|
12th March 1927, Page: 258, Column: 1 Accidents In MinesBy Thomas Jameson. The natural conditions that exist underground are so varied that it is impossible for legislation alone to bring about that condition of immunity from accidents that is so much to be desired. Legislation is necessary, but nothing can give place to an intelligent appreciation of the dangers attending underground operations, and the whole-hearted efforts of officials and workmen alike to take all possible steps to prevent accidents are absolutely essential. Good results can only be achieved by the hearty co-operation of officials and workmen, as no amount of "Safety First" proposals will be of any use unless we can produce complete unity of understanding and united efforts on both sides. Discipline and Supervision. No man respects weak discipline, although he may take advantage of it; discipline is impossible under a system which permits one day what is forbidden at another time. Workmen and officials should always be amenable to discipline, and willing to carry out instructions. Each workman should be made acquainted with Section 74 of the C.M. Act, and should be made to understand that his conduct determines both the safety of his neighbour and himself, and that regulations are laid down to require special conduct in relation to dangers which have caused the loss of many lives. That the problem is also one of economics is shown by the fact that for the twelve years 1908-23 (omitting 1915-18) nearly 19 million pounds were paid as compensation for fatal and non-fatal accidents. During 1923 the amount of money paid out was £3,215,529 which on an output basis is equivalent to 3d. per ton of coal raised. We see, therefore, that by reducing the number of accidents we automatically bring down, however slightly, the cost of production which is of vital importance at any time, but especially at the present time when the industry is passing through a critical period of its existence. It should also be pointed out that when compensation is paid nothing is received in exchange and there is a loss of output, and the moral effect results in a loss of efficiency, and these constitute a dead loss to the industry and the country Firemen and Accidents. That firemen as a whole have done and are still doing very important work no one will doubt, and one could quote numerous cases where these officials have shown remarkable tact when faced with very difficult problems. With regard to accidents, especially those which occur at the coal face, the person to whom you must look for valuable assistance is the fireman, since he is the man on the spot who knows the details and conditions of his district better than anyone else. It is true that his responsibility is a dual one, but there is nothing in the nature of his work to prevent the full realisation of his Association's motto that "Combined efforts shall accomplish all things." The time is past when the colliery manager requires his firemen to hurry and bustle, but rather he wishes them to go slowly and carefully, so that they may have time to examine their districts and to concentrate on safety precautions as well as output. It is only fair to the firemen to say that they are sometimes asked to take charge of districts which are too large, but in such cases they should not be afraid to approach the manager with a view to obtaining assistance and explaining the difficulties. The fireman is usually a man of wide experience of pit work, he is a valuable asset to the mining industry, but we are not making the best use of the knowledge he has so hardly gained. In addition to discussing daily with the under-manager we believe that much could be done if the fireman was instructed to send to the manager each week a full Written report on the condition of his district. He should be granted a personal interview, say, once pec month, thus bringing about more direct contact between the manager and the firemen, and so bridging the gap between manager and workmen. Responsibility of Workmen. If we could persuade the workmen that it is directly to their benefit to become more associated with "Safety First" campaigns, which are now conducted at most collieries, much would be achieved. They should be able to suggest details which would, no doubt, lead to important results. The idea of suggestion-boxes in the colliery yards has not met with the success which was hoped for. Safety is essentially a personal matter, and we must adhere to its principles since we cannot delegate it to someone else. Each individual, from the colliery manager to the haulage boy, must accept his own responsibility for the propagation of safety. Human nature is apt to follow the lines of least resistance, and a careless habit once acquired is very difficult to eradicate ; this not only applies to the workmen but to all concerned with the working of mines. Officials should always realise that men on special work often know more of the details of the work than do the officials. Workmen should be encouraged to make suggestions, and it will be found that they will take greater pains and interest in their work, especially if they know the ultimate aim of the job in hand. The time which an official spends in explaining a certain class of work, laying stress on the safety side, is always worth while, and will go far in the prevention of accidents. An official should be psychologist enough to understand his men, and realise that a workman can soon be made contented with his work if only he is approached in the right and proper manner. It is possible to learn something oven from the apparently most ignorant person. A capable workman is a great asset to safety, and he is usually the most efficient