|
18th December 1926, Page: 164, Column: 1 Co-Operative Coal SellingReports of CommitteeThe Reports of the Departmental Committee on Co-operative Selling in the Coal Mining Industry show that the Committee interpreted the term "co-operative selling" widely, placing more emphasis on the first word than on the second. The leading report was signed by Sir Frederick William Lewis, Bart, (chairman), Sir Thomas S. Catto, Bart., Rt. Hon. Vernon Hartshorn, M.P., Sir Hugo Hirst, Bart., Rt. Hon. Sir Alfred M. Mond, Bart., Sir W. Harry Peat, K.B.E., Mr. Frank B. Varley, M.P., and Mr. J. A. Warriner. The scheme proposed is voluntary, and in a memorandum Messrs. Hartshorn and Varley make it clear that they signed the report because they are in general agreement with their colleagues that the principle of organised marketing is desirable and that it is much to be hoped that the principle will be put into general practice on a voluntary basis, which they recommend should be given a full trial first. However, failing substantial progress during a two-year period they think the Board of Trade should have power to propose a scheme which, when settled after full investigation and consultation with the industry, should be imposed on all concerned. Three members of the Committee, Mr. J. R. D. Bell, Sir David R. Llewellyn, Bart., and Mr. A. K. McCosh, in a minority report express views opposed to the principle of co-operative marketing. Committee's Conclusions. Following a general discussion of the question the eight members who sign the main report give their general conclusions as follows :— "(a) The Principle of Organised Marketing. — After carefully considering and analysing the various arguments for and against the development of organised marketing in the coal-mining industry, we have come definitely to the opinion that, in principle, such a development would be beneficial to the industry. Organised marketing is increasingly recognised as an effective method of avoiding excessive competition, of achieving economies and improvements in marketing and of helping to stabilise an industry. In one form or another it has been widely adopted in many other industries in this country and in the coal-mining industry of Germany. It seems to us clear that the British coal-mining industry also could make effective use of it. But we feel that a serious impediment lies in the present lack of consolidation in the industry ; and we are convinced that the full development and benefits of organised marketing within the industry cannot be realised unless the industry can be consolidated, by amalgamations, into a much smaller number of units . . . . . Local and District Organisations. "(b) Local and District Organisations. — (i) Local Organisation. — The least comprehensive form of marketing organisation — but not necessarily the least effective — is that set up between several neighbouring colliery owners who either make some form of price arrangement to avoid undue competition one with another, or combine to obtain the economies and other substantial marketing advantages of a local selling pool. The potentialities of local arrangements such as these are limited by the unabated competition of neighbouring and other colliery owners selling in the same markets. Nevertheless, they serve a valuable purpose both in themselves and in preparing for a closer physical co-operation between the collieries concerned. They also open a way towards a more comprehensive marketing organisation to cover the whole district or coalfield. We, therefore, advocate the development of local marketing arrangements, and in particular we make an emphatic recommendation in favour of the organisation, wherever practicable, of local selling pools on the general lines of those already in operation in the South Yorkshire coalfield. "(ii) District Organisation. — The district organisation, by which we mean an organisation to co-ordinate the marketing of coal over the whole of a coalfield or other economically-defined selling area, has more effective scope than a local organisation for influencing the market, but not to the extent of raising any substantial objection on the ground of monopoly. If it is working independently, and is not co-ordinated with other district associations by an overriding central committee, it can have no effective monopoly; its operations are kept fairly strictly within legitimate bounds by actual or potential competition. From the standpoint of the interest of the Industry we regard the development of district associations as desirable, and we recommend accordingly. But we think it desirable also that price-output organisations, in their own interests as well as In the interest of the consumer, should have (as selling pools have intrinsically) a constructive side to their activities as well as a merely defensive or protective policy. Mere price-output regulation tends to become an argumentative business, and the members of a district marketing organisation are more likely to work and hold together effectively if they make common cause, as well, in more inspiring activities directed to achieving greater efficiency in transport and distribution. A district association might also be helpful in organising pools of wagons among its members, and in co-ordinating improvements in the preparation of coal for the market. On the side of economies in production a district marketing organisation cannot be directly concerned, but indirectly it might be helpful in stimulating amalgamations and in the concentration of production on the more efficient mines . . . . "The chief difficulty of district organisation will lie, . . . In getting a sufficient measure of agreement — backed by loyal and active support. A district organisation is impracticable without the membership of practically all the coalowners in the district; a very few coalowners could obstruct the desire of a large majority to organise. The