26th March 1927, Page: 282, Column: 2
Storage Battery Locomotives*
By A. W. Browne, A.M.I.E.E.
The use of storage battery locomotives in coal mines in this country has made
very little headway, whilst in America the development has been increasing
steadily and surely. During the past few years there has been a distinct change
in feeling towards the battery locomotive. It is no longer looked upon as of
doubtful value and reliability, because experience has proved that its use is a
means of reducing operating costs and increasing production without a
corresponding increase in capital cost.
When considering the question of installing storage battery locomotives in any
mine it is necessary to decide first of all to what extent the mine is to be
adapted for locomotive haulage. If the best results are to be obtained from a
locomotive it is necessary to alter the conditions usually found underground
and provide a heavy and well laid track ; curves of ample radius and to level
out as far as possible the extra heavy gradients. Such alterations will make
the working of the mine more efficient whether locomotives are installed or
not. The light section tracks and narrow radius curves usually found
underground are responsible for considerable delays and accidents due to the
frequency with which sets become derailed. The capital cost involved in making
these alterations is very quickly repaid by the reduced cost of maintenance,
and the time saved by the elimination of stoppages.
A storage battery is typically an electrochemical apparatus which stores
electrical energy by virtue of the chemical reactions taking place at the
electrodes. While a battery is charging the electrical energy is converted into
chemical energy, and while the battery is discharging at a later time this
chemical energy is reconverted into electrical energy. A battery consists of a
number of cells connected in series, the number depending on the voltage
required. Each cell is made up of sufficient positive and negative plates to
give the desired capacity. The capacity of a storage battery may be expressed
in two ways, either as the ampere hour capacity or as the watt-hour capacity.
The ampere hour capacity is the amount of current it will give for a given
time. The watt-hour capacity is a measure of the energy or ability to do work.
The watt-hour capacity is obtained by multiplying the ampere hour capacity by
the average voltage of the cells during discharge. When stating the capacity of
any cell, it is necessary to specify the rate at which the cell is to be
discharged, the temperature and the final voltage. With lead acid batteries the
capacity is usually given at the 5-hour rating to a final voltage of 1.7 per
cell. The capacity is affected by temperature, increasing with increased
temperature, owing to the lower resistance of the electrolyte, and the
increased chemical activity of hot acid.
The entire theoretical capacity of a battery cannot be obtained on discharge
for several reasons. (1) The diffusion of the electrolyte into the pores of the
plates is retarded as the discharge proceeds and the pores become partially
clogged with lead sulphate. (2) The resistance of the active material and the
electrolyte increases as the discharge proceeds. (3) It is not practical to
discharge the battery to zero volts.
The principal factors which affect the capacity of a cell are as follows : (1)
The amount of active material in contact with free electrolyte. (2) The rate of
discharge. (3) The concentration of the electrolyte. (4) The temperature of the
cell. (5) The porosity of the plates. (6) The design of the plates and
separators. A battery will not give the same capacity when discharging at high
rates as when discharging at low rates, for instance, the capacity of a battery
when discharging at the 1-hour rate will be about half the capacity obtainable
at the 10-hour rate. The reason for this is that at high rates of discharge the
lead sulphate is rapidly formed at the surface of the plates, which prevents
the free access of the electrolyte to the active material. This clogging of the
pores of the plates naturally limits the available capacity of the wall. When
the discharge is made at a low rate there is less tendency for the lead
sulphate to form on the surface exclusively, and there is time and opportunity
for the electrolyte to diffuse into the pores of the plates during the
discharge.
Direct current only must be used for charging. There are three methods of
charging in general use : (1) The Constant Current method. (2) The Constant
Voltage method. (3) The Modified Constant Voltage method.
Care and Attention. — A storage battery locomotive requires but
little care or attention, even less than a pit pony. The locomotive battery of
present construction should not, except in cases of severe accident, have to be
removed from the battery container until it has given its useful life and is
replaced by a new battery. During its useful life the battery only requires its
daily charging, when in actual service, a weekly topping up with distilled
water, and occasionally cleaning off the top of the cells ; this latter can be
done with a jet of air or steam. All connections should be inspected
periodically to ensure that they are tight and making good contact. The life of
any storage battery, or the time of its renewal, is in the user's hands. He can
get a number of years' service or a number of months' service, depending on how
much he is interested. If a battery is being over-worked, that is, discharged
beyond its rated capacity, the specific gravity of the electrolyte will fall
below the reading obtained for a normal discharge. The specific gravity will
also fall while a cell is on open circuit if there is any short circuit within
the cell. In fact the only sure way of telling whether or not a cell is in a
healthy condition is to note the specific gravity of the electrolyte, and the
voltage and temperature at the end of discharge and at the completion of the
following charge.
