26th March 1927, Page: 283, Column: 2
Spontaneous Combustion*
By William Lomax, B.Sc, Assoc.M.I.Min.E.
The occurrence of underground fires due to spontaneous combustion is
fortunately not very common in the Lancashire coalfield. According to the final
report of the Departmental Committee on Spontaneous Combustion the seams most
liable to spontaneous heating are the Doe or Dow Mine and the Trencherbone or
Wigan Nine Feet Mine. No mention is made of the Ravine Seam, which is but
casually referred to in the evidence presented, though this seam in the Wigan
district is most liable to spontaneous combustion. Isolated cases have occurred
in other mines not normally liable to heating, but these have been associated
with certain peculiar circumstances. Attention will be confined to the Doe and
Ravine Seams, which are both extensively worked at the present time.
The Doe Mine. — The Doe Mine of the Manchester area alters
considerably in character in various parts of the coalfield and is known by
different names. It corresponds to the Wigan Five Feet of the Wigan district,
though there is not much resemblance between the seams in the two localities.
Its liability to heating would appear to be confined mainly to the Manchester
district, where much difficulty due to fires has been experienced. The seam may
be divided into three portions, the bottoms, middles and tops, and contains a
number of partings or dirt bands. The total thickness of the coal is about 7
feet, the bottom and the middle coal being of fairly good quality while the top
is mostly inferior. The roof is of a tender blue shale or metal.
Detection and Method of Dealing with Fires. — The majority of the
fires which have occurred have been small and no great difficulty has been
experienced in dealing with them. The usual symptoms are always apparent,
namely, the deposition of moisture on the floor, roof and sides, commonly known
as "sweating," followed by the distinctive "gob-stink." A
rise in temperature may also be noted and, if the heating is extensive, smoke
will issue from the goaf. As a general rule there is no special organisation at
the collieries for the detection of fires, but all officials are trained to
understand the various indications of abnormal conditions which are apparent to
the senses. The method of dealing with a fire when it occurs depends upon the
existing underground conditions.
The opinion expressed to the writer by a colliery manager with extensive
experience of gob-fires in this seam was unless it was known that the area
involved was definitely limited by a brick wall or other solid barrier,
filling-cut should not be attempted. When filling-out the heated material air
rushes into the hot mass and the fire may spread indefinitely. There is a case
on record in which a fire travelled over 1,000 yards through the waste. Usually
the affected area is sealed off by means of stoppings built of brick, sand and
flue dust, though there have been cases in the Doe Mine in which whole
districts have had to be flooded with water to extinguish the fires. In sealing
off fires care is taken that a good supply of fresh air is available for the
men engaged in the work while, at the same time, keeping it from the fire
itself. There is a case on record some 30 years ago in this mine where three
men lost their lives during sealing operations. Six stoppings were erected
simultaneously to seal off the fire. One man completed his stopping before the
others and the fumes were forced down on the men working on the other
stoppings. Rescue apparatus are always at hand though their use is dispensed
with as much as possible, since the working capacity of a man wearing rescue
apparatus is strictly limited underground. Stone dust is extensively employed
in all operations. In some cases use has been made of small fire extincteurs
which have been valuable in keeping down flame and glow during sealing
operations.
Re-opening a district which has been sealed off is an operation fraught with
serious dangers. It is almost impossible to seal off an area in such a way that
all heating will cease and conditions again become normal. The heat would, at
any rate, be retained in the strata for a considerable period. Therefore, if a
fresh supply of air be again applied to the mass ignition may again quickly
take place. The writer was informed that greater confidence would be felt in
re-opening a district which had been flooded out rather than one which had been
sealed off due to the presence of a gob-fire.
The Ravine Mine. — The Ravine, Ravin or Raven Mine, occurs and is
known by different names in the greater part of the Lancashire coalfield. The
Ravine seam varies considerably in thickness, structure and composition in
different areas and resembles in many respects the Doe Mine. It is
characterised by the large number of dirt partings, associated with the coal,
which vary in number, thickness and relative position in the seam. These
partings greatly decrease the value of the coal itself and are so thick in some
areas that the seam is practically unworkable. Where the seam is extracted the
total thickness worked is roughly from 6 to 7 feet thick with a total thickness
of coal varying from 4 feet 6 inches to 6 feet. It may be divided into three
portions, the bottoms, middles and tops, which are separated by dirt partings
varying in thickness from a few inches to about 2 feet.
