|
6th November 1926, Page: 116, Column: 1 The Future Of The Mining IndustryBy Prof. Geo. Knox, F.G.S., M.I.Min.E. Use of Oil Fuel. — The development of the motor ship since the war has undoubtedly added to the difficulties of the mining industry in this country by the rapid elimination of the use of bunker coal for shipping, and this falling off in exports for this purpose is going to increase. It has been shown that in 10,000-ton ships running at 9½ knots the fuel consumption varies in the proportion of 45 tons best Welsh Steam Coal, 28 tons fuel oil (for raising steam in boilers), and 12 tons fuel oil (in Diesel engines). Lord Bearstead has shown that ships of the "Arum" class use 6 tons of oil per day, as against 24 tons of coal for similar sized ships using coal in steam boilers. As fuel oil can be obtained at any port in the world at £5 per ton (which in the ratio of 4 to 1, 1s equivalent to coal at 25s. per ton), it is evident that export coal would require to be very low in price to compete with oil fuel. It is true that the capital cost of equipping a motor ship with power is higher than for steam driven ships, but the other advantages claimed for motor ships more than counterbalance this. Owing to the use of the double bottom for oil storage motor ships have 25 per cent. more space for carrying goods or passengers, and the smaller amount of fuel required — 150 tons being a maximum for the longest voyages — this increases the radius of action of the ship by 300 per cent. Again, much time is saved in bunkering — 550 tons can be taken on board per hour — and even if a berth is not available at any port of call the ship can be fuelled from barges and thus prevent delay. There is also a saving effected in the number of men employed to run the ship, so that everything considered the advantages accruing from the use of fuel oil in the Mercantile Marine and Navy respectively are such as to have rendered it a formidable competitor with coal for power production in shipping. In 1913 there were just over a million tons of shipping using oil fuel, and to-day we have about 20,000,000 tons. In 1913 we imported 95,000,000 gallons of oil, which has now increased to 400,000,000 gallons. About 40 per cent. of the new ship construction in this country and 80 per cent. of continental construction at the present time is being built for internal combustion engines. How to Meet this Competition. — The only apparent method by which the mining industry can hope to successfully meet this competition is by carbonising the bunker coal previously supplied to ships (with additional small coal for which as a rule very low prices were obtained) and thus produce the necessary supply of fuel oil required by British shipping. A large amount of experimental work has been carried out within recent years with a view to utilising the small non-coking coals for the production of smokeless fuel, and the recovery of the residual oils, etc. Although many difficulties have been met with it can be confidently predicted that we are on the eve of a great change, and that in the course of a very short period low temperature carbonisation will be a commercial success. The difficulties which have beset low temperature carbonisation in the past have been threefold : (1) The swelling and sticking of the charge in the retort. (2) The long period of carbonisation required due to the low thermal conductivity of coal, necessitating a large capitalisation per ton. (3) The friable nature of the smokeless fuel and the hybrid type of oils recovered. The chemical constitution of coal is now fairly well proved, and the reasons for the behaviour of coal under heat treatment explained. Dr. Illingworth has shown that coal consists of four main types of substance which he has termed the "Alpha," "Gamma," "Beta," (or Beta Cellusoic), and "Ulmin" compounds. The "Gamma" compound is the cementing ingredient in coal on carbonisation and gives rise to large volumes of paraffinoidal and naphthinic hydrocarbons. Under heat treatment this compound melts and makes the heated coal plastic, hence the trouble met with in the swelling and sticking of the charge in the retorts. As this substance can be decomposed at temperatures ranging from 300° to 500° Cent., it can be extracted before the coking temperature is reached. Temperature gradient curves can now be determined from the chemical analysis of coals or mixtures of coals, and the "gamma" compounds extracted before the final critical stage of coke formation is reached. The period of carbonisation has been materially reduced and the resultant smokeless fuel made almost as hard as metallurgical coke, with a yield of oil varying from 14 to 28 gallons per ton of coal carbonised according to the nature of the coal. Many other workers have been engaged on this problem in this and other countries with varying degrees of success. It is certain that the next few years will see a development in the carbonisation of coal (particularly small coal) which will be of immense importance to the mining industry, and which will compensate for the loss of the bunker trade and at the same time provide our towns and cities with a smokeless fuel for domestic purposes and supply all the oil required for our Navy and Mercantile Marine. Cheaper Power Production. — A great deal has been written about the supply of cheap power that would be available from "Super" Power Stations and the saving that would be effected in its more general application in mining engineering, but the most that we can expect from improved thermal efficiency is to save one pound of coal per kilowatt-hour which