Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

23rd October 1926, Page: 106, Column: 1

The Future Of The Mining Industry

By Prof. Geo. Knox, F.G.S., M.I.Min.E.

Although conditions in the mining industry could hardly be worse than they are at the present time, and the outlook for the immediate future is anything but hopeful, yet I am sufficiently optimistic to believe that having weathered this storm as we have done many previous ones we shall again set our house in order and proceed to build up a safer and more efficient industry in the future.

Leaving out of consideration all political issues or financial questions of currency and rates of exchange or loss of export markets as a result of the war, there are other alleged contributory causes of the present difficulties which require the closest attention and consideration of students in mining engineering. Among these may be cited: (a) Inefficient management due to lack of specialisation in the various branches of mining engineering, (b) The reduction in the use of coal for bunkering by the substitution of oil fuel. (c) The necessity for increased use of mechanical appliances in coal production, (d) Decrease in output per man employed and increase in the cost of production, (e) The need for super-power stations and the production of a cheap power supply, (f) The large number of small collieries and old collieries which are productively uneconomic.

Inefficient Management. — It is perfectly true to assert that the mining industry — like every other industry — can be more scientifically developed than it is at present, there being no finality to progress, but from the management point of view British mines will compare favourably with those of any other country, where similar conditions exist. Although developments take place in different coalfields along different lines and at varying rates, the spread of technical information is so rapid to-day that as soon as the establishment of general fundamental principles has led to a definite scientific standard of development in one country it is very soon copied by others. It is true that in some parts of the United States (America) — where enormous profits were realised during the war — and in new districts like the Limburg Campine Coalfield, the general rate of progress has been greater than is the case in this country, but the reasons for these rapid developments are sufficiently well known not to require recapitulation.

Inefficiency. — A general standard of efficiency is not so easily attainable in the actual getting of coal at the working face as in the subsidiary branches of mining dealing with the haulage, winding and preparation of coal for the market. This is due to the very variable geological conditions pertaining to certain coalfields, the age of the collieries, etc., yet in this direction probably more than in any other mining operation lies the greatest opportunity for cheapening the production of coal.

Owing to the great dissimilarity in the conditions under which coal is obtained in United States of America as compared with British mines, a comparison is somewhat difficult as the following statistics indicate :— (a) 75 per cent, of British coal is obtained from thin seams, as against 25 per cent. in America, (b) The average depth at which coal is mined in America is one-fourth that of Great Britain, 50 per cent. of British coal being won from seams below 900 feet in depth, as against 0.3 per cent. in America, (c) 70 per cent. of our miners are employed in collieries which are at least 30 years old, whereas in America 50 per cent. of the men are employed in mines less than 15 years old. These thicker seams in newer and shallower mines account partly but not altogether for the difference in output per man employed, which is 3.75 tons in U.S., as against 0.784 ton per man (for all workers) in Britain, or 4.34 tons as against 0.977 ton for underground workers only.

There is one direction in which American mining practice is ahead of us, viz., in the use of coal cutting, conveying and loading machinery, which is made largely possible by the thicker seams worked and the use of electric power transmission close up to the working face, which in many of our mines is quite impossible on account of the danger involved.

In 1923 the United States of America National Coal Commission, in submitting their report on Underground Management in Bituminous Mines, referred, among other things, to the need for (1) the development and efficient application of mechanical devices to replace hand loading, and (2) the better control and co-ordination of underground operations, particularly cutting, loading and hauling of coal.

The importance of the use of loading machinery from the point of view of safety and efficiency may be appreciated, they say, when in many cases the total cost of the coal at the mine may be more safely produced at a reduction of 30 per cent., as shown by the actual operating results, without any reduction in wages. The area of working face to be kept open and the number of men employed were almost halved while the output per man employed was increased by 80 to 90 per cent. Other advantages obtained by the concentration of work in small areas are the reduction of costs (other than coal getting) and the increased safety owing to the speed of working and better control of subsidence. Excessive roadways are done away with, tram lines and timber reduced, with a reduction in the cost of supervision and losses in ventilation.

It is from this modern method of concentrating work in our newer mines and the more intelligent application of such aids to production as mechanical picks — where coal-cutters cannot be applied — and the more universal application of mechanical conveying and loading, that we have to look for the means of reducing our costs of production in coal getting.

On a recent visit to the mines on the Continent it was noticeable how extensively — particularly in thin seams — the use of pneumatic picks was resorted to for coal getting, ripping and repairing. In seams varying from 22 to 30 inches in thickness, and very highly inclined, the average output per "pick" varied between 8 and 12 tons per shift, which is considerably higher than the yield from the best seams in this country. It is difficult to understand why the use of this mechanical aid to industry is so seldom applied in this country. It cannot be a question of safety in this case, as its use involves the application of compressed air which can be safely taken into any part of the most fiery and dusty mines.