In extracting the seam, the dirt bands are left behind in the waste, but no
difficulty is experienced with heating from this material. As the back timber
is withdrawn the coal roof breaks down in the waste and under favourable
conditions heating takes place. The temperature in the waste of the Ravine Mine
is very often higher than in the working places, due to the heat produced by
the oxidation of the coal substance and the pyritic matter. This heat is
sometimes accompanied by the production of small quantities of firedamp, carbon
dioxide and moisture. Abnormal heating is met with only in the waste, and fires
in the solid coal are not known. Such heating is accompanied by the usual signs
of sweating and gob-stink, together with a rise in temperature of the air in
the vicinity. Actual outbursts of flame have never been reported since all
precautions are taken when undue heating is noticed. Much difficulty is
experienced in locating the actual position of a fire in the waste and
filling-out is never attempted. A heating area is always sealed off by the
erection of stoppings. In erecting the stoppings sand and flue dust are used
for the packing between the outer and inner walls. The stoppings are cut into
the roof, sides and floor to solid strata and the sand and flue dust well
pressed and allowed to settle between the walls before completing the filling
and closing the outer wall.
Fires have usually been dealt with by filling-out. The probable location and
possible limits of the heating were first determined. Roads were then driven
through the goaf at each side of the affected area and a connection between the
two made, these roads being extensively treated with flue dust and sand to cool
down any heated matter. The area being thus limited by the roads digging
operations were commenced. Flue dust was applied to the whole mass, which was
then filled into boxes and taken out. The space was then completely filled with
flue dust, the use of which is to be highly recommended. There is always an
abundant supply of this at a colliery, obtainable at very little cost. It acts
as a good heat insulator and is most effective in damping down any local flame.
It is usual to keep the roads open round a treated area so as to provide a good
air-current and allow of regular inspection. These roads should be supported by
metal props and bars, wood being very undesirable.
Faults. — The Lancashire coalfield is characterised by the large
number of faults in the strata. These vary in extent from a few inches to
hundreds of yards and alter in number and character within even a very small
area. These faults change the nature of the coal and invariably render it of an
inferior quality and of a porous nature. The roof is also broken up and leakage
of air readily takes place along the fault plane. Further, the presence of
faults increases the difficulty of laying out workings so that the liability to
spontaneous combustion may be minimised. A number of fires have occurred in
which a fault or a number of faults may be described as an important factor in
the initial stages of the heating.
Conclusions. — Underground fires due to spontaneous combustion are
not very prevalent in the Lancashire coalfield. The seams most affected are the
Doe and the Ravine, and their liability to heat up is due to their physical
structure and chemical composition coupled with other favourable conditions
produced in their extraction underground. The presence of faults is a
contributory factor. As there is no liability to serious outbursts of firedamp
in the mines there is no great danger of explosions being produced by
spontaneous combustion, provided that the necessary precautions are taken
during sealing or filling-out operations. Fires always occur in the goaf and
the method of dealing with them depends on the particular local circumstances.
Sealing off is most common, filling-out is sometimes done, while flooding the
district has occasionally been resorted to. The method of working the seams
liable to heating follows no general rule and depends on local circumstances.
An interesting discussion followed the reading of the paper. The President,
Mr. George Hunter, A.R.T.C., M.I.Min.E., said that in regard to the
re-heating and the re-opening of areas shut off on account of underground fires
he thought the experience in the Lancashire coalfield was more or less similar
to what was found in the whole of the coalfields. The only reliable conditions
under which an area where there had been fire could be re-opened were those
which existed after the place had been flooded. He knew several instances where
fires had been built off, and the indications from observations taken had been
that the ignition had long since died down, but in course of time, in some
cases even after twenty years, it had reasserted itself when re-opening took
place.
Mr. H. Stephenson, Agent of the Tyldesley Coal Co., Ltd., as one who had
had experience in some of the coal seams referred to in the paper, said in his
opinion every scrap of timber that could be withdrawn in a mine liable to
spontaneous combustion should be withdrawn. His experience was that the smell
of spontaneous combustion underground was not long before it made itself
evident, and provided the firemen in the district had a good sense of smell it
was soon detected. He recalled a case in which by smell in going along the
return airway he eventually located a fire behind a pack, and the reason it had
not been found before, he afterwards discovered, was because the fireman of the
district had no sense of smell. Thinking he would give the fireman a chance of
locating the fire he sent him to try and find it, but the fireman came back and
said he could not locate any fire. He then asked the fireman if he could not
smell it, and the man admitted that he could not smell very well. The man was a
splendid fireman in every branch of his work, except that he had no sense of
smell. By the time they could get through the pack to the fire it was a roaring
furnace almost.
Mr. Hunter said it had been suggested, and he thought the suggestion was
carried into effect in some places, that where it was necessary to leave in
timber the timber should be specially treated so as to reduce any liability to
ignition.
A vote of thanks was passed to Mr. Lomax for his interesting and
informing paper, on the motion of Mr. J. W. Wilton, His Majesty's
Sub-Inspector of Mines.
* From paper on "Spontaneous Combustion in the Lancashire Coalfield,"
presented at the recent meeting of the Past and Present Mining Students'
Association at the Wigan Mining and Technical College.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Hunter, George | | President | |
| Lomax, William | | | |
| Stephenson, H. | | Colliery Agent | |
| Wilton, J. W. | | H.M. Sub-Inspector of Mines | |