success and stability of such an organisation, once it has been set up, depend upon the enduring loyalty of its members ; in difficult times the default of a small minority, or their evasion of the agreement they have entered into, would bring about the collapse of the organisation. A numerous membership intensifies these difficulties and is a source of internal weakness and difficulty. The ultimate solution is amalgamation into fewer units, but we have considered whether there are any steps that might be taken by the Government to mitigate the immediate difficulty arising from lack of consolidation in the industry. We are not prepared to contemplate anything in the nature of general compulsion, but we think it would be reasonable for Parliament, in cases where it is only the opposition of a small minority that prevents the setting up of a marketing organisation for a particular district, to compel them to come in, provided the circumstances are such that their rights and interests can be effectively protected. The safeguards required must of necessity be more extensive than those provided for amalgamation and absorption schemes by Part I of the Mining Industry Act, 1926. There are obvious differences between an amalgamation and a marketing agreement between independent concerns, and we are inclined to think that there will be circumstances in which it will prove impossible to make these safeguards really effective. "We recommend legislation to adapt and apply Part I of the Mining Industry Act, 1926, so that a minority of, say, 25 per cent. or less, calculated on a tonnage basis, can be compelled to come into a scheme for a district marketing organisation, backed by a 75 per cent. majority, and proved to the satisfaction of a tribunal to be a scheme for the more efficient marketing of coal, consistent with the national interest, and fair and equitable to all its members. In circumstances where the safeguards which can be afforded to the minority are found by the tribunal to be insufficient, and the scheme is disallowed accordingly, the constructive alternative may be for the parties to consider a scheme for an amalgamation, or a series of amalgamations. The foregoing proposal would, we hope, facilitate the setting up of marketing organisations in some colliery districts. The stability and effectiveness of marketing organisations, after they have been set up, would be strengthened if they could be sure of the support of the law in exercising their functions and enforcing their agreements. We commend to the attention of the Government the question of revising and clarifying the law on Restraint of Trade so as to remove the present uncertainty as to the status in law of marketing organisations and to define their legitimate objects . . . . Co-ordination of Organisations. "(c) The Co-ordination of District Organisations. — So far, we have only considered the development of district marketing organisations acting independently and competing with each other except in their local markets. In course of time there would be an increasing tendency towards, and need for, working agreements between neighbouring associations which in its final development might be expected to bring about a co-ordinated system of marketing covering the whole or a large part of the country. We consider that from the standpoint of the coal-mining industry such an extension of the effective scope of district marketing organisations would be a desirable development. But the fact must be faced that a system of district organisations federated in this way would tend to acquire a monopoly over an article of prime necessity to the economic and social life of the country. As we have already indicated, adequate safeguards against abuse would be imperative, and, even so, a federated marketing organisation of this kind could not be justified unless the industry effected economies, not only in the marketing of coal, but also in all phases of its production and transport. The gains to the industry from a federated organisation could not be justified to the community and could hardly be maintained unless they were derived from economies and increased efficiency, and not from higher prices to the home consumer. The views we have already expressed in regard to the consolidation of the industry by amalgamations are relevant in this connection also. Exports. "(d) The Export Trade. — The export trade, whose prosperity is so vital to the industry and the nation, calls for separate consideration since, as we have already recognised, the exporting districts cannot be married in one organisation with the districts whose trade is mainly in the home market. We recognise, also, that the stabilisation of prices and output cannot be effectively achieved in the export trade except by forming a marketing organisation in each of the exporting areas and co-ordinating these organisations by a central committee, which at a favourable opportunity would be in a position to negotiate an international agreement. This we regard as the ultimate solution of the problem of organising export marketing, but in the present state of opinion in the exporting districts it is impracticable, and, in any case, probably, could only be reached by gradual stages. "As a first step the setting up of local selling pools by the exporting colliery companies would be practicable and, we are convinced, advantageous ; the large selling pools in South Yorkshire engage substantially in the export trade. We suggest also that benefit would result from a closer co-operation between the colliery owners and the coal exporters such as might be brought about by a joint committee or organisation of the two interests in each of the exporting coalfields. Such an organisation might be able to formulate, and help its members to carry out, an export policy for the district and it might be able to prevent the unnecessary factoring of export coal and