workman from all points of view. Colliery Explosions. Up to comparatively recent years explosions were termed "Explosions of Firedamp," and it was only when it was observed that explosions took place in some of the best ventilated pits that the theory of the coal dust explosion was put forward. The two chief igniting agents for coal dust are : (1) the flame from a shot, and (2) flame from burning gas. Accumulations of firedamp may be readily ignited by (a) a naked light, (b) defective safety-lamp, (c) electric or other sparks. It is interesting to note that after 1896, the date of the first Explosives in Coal Mines Order, the decrease in the number of explosions is especially marked, and, since then, has on the whole been well maintained. The death-rate has been largely reduced owing to the extra precautions which have been taken, especially in regard to ventilation, safety-lamps, shot-firing, electrical apparatus, and the improved construction of pit tubs which are more dust-tight, and must be kept in good repair. It should be realised that even a slight trace of gas is dangerous when shot-firing, as it may be the forerunner of a dangerous feeder, and gas should always be reported even if it is cleared in the meantime. The present system of shot-firing has made it possible to place explosive material in the hands of a few competent persons, who should fire the shots when the minimum number of workmen are below ground. Stone-dusting should always be done systematically, and it is very important to see that periodic cleaning up of all dust is carried out. No shot should be fired unless after a thorough examination gas is absent, and efficient stone-dusting has been effected near the shot-hole. Falls of Ground. To miners and those interested in the mining profession, it is well known that more persons are killed by falls of ground than by any other cause. For a long time much research has been conducted with the view to rendering explosions impossible, but it is high time that accidents from Falls of Ground and Haulage Operations took a more prominent part in our discussions since they are of a more urgent necessity, because they show the least sign of improvement. From 1851 to 1925 the number of deaths from falls of ground was 35,970, whilst for the same period the number due to explosions was 12,596 ; in other words for every one killed by explosions 2.4 were killed by falls of ground. The specified distances apart at which the roof supports should be set and advanced should be reconsidered by the management from time to time in the light of any change in the character of the strata. Any lessening of the distance that may be found necessary should be thoroughly impressed on the workmen by the officials, as it is of first-rate importance to point out the need of setting such supports securely, in proper order, and without delay. Very often workmen seem to think that they have done all that is required when they comply with the strict letter of the Act. It would be much better if the men were specially instructed that the distances stipulated were maximum distances, and that additional supports might not only prove judicious but would add materially to their safety if the props were put up where circumstances warrant them ; and their attention should also be directed to Section 50 (7) of the C.M.A. and General Regulations, part 6. It is fallacious to suppose that what we call a bad roof need be productive of more accidents than a good roof. A roof containing numerous dislocations parallel to each other necessitates a special systematic kind of timbering, while a good roof in which the dislocations occur rarely but unexpectedly is fraught with danger from the want of a rigid system of timbering. Some Defects — and Suggestions. Some of the chief timbering defects which one finds are :— (1) Insufficient props and sprags. (2) Poor lids, which are often too thin and ill-shaped. (3) Props not set at the correct angle to receive the roof weight. (4) Neglect to place the lids across the joints, breaks or slips. (5) If the strata are inclined neglect to "sink" the foot of the prop into the floor. (6) Placing the timber without system, thus throwing unequal weight upon the supports. At this stage the following suggestions might be helpful :— (1) If supports are to be set properly it is essential that proper tools (saw, axe and hammer, pick and shovel) shall be used. (2) With a little practice it will be found that to set a support well will take no more time than to set it badly. (3) See that supports are set as soon as possible after the roof is exposed and thus help to keep the roof whole. (4) See that there is never too great a span of unsupported roof. Too great a span means other supports are overloaded and may break or be reeled out. (5) Give careful attention to places (such as rippings) where there may be special weaknesses, and always put a bar under the edge of the ripping instead of being satisfied with props. (6) Never leave without a support roof or side which you have attempted to take down. It may fall unexpectedly. (7) Wherever possible set sprags, before commencing to undercut, and don't be afraid of setting extra supports when necessary. Chocks are of great value where the roof is heavy or where there is a shortage of packing material. They are elastic, and possess a large bearing surface, and enable other timber to be withdrawn from the goaf with comparative safety. They may be built as temporary supports for the coal face, or permanent supports for the roadways. For the maintenance of roadways near the coal face the jack walls are of primary importance. They should be always well built of strong rock if available, and should be completed once the