is equivalent to about one-tenth of a penny. The efficiency of even the largest Power Station is between 15 and 20 per cent. of the thermal energy in the coal unless the heat in the exhaust steam is utilised, when it may be increased to from 50 to 60 per cent. Part of the heat in the fuel goes up the boiler chimney, but 60 per cent. of it passes away with the cooling water from the condensers. This heat can be utilised in heating up towns and villages in the vicinity of the power Station, as is done in Birmingham, Manchester, London and elsewhere on a comparatively small scale, and in America and on the Continent on a large scale. By linking up the existing power Stations, thus equalising the load on the mains over large areas, and supplying heat as well as power, a greater saving could be effected. If the "Super" Power Stations are to be erected at the collieries as suggested this heat could not be used as effectively owing to the distance from large populous centres. Other advantages would, however, be obtained from colliery power stations, if associated with low temperature carbonisation plants and using the gas or oil in internal combustion engines for power production, and this appears to be the most promising line of development in the future. The supply of cheap power is necessary not only for colliery consumption but for many other industries as well, and whatever scheme is eventually adopted every endeavour should be made to make the fullest use of existing plant and extend their usefulness locally by utilising the "waste" heat from the condensers. Decrease in Output and Increase in Cost. — The relatively larger number of old collieries in operation year by year, the decreasing thickness of seams worked, and the greater depth from which coal has to be won, together with the shortening of the working day, have all contributed to the reduction in output per man employed and increased the cost of production. It would be difficult to apportion the relative part which each of these changed conditions has played in bringing about the present state of affairs. The workmen say that by regrouping, amalgamation or absorption schemes, and the re-organisation of industry thus made possible, there is every likelihood of the industry being placed upon a sound economic basis. On the other hand the employers say that unless longer hours are worked it is impossible to carry on the industry at all. In a large number of old mines it will be found increasingly difficult to reduce working costs, because it is impossible at their stage of development to adopt a modern method of concentration in working or to apply mechanical aids for cutting, conveying and loading because of the large capital costs involved. A number of small mines may also find it difficult to carry on, and where possible by amalgamation or re-organisation the coal in the older and smaller concerns may be more profitably extracted by adjoining collieries. In any case the Government has now passed legislation making it possible for the hours of work to be increased by one hour per day ; and also through the Mining Industry Act, 1926, made provisions for the re-organisation of the industry. Both are permissive Acts, but until a better spirit prevails and the goodwill of both parties secured to an agreement lasting over a period of years, there is little hope for a speedy and continued recovery of the coal trade. As already stated, however, the question of the future management and development of the mining industry is the one with which we as students are chiefly concerned. Under modern conditions it ought to be possible for the Mine Surveyor, Electrical, Mechanical and Chemical Engineers to have their duties sufficiently well defined that no overlapping is necessary. The Colliery Manager is not responsible for making the survey of his mines, or supervising the use of machinery above ground or attending to the production of power, preparation of coal or coking and by-product recovery. Why then should it be necessary to attempt to partially train him for all these branches when responsible officials are already being trained to manage these various departments ? On the continent a great measure of the success of colliery undertakings is no doubt due to the fact that well-defined departments have been established to deal with the various branches of colliery work making it possible for a high degree of specialisation in the training of each section. The technical educational training of a Colliery Manager should therefore be largely confined to the various branches of underground work. The duty of the Mining Colleges would thus be simplified, in having to train mining students in those fundamental principles only which deal with safety and efficient underground working. More time could then be devoted to training them in accuracy of thinking, observing, classifying and working which would provide them with an intellectual equipment capable of being expended indefinitely with the aid of experience gained while following their profession. This would enable them to give more time and attention to improvements in coal production, and for the exercise of that tact, discretion, prudence, judgment and promptness in action so frequently demanded of them, and make it possible for the quality of service rendered by Colliery Managers to the community being appreciated at its proper value. * Paper presented at opening meeting of the Past and Present Mining Students' Association in the Mining and Technical College, Wigan, Concluded from page 107.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||