Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

16th July 1927, Page: 410, Column: 1

Institution Of Mining Engineers

Newcastle, situated in one of the oldest mining districts in the world, was selected for the 86th general meeting of the Institution of Mining Engineers, Wednesday, 29th June, being the opening day of the gathering. Papers introduced for discussion included :— "Notes on the Overhead Koepe Winding Plant at the Murton Colliery of the South Hetton Coal Company, Limited," by Mr. George Raw, B.Sc. "The Sutton-Steele-and-Steele Process of Cleaning Dry Coal, with some Remarks on Pneumatic Separators," by Mr. Kenelm C. Appleyard. "Experiments on the Reversal of Mine Ventilation," by Mr. W. D. Lloyd and Mr. J. N. Williamson, B.Sc., Ph.D. "An Attempt at the Rationale of Faulting and Subsidence," by Professor Henry Briggs, B.Sc., Ph.D., A.R.S.M.; with an appendix by Mr. John Morrow, M.Sc., D.Eng. "The Driving of Narrow Places," by Mr. S. Walton-Brown, B.Sc. "The Composition of the Gaseous Mixture given off from Coal," by Mr. J. Ivon Graham, M.A., M.Sc., and Mr. A. Shaw, B.Sc.

Overhead Koepe Winding Plant.

In his paper Mr. Shaw mentioned that the first overhead Koepe winding plant in Great Britain was erected in 1914 at Plenmeller Colliery, near Haltwhistle, Northumberland. Suitable conditions and the satisfactory results obtained from the Plenmeller plant led to the decision to install an overhead Koepe plant on similar principles at Murton Colliery. The equipment was needed for the upcast shaft of the colliery, and the duty required was as under :— Net coal load per wind, 4 tons; depth, 1,431 feet; winding time, 80 seconds. Decking : A total of 40 seconds for the separate decking of 4 decks, each deck carrying two tubs of 10 cwt. capacity each. The plant was put into use in December, 1923, and has been in full commission since that date. In his concluding remarks Mr. Shaw said it was not his intention to advocate the general adoption of the Koepe system of winding, but to place on record the performance of a large plant that was chosen to meet particular conditions. The capacity and behaviour of the installation has been entirely satisfactory, while the winder itself has responded to more protractedly severe demands than could have been foreseen at the time of the decision to install it. He was satisfied that the plant does not involve a capital outlay of more than 75 to 80 per cent. of that of a ground-level drum-winder, while in electrical energy its consumption is not more than 85 per cent. of that of the drum type. A large overhead Koepe winder is impossible with steam, and where steam is generated more cheaply than electric power can be secured, the overhead winder may be precluded on that ground. He considers the treatment accorded to the winding rope by the overhead Koepe winder to be one of its greatest advantages, eliminating as it does practically all the factors which deteriorate winding ropes on other winders. The cleaning and care of the rope, as well as the rope adjustment and separate decking arrangements, have been detailed with care, so that the experience gained may be put on permanent record, but these involve little trouble. As stated in his notes on the Plenmeller plant, the Koepe system is inadmissible for sinking.

Cleaning Dry Coal.

A large amount of interest has been taken in recent years in the subject of coal cleaning, and the coal industry owes a great deal to the valuable work done by those inventors and companies who have developed and piloted to success the several systems of wet washing which are now standard names. Mr. Appleyard said inventions for the purpose of dry-cleaning coal date back to the middle of last century. Most of the early ones consisted of some form of stationary apparatus with pulsating air-currents, acting in the form of a jig. They were not usually very efficient, and where efficiency was obtained it was at the expense of capacity or air-consumption. To such an extent was this the case that apparatus of this kind is no longer in general use even for cleaning ores, and it is generally recognised that the type of apparatus using a reciprocating table with air passing through it offers the best opportunity for obtaining the large capacities and economical operation required by the coal industry. Practically all the early inventions came from America, and the first modern pneumatic separator was invented and patented by Mr. H. M. Sutton, Mr. W. L. Steele, and Mr. E. G. Steele. Their first English patent was taken out in 1905.

In his paper Mr. Appleyard said the economies to be obtained from cleaning coal may be divided into three general categories : (1) Those obtained by the producer in his own concern, the proceeds of which accrue to him. (2) Those obtained from a middle party. (3) Those accruing to the consumer. The principal advantage under (1) is that in bad times a producer selling clean coal is better able to keep his pits going full time than if his coal is dirty. He is able to meet the demands of the slowly increasing number of concerns who buy coal on analysis and calorific value by selling his product on a guaranteed basis, and is not so liable to the present considerable differences of opinion which arise between buyer and seller as to the analyses of shipments — differences often arising from particular samples containing an unfair percentage of the dirtier smalls. The economies under (2) consist of the elimination of freight charges on surplus material both on land and sea, with subsequent reduced dues, loading and unloading costs, and in many cases a reduction of trimming costs with dry coal as against wet. The savings under these two heads may be considerable. The advantages to the consumer under (3) are so numerous as to involve the mere recital of some of them grouped under the main heads of the consuming industries. In all cases dry coal is cheaper to handle than wet coal, having more coal-substance per ton, and being a rather more free-running material, especially in the slacks. A further general saving is, of course, the elimination of the necessity of paying for incombustible material, any sum saved beyond that necessary to be paid to the producer for his, better product being clear gain. Another general saving with dry as against dirty or wet coal is that in any carbonising process some part of the good-fuel value in coal must be utilised in heating the waste product or in driving off the moisture.

