Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

4th December 1926, Page: 152, Column: 2

The X-Ray Examination Of Coal

By F. J. Harlow, B.Sc., F.Inst.P., A.R.C.Sc.

In dealing with the world of humanity it is considered to be an accomplishment "to see through people," and the lecturer said that in the realm of physical science such had been the achievements of the last thirty years that we could, in the physical sense, now see through anybody or anything. The scientific study of X-Rays and their many applications was a most fascinating one and had led to such momentous results in so many directions that it could scarcely be realised that it was only thirty years ago that the Rays were discovered by Professor Rontgen, and that it was only just prior to the War that a long controversy as to their nature was settled by the epoch-making discovery of the X-Ray spectrometer. Principal Harlow went on to say that the cathode rays which had been shown to be minute particles of electricity called "electrons" were projected at enormous speeds from the cathode and they possessed, amongst other properties, that of exciting fluorescent lights in certain minerals, and he explained that screens made of fluorescent material could now readily be purchased from vendors of scientific apparatus. It was now known that X-Rays are produced whenever cathode rays impinge on matter. The sudden stoppage of the electrons travelling as they have been proved to do with velocities of the order of a hundred million metres per second was the cause of the production of these rays.

The Examination of Coal Specimens.

After describing the means of generating the high tension supply of electricity required in the production of X-Rays, the lecturer explained that one of the pioneer workers in the X-Ray examination of coal, Mr. Norman Kemp, of Edinburgh, had designed a form of X-Ray high tension transformer unit which he calls the "Carboscope" suitable for the examination of coal specimens. Although no attempts had, so far as Mr. Harlow was aware, been made to investigate coal structure by this means it might yet be possible by means of the X-Ray spectrometer or some similar device to obtain a great deal of information about fusain, clarain, durain, and vitrain. He explained that the radiographs of coal and coke specimens would perhaps scarcely convey all that could be obtained from a radiograph. Indeed a single radiograph might be very deceptive because all the shadows of the denser parts which in themselves might be distorted were thrown on to one plane. If, however, two stereoscopic radiograms were prepared the internal construction of the specimen might be seen in proper perspective. Stereoscopic pictures could easily be prepared by making exposures with the X-Ray tube in two positions relative to the object six centimetres apart. Through the kindness of Mr. Norman Kemp the lecturer was able to exhibit a number of hand stereoscopic pictures of coal and coke. The layers of infiltrated impurities stood out in perspective and gave a great deal more information than is obtainable from an ordinary radiograph, or indeed from ordinary visual observation of the specimen.

Coal Washing Characteristics.

"The radiology of coal appears so far to have attained, in the hands of Mr. Norman Kemp, and of his colleague, Mr. McLaren, its greatest measure of success in connection with the determination of washing characteristics," the lecturer said. "The ash of coal is generally speaking made up of these distinctive portions :— (a) The dirt or shaly matter included with the coal either by admixture in the hewing operation or through its intimate association with coal through inter-bedding. (b) Mineral matter occurring within the coal through infiltration as many of the radiographs seen reveal. These infiltrations are mainly of calcite, gypsum, or pyrites, (c) Finely divided foreign matter doubtless deposited during the formation of the coal and disseminated throughout the coal substance in a finely divided state. Most of the first-named may be removed by coal washing processes, also probably in some cases a certain amount of the second, but the third it is scarcely possible to remove in this way, and it is this latter which constitutes what is termed the 'Intrinsic Ash.' By an elaborate classification of the coal by the well known 'Sink and Float' process using solutions of varying densities it is possible to obtain an approximate value of the intrinsic ash, but it will be seen that radiographic observation of coal samples enables us to pick out readily pieces of coal containing nothing but intrinsic ash. This can be done much more satisfactorily by means of X-Rays than by the sink and float process as owing to the differing densities of different pure coals there can be no standard solution for all coals, the float portion for which one can be sure will contain only intrinsic ash. This then is one important operation in which X-Rays can be of distinct service.

"The washing capabilities of coal can be readily ascertained from a 'Washability' or 'Ash Characteristic' curve which may be worked out either by the float and sink method or by a jigging process." Principal Harlow went on to state: "The determination with precision of a washability curve is a matter of considerable importance if satisfactory coal washing is to be effected, and I want to show you how the X-Rays may be a valuable aid in this determination, especially if the jigging method is employed rather than the float and sink method. In the jig the unwashed coal is subjected to a current of water which passes intermittently upwards between the coal and dust particles. The coal rises repeatedly and then settles, and as a result the coal and dirt particles become classified according to density, the heaviest particles of shale and other impurities being ranged at the bottom and the lightest particles of coal at the top. If this process is carried out in a jig which lends itself to X-Ray examination the whole process may be followed, and what is of the highest importance in obtaining an accurate washability curve one can see quite readily when the classification is complete. By a simple device layer after layer of the classified coal may be removed, its ash content determined and a washability or ash characteristic curve constructed. If a rough division of the sample of unwashed coal into clean coal and dirt is required, this may be effected by dividing the coal as classified in the jigging process into the dense portion and the relatively light portion, the most appropriate division between the two being revealed by the X-Ray examination.

