26th February 1927, Page: 248, Column: 1
Atmospheric Conditions And Accidents
The Industrial Fatigue Research Board have issued a report on "The
Relation of Atmospheric Conditions to the Working Capacity and the Accident
Rate of Coal Miners." The price of the report is 1s. 3d. It is explained
in the preface that the relation of the worker's physical environment to his
well-being and efficiency has been explored in several of the investigations
undertaken by the Board, and abundant evidence has been adduced to show that
physiologically unfavourable conditions in this respect may often have a
detrimental influence on working capacity, particularly where occupations
involving heavy muscular effort are involved, such as many in the tinplate,
iron and steel, and glass industries.
In coal-mining, where the temperature is often high and the work arduous, the
same effect would be expected, but the evidence on this point hitherto obtained
is rather slight and contradictory. It seemed, therefore, desirable to arrange
for some special investigation as to the actual difference in the working
capacity prevailing under existing conditions in the hotter and cooler seams
respectively, and in accordance with the recommendations of the Health Advisory
Committee of the Department of Mines, the concurrence of that Department was
obtained in the extension of an inquiry, already in progress by Dr. H. M.
Vernon and Mr. T. Bedford into the atmospheric conditions in coal
mines, to cover this point.
The index of working capacity usually adopted, namely output, could not be
applied in this instance owing to the large variations in the ease of getting
coal, and accordingly two other measures have been substituted. The first
consists in the duration of the rest pauses taken from work. As the authors
show, work involving heavy muscular effort is never truly continuous, but
consists of a series of spells of activity interrupted by short pauses
voluntarily taken by the workers. The relative duration of these spells and
pauses has been taken as an approximate measure of the working capacity. The
second measure is the time required to carry out a given task, in this
particular instance the filling of a tub, on the assumption that an increase in
this time denotes a corresponding reduction in working capacity. In addition,
some information has been obtained on the relation of atmospheric conditions to
accident incidence.
The report shows that there is a heavy loss of working time, due to resting, in
the hot seams as compared with the cool, and although the present
investigation, being based on actual observation of the colliers concerned, was
necessarily limited in scope and dealt, in fact, with the different seams in
only two collieries, the consistency with which working capacity is shown to be
smaller in the hotter seams suggests that the same effect would hold generally
throughout the coal industry.
These rest pauses are taken almost unconsciously, and under existing conditions
are probably actually necessary in the interests of the worker. Economically,
however, they are clearly one source of loss of production, and if the total
number of men working in hot seams could be ascertained, this would probably be
found to be an important one.
The same conclusion is indicated by the comparison of the tub-filling times and
the accident rates.
The question then arises as to how this loss can be prevented or reduced. The
natural temperature and humidity of the workings cannot, of course, be
controlled, but one possible method of ameliorating conditions, namely,
increase in air movement, is indicated in the report. This suggests, in short,
that ventilation that is adequate for the shallower and cooler seams is
insufficient for the deep and hot seams. The Board understand that the
Committee on Temperature in Deep and Hot Mines, of the Institution of Mining
Engineers, is already engaged on the study of this question, and they think
that when its work on the engineering side has solved the practical problem of
securing increased ventilation in seams where this is called for, not only will
discomfort on the part of the men employed tend to diminish, but a notable
increase in output will result.
As the Authors say in summary:—
The influence of atmospheric conditions on the working capacity of colliers can
conveniently be measured by noting down (a) the rest pauses taken from work,
and (b) the time taken to fill the tubs. 138 men were watched for an average
period of 90 minutes each, and in air with a wet kata cooling power of 19 to 11
they were found to rest 7 minutes per hour, whilst in air with a cooling power
of 7 to 5 they rested 22 minutes. Tub-filling took 8.0 minutes under the former
conditions and 9.6 minutes under the latter, and the rate of production of the
men was calculated to be 41 per cent. less under the most adverse atmospheric
conditions than under the most favourable ones.
The rest pauses taken were partly voluntary and partly involuntary (due chiefly
to the lack of tubs). If, however, regard is paid only to the voluntary rests
taken during such time as work is possibU the effect of atmospheric conditions
still proves to be very marked, though not so great as when all the rests are
taken into account.
The average air velocity at pillars and headings was only half that observed at
longwall faces, but it can be greatly increased in headings by keeping the
brattice well advanced. When the brattice was 5½ feet distant from the
face the velocity was 68 per cent. as great as that observed in the intake and
return airways ; but when 31 feet distant it was only 32 per cent. as great.
The accident rate appears to be influenced by atmospheric conditions, for at
one colliery, where the wet kata cooling power in three seams was 15.2, 11.3
and 10.2, the (modified) accident severity rate of the colliers and trammers
was 3.2, 4.8 and 4.9 respectively. Also at one colliery, where the ventilation
in the airways was worse than in the other, the accident severity rate to
underground workers (other than colliers and trammers) was 55 per cent. greater
than in the other colliery. At the coal face, however, where the ventilation in
the first of these collieries was better than in the second, the severity rate
of the colliers and trammers was only 4 per cent. in excess. The accident
frequency varied in the same way as the severity rate.
There is reason for thinking that the more adverse the atmospheric conditions
experienced underground, the greater the reduction in the health of the miners.
n
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bedford, T. | | | |
| Vernon, H. M., Dr. | | | |