|
19th May 1927 The InquestTribute To Deceased's Public ServicesSitting with a jury at the Miners' Welfare Hall, Little Broughton, Mr. D. J. Mason, coroner, held the inquest on Saturday. There were also present Mr. Louden, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. T. Cape, M.P., representing the Cumberland Miners' Association; Mr. G. F. Foggo, manager of the Buckhill Colliery. Mr. R. Telford was appointed foreman of the jury. George Wilkinson, coal hewer, of Little Broughton, identified the body as that of his brother-in-law. Tweddle Stephenson, Great Broughton, mining surveyor, produced the plans of the working place in which the accident happened. The stone which came away from the roof measured 10 by 12 and would be about five tons in weight. The stone broke up as it fell. Mr. Cape: The slip, I take it, would not be visible prior to the fall? — No, it is one of those things in mining that one is never sure of. Joseph Bell, West End, Brigham, said he was working mates with Cowan when the accident happened. He had been working about three months in the place and was quite familiar with the district. Witness had been a miner all his life and he and Cowan were experience miners. They made an examination of the roof before commencing work, including that particular part of the roof from which the stone fell, and they were quite satisfied the place was perfectly safe. The deputy for the district was in the place between 8-30 and 9 o'clock, prior to the fall and examined the roof, and had no complaint to make. Witness had not seen the roof since the accident happened; in fact he had never been near the place. Witness and his mate were hewing at the far end of the working, and Cowan was in the "lift," where he was also hewing coal. The Coroner: How many were working together in the working place? — There were three of us. No Warning The Coroner: Was any warning given of the stone coming down? — No, not any, but I heard the stone when it fell. I was about two yards behind where the fall took place. To the Coroner: He did not hear the deceased speak. Cowan's legs in fact were visible from under the stone, and with the help of George Webster, the deputy, they got him out in about half-an-hour. During that time they had one or two stones to break. The Coroner: Was the place sufficiently propped? — Yes. And sufficient timber in the place in case it was required? Yes. And you think it was just a pure accident? — I do. And one of those risks which miners unfortunately have to take in connection with coal mining? — Yes, that is so. George Webster, Lister Terrace, Great Broughton, deputy, said he had been in Cowan's place about ten minutes before the accident occurred. There was then no indication of anything being wrong with the roof. Witness did not notice any cross slips, and there was nothing to indicate such a thing when he examined the place. Mr. Cape: Did you know there was a slip behind? — Yes. And you took every precaution to deal with it? — Yes. Continuing, witness thought the roof was heavy from falling ground. He had been deputy six months in the district, which had been going about 12 months. There had been a few slips and faults, but he did not think there was any necessity for any special precaution. Witness knew he had capable men in the working place. The Coroner, in summing up, said they had had no evidence to show how the accident could have been avoided. It was one of those unfortunate accidents concerned with mining, and it was doubtful if propping would have prevented it. He knew there was a certain amount of carelessness by the men, and Mr. Cape would excuse him for saying so, but he could see that the most experienced miner could not have foreseen the accident; it was one of those risks which miners unfortunately had to endure in course of their employment. The jury returned a verdict of "Accidental death." A Capable Steady Workman. The foreman, on behalf of the jury, expressed their sympathy with the widow and family in their loss. They knew the late Mr. Cowan to be a steady, capable workman, a man who loved his home and his family, and who was held in the highest respect by his fellow-workmen and by the management of the colliery. The Coroner joined in the expression of sympathy, as did Mr. Cape, who said he had known the deceased since childhood and his parents before him, and could endorse every word the foreman had said concerning the life and service of the late Mr. Cowan. The death of Mr. Cowan under such tragic circumstances was undoubtedly a great blow to the village. He had been a useful member of the Buckhill Colliery Miners' Lodge and the Cumberland Miners' Association and on behalf of these organisations he wished to associate himself with the expressions of sympathy. Mr. Foggo, on behalf of the directors of the Allerdale Coal Company, also added his tribute to the memory of the deceased.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||