"In any arbitrary relative percentage amounts of washed coal and of refuse the ash contents of the coal and of the refuse may be obtained. If the commercial value of the coal with various ash contents is known the economic value of an improvement in the washing process can readily be calculated. It is perhaps open to question whether classification by the jig is as satisfactory as the float and sink method, but whichever method is employed a preliminary X-Ray examination of the coal must be of considerable assistance in that it enables one to get valuable information as to the nature and mode of occurrence of the non-combustible foreign matter associated with the coal. Further, by being able to pick out readily the purest lumps of coal in the sample from which the 'Intrinsic Ash' may be determined, the limit beyond which it is impossible to go in the washing process is readily obtainable.

"It must be confessed that the useful application of X-Rays to technical coal problems is in its infancy, and much research has yet to be done before the utility of X-Ray examination is definitely established, but whatever its value may prove to be I think you will agree that the subject is full of interest and the fullest investigation of the possibilities well worth while."

Points Raised in Discussion.

At the close of the lecture Mr. Colin McLuckie, lecturer in the Mining Department at the Wigan Mining College, said coals that contained a high percentage of ash were said to be inferior. They were designated inferior because the inorganic matter present reduced the heating value of the fuel. As to whether or not the ash content could be reduced in a coal of this description in order to increase its market value would depend upon how the impurities were distributed in the coal. If the inorganic matter was finely disseminated throughout the coal in a finely divided state there was no process that could possibly be applied in order to reduce the ash content. On the other hand if the impurities were inter-bedded with the coal there was a possibility of reducing the ash content by first passing the coal through breakers which would crush it up, and incidentally cause some of the dirt bands to separate from the coal. After the crushing process the coal could be sized and washed, the mixed impurities being removed, and the ash content consequently reduced. An X-Ray examination of inferior coals would certainly reveal any possibilities for the advantageous application of this process. From the details shown by the stereoscopic radiographs of coal he should think it would be possible to study the behaviour of the impurities in coal seams liable to spontaneous combustion. That was to say, if a "band" in a particular coal seam was liable to heat up a piece of the "band" could be radiographed when freshly mined, and taking radiographs of the specimen at stated intervals any physical and chemical changes taking place in the impurities, such as the pyritic bands, could then be readily detected, and information obtained as to the part taken by such impurities in promoting spontaneous heating. While the application of X-Rays to industrial problems was still in its infancy he was optimistic enough to say that in the future the X-Ray apparatus would find a place of usefulness in assisting to solve many of the complex problems that awaited solution in connection with coal.

Mr. F. Edmond, general manager of the collieries of the Wigan Coal and Iron Co., Ltd., in the Standish area, said that in examining the coal seams in different parts it had in the past been very difficult to come to a decision as to whether such and such a seam in one county had any relation to such and such a seam in another county, and in connection with the lecture it had occurred to him that it might be possible in the future by means of X-Ray examination, in addition to a microscopical examination, to find out some of the old hidden secrets of nature in this respect, and be able to define the relationship between the coal seams. All things were not impossible, and we had seen such wonderful things done in the way of wireless that it might not be impossible some time in the future by means of X-Ray examination of the crust to tell whether any particular, fault was going to run in such and such a direction, and how far it would run in any direction it took. From a market point of view we knew that we were moving towards the point at which coal seams would be valued and their prices fixed according to their calorific values, and by means of X-Rays it might be possible to find out, and to define, still further what was the relationship, and value, of one coal seam to another in this respect.

Mr. T. H. Byrom, F.I.C., F.C.S., author of the "Physics and Chemistry of Mining," said it seemed to him that the most important development of the use of X-Rays in connection with mining might be in deciding whether a mine was dusted properly or not, and whether the right proportion of stone dust was mixed with the coal dust.

* Summary of paper read at the November meeting of the Past and Present Mining Students Association by Principal Harlow, of the Mining and Technical College, Wigan.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Byrom, T. H.      
Edmond, Francis    General Manager  Whos Who Page
Harlow, F. J.    Principal  
Kemp, Norman      
McLaren, —      
McLuckie, Colin    Lecturer  
Rontgen, —, Prof.      


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print