Reversal of Mine Ventilation.

The experiments on the reversal of mine ventilation described by Messrs. Lloyd and Williamson were made at the suggestion of the President of the Institution (Dr. J. S. Haldane), with a view to ascertaining, if possible, the effect of reversal of a mine air-current on the quantity of gas given off from the coal-face, this information having been asked for by the "Gob-fires" Committee. The Authors report that from their experiments it appears that: (a) The risk of doubling or increasing the gas content in a column of air made to sweep a gas-emitting region twice (by reversal) is much less than might be supposed. The increase in pressure tends to check, at least temporarily, the normal issue of gas. (b) From the point of view of gas-concentration, a greater danger appears to arise when resuming the normal air-flow circuit after a reversal of short duration, in that the gas-content of the return air is considerably increased above the normal by the quantity of gas carried back on to a district from the intake, (c) The experiments do not show that there is any marked increase in the issue of gas caused by the suddenly reduced pressure due to the reversion to normal conditions after a period of reversed flow, (d) While the general body of an underground air-current quickly responds to a reversal of direction effected on the surface, the air does not travel backwards en bloc. As a consequence, the gas content of such an air-current does not decrease suddenly but very gradually, (e) It would seem reasonable to consider that similar phenomena would occur in the case of the emission of smoke or dangerous gases from an underground fire, or of afterdamp from an explosion. The concentration of such emitted gas would be gradual throughout the districts affected, and, conversely, the driving-out of dangerous or noxious gas by means of a supply of fresh air would only be gradual. As pointed out by Bain and Haldane, these phenomena are of much importance with regard to mine-rescue work in connection with underground fires or explosions.

Subsidence.

At the close of his paper, "An Attempt at the Rationale of Faulting and Subsidence," Professor Briggs says that despite the limitation of the survey of the mechanism of subsidence, certain inferences which may be of service to anyone attempting a more complete treatment seem admissible ; and these are :— (a) Subsidence is due to a combination of shearing, bending and sometimes of flowage of the several strata involved. Tension-breaks have a minor influence. The beds behave as individuals, and not as a compact whole. (b) Their behaviour differs so much, as so many factors (method of mining and of packing, thickness of seam, manner of collapse of the immediate roof, etc.) have an influence, that no attempt to group together an extensive series under a single rule can be anything but unsatisfactory, (c) Shearing causes positive and bending causes negative draw. Subsidence due to shearing has a larger horizontal extent and a smaller vertical displacement than subsidence due to bending, (d) A bed may bend under one set of conditions, or at one stage of subsidence, and shear under other conditions, (e) The greater the superincumbent load, the more flexible is a bed. A bed which shears at moderate depth would be more inclined to bend at great depth. Hence draw is not directly proportional to depth, being relatively less for greater depths. (f) The time factor is important. Bending and flowage are slow processes, (g) Lines of levels run across the surface may supply information of immediate use to the mining company concerned, but, unless supplemented by a great deal of other information, are of little or no service in investigating the general problem of subsidence, and are more likely to confuse than elucidate the issue. Organised observations on the strength and physical characteristics of the various strata, and on their behaviour as seen in shafts and drifts passing through subsided ground and in seams subsequently extracted over the workings causing the subsidence, are more likely to furnish reliable data, (h) Owing to the presence of beds which bend, the draw in fairly flat coal-measure strata is less than that indicated by normal faults in that district. The hade of such faults (omitting from consideration transcurrent faults or wrench-planes) should be helpful in deciding the size of supporting pillars, inasmuch as their hade gives results on the safe side unless running ground be involved.

Gaseous Mixture from Coal.