unnecessary speculation, by keeping a register of bona-fide exporters. If this were done on lines satisfactory to the colliery owners of the district, they might be in a position to agree to do export business through such registered exporters alone. Further, such an organisation might use its influence (or even administer rules mutually agreed) to deal with questions of analysis and certification and with improvements in cleaning or changes in grading to meet foreign markets. It might also be possible to use the organisation as a medium for co-ordinating prices of tenders and forward contracts. Some of the suggested functions of the joint export organisation may not be generally practicable, but we venture to hope that the suggestion that organisations should be set up to effect closer co-ordination between the coalowners and the coal exporters may commend itself to both these parties. Once such organisations were set up and had gauged the extent to which the different exporting districts were competing unnecessarily, one against the other, they would, We believe, be impelled in time to examine the possibilities of coming to a working agreement. The ultimate aim of a national co-ordination of export marketing might then come into sight." The proposals of the Committee set out briefly are as follows :— 1. The development of organised marketing in the coal-mining industry is desirable in order to avoid excessive competition, to effect economies and improvements in the marketing of coal and to help to stabilise the industry. 2. The present lack of consolidation in the industry is a serious impediment, and the full development and benefits of organised marketing cannot be realised unless the industry can be consolidated, by amalgamations, into a much smaller number of units. 3. Organised marketing is only immediately practicable in, those localities and districts where there is a fairly general desire among the coal owners to develop it. 4. The voluntary development of local arrangements — mere particularly selling pools — among neighbouring colliery owners is advocated. 5. District organisations, of wider scope than local arrangements, are the next stage of development. Where, In any particular district, a fair and equitable scheme for more efficient marketing is supported by a majority of 75 per cent, or more calculated on a tonnage basis, powers should be vested in a tribunal to make the scheme compulsory, subject to effective safeguards for the minority. 6. The co-ordination of district associations will be, ultimately, a desirable development, but can only be justified to the community by the industry effecting and sharing with the consumer economies, not only in the marketing of coal, but in all phases of its production and transport. 7. The Government is advised to consider the question of revising and clarifying the law on restraint of trade so as to remove the present uncertainty as to the status in law of marketing organisations. 8. In the export trade, local selling pools and the possibilities of closer co-operation between colliery owners and exporters should be developed. The Minority Report. Following some details of the Rhenish-Westphalian Coal Syndicate the minority report is set out, expression to the following views being given :— Stripped of all the extraneous considerations by which the discussion of the matter is frequently confused it is clear that the main objective of co-operative selling arrangements would be to compel the consumer to pay higher prices. Control of output is essential to the realisation of this object. This policy of increase of price by way of limitation of output is diametrically opposed to the real need of the country and of its coal industry to-day ; namely, a high rate of production at a low cost. The principles underlying the idea of co-operative selling are fundamentally unsound. The point of view involved must always be limitation rather than expansion of output, and the tendency must be to sterilise the development of the coal industry, hamper the expansion of industrial activity, and depress the standard of living all round. The reaction upon relations between capital and labour must be bad because of the encouragement that would be given to vain attempts to improve the position of the worker in the coal-mining industry by seeking to attain high nominal rates of wages and better nominal conditions through high prices at the expense of regular employment and real earnings. The minority claim that in the period preceding the strike any attempt artificially to raise the general level of coal prices would defeat its own object by limiting demand. The report says :— So far as the part of the inland trade of the country, subject to foreign competition either in Great Britain or abroad is concerned, it would have had disastrous consequences. The iron and steel industry, for example, the largest consumer of coal in this country, its demand exceeding 30,000,000 tons per annum or one-fifth of the entire home demand, has been operating under the stress of severe competition with foreign iron and steel produced by the aid of cheaper foreign coal, and in consequence it was forced to sell its products at less than 20 per cent. above 1913 prices. Any appreciable increase in the price of coal which immediately before the stoppage was about 63 per cent. above the average price over the five years, 1909-13, would have shut down a considerable portion of the industry already working below its normal rate of production. In their concluding objections to co-operative selling the minority add : "A further point is that participation in an arrangement of this kind would mean revolutionary changes in the organisation of the British coal export trade involving the abandonment of the system of selling by well-known brands and the loss of valuable-personal connections abroad."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||