21st May 1927, Page: 340, Column: 1
Why Supervision Is Necessary
In Circular 6032 of the U.S. Bureau of Mines Mr. J. W. Paul stresses the
psychology and reaction of the mind of intelligent and experienced persons in
relation to dangers with which all persons have to deal.
Intelligence and experience are no guarantee that miners and persons in other
occupations will always be careful in the face of potential danger. This is
attested every day, in broad daylight by the numbers run down at railroad
crossings, on the streets of cities, and on highways in country districts.
Trains and vehicles follow definite lines of travel which are in plain view and
are well known to all adult persons.
Preoccupation in play or concentration of mind on some personal desire may
account for accidents to children who, when it is too late, become bewildered
and, on the spur of the moment, usually make a dash for safety even though it
takes them directly into the path of death. Then as regards adults, Mr.
Paul says preoccupation of mind and a disposition to take a chance in the
face of danger result in many being killed and injured ; also, there is a class
who defy reckless motor drivers to run them down, and many of this class meet
their challenge — sacrifice their lives through their stubbornness to
yield a few inches for the passage of a vehicle, the driver of which assumes he
will be given clearance.
The circular has been drafted with special reference to miners, and Mr. Paul
notes that experience with danger often leads to fearlessness without
caution, although there are many exceptions to this statement. The average
miner will confront any of the dangers found in mines without the slightest
evidence of fear. Many miners, he says, are supersaturated with fearlessness
and this often leads to unnecessary exposure to dangers that result in
fatalities or injuries — their bravery overcomes their better judgment in
analysing a dangerous condition.
The circular indicates that in developing a mine, the directing genius on
management has control of all features of construction, so he may plan the
development in a manner to minimise the liability of accident, but he has no
control of the nature or character of the roof that will be encountered, and
the roof of a mine is always a source of accidents if it is not properly
supported and regularly inspected. Support of the roof is governed by the
method of mining, by systematic inspections and by artificial supports, such as
timbering. The method of mining is determined by considering the factors that
give promise of the greatest economy in the cost of production, it is further
stated, and is not always based upon factors that give promise of maximum
safety of the workmen. Where the latter has been disregarded in planning the
mine, there is need for concerted vigilance in adopting operating regulations
that will provide for the safety of the workmen, and this involves artificial
supports of the roof which call for rigid inspection and a system of timbering
that must be strictly carried out. When any system of timbering is adopted,
there must be regular inspection to see that the system is being fully observed
by all persons who have the performance of any duty incident to the
preparation, delivery or placing of the timber as a roof support.
Many men in mines are prone to take chances, and often defer the placing of a
prop under roof that has all appearances of being ready to fall, while they
perform some other task, such as loading coal that may be in the way of a
footing for the prop. This procrastination frequently results in the loss of
the life of the miner through the fall of the roof material. So many accidents,
usually fatal, occur from this practice that it is questionable whether it is
in the interest of safety to rely wholly upon the miner to exercise his
judgment as to the time and place of setting a prop, crossbar or any other type
of roof support. This, the circular says, is not directed to all miners, since
many are cautious and exercise the best judgment in placing timber at the
proper time and in the proper place, but the records of many fatal accidents
from falls of roof show that miners with years of experience had neglected to
support the roof when there was timber nearby and in many instances when they
had been directed by the foreman to place the timber before doing any other
work. It is strikingly apparent that accidents from falls of roof among men of
this temperament can only be reduced by closer supervision on the part of the
underground officials in authority.
It must be assumed that any qualified mine foreman is not long in learning to
know the men who may be depended upon to place timber at the proper time for
their own protection, and he will likewise learn to know who will not place
timber properly except under his personal directions and during his presence.
It is this latter class of men who swell the list of fatalities from falls of
roof. At a number of mines where accidents from falls of roof have been very
much reduced over previous periods of high accident rates, it has been found
that the reduction has resulted from the adoption of a system of timbering
suitable to the roof conditions and to a strict supervision of the timber
regulations.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Paul, J. W. | | U.S. Bureau of Mines | |