2nd July 1927, Page: 388, Column: 1
Machine Mining*
Physical Conditions Provide Variety.
The speaker said that he had had many years' practical experience in Yorkshire
and Nottinghamshire, and until about three years ago he had thought he was well
informed upon many of the difficult problems connected with the machine mining
of coal he had found, however, that in many parts of Lancashire and North Wales
physical conditions provided a much wider scope for variety of method. He had
never attached much importance to stereotyped rules of procedure in machine
mining, but by carefully observing the operation of natural laws under a
variety of conditions, and comparing the results, where the conditions could be
correlated, he had learnt in which direction to look for the thin dividing line
between success and failure in machine mining enterprise.
The subject of coal mining had recently attracted world-wide attention, and
many scientists and economists had endeavoured to find a solution of the
troubles, by putting coal to better uses. They had carefully considered the
values of by-products and residuals, and the conversion of coal, on a large
scale, into electric power. Such schemes were progressive, and important, but
all tended to economy in the use of raw fuel. His opinion was that, whatever
progress was made in this direction, many years would elapse before the output
of coal could be reduced. economically below 200 million tons per annum, and
many of the difficulties which had persistently attended the getting of coal
for half a century would still remain.
During at least two decades, great hopes were held out that the application of
modern machinery would remove many of the troubles associated with the winning
of thin and inferior seams of coal. As some knew only too well, many of the
rich thick seams had become exhausted, and the only alternative to closing many
collieries had been to exploit mines of less value. Changed conditions had
necessitated the application of machinery to coal getting — in some cases
with success, in other cases with failure, often synchronising with periods of
boom and depression in the industry. There could be no greater misconception of
the value of machinery than to employ it simply to make up leeway during a boom
period. It was a fallacy to rely upon cheap labour as a solution to many of the
problems confronting us to-day.
Some Practical Application.
The speaker then referred to several incidents within his own experience,
connected with the application of machinery. The first dated back to 1904, when
a thick seam of good quality had been worked for a considerable period, until
within seven or eight years of exhaustion, when it was realised that, if the
colliery were to remain open, other seams would have to be worked. Consequently
a seam 2' 8" in thickness was opened up, 300 yards of face being prepared
for coal-cutting machines, the filling gates being put in at 12 yards centres.
The overall cost of production was far too high, when compared with the average
selling price of the coal, and when the main seam became exhausted the
directors stated that they would find the necessary capital for equipping the
mine with up-to-date plant, but the cost of production would not have to exceed
greatly that of the main seam (at that time about 4s. per ton into trucks
exclusive of royalties and overhead charges). Officials and workmen became
interested, and co-operated in applying a system of intensive machine mining,
with highly satisfactory results. An advance of the face at the regular rate of
8 yards per week reflected great credit on all responsible for organising and
carrying out the scheme. The cost of production was brought down to an economic
figure, wages maintained, and the seam was further developed, to yield an
output of a thousand tons per day, 40 per cent. of which was non-coking slack
of small value. In another case, having little in common with the first, except
that the conditions were even more favourable for the application of coal face
machinery, the richer seam had also been worked until attention had to be
directed to the working of the thinner seams, in order to maintain the output
of coal at a certain figure. The seam varied from 2' 8" to 3' 0",
with excellent roof and floor conditions ; there was no water, very little
firedamp, and inclination about 1 in 8. Ample time was given to develop the
seam for the required output of about 300 tons per day. A pair of bords were
driven 33 yards apart, and the filling gates put in at 33 yards centres.
Coal-cutting machines were installed, and traversed both end and bord faces,
undercutting to a depth of 5' 6". At the commencement, the fillers
averaged about 8 tons per shift each, and for a time, the cost of production
was kept within permissible limits. This continued until the main bords had
been advanced a distance of 400 yards, and the district became too large for
the output required. So far as he could ascertain there appeared to be no
stopping place, and, moreover, sufficient attention had not been given to
repair work — eventually parts of the district were stopped. The seam had
been over-developed, and when the opportune time arrived for dealing with an
increased output of coal it was unobtainable, owing to the general disrepair of
the roadways and facings. This resulted directly in the reduction of output by
200 to 300 tons per day below its normal capacity. The effect on overall
production costs soon led to an enquiry, and as the conditions favoured the
application of face conveyors, one was installed as an experiment. Early
results were so satisfactory that two more conveyors were installed, in other
parts of the district. By the time number one had advanced about 300 yards the
roof in the main gate had subsided to such an extent that difficulty was found
in maintaining sufficient height for the tubs to pass, and eventually, on
reaching a small fault, the section was temporarily abandoned. Almost at the
same time, a fall of roof had occurred on No. 3 face. Something had to be done
to make a show, and instead of immediately recovering that part of the face
blocked by a fall of roof, about half of the entire length was advanced, the
remainder being left altogether. No difficulty whatever was experienced in the
cutting and coal filling operations, the chief reason for failure being
connected with the floor dinting — it was impossible to rip the floor,
and finish to the required dimensions in a single shift, consequently half of
the width was often left back. When a decision was made to turn the faces over
every two days, far better results were obtained.
The speaker referred at length to the most important question "how to
control roof-weights," and also to the correct depth of undercut. One
candidate for a mining certificate when asked what he would do to prevent falls
of roof, replied "leave the coal in." There was something of value in
the answer, for it was when extracting the coal that the roof might become bad
or unsafe. At a large colliery in North Wales, the main seam, 5' 6" in
thickness, was developed on the longwall principle, the whole of the coal being
extracted in one operation — in some districts the roof became so friable
that 12" of good coal had to be left to form a safe cover. Clearly this
was a case in which many would have hesitated to recommend the use of
coal-cutting machines ; however, several were installed, undercutting the coal
to a depth of 5 feet, and it became possible to extract the whole of the seam
safely and economically.
Conveyors and Output.
Referring to the use of conveyors, the speaker stated that it was largely in
connection with rapid and systematic advance of the faces that conveying had,
of late years, been recognised almost aa a necessity. As compared with filling
into tubs, the work was lighter, and bigger tonnages could be more quickly
delivered into one roadway or gate. In many districts this system had been
confined to thin seams, in which the tubs could not be taken right up to the
working face, but of late years it had been extended to thicker seams for the
sole purpose of increasing the output per filler, and per gate.
As in the case of coal-cutting, no definite rule could be laid down as to the
method most suitable for a particular case. The whole of the circumstances
would have to be carefully investigated before a final choice of system could
be made. As a general guide, he thought they might say that the output per
conveyor should not fall much below 100 tons per shift, and for very thin
seams, only yielding about 50 to 60 tons per cut, the centre gate or tandem
system should be considered. Whether the faces were filled out every day, or
not, depended upon several important factors, such as thickness of seam and
depth of undercut. He could quote many instances showing considerable
variation, each with its own peculiar features. He was interested in a case in
which an attempt would be made to obtain an output of 350 tons per day from a
4' 6" seam, and he knew of another case where from a seam 3' 9" in
thickness, 180 yards yielded an output of 1,000 tons per normal week of five
days; one coal-cutting machine was employed, and a double shift of filling was
in operation. Eighteen inches of floor was taken up from the gate, and 3 feet
of top ripping. The costs per ton, including 10d. for packing, for about two
years prior to the recent stoppage, averaged 2s. less than hand getting costs
in the same seam.
The speaker referred to other instances of a similar kind. What he wished to
emphasise was the absolute necessity of employing a system which could be
reasonably maintained, without serious risk of great fluctuation in the daily
output of coal.
* From a lecture given before the Leigh Municipal College Mining Association,
by Mr. J. Barke.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Barke, J. | | | |