|
2nd June 1927 Intricate Case For JuryWhitehaven Pit Labourer's DeathA Whitehaven Coroner's jury had a very intricate case to consider on Saturday and Tuesday, concerning the death of Edward Wilkinson (50), surface labourer, of High Road, Arrowthwaite, who died in Whitehaven Hospital on Friday. Mr. W. Loudon, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. W. A. Butler, Cumberland Coal Owners' Association; Mr. R. Steel, agent and works manager for the Whitehaven Colliery Company; and Mr. H. C. Hanlon, miners' agent, were also present. When Mr. D. J. Mason opened the inquest on Saturday, Mrs. Emma Wilkinson, widow of the deceased, said her husband was employed at Haig Pit. He had always enjoyed good, health during their marriage. On April 16th deceased went to work as usual. He returned for dinner between 12 and one, but did not say anything about an accident. He went back to work immediately after dinner. Deceased returned home about 6 or 7 o'clock in the evening, and went to work on the following day, Sunday, about 6 o'clock in the morning. On his return he complained of pains in his side and knee, and witness had to assist him upstairs. Between that date and May 9th he was medically attended. The knee was swollen and there were bruises above and below the knee, and deceased suffered extreme pain. "Struck His Knee." Joseph Fisher Craddock, 16, Woodville Terrace, a rigger at Haig Pit, said he was working at the pit on April 16th, the deceased being one of his men. They were putting a new cage on, and about 11 o'clock witness saw him pulling a face. Asked what was wrong he said he had struck his knee on the cage. The cage was being lifted by the engine, and deceased was moving some rollers under the cage. Witness was on the opposite side of the cage. Deceased limped a bit, but carried on with his work. The next day deceased complained of being bad, and had to go home. He was sick and appeared to be in pain. The inquest was adjourned until Tuesday. On Tuesday morning, Dr. E. H. Ablett, Whitehaven, said he first visited Wilkinson on April 17th. He complained of pain in the side and pleurisy. He made no mention of pain in the leg at that time. Within a day or so he developed definite pneumonia of a bad type and as the result he was very debilitated. He slowly recovered from the pneumonia and one day he complained of pain in the right knee. Witness could not remember the date of this complaint but it was some time between April 25th and May 9th. Witness did not examine the knee at the time, thinking he had been lying in an uncomfortable position and his knee was twisted, but the next day Wilkinson complained of more pain in the knee. Witness examined the knee and found puffiness round the joint and signs of an inflammatory condition. He asked Wilkinson if he could remember any history about the knee and he said he could not. This was not surprising because owing to his debilitated condition his memory was probably not at its best. No Sign Of Extreme Injury. In answer to the Coroner he said there were no signs of extreme injury then, but assuming that there had been an accident, any bruise would by then have had time to clear up. Asked whether the alleged accident had any bearing on the case, he said that an accident to the knee would reduce the normal healthy condition of the joint, lowering its resistance to infection. Continuing, he said that four or five days later, when the joint had become much worse, Mrs. Wilkinson informed him that there was a history of an accident. Up to that moment he had diagnosed pneumococcal arthritis. This was an infection of the knee joint by the same organism which caused the pneumonia. The organisms were circulating in the blood and settled at the knee. The history of the accident led him to think that the condition might be due to septic organisms entirely unconnected with pneumonia. Two Abscesses. Later, Wilkinson was removed to the hospital and the knee joint was opened. It was full of pus and he took a sample and sent it away for analysis. The report confirmed his diagnosis that it was a case of pneumococcal arthritis and stated that there was no trace of other organisms. About five days after the knee was opened they found a secondary abscess in the calf, which had been drawn from the knee. There was a probability that an injury to the knee by lowering the resistance of the tissue allowed a secondary inflammation to take place or allowed the organism to settle there. The primary cause of death was pneumonia and the secondary cause pneumococcal arthritis of the knee and toxaemia. Had he not had the arthritis he would not have died from pneumonia. On the other hand, if he had not had pneumonia he would not have had pneumococcal arthritis. Addressing the jury, the coroner read over the evidence of Saturday's hearing and remarked that Craddock's statement that Wilkinson told him he had struck his knee on the cage was not evidence. What the jury had to decide was whether there had been an accident or not. He reminded them that they had not to return a sympathetic verdict and that nothing that the jury decided would affect the question of compensation. After a retirement the jury agreed that "In the absence of direct evidence that the accident did occur, we are unanimously agreed upon an open verdict." The Coroner recorded a verdict to this effect and in accordance with the medical evidence of cause of death. Mr. Steel expressed the sympathy of the Colliery Company with Mrs. Wilkinson and remarked that her husband was one of the finest men they had. He was always anxious to work and had been working seven, eight and nine shifts a week. The foreman expressed the sympathy of the jury in similar terms.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||