26th February 1927, Page: 242, Column: 1
Locomotives For Colliery Purposes
At the January meeting of the Students Section of the North of England
Institute of Mining and Mechanical Engineers Mr. Percy Hope gave a paper
on "Steam and Electric Locomotives for Colliery Purposes." He said no
one will deny that the application of engineering science to mining is still
rapidly increasing, and though some maintain that electricity is being used
where steam would be more economical, it still remains true that in the future,
when our knowledge of electrical engineering is more advanced the economy of
electricity over steam will be more marked. Initial cost is not, generally
speaking, a factor of primary importance in considering machines of the same
type ; for example, two makes of coal-cutters, or two electric motors. In the
case of steam and electric vehicles, however, the margin may be as much as 100
per cent., i.e., £1,500 to £3,000, and it will obviously require
great care and discrimination in deciding which type to adopt, even on these
grounds. Simplicity of operation, simplicity of construction and rigidity of
structure are three other essential features in any machine which is to give
satisfactory service under rigorous conditions. In connection with cost, must
be considered interest and depreciation. The life of the vehicle will, of
course, be decided by the manner in which it is used or ill-used. We cannot
consider it fair to constantly work an engine at 75, or even 50 per cent.,
above its rated capacity, whilst the state of the track, the gradients
encountered and the maximum speed desired, are all factors to be considered in
the question since they will affect the length of service obtained from the
engine.
Before the Engineering Conference in 1921, Sir Vincent Litchfield Raven
read a paper on "Steam v. Electric Locomotives," in the discussion of
which the following points were emphasised :—
(1) The steam locomotive, being an independent unit, has a limited power which
cannot be greater than of its boiler. (2) Boiler and cylinders are costly to
maintain, whilst reciprocating parts such as cranks and crankshafts cannot be
very well balanced and wear and tear is consequently heavy. (3) The cost of
maintenance of electric locomotives was estimated to be 1/3rd that of steam
locomotives due mainly to the absence of reciprocating parts and consequent
better balance, the absence of vibration of a heavy character and in there
being fewer moving parts. (4) The steam locomotive radiates heat whether
standing idle or coasting or running which greatly increases the cost, and it
was stated that engines engaged on shunting work are standing 41 per cent. of
their total time on duty.
If a rather heavier duty than usual has to be carried out, say when the
locomotive is required to haul heavy loads up long gradients, the boiler, being
unable to generate steam quickly enough, allows the speed of the engine to
decrease rapidly and it has, so to speak, to drop into bottom gear. It will be
immediately seen, also, that it may be impossible for the steam locomotive to
overcome the inertia of the load although once started it could keep the trucks
in motion. An electric locomotive could, however, draw sufficient extra power
from the conductors, or the batteries, to maintain a sufficient overload to
start the train. The author does not advocate this as being good practice, but
it most certainly is a case which occurs at times at any colliery, and the
ability to deal with the slight overload at the start is a very useful
propensity the steam locomotive does not possess. Besides, owing to the uniform
turning effort of the motors, and the better factor of adhesion thus obtained,
it may be able to start up without any overloading. The electric locomotive
has, too, a better acceleration than the steam, enabling it to complete more
journeys in a given time, and it can thereby deal with more work. Having curves
of a comparatively small radius to negotiate it is a necessary feature of
design to have a short wheel base, say 6 feet on all types, and in steam
locomotives there is always considerable overhang at each end. Overhang causes
the rocking motion (called "nosing") so common in colliery
locomotives, and is often the cause of derailment, certainly the cause of rapid
wear of tyres and rails. The electric locomotive can, however, be constructed
with very little overhang and the weight equally distributed over the whole
frame.
The absence of any moving parts, at least in the power unit of the electric
locomotive, does not make a very considerable difference to the maintenance
costs, and it should also be remembered that there are no boilers to be
periodically tested, cleaned out or repaired, so that the electric locomotive
is available every day it is required, although in the case of the battery
locomotive a part of each day is required for charging. The maintenance costs
of battery locomotives should, however, be excepted.
Coal consumption on colliery locomotives is a fairly big item, since the
locomotive drivers do not burn low quality fuel, but get the best quality they
can. The average steam locomotive burns about 1½ pounds of coal per ton
mile. This average was obtained from a colliery using in all seven locomotives,
and therefore over one year of 280 days normal working any saving by preventing
loss of heat is greatly to be desired. On the other hand, an electric battery
locomotive doing similar work requires 0.134 B.T.U. per ton mile, and the
overhead type 0.074 (average). It stands to reason that no colliery locomotive
can be as efficient in generating and using steam as a central power station
plant, and if the transmission losses and conversion losses are less than the
difference, it is immediately evident that the cost per unit of power will be
less on the electric locomotive.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Hope, Percy | | | |
| Raven, Vincent Litchfield, Sir | | | |