|
30th June 1926 Mine Hours BillSecond Reading CarriedLabour AngerMr. Wheatley And Subsidies. Westminster, Tuesday. The second day's debate on the Eight Hours Bill was certainly more lively and possibly more useful. It began with an example of the organized rowdyism which the House is learning to expect from the Socialist back benches, and which succeeded in partially drowning the observations of Colonel Lane-Fox. He managed to explain that the Bill was purely permissive, and might appeal to the miners, especially those who thought of their wives and children. Mr. Westwood white, and Mr. Kirkwood scarlet, with rage, seized upon this as a charge of callous selfishness against those to whom the Bill would not appeal, and only the great patience of the Speaker in repeatedly explaining that the proper answer to any opinion was argument, not abuse, secured enough of a lull to enable Colonel Lane-Fox to deny any offensive intention. Loud murmurs, however, continued all through his explanation that the Bill offered the only chance of maintaining wages without a rise in the price of coal which would be fatal both to the export trade and to the heavy industries. There might still be some unemployment, but at least not on the scale which the policy of the Miners' Federation contemplated. He claimed that the letter sent by that body in reply to the Prime Minister's proposals on May 20 did constitute an agreement upon measures of reorganization which the Coal Commission had urged should precede any sacrifices from the miners. Finally, in reply to loud ejaculations of "liar" in various tones and phraseology, he asked bluntly, "What is your alternative ?" Mr. Wheatley, who was listened to in exemplary science, gave it. The two main themes of his speech were an attempt to discredit the Prime Minister and an effort to lead his own party along the road of a new industrial party. He began with the claim that the Bill was part of a general attack on working conditions, and the assertion that Mr. Baldwin had declared, last July, a general reduction of wages to be necessary. Sharply challenged for his authority, he produced the Daily Herald, amid loud laughter. Subsidies All Round. At any rate the Government had, for the first time in history, taken sides in an industrial dispute without any mandate and had said to one party, "Don't break the law. We will change it for you." That raised a grave constitutional issue and marked out the Prime Minister as the champion of reaction. Having gained a cheer by this personal attack, Mr. Wheatley turned to policy. It might be good strategy to wait until reaction produced revolution, but the human suffering during the wait was too great. The apogee of the competitive system was the creation of a servile class, indefinitely malleable between the cruel hands of price-cutting capitalists. Fighting trade unionism, which was quite independent of foreign promptings, would never stand it. If prices were not cut, longer hours would not extend markets, and unemployment was inevitable. Better spend money on uneconomic work than uneconomic idleness. In fact, the easy market afforded by industrial development at home was nearly closed, and only increased purchasing power, i.e., increased wages, could create a new one. The first pillar of the new system was, therefore, to be inflation. The second was to be the subsidization of all "essential" services, including mining. It mattered no more whether mining paid or not than whether the Army paid or not. It would, therefore, be a simple matter for the miners to go back on the old terms pending reorganization. It was only due to them after they had been tricked into thinking that negotiations would be resumed on the basis of the Samuel Memorandum and the general strike had been called off in the national interest. At least this speech dared to bring the demand for a subsidy into the open and tack it on to a theory of industry logical, if bristling with begged questions. The more obvious were well answered by Sir F. Meyer before the house returned to the Bill. Mr. Skelton then accepted it on the ground that longer hours had less effect on a standard of living than lower wages ; and Miss Wilkinson produced a clanking exhibit in support of an accusation of inhumanity against Somersetshire owners. This brought a very interesting speech from a coalowner, Mr. Wragg. He thought the temporary demand after the stoppage would keep the price high enough to maintain pre-stoppage conditions for a month. During that time the Commission should be called together and fix rates and hours for each district. Nobody responded, and Mr. MacDonald summed up the by now conventional case against the Bill. The Government had never replied to the prophecies of its terrible economic effects and the premium it would set upon the likelihood of more fatal accidents. They had never denied that it meant both longer hours and lower wages. They could not deny that the conditions postulated for it by the Commission were not fulfilled, and the results of it foreseen by the Commission would follow. It was not, therefore, a business proposition. Secondly, it brought "not peace but a sword" to the industry. It was an owners' Bill, suggested only by them, approved only by them. It must, therefore, further exacerbate their relations with the miners. Possibly the men might drift back to work, but bitterly and revengefully, knowing that eight hours' work would be a permanent feature of the industry thereafter. Mr. Baldwin's Reply. When Mr. Bridgeman rose to reply, the early rowdyism broke out in redoubled force, the same persons clamouring for Mr. Baldwin with a ferocity which refused to abate even before the Speaker's reproof. When at last it showed signs of flagging, Mr. Stephen and others revived it by repeating accusations against the Prime Minister's honour, to the effect that he had tampered with the Chairman of the Commission, and that his holding in Baldwins, Limited, made him a person who would profit financially by the Bill. After this sort of futility had lasted for some time, in defiance of the Chair, Mr. Baldwin sprang to his feet with a scornful gesture, and faced his critics, who actually fell silent. In low tones, which betrayed how very deeply he was wounded by such a disgraceful scene, he replied that there was, of course, no shadow of truth in the first accusation. As for the second, it was true that he had a holding in Baldwin's, Limited, and had kept it there instead of profiteering, realization, or investment during the war. The statement had appeared in Lansbury's Weekly without this qualification or the fact that he had not received a penny from this source for five years. His money was, and always would be, in British industry. If the suggestion was that he was improperly influenced by this holding in an old family business, then — his voice broke and recovered — he would be judged by those whose opinions he valued on both sides of the House. The Conservatives by this time were roused to a pitch of intense excitement, and accorded their leader a thunderous ovation, in which the very uncomfortable Front Opposition bench joined. Mr. D. Graham, who had first made the charge in the course of an otherwise unnoticeable speech, proceeded to make a long and rambling explanation to the effect that he had drawn his facts from the Sunday Times, but an exasperated House would not listen to an attempted justification by Mr. Lansbury. The same tumult broke out when Mr. Bridgeman again attempted to speak, but the Speaker, who had gone to the very limit of patience, frustrated the obvious objective of all this false emotionalism by putting the question. All the disturbers passed quietly into the Lobby, where they were beaten, and the Bill carried by 355 votes to 163. An attempt to sing the "Red Flag" worthily concluded an unedifying evening.