9th July 1926
Mine Hours
A "Scene" In The Lords
Measure Passed
Ministers As Directors.
Westminster, Thursday.
The most important thing in the closing stages of the debate on the Eight Hours Bill in the Lords was the emphatic declaration by both the Government speakers, Lord Salisbury and Lord Cecil, that the Government accepted no responsibility
for the offers posted at the pits in anticipation of the passing of the measure. These terms were not, and could not, be Government terms. The Bill was not being passed with the idea of putting compulsion upon either side. Therefore, although the
Government had acted in order to prevent the terms being, in their opinion, unfair, they did not take up the position of being arbitrators issuing or enforcing an award. Labour peers suggested inserting a suspensory power in the Bill ; and developed at
enormous length the usual arguments that the Bill was no solution ; but all that Lord Cecil would reply was that the Government did not pretend that it was, and were fully aware that peace must come from agreement between the protagonists, aided at any
and every favourable opportunity by the Government.
Unusual Scene.
The most exciting thing, however, was the spread of the infection of disorder from the Commons to the usually decorous atmosphere of the Upper House. The Peers had long been growing restive beneath the harangues of their Labour colleagues, and a rumble
of "Divide" interrupted and incensed Lord Parmoor. Lord De La Warr broke down their patience altogether by speaking for nearly an hour, and when Lord Arnold rose to follow suit, Lord Salisbury, after a few minutes,
jumped up and exclaimed that in the face of the obvious intent to abuse the traditions of the House, he would move the closure. The Lord Chancellor, brushing aside protests from Lord Arnold, put the question, but at once pandemonium broke loose at
the Bar, where a number of Socialists from the Commons had congregated. Shouts of "Shame," "Four hours for you and eight for the miners" — the latter from Mr. H. Maclean — rose above the general uproar. Lord
Arnold, gesticulating heatedly towards the Lord Chancellor, claimed to have convincing arguments to advance. The unprecedented event was terminated by the Lord Chancellor quietly repeating the question ; but there was further altercation before the
Bar could be cleared, and the closure carried by 44 votes to four. There was no division on the third reading.
Chorus Of Hisses.
The arrival of Black Rod in the Commons to summon that House to hear the Royal Assent was the signal for a fresh outburst. There was a murmur as the three knocks on the main door announced his presence, and when he reached the Bar, Mr. T. Williams
leapt to his feet and moved that he be not entertained. The Speaker took not the slightest notice, whereupon the vast majority of the Socialists began an uproarious chant of "Ho ! Ho !" which continued the whole time Black Rod was delivering
his message. It died away as the Speaker left the Chair, and the rioters left to take up strategic positions in the Lords. There the premeditated disorder continued when the Speaker's procession arrived. Mr. Buchanan, Mr. Stephen, and
others entered the galleries reserved for members of the Commons, talking and laughing, but directly the reading of the Letters Patent began they set up a chorus of hisses and coughs, which strengthened into shouts of "A murder Bill" as the
Lord Chancellor went imperturbably on to deliver the Commission.
The climax of this buffoonery was reached when the Clerk uttered the final phrase of the ceremony, "Le Roy le veult," cries of "Bon soir" and "Honi soit qui mal y pense" issuing from the interrupters, followed by loud
laughter. Those who had accompanied the Speaker to the Bar retorted with, "What a circus," as they retired into the Lobby. A scuffle between a Conservative and a Socialist on the way back led to some protests from Mr. Kirkwood when the
sitting was resumed, but as the disputants entered smiling together soon afterwards, and the Chairman ruled that free fights were not a legitimate excuse for interrupting business, the House was finally able to resume in comparative peace, after this
interval of unseemly advertisement.
Attack On Ministers.
The campaign to discredit individual Ministers developed further to-day, and will be fought out in the open as a separate issue at last. During question-time Mr. Johnston asked whether Mr. Chamberlain was still a director of a certain
Birmingham firm, which was "in contractual relations" with the Government. The Prime Minister replied that he (Mr. Chamberlain) was a director, and quite properly so, because the firm was a private family concern, and therefore included
in the category of those in which Sir H. Campbell-Bannerman in 1906 and the War Cabinet in 1917 had declared it permissible for Ministers to hold interests. The rest of the insinuation he left to Mr. Chamberlain himself, who with frigid
clarity, and amid the fervent cheers of the exasperated Conservatives, exposed the whole genesis of these attacks in a personal statement.
Experts, inspired or paid by unknown persons, had recently been searching the records at Somerset House for potentially defamatory information. Their fruits were not definite charges, but insinuations, which he would answer, lest contempt were mistaken
for admission. First, the Prime Minister had shown that the directorship was perfectly regular. Secondly, by the defeat of an amendment to the Address in 1900 the House had declared it to be quite legitimate for Ministers to retain an interest in firms
enjoying Government contracts. Thirdly, he took no part whatever in the conduct of this particular firm, save as a trustee for the family interests. He did not know or inquire what contracts it made, but in 1897, when he was actively in it, only a
trifling proportion of its business was concerned with Government contracts, and, so far as he was aware, that was still the situation.
This statement was interrupted by a terrific uproar at one point when Mr. Chamberlain referred to Mr. Johnston as "a specialist in such questions." The Speaker at once intervened to insist that personal explanations must not be
controversial — to which Commander Locker-Lampson retorted that attacks on a Minister's honour must be, and Mr. Duff Cooper pertinently observed that those who dared not make open charges must not complain of retorts to insinuations.
This rankled in the breast of Mr. A. Henderson, and, after the statement, he announced that the Socialists would table a motion for debate ; as indeed the Speaker had already indicated to be the proper procedure. Both sides proved by their cheers
that they were thirsting for it. The Speaker took occasion to administer a severe rebuke to those who allowed their feelings, naturally on edge, to lead them into reciprocal insults, and earnestly begged that nothing should occur which would obscure the
important issues with which Parliament was concerned.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Arnold, Lord | | | |
| Buchanan, — | | | |
| Campbell-Bannerman, H., Sir | | | |
| Cecil, Lord | | | |
| Chamberlain, — | | | |
| Cooper, Duff | | | |
| Henderson, A. | | | |
| Johnston, — | | | |
| Kirkwood, — | | | |
| Locker-Lampson, —, Commander | | | |
| Maclean, H. | | | |
| Parmoor, Lord | | | |
| Salisbury, Lord | | | |
| Stephen, — | | | |
| Warr, De La, Lord | | | |
| Williams, T. | | | |