9th April 1927, Page: 296, Column: 2
Coal Investigations In Nova Scotia
At the Sydney meeting of the Engineering Institute of Canada the Minister of
Mines said :
"The Department of Mines is about to undertake an investigation of the
coals of Nova Scotia, their properties and characteristics, and the most
efficient methods of using these coals under present conditions. No extended or
systematic study of the coals of Nova Scotia has been made since the time of
the coal tests carried out under the direction of the Geological Survey of
Canada about 1908-1912 by Professor Porter, of McGill University, and
your own General Secretary, Mr. R. J. Durley, at that time Professor of
Mechanical Engineering at McGill University. Since the date of these tests many
new mines have been opened, the older mines still operating have reached new
depths where the properties of the coal have in many cases changed
considerably, and the general knowledge of the constitution of coal and the
conditions and equipment necessary for its efficient utilisation have advanced
considerably. The methods of mining coal and the equipment in use in the mines
of this Province have kept up with the most advanced practice of the rest of
the world and have now reached a high plane of excellence. It is felt,
therefore, by the Government that the best means of aiding the coal mining
industry and of furthering the much-to-be-desired expansion of the industry is
to study the coals themselves and obtain information which would be of service
to the coal users, present and potential. This would permit of more economical
results being obtained from Nova Scotia coals, and would enable them to
displace to a large extent the competing imported coals. The advantage of the
enlarged market to the coal industry of Nova Scotia and to the Province
generally is, I think, obvious, and will easily repay many times the cost of
the proposed investigation.
"The investigation is to be carried on at the Technical College at
Halifax, and so far as possible by the staff of the college, for the reasons
that there we have available the necessary equipment and a trained staff.
Advantage is being taken of certain considerable replacements and extensions of
the boiler and steam plant necessary for the College instructional work and
already authorised, to make changes in such a way as to suit the requirements
of the proposed investigation. These changes are now well under way, and it is
expected that the preliminary tests may be started in a few weeks.
"Now let me say something as to what it is intended to do in this
investigation. It is evident that the greater the amount of slack and low grade
coals that can be used within the Province the greater the amount that can be
exported from the Province of higher grade coal, which can stand the expense of
shipment to the distant competitive markets. Also we know that there are
throughout the Province a large number of small hand-fired boiler plants which
try to use these slack coals, but find great difficulty in doing so efficiently
and satisfactorily. It is proposed, therefore, that the first question to be
investigated should be whether these plants cannot be helped to get more
economical results with slight capital expenditure for suitable equipment and
by better methods. This involves a study of draughts, grates, combustion and
mixing arches and walls, and other conditions, as well as the methods of
firing.
"This first step in the investigations is to find how the existing
hand-fired boiler plants can be helped. The next step would be to find how new
plants should be built in order to give the best possible results. The most
important factor to be studied now is the height from grate to boiler surface,
so that we may determine what this should be for different coals and for
different conditions. In order to determine this, the boiler at the Technical
College which is to be used for these tests has been set at an extreme height,
and plans have been made for mooring the grates up or down as desired. The
effect of the bridge wall, its location, height, and shape, must also be
considered, as well as that of the combustion chamber behind the bridge wall.
"It is hoped after this to take up the use of coal under boilers in the
pulverised form, particularly from the points of view of the small plant and of
using low grade and slack coals. Since, however, this cannot be done for some
considerable time yet, and the art of burning pulverised coal under boilers is
at present in a stage of considerable development, no definite plans are being
made now for this part of the investigation. Possibly the chief matter to
determine will be the suitability of the various types of equipment available
for Nova Scotia coals.
"It may be that as the investigation develops it will become desirable to
extend its scope to include other methods and processes for utilising coal. It
is to be hoped that this will be so, because it will prove the success of the
investigation. In any case, the scheme outlined shows a serious attempt to
tackle an important problem, and I feel sure it will yield valuable results.
The assistance and co-operation of all interested in the coal industry of Nova
Scotia, and especially of the coal producers, is hoped for and indeed
confidently expected, and suggestions regarding particular features to be
investigated or desirable methods to be followed will be gratefully received
and carefully considered by the staff conducting the investigation."
Characteristics of Coal Discussed.
In connection with the Engineering Institute of Canada a paper given in the
Canadian Mining Journal was presented by Messrs. W. S. Wilson and
M. W. Booth, of the Dominion Iron and Steel Company, on "The
Characteristics and Utilisation of Nova Scotia Coals." All of the Nova
Scotia coals possess high volatile content up to 60 per cent. It is estimated
that in the proven sections of the coalfields of that Province some 2,770
million tons of coal are available. A statement of analysis of Nova Scotia coal
submitted showed that the coals are not high either in ash or sulphur as is
often stated. There are extremes of both, but the variety of the coals is such
that a selection can be made for any purpose. To put it concisely the authors
state that "the greater percentage of Nova Scotia coals contain sulphur in
excess of 1.5 per cent., but not so as to be materially detrimental to their
value except in certain cases such as metallurgical and domestic gas
purposes."