Stated briefly, the care and attention required by a lead acid battery of
reputable make on locomotive work can be summarised as follows : (1) Add
nothing to the cells but pure distilled water, and do this often enough to keep
the plates always covered. (2) Charge the battery only as frequently as the
service demands. (3) Give equalising charges after every five or six cycles of
charge and discharge with a minimum of one per month. (4) When charging avoid
gassing at high rates of charge. Reduce to the finishing rate of charge when
the cells commence to gas freely. (5) Avoid high temperatures of the
electrolyte. Reduce the charging current if temperature reaches 110° F. (6)
Attend to weak cells without delay. (7) Keep the battery clean and the filling
plugs and connections tight. (8) Keep records of specific gravity of
electrolyte and voltage of cells.
Mine Locomotives in Service. — There are not many locomotives
operating in mines in this country at the present time, but there is distinct
evidence that a number of colliery engineers are now giving the matter serious
consideration. A locomotive is operating at a Northumberland colliery, and is
used for taking the men rapidly to and from their work and to dispense with a
long fatiguing walk. In this case a special road was driven and this is used
solely for the locomotive and its train of coaches. The track is strongly
constructed and consists of flat bottomed fish-plated rails of 28lb. per yard
section with sleepers every 2 feet. The road is undulating, the heaviest grade
being 1 in 24. The locomotive with its battery weighs 7½ tons and is
fitted with two 15 H.P. series wound motors. The total weight of a complete
train, including the men, but excluding the locomotive, is about 28 tons. The
train will accommodate 300 men in 25 ball-bearing vehicles, each holding 12
men. These coaches are arranged like jaunting cars, the men sitting back to
back, so that free access and exit to and from every seat is always available.
The average speed of the train is approximately 8 miles per hour. Approximately
1,000 men and boys are taken in and brought out again each day, and the time
saved is about 40 minutes per person per day, a total of 660 man hours per day.
The total cost of running this locomotive over a period of 22½ months is
£3 per day, or 0.006 pence per person per mile. This cost includes 10 per
cent, interest and depreciation on locomotive and charging set; 33 1/3 per
cent, interest and depreciation on batteries; drivers' wages, locomotive and
battery renewals, alternating current power at 1d. per unit, stores, distilled
water, and electrician's attendance to batteries.
Two coal hauling locomotives will be operating in two Scottish pits very
shortly. In one case the locomotive will have to haul about 150 tons of coal in
seven hours at a distance of about 1,920 yards. The track gauge is
21½" and the gradients are all in favour of the loaded tubs, the
heaviest gradient being 1 in 17 for a short distance. Actually the locomotive
will be capable of hauling 200 tons of coal in seven hours. It will probably be
used to ride the men inbye as well. The total weight, including battery, is
4½ tons. In the other case, the duty the locomotive will have to perform
is to bring out 350 tons of coal in seven hours, the length of the road being 1
mile with a gradient of 1&189; per cent. in favour of the load. The weight of
the locomotive with battery is 8 tons, and the average speed of operation will
be approximately 8 miles per hour. The colliery are at present putting down 45
lb. rails, and are providing for 25 feet radius curves. It is intended to use
this locomotive not only for coal haulage but also for taking the men inbye.
Although the primary object in using storage battery power is to eliminate the
danger of the ignition of gas or coal dust, there are several other advantages
afforded by battery operation. The most important is that the power is always
available as and when required ; there are no transmission troubles or losses,
and there is a saving in the elimination of cables and bonds, and the peak load
on the power supply is reduced. The number of animals which can be replaced by
a storage battery locomotive depends entirely on local conditions. It generally
runs from three to five miles or ponies per locomotive, and usually this shows
a good margin of profit in favour of the locomotive, besides which the number
of tons gathered and hauled is generally greater due to the shorter time it
takes for each tub to be returned empty to the working face. This also enables
a greater output to be handled with a given number of tubs. Cases are on record
where a storage battery locomotive has replaced six or seven mules, but this,
of course, is exceptional. A much closer cost can be worked out in the case of
locomotive operation than with animals, because with the latter there must be
an allowance included to cover the variable cost of extra animals to take care
of those injured by accident or rendered unfit for service by sickness. A
storage battery locomotive properly taken care of is ready for service at all
times, and this cannot be expected of every animal out of the total number
used.
* From paper presented at the March meeting of the Manchester Geological and
Mining Society.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Browne, A. W. | | | |