building has commenced, and not left to be finished off on some subsequent shift. Testing of the roof should never be substituted for setting props as is sometimes the case ; by all means test the roof, but make sure that the props are set. Props will secure the roof, tapping it will not. All roofs should be considered dangerous since no one can be sure that any roof is safe even when a solid ringing sound is heard on testing. Many accidents occur whilst men are travelling to their work. This type of accident is one which is very difficult to guard against. If the roadway is high it only requires a small stone to cause a serious accident. Many of these accidents could be avoided by setting bars in places that appear safe. Recent years have witnessed the increased use of the carriages to convey the men to their work underground. In addition to the men being quite fresh and active when they reach their work this type of conveyance will prove of great benefit in the prevention of accidents because only a minimum amount of time is spent in travelling. Repairing Roadways. Accidents which occur whilst workmen are engaged on repair work are usually less in number than those at the coal face because there are fewer men employed on this work. The work is dangerous for the workmen are dealing with loose material, and before commencing to timber they should make sure that they are standing on safe ground, and that safe ground is behind them. Many accidents are caused owing to the workmen, who may be engaged placing extra bars near broken ones, starting in the most convenient position, perhaps in the centre, instead of starting at the end and keeping under good timber with central supports. In Lancashire the accidents on main roadways, as distinct from those which occur at the coal face, whilst repair work is being carried on, are greater than in most coalfields. This is undoubtedly due to sudden movements or "crumps" caused by the proximity of worked-out seams, and highly inclined strata. It often happens that a sudden crushing takes place, displacing several sets of timber which apparently were very well placed. Usually we find that the greater the inclination the more the props should be under-set. Unless props are under-set in steep mines they are apt to fall out before the roof has had time to tighten them, or they may be reeled out by pieces of coal or stone, and therefore they should be under-set and stamped into the floor. Lids are indispensable accompaniments to props, and although their primary use is to tighten the props against the roof, they extend the bearing surface, and act as greater cushions, thus enabling the props to have a longer life. Haulage Accidents. In point of number, accidents on haulage planes come second to falls of ground. In many cases injury would be avoided if those engaged in mines had a greater knowledge of the dangers attending the work they perform. At the present time a man or boy is rarely taught his work, still less the dangers that he may encounter. They have in most cases to gain their experience by trial and error ; this is often brought to light after a serious accident. A boy when starting work on the haulage should be well tutored by the person in charge of that section of the haulage. Instead of telling the boy what he must do, it would often be better to tell him what he must not do. From official records we find that a considerable number of the fatalities are due to runaway tubs. The chief causes of runaways are:— (1) Failure of the drawer to hold the tub on the incline. (2) Breakage of rope or chain. (3) Breakage of coupling or drawbar. (4) Loss of control by driver. (5) Accidental detachment of rope. (6) Failure to attach tub to rope before passing over incline. A common cause of runaway tubs on endless rope inclines is the breakage of the chains. Much good would accrue if the chains were systematically annealed. At one colliery an investigation which took place after an epidemic of broken chains proved that the failure of the chains was due to the use of inferior material for the repairing of broken chains. The reports of the Divisional Inspectors of Mines indicate quite clearly that many accidents could be avoided by a more liberal use of safety appliances, in circumstances where the possibility of a runaway tub is obvious. A common source of accident is due to the failure to provide or use auxiliary stop blocks. All shunts and junctions should be well lighted and whitewashed. The chief means of avoiding accidents are :— Only allow minimum travelling on roads, and the provision of runaway protection gear. It is often difficult to catch boys or men riding on tubs, as pointed out by Mr. T. Greenland Davies, H.M.I.M. for the Northern Division. The ropeman at one colliery saw several boys riding on a set of tubs. He managed to secure two of their caps as the set passed hoping to recognise the offenders when he got to the pit bottom, but when he arrived there he found thirty boys bareheaded. Riding on tubs should be prohibited in all mines, and with this point in view Section 43 (2) of the C.M.A. should be amended. Whatever our job is in the mine, we are in a position to help to reduce the number of accidents. It is not sufficient to make use of propaganda ; we must appeal to every class of official and workman to take a keen interest in "Safety First" campaigns. Only by the hearty co-operation of all concerned can we take an optimistic view of the future accident rate. * From paper by Mr. Thomas Jameson, of the Long Lane Collieries, Ashton-in-Makerfield, before the Past and Present Mining Students' Association at the Wigan Mining and Technical College.
|
|||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||