Specialisation. — It is often said that we have no organic idea in mining education in this country, and this is hardly to be wondered at when you consider the Admirable Crichton type of superman required for colliery management. Besides being required to have an intimate knowledge of everything pertaining to the safe and economic production of coal under all manner of difficult conditions, he is supposed to have a good technical training in Mechanical, Electrical and Civil Engineering, together with a knowledge of Chemistry, Geology and Mining Legislation. Having accomplished all this he is expected to be a psychologist capable of dealing with the most important machine employed in mining — the workman — and determine the limits of grousing due to "fatigue" which is as common to men as to metals, and be able to lubricate the rough places whereby satisfactory results may be obtained. If it be agreed that the organic idea in technical education is firstly to teach the youth how to learn, and, secondly, what to learn — the latter being largely determined by what he has to do in after life, then there is some reason for the gibe.

It is hopeless to attempt to make any mining student proficient in all the branches of study referred to, and, after all, the real work pf the Colliery Manager is not to deal with coking and by-product recovery, the preparation of coal for the market, or the production, conversion and distribution of large power supplies and other allied subjects. His main business is to arrange for the production and transport of coal with safety and efficiency ; to organise the work to be performed by others ; to consider and act upon the reports of his subordinates, and to negotiate and determine all kinds of knotty problems affecting employment, wages, costs and outputs, which makes his work as much humanistic as technical. In carrying out these duties he is surrounded by voluminous legal enactments, so that much of his time is devoted to making and signing reports.

The sooner it is realised that mining engineering can be profitably sub-divided so that the Mine Surveyor, the Mechanical and Electrical Engineers and the Chemist have legally allocated to them their respective duties in separate and distinct departments, the sooner will it be possible to devise an educational training for Colliery Managers and other underground officials of an organic nature.

The day has gone past when the Mine Surveyor should look upon his post as a stepping stone to Colliery Management. The Surveyor of the future, instead of being merely concerned with measuring up work which has already been completed, will have to provide the plans for their construction. He will not only be required to make an accurate plan of the mine workings, but will be expected (as the engineering draughtsman or architect would) to prepare the plans beforehand from a geological survey of his mineral properties. He ought also to know something of the laws relating to mining properties and their leases, and how to value the minerals they contain. He should also have a knowledge of the relation of subsidence to the various methods of working so that he can lay out the required pillars for the protection of property, railways, etc., and he may conceivably be called upon to design garden villages, water supply systems, and branch railways. If these duties were definitely assigned to him, and he alone made legally responsible for their proper supervision, why trouble the Colliery Manager with them ?

The same remarks apply to the Chemist and other grades of Engineers engaged in mining operations, and when reorganisation becomes effective and colliery units grow increasingly larger, the idea of making the Colliery Manager responsible for all these activities will become still more absurd. In actual practice the Colliery Manager has very little to do with the large surface equipments and subsidiary undertakings, but until the various departments have been clearly denned it is an exceedingly difficult matter to give the Colliery Manager the proper course of technical training required for his particular post.

Until such specialisation takes place the prevailing system of technical educational training involving the contemporaneous study of a large number of distinct subjects must continue, but this is no reason why the Colliery Managers' examination should continue on the present lines. If the Mines Examination Board would introduce what is now generally known as the "tandem" system whereby only single subject or closely allied subjects are taken at one time, this would enable many excellent officials to obtain the necessary qualifications who under the present system cannot pass in all the subjects at any particular examination. Although some candidates have passed in all the subjects of examination they are still without their qualification because from various causes they were unable to pass in all at the same time. The Mines Examination Board have performed a useful service in establishing a national standard which they have gradually raised to its present high degree. Much better results would be obtained, however, if they could hold examinations on different occasions for applied groups of subjects such as (1) Ventilation, Gases, Lighting, Explosions, Gob-fires, and Explosives, or (2) Methods of Working. Coal Cutting and Conveying, Timbering, Subsidence, etc., and (3) Pumping, Sinking, Pitting, Haulage and Mining Machinery generally, instead of holding one examination for all these subjects.

(To be concluded.)

Paper presented at opening meeting of the Past and Present Mining Students Association in the Mining and Technical College, Wigan.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Knox, George, Prof.      



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
23 Oct 1926  The Future Of The Mining Industry (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 Nov 1926  The Future Of The Mining Industry (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print