20th November 1926, Page: 129, Column: 1
The Preservation Of Mine Timbers
By George Booth.
In mining operations the cost of timber is an item of much importance, because
the life of mine timbers is, in many cases, very-short, and, as the supply of
the better grades becomes depleted, less durable kinds must be used. This, of
course, tends to shorten still further the period of serviceability. While it
is possible that concrete and steel may to some extent take the place of timber
in mines, their high initial cost and the difficulty in installation will
greatly restrict their use. Moreover, wood, besides being comparatively cheap
to handle, possesses other desirable qualities, and for many purposes a
satisfactory substitute is hard to find. Both the decreasing supply and the
increasing price of timber make its more efficient utilisation imperative.
Agencies Destructive to Mine Timbers. — Timber used in mines is
exposed to destruction from many sources. Wear, breakage, and waste are
responsible for much loss. Wood rollers and drum laggings must be frequently
replaced on account of the constant wear by ropes. Unprotected timber in chutes
and mills is also rapidly worn by abrasion, and track ties in main haulage ways
get worn by the feet of mules, cut by ropes, etc. Large amounts of timber are
broken by "crush" and "squeeze" and much temporary timber
is buried beyond all recovery in pillar workings and in those mines which
resort to back filling. Decay and insect attack, however, cause the greatest
damage. If not totally destroyed by one or both of these, the timbers
frequently become so weakened that they break under the pressure upon them.
The relative importance of the different destructive agencies varies greatly
with conditions underground, but under average conditions they are as follows :
wear 5 per cent., breakage 20 per cent., waste from all causes 25 per cent.,
decay and insect attack 50 per cent.
Methods of Increasing Durability. — To protect mine timbers from
mechanical wear is usually impracticable, and preservative treatment of timber
subject to rapid wear, breakage, and fire, or of that buried in old workings,
would be unwarranted. On the other hand, a large amount of timber is destroyed
by decay and insects long before it has given its desired service, and if this
can be prevented at a reasonable cost a considerable saving can be effected.
Timber purchased for treatment should be sound and free from decay. All bark
should be removed, and the timbers or props should be piled with sufficient
space between them to permit a free circulation of air throughout the pile, so
that they can be thoroughly air-seasoned. All timbers should be cut and framed
to their final dimensions and form before treatment, if at all possible, since
the sawing and cutting of treated timber may expose untreated wood, which would
be subjected to attack by wood-destroying organisms. Thorough treatment of wood
with coal-tar creosote, the accepted best standard wood preservative for
general use, will retard decay for twenty or thirty years, and the treated wood
should give a length of service many times that usually obtained from untreated
timbers.
Treated timber has many advantages. Its extensive use by the railways over a
long period of time has thoroughly demonstrated the economies which are
effected by employing it in place of untreated material. Creosoted structural
timbers are being used more and more by other industries, and its relatively
small use in mines seems strange. Creosoting not only increases the life of the
wood, but it reduces the danger from fires by keeping the wood sound. Sound
wood is harder to ignite than partly decayed wood, and it will withstand flames
a longer time without failure. Unquestionably, freshly creosoted timber can be
ignited easily and the oil on its surface burns freely, but after the treated
timber has seasoned a few months the volatile fractions of the oil disappear
and the creosoted wood is not much easier to ignite than untreated wood. The
extent to which creosoted wood should be regarded as a fire hazard has never
been determined satisfactorily. The only recommendation that can be made in
this respect is that some other preservative than creosote should be used in
places where the fire hazard is considered of utmost importance, unless the
treated wood is covered with a fire-proof coating of some kind.
The importance of coal-tar creosote to the wood preserving industry is
evidenced by the fact that the demand is usually greater than the supply. Its
advantages are : high toxicity to wood-destroying fungi, relative insolubility
in water, low volatility (which enables it to remain in the wood and retain its
effectiveness almost indefinitely), and ease of application, easy determination
of its depth of penetration, and relatively small cost.
There are various ways in which timber can be treated. In general, the pressure
treatment is recommended wherever practicable. It is only in this way that any
depth of penetration of the wood by the preservative can be obtained in most
timbers, and good penetration is necessary to secure long life. Three of the
processes in common use are as follows :—
The Rueping Process. — This process comprises the following
operations: (a) The treating cylinder containing the wood is filled with
compressed air and so held for an hour or more. (b) It is then filled with oil,
the air being allowed to escape, but without reducing the pressure, (c) When
full of oil, the pressure is increased to a maximum of 150 to 2001b. per sq.
inch, and held until the specified absorption is obtained, (d) The oil is then
drained from the cylinder and vacuum-drawn to remove the excess of oil from the
wood. The air imprisoned during (a) expands during (d), forcing out a certain
amount of oil, and the process is therefore called the "empty cell"
process. If desired, the operation (a) may be omitted and the air pressure
applied afterwards.
The Lowry (Empty Cell) Process. — This is used chiefly for
creosoting air-seasoned cross-ties, poles, posts, paving blocks, and silo
staves. It consists essentially of the following steps : (a) Without at first
drawing a vacuum, creosote, at a temperature not exceeding 200 deg. F., is
injected into the wood to saturation or to a specified amount, (b) A quick
vacuum is drawn to remove the excess oil from the timber. The air imprisoned by
injecting the oil without a preliminary vacuum expands during the final vacuum,
forcing out a certain amount of oil with it. It is usual to leave about 2½
gallons of creosote (6 to 8 lb.) per cubic foot in railway ties, and 6 to 10
lb. per cubic foot in other timber.
The Colman Process. — Used almost exclusively for the treatment of
Douglas fir piles, and consists of the following steps: (a) The timber is
steamed at a pressure of 50 to 10 lb. per square inch for 3 to 8 hours, time
and pressure varying according to dimensions of material and previous degree of
seasoning. (6) The steam is released and a vacuum drawn until the timber is
considered seasoned. This usually requires from 7 to 14 hours. The temperature
within the treating cylinder during the vacuum period is usually maintained
between 180 and 212 deg. F. (c) Oil is injected at a pressure of 80 to 1401b.
per sq. inch until the desired absorption is obtained.
* Excerpts from paper presented at the June meeting of the Northern Alberta
branch of the Canadian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy,
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Booth, George | | | |