The authors also affirm, supporting their statement by quotations from reports
on the subject, that the sulphur content plays a very minor part in the
spontaneous combustion of a coal pile. They believed that the fineness of coal
is a bigger factor than its chemical constituents as a cause of fire, and in
line with the experience of the Dominion Coal Company they would say that
screened coal could be banked to a height of 36 feet, run of mine to 25 feet
and slack to 14 feet, as maxima without danger.
It was also stated that in storing, Nova Scotia coals lost in appearance only,
due to oxidation and weathering, but not in heat value. Experience shows that
banked coal becomes slower burning and therefore more adapted for use in
furnaces not especially designed for Nova Scotia coals. Certain coals similar
to those of Nova Scotia, tested at the University of Illinois, showed that
practically the same efficiencies and boiler ratings could be obtained from
coal after as much as six years' storage as from freshly mined coal.
Due to the high volatiles in Nova Scotia coal it is particularly well suited as
raw material for by-product coke operation.
Boiler Plant.
The problem of boiler plant design and operation resolves itself into four
factors — (1) the coal to be used, (2) the boiler, (3) the stoker, (4)
the furnace.
The coal has been dealt with above and by a policy of elimination and selection
a coal is now offered of a high grade that is eminently suitable for mechanical
stoker or steam raising purposes.
The boiler offers the least number of problems in obtaining the desired results
inasmuch as it is the driven, and the coal, stoker and furnace the driver.
Pressure and size tend to increase gradually and apparently this offers no
insurmountable difficulty to the designer.
The stoker is a very live question. Often the question is asked as to what is
the proper type of stoker on which to burn Nova Scotia coals. The answer is
that all types of stokers, including underfeed, overfeed, and chain grate are
successfully burning Nova Scotia coal. The question is a matter of design of
details rather than principle, coupled with the limits as imposed by size or
grate area. The authors recommend the following details in design of stokers
when Nova Scotia coal is to be used :
Underfeed : (a) Provision of side wall air backs to prevent adhesion of clinker
and erosion on side walls, (b) Front wall sealing by Barnitz blocks or other
devices, (c) Design of air tuyere that will leave no projection on which
clinker may lodge or adhere, the air space being large and so designed as to
sweep the entire surface of the tuyere and yet avoid any blow torch action, (d)
Design of ram extensions in the same way to avoid adhesion of clinker and blow
torch action where air cooled, (e) Steam dumps and deep ash pits have proven a
great help in the burning of this class of coal.
Overfeed : (a) Low bridge wall and large combustion chamber beyond with flat
arch design over grate in some cases have overcome the chief objection to the
operation of this class of coal on this type of stoker, (b) Steam jets under
clinker grinders and lower end of grates prevent clinker trouble, (c) Ash pit
doors open continuously when natural draft is used.
Chain Grate. Natural draught chain grates generally operate without difficulty.
Provision is required in cases on side walls above grate to prevent clinker
adhesion by provision of air or water cooling or by special brick and also for
rear dump plates or water back to prevent larger proportion of combustible in
the ash. This conduces to longer life of arch, less combustible in ash, better
fire distribution over entire grate and prevents inrush of cold air at ash pit
clearing times.
Pulverised Fuel: Nova Scotia coals are particularly well suited to this method
of firing due to — (1) high B.T.U. content, meaning less coal to
pulverise, (2) low ash content, (3) easily pulverised, being friable, (4) ash
characteristics are suitable.
The Furnace and setting design is of prime importance in the burning of Nova
Scotia coal and correct volume of furnace for the combination of the gases
before reaching the cooling surface of the boiler is essential. This is the
particular in which furnaces designed for other coals differ most from that
design needed for the coal in question, and not less than one cubic foot should
be provided for every 3 pounds of coal burned on the grate per hour for maximum
rating.
The general trend of the paper was to show that Nova Scotia coals were suitable
for practically all purposes, provided only that they were properly burned and
properly selected. Any present prejudice was due to the fact that they were
being burnt in furnaces usually designed for coal of different characteristics
— principally for low volatile coals, those in question being high in
this constituent.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Booth, M. W. | | Dominion Iron and Steel Company | |
| Durley, R. J. | | General Secretary | |
| Porter, —, Prof. | | McGill University | |
| Wilson, W. S. | | Dominion Iron and Steel Company | |