall have a right to compensation for damage accorded them. Claims for compensation shall be enforceable in England in the County Court irrespective of the amount), and in Scotland in the Sheriff Court of the county. A further recommendation is that private owners of houses already possessing a right to compensation, where the value of the hereditament does not exceed £700, should have the benefit of the same procedure as in the above case. The Commission recommend the introduction of legislation to provide for the compulsory disclosure, subject to proper safeguards, of colliery underground plans (a) To prospective builders in general, and to local authorities in particular in connection with the preparation and subsequent development of town planning and housing schemes, and (b) to owners of houses of the type referred to who desire to prefer claims for compensation for damage believed to be due to subsidence occasioned by mineral workings. With a view to removing existing anomalies the Commission recommend that negotiations similar to those which resulted in the passing of Part II. of the Mines (Working Facilities and Support) Act, 1923, should now be set on foot, with a view to the introduction of legislation to amend the code in its application to undertakings other than railways. In connection with this recommendation they suggest (a) the extension of the benefits of the code to cover public buildings, public baths, recreation grounds, cemeteries, etc., to which they do not now apply, and (b) the increasing of the prescribed distance, at any rate for the purposes of notice, to one-half the depth of the seam. In addition to the specific recommendations, they express the hope (a) that the British Colliery Owners' Research Association will expedite its promised inquiry into the methods of working coal, with special reference to the mitigation of subsidence ; (b) that in connection with the subsidence problem local authorities will take full advantage of the very wide powers conferred on them by the Town Planning Acts ; (c) that every encouragement will be extended to local authorities to carry out experiments by way of testing the relative merits of the different special methods of construction; (d) that local authorities will give special consideration to subsidence damage in framing their building bye-laws and that these bye-laws will be frequently revised to keep them abreast of advancing scientific knowledge. The opinion is expressed that in the future much may be done to minimise damage by subsidence, suggested remedies including (1) hydraulic stowage, more scientific methods of mining, the scientific lay-out of the surface, precautions to be taken in the construction of surface buildings, and enlightened building bye-laws. These questions are discussed in the Report from which excerpts are made as follows :— "With regard to hydraulic stowage, many witnesses having suggested that this method of packing should be made compulsory in this country, we considered it desirable to obtain full evidence as to the working and cost of the system elsewhere. For this purpose we called in evidence Major H. M. Hudspeth, one of H.M. Inspectors of Mines, who submitted to us the results of an exhaustive study at first hand of the conditions with respect to hydraulic stowage which obtain in France, Belgium, Germany and more particularly in Upper Silesia. "Major Hudspeth's general conclusion is that hydraulic stowage undoubtedly reduces surface damage to a minimum, though it may increase the actual area over which subsidence occurs. It has, too, the collateral advantage of preventing spontaneous combustion underground. Its universal adoption in Great Britain is, however, impracticable, firstly, because of the cost, which Major Hudspeth puts at 1s. per ton even in the most favourable circumstances ; secondly, because of the scarcity of suitable stowing material (except, perhaps, in a very few areas such as South Staffordshire) ; thirdly, because it is unsuitable for longwall workings — the most usual form of workings in this country ; and fourthly, because the natural conditions at many pits are unfavourable, e.g., the seams are flat and thin, or the conditions of roof and floor are such that the introduction of water underground would be fatal to the working of the mine. Hydraulic stowage might, however, in exceptional cases be desirable and even economic ; and we have it in evidence that it is in fact being advantageously employed to some extent at Motherwell, where the cost is estimated at 1s. 3d. per ton. "It may be recalled, in this connection, that under the Mines (Working Facilities and Support) Act, 1923, power is specifically given to the Railway and Canal Commission, in granting applications for the imposition of restrictions upon the working of minerals required for support, to include restrictions upon 'the methods of working or packing' (Section 8 (6)). In the case also of applications for a right to work minerals, the Commission are empowered, in granting the right, to impose such terms and conditions as they may think fit (Section 6 (1)), which clearly might include one that hydraulic stowage be employed. In point of fact, however, we understand that in none of the Orders so far made under the Act has any obligation to employ hydraulic stowage been imposed. "In so far as concerns methods of mining, we are advised that the least damage is caused where the workings are advanced regularly and quickly by longwall, preferably by machine cutting and where packing is tight. More regular and even working tends to avoid actual surface damage by making the subsidence less uneven. Longwall working is, however, not always possible; for example, in very thick seams, and also where the roof is bad, bord and pillar working is necessary. A systematic examination of the effects on the surface of the various methods of working is, we understand, in contemplation by the British Colliery Owners' Research Association. We trust it will not be delayed, for such an examination should be of great value in regard to the economic development both of surface and minerals. "With reference to the layout of the surface, we have referred to the disadvantage of building houses in long terraces and the advisability of constructing them in blocks of two or four instead. This is the growing modern practice. The more scientific 'zoning' and development of the surface according to the current conceptions of town and regional planning should also do much to mitigate the damage caused by subsidence. "We are informed that provision can be made under town planning schemes not only for the separation of industrial and residential areas, but also for the prevention or special regulation of building or other surface works on land liable to subsidence, and that a scheme may specify, e.g., the number of houses to the acre, the number of storeys in a house, and the maximum number of houses which may be built in one continuous block. It is to be hoped that the authorities responsible for the preparation and administration of such schemes will take advantage of the very wide powers conferred on them by the town planning acts. In this connection it is obviously desirable that these authorities should have the fullest available information as to existing and prospective mineral workings and their probable surface effects. "With reference to precautions in the construction of surface buildings, expert evidence tendered to us, particularly by Dr. Oscar Faber and Colonel Arthur, shows that by suitable precautions in construction taken at an expense which, although in some cases proportionately serious, is rarely out of the question, the greater risks of damage to buildings due to subsidence can be avoided. Dr. Faber expressed the view that ordinary brick buildings would suffer much less from subsidence if lime mortar were replaced by cement mortar, the tensile strength of the latter being many times greater. The resulting increase of cost would not exceed two or three per cent. In his opinion it would be possible to secure practically complete protection against damage by subsidence at an additional cost in the worst cases of not more than fifty per cent., and in the great majority of cases of much less. Generally speaking, the larger the building the less would be the proportion of additional cost involved. For very tall buildings a steel framework would even be cheaper than brickwork. The ordinary miner's cottage in a mining area would, he considered, be perfectly safe if built of ordinary brickwork with cement mortar on a properly constructed ferro-concrete raft. It seems true that in some cases the additional cost would still be prohibitive ; but not so in all, and with constantly improving methods of construction its tendency would always be to decrease. Colonel Arthur considers that even now comparative safety would be attained at an increased cost of from two to nine per cent. for houses of the type erected under the 1919 Housing Act."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||