Messrs. Graham and Shaw introduced their paper by saying that although numerous papers have been written to describe the occurrence of firedamp, the pressure of the gas in coal seams, and the quantity of gas evolved both normally during mining operations and on occasion of outbursts, little data appear to be extant regarding the actual composition of the gases evolved from freshly-exposed coal. For the sake of brevity, it was originally intended to entitle their paper "The Composition of Firedamp." Since, however, the use of the term "firedamp" should, strictly speaking, be confined to the inflammable gases evolved from coal, the paper was brought before the Institution under its present title. It is, of course, well known that the chief constituent is methane, and that this has been found, in some cases, to amount to nearly 100 per cent. of the volume of gas evolved. The result of this knowledge is that amongst mining engineers the terms "firedamp" and "methane" have become almost synonymous. The explanation of the large quantity of gas found frequently in coal has been given in past papers, in which it has been shown that the gas is "adsorbed" by the coal in amount depending upon the partial pressure of the gas. When the pressure is released, gas is evolved from the coal. The results obtained by the Authors show that the composition of the gaseous mixture obtained from boreholes varies considerably from almost pure methane to a gas containing only 60 per cent. of combustible gas. When the flow of gas has been small, it is difficult to say whether the constituents other than methane are evolved from the coal or are due to "blackdamp" resulting from the presence of air in the borehole. In deciding this, the laboratory experiments upon the oxidation of coal and the relation found between the products of oxidation of carbon dioxide and carbon monoxide respectively, and the amount of oxygen absorbed are of assistance. For example, since the Authors find that, in general, the larger quantity of carbon monoxide is found in the cases showing the greater amount of air, they assume that this has been mainly produced as a result of oxidation taking place in the borehole. For fresh coal the absorption of oxygen is approximately 300 times the production of carbon monoxide. During the fresh oxidation of coal carbon dioxide is formed in amount, as a rule, not more than 2 per cent. of the oxygen absorbed. In practically every case calculations show that only a small proportion of the carbon dioxide can have been formed as blackdamp even if all the nitrogen found were produced as such. They must conclude, therefore, that from certain coal seams the gaseous mixture evolved from the coal may contain up to 5 per cent. of carbon dioxide. The amount of nitrogen present with the evolved gases cannot be fixed so definitely, but it would appear that up to 20 per cent. by volume of the mixture is possible, although about 10 per cent. would seem to be of a more general occurrence where a moderate quantity of gas is given off from the coal. Where a considerable quantity of firedamp is evolved, such as from the Barnsley seam, the nitrogen percentage is comparatively small.

The Driving of Narrow Places.

This was the subject of the paper by Mr. S. Walton-Brown, who said in his general remarks it was hoped that the future tendency in the design of underground machinery would be towards simplification, as elaborate gearing is apt to need replacement and the cost of so doing is very heavy.

"The flitting speed of most advantage," he proceeded to say, "will depend on local circumstances, and the straighter the road to be negotiated — that is, the larger the pillars formed — the faster will be the rate likely to be favoured.

"Braking is a difficult problem, even when direct contact is made with the rails, and on extreme grades ropes are probably safer, although somewhat slow and cumbersome. Sand should be used when necessary. The use of a wheel in the jib (in-bye end) is a contentious point, but it undoubtedly reduces the power consumed, and in one case covering a period of about 17 years such wheels have given little trouble.

"There is considerable doubt as to whether it is wise to incur the expense of fitting ball- or roller-bearings to flitting-trucks. The power saved is infinitesimal, and other troubles are more than likely to swallow up any saving. Plain bearings are being experimented with, and are in use elsewhere on much larger machines.

"Until the initial cost of conveyors falls, their use in the first working of thin seams will always entail a serious capital expenditure. The adoption of simpler and cheaper designs, quite capable of dealing with the small outputs entailed, should be experimented with. In order to avoid the presence of timber, the places might be cut down to about 5½ feet wide. Where the permanent conveyors are employed in the first working, preparatory to the second working, simple devices which will mechanically load coal are of advantage, as, for example, the 'Duckbill' loader, which can be attached to shaker-conveyors. Shaker conveyors have also the advantage that branch narrow places can more easily be driven off the same source of motion than is the case with other types. Conveyors should be installed (when used for the first working) in such a way that they are ready for use, without any alteration, in extracting the pillars as soon as the latter are formed.

"A means of transport for men from the conveyor loading-end to the face, as, for example, an improved tram, would be advantageous where the distance to be travelled 'in the low' is considerable.

"Auxiliary ventilation will often be necessary to clear shots. A method of breaking down coal without degradation of the atmosphere, such as is caused by the firing of shots, would be of assistance, provided it did not adversely affect the size of the coal produced.

"Cap-lamps are recommended for coal-cutter operators. If electric, about 15 candle-power should be available.

"Although very large sums have been devoted to research by British coal-owners, the allocation to persons desirous of effecting experiments on the productive side have been exceedingly limited. It is thought that a more liberal view (although there might be more failures than successes) would result in the evolution of many ingenious devices, and that the financial balance over a course of years would be well on the right side.

"Haulage and mechanical loading in thin seams appear especially deserving of attention. The evolution of an unbreakable cutter-pick which would retain its cutting efficiency for at least a full shift would be of great value."


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Appleyard, Kenelm C.      Whos Who Page
Briggs, Henry, Prof.      Whos Who Page
Graham, J. Ivon      Whos Who Page
Haldane, John Scott, Dr.      Whos Who Page
Lloyd, W. D.      
Morrow, John      
Raw, George      Whos Who Page
Shaw, A.      
Steele, E. G.      
Steele, W. L.      
Sutton, H. M.      
Walton-Brown, Stanley      Whos Who Page
Williamson, J. N.      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Murton Colliery  Murton Colliery
Plenmellor Colliery  Plenmellor Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print