|
30th July 1927, Page: 4, Column: 1 Fuel ResearchAnnual Report of BoardIn the Report of the Fuel Research Board for 1926 (H.M. Stationery Office, 1s. 3d. net.), Sir Richard T. Threlfall, K.B.E., F.R.S., expresses the view that "the coal stoppage in 1926 may, in the long run, prove of advantage to our work as the experiences of that year have undoubtedly increased the interest taken by the mining industry in this work, and have led to a greater realisation of its importance. This, together with the provisions of the Mining Industries Act of 1926, giving officers of the Department right of access to underground workings and the right to obtain samples of seams opened up or worked, will undoubtedly facilitate progress." The investigation of methods of sampling large commercial consignments of coal will be pressed forward. The Board have always considered this a matter of importance to the country, and especially so to the export trade in coal. There are indications that one result of the coal stoppage has been the greater realisation among colliery owners and coal exporters of the importance of the proper grading, sampling and analysis of consignments of coal. In this connection it is important to ascertain the effect of cleaning, grading and blending of the various seams as at present carried out, and samples are accordingly taken, and examined in the laboratory, of the coals as dispatched from the collieries after treatment. Ordinary commercial examination of consignments of coal does not fall within the province of the Board and is not carried out by the staff. Low Temperature Carbonisation. The question of the low temperature carbonisation of coal has been before the Board from its inception, as being a possible means of so treating coal as to obtain at once a source of oil fuel and motor spirit, and a solid smokeless fuel that can be burned in any domestic grate. "The technical difficulties," the Board says, "have been largely overcome, and several processes have been devised which yield oil-producing fuel; others, producing the solid fuel largely in the form of breeze, may give a greater yield of tar. The difficulty has been, and is, to devise a method than can be worked so cheaply that it will be commercially possible to carbonise the whole or a large portion of the forty million tons of coal now burned yearly in the raw state for domestic purposes, bearing in mind that coal is one of the most highly priced products of our mines." "Much consideration has been given to the best method of carrying any suitable process to the final stage of its development, namely, a test under strictly commercial conditions, and on a commercial scale. Those processes which produce the largest proportion of lump coke suitable for domestic use also produce considerable quantities of rich gas which forms a valuable portion of the products of carbonisation. If such a process were to be adopted throughout the country very large quantities of gas would be produced, the full value of which could only be realised with the cooperation of the gas undertakings." Dr. C. H. Lander, the Director of Fuel Research, also makes a note in his report to the effect that, "disastrous as the coal stoppage has been in many ways, there are signs that gain as well as loss may result. It is becoming more universally realised that the proper utilisation of our coal resources is of importance to the coal industry and to the general industry of the country, and that a condition precedent to this is a knowledge of the characteristics of the various coals available, of the purposes for which each variety is most suited, and the methods by which it can be prepared for utilisation." In his general survey of the question of low-temperature carbonisation Dr. Lander says :— The Royal Commission on the Coal Industry (1925) paid considerable attention to this matter, which was brought prominently to their notice, and took evidence from various independent workers on the subject. In their report they state, "We have given close attention to the question of low-temperature carbonisation, but can find no evidence that the system has yet been anywhere established on a commercial scale for a period sufficiently long to enable the claims made on its behalf to be fully tested." This statement rather naturally prompts questions as to how near we are to a practical process, and what progress has been made in recent years. It may be said at once that distinct progress has been made, but it is still quite impossible to answer the first question beyond saying that it must necessarily be several, and probably many, years before any appreciable fraction of the 140 or so million tons of coal burned in the raw state in this country each year is treated by this method. That this is inevitable will be shown by a consideration of the stages through which any process of this type must necessarily pass before it is adopted on a large scale. These stages may be stated as follows :— (1) The suggested method must be investigated under laboratory conditions where the varying factors involved can bo subjected to close control and where relatively high accuracy of measurement can be obtained. (2) The process must then be carried a stage further by erecting an intermediate scale unit with a view to obtaining further designing data for a still larger unit. In this stage the plant will probably deal with several hundredweights a day. (3) Making use of the information yielded in stage 2, a full-scale unit must now be erected and tried out. The size of this unit would depend upon the type of plant, but might range between, say, 5 tons and 100 tons daily capacity. It is essential that this unit should be capable of multiplication to the full size of a commercial unit without any alteration in scale. (4) A commercial battery consisting of several units similar to those developed in stage 3 would then be erected in some favourable locality, and the economic possibilities of the system examined in actual practice, and, if necessary, tested by actual commercial audit. Though each stage will provide data to guide the designer towards successful accomplishment in the next, it will not provide anything like complete information, and it is to be expected that several designs will be tried, and found wanting, during the progress through stages 2 and 3. The end of stage 3 should prove the technical success of the process and give some idea of the commercial possibilities, but only at the end of stage 4 can a process be said to have been proved. The penalty of proceeding to a higher stage before the completion of the preceding one is almost invariably not only a financial loss, but a general, and possibly undeserved, discrediting of the method. The histories of the early stages of coal-gas manufacture and of low-temperature carbonisation provide, unfortunately, many illustrations of this truth. There are probably about two hundred methods of low-temperature carbonisation which have been suggested, and more or less proved, at any rate, to the satisfaction of their sponsors, so far as stage 1. There are a few being developed on sound lines, most of which have reached the end of stage 2 ; five or six are approaching the end of stage 3 ; two or three are in stage 4 but no one has yet reached the end of stage 4, where audited figures can be produced to show that actual profits have been made under normal working conditions. In every case where an attempt has been made to omit one of the stages enumerated above, the result has been disaster. It must be emphasised again that it is extremely unlikely that any one system of low-temperature carbonisation wiU ever be adopted to the exclusion of other systems. The type of plant to be adopted in any given case will depend on the object aimed at, and the raw material available. The problem of producing a free-burning lump coke, which will replace raw coal for domestic purposes, is quite different from that of recovering oil-producing tars from special material such as cannel coal, or again from that of producing coke breeze, or pulverised coke for use under boilers. The use that can be made of the gas, and hence its commercial value, will depend on local circumstances as well as on the quality of the gas ; this again will have a bearing on the most suitable type of plant to adopt. It has been claimed that by low-temperature carbonisation a low-grade cheap coal can be so treated as to yield a higher grade and higher-priced solid fuel as well as valuable by-products, and, in some cases, this would appear to be true. The economic results to be expected will, however, depend on the reasons for the cheapness of the coal. In some parts of the world, such as Germany, Canada and Australia, there occur large deposits of brown coal, which is a low-grade fuel, but which often occurs in thick deposits workable by open-cast methods at a very low cost. In such a case, any fuel produced by carbonisation would compete with higher grade, and more expensive, fuels produced elsewhere, and an increase in the demand for the product would not increase, and might decrease, the cost of mining the brown coal. In this country the production of low-grade slacks is incidental to the production of the more valuable coals, of which they originally formed a part, and they cost as much to mine as the higher-priced coals. The average selling price must cover the average mining cost, so that the loss on the low-grade slacks must be covered by the higher selling price of the higher-grade product. If a process be developed for the manufacture from the slacks of a low-temperature product which competes with the high-grade coal, the demand for the latter will be reduced, and the margin of profit on its sale will also be reduced. If the process be adopted on a really large scale, the profits on the high-grade coal will no longer be sufficient to meet the losses on the low grade, the price of which will therefore rise. This process will continue until a new economic balance is obtained, and the general result will be a cheapening of the high-grade fuel, but an increase of price of the low grade. The net result should be a gain both to the mining industry and the country generally, but the difference in price, between the untreated low-grade raw material and the higher-grade fuel produced from it, will be much less than in the cases of the brown coals. There is thus less margin available for working expenses, so that a carbonisation process that would pay handsomely in the one case, might be quite impracticable in the other. It is important to distinguish between low grade and low quality. Brown coal, and slack or fines, of small ash content, are low grade but good quality. A slack of high ash content would be a raw material of inferior quality and would give a coke of high ash content and reduced value. In attempting to create a market for a new product it is very important not to create a prejudice by supplying a material of poorer quality than its competitors ; it should rather be superior. It is well also to realise the magnitude of the task of developing fuel treatment to the point where smoke production from domestic chimneys is entirely eliminated. The replacement of 30 or 40 million tons of raw coal now burned annually in domestic grates by coke produced by low-temperature carbonisation, will involve the starting of a new industry comparable in size with the existing carbonisation industries. The carbonisation of 40 million tons of coal would result in the production of some 30 million tons of semi-coke, some 600 million gallons of tar, and some 1,200 million therms of gas of high calorific value, together with some 60 million gallons of crude light spirit which can be obtained by scrubbing the gas. This spirit has a very high benzole equivalent. Against these figures must be set the fuel required for heating the retorts, which may be obtained from the coke, tar, or gas, or from low-grade coal, whichever is the cheaper in the circumstances of each plant. These figures are rough approximations, and are only given to show the magnitude of the problem involved. The cost of the plant for this purpose would amount to at least £60,000,000, not including any plant for the treatment of the crude products. The gas made would considerably exceed the total at present made by the gas undertakings, from which it follows that the co-operation of the gas undertakings will be essential for the development of low-temperature carbonisation on a national scale. If the whole of the coal (110 million tons) at present burned in this country in the raw state were to be carbonised, the above figures would have to be multiplied by 3½. Hydrogenation Process. The possibilities of obtaining oil from coal by the hydrogenation process developed by Dr. Bergius have been actively investigated during the year. The process consists of submitting the coal in a powdered form to the action of hydrogen at a temperature of some 450° C. and a pressure up to some 200 atmospheres. A certain amount of iron oxide is added, partly to remove sulphur, and the coal is usually mixed before treatment into a stiff paste with heavy oil or tar, a heavy fraction of the liquid product from a previous treatment being suitable for this purpose. The material is stirred while the reaction takes place. Experiments carried out in a small bomb at the Fuel Research Station for the past four years showed conclusively that, as claimed, a considerable portion of the coal substance was liquefied by the process, and that the process was applicable to British coals. The results show conclusively that such British coals as have been examined are suitable for the treatment, and that by this means it is possible to obtain from the coal a far greater proportion of liquid fuel than by any other method at present known. The yields so far obtained from typical bituminous coals are somewhat as follows : crude oil and spirit, 50 to 60 per cent. ; gas, 20 per cent. ; partially converted organic matter, 15 per cent. ; and the remainder water or inorganic matter. This compares with, say, 10 per cent., or less, oil-producing tar, which is the most obtainable from similar coals by low-temperature carbonisation. The oil produced contains cyclic, aliphatic, and aromatic hydrocarbons, phenols, and a small proportion of acids and bases ; on distillation some 20 to 25 per cent. of the oil remains as pitch. The above-mentioned yields are obtained from the coal actually treated, and in quoting them no allowance has been made for the considerable amount of coal required for the heat, power, and production of the hydrogen used in the process.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||