6th November 1926, Page: 123, Column: 2
Coal v. Oil
In the course of a Paper on "Steam versus Diesel Machinery for Cargo
Vessels," read by Mr. W. G. Cleghorn before a meeting of the
Institution of Engineers and Shipbuilders in Scotland, at Glasgow, the author
compared a Diesel with a coal-burning vessel, having worked out, for varying
prices of Diesel oil, the price of coal, which resulted in the same freight
rate for both vessels. Curves included in the Paper showed for various lengths
of voyage, the prices of oil and coal which resulted in a 5 per cent. profit
from the same freight rates in either the Diesel or steam vessel. Assuming
Diesel oil at 60s. per ton and coal at 20s. per ton, on an 8,000-mile voyage
the reciprocating coal-fired machinery was the better; indeed, the steamer
could afford to pay 24s. per ton for coal before the Diesel vessel equalled it,
a difference of 4s. A point of interest was that in a comparison of steam and
Diesel machinery there was a range in the price of oil within which the Diesel
vessel was the best. If the price of oil was above this range, the coal-burning
steamer was the best; if it was below the range, the oil-burning steamer was
the best.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Cleghorn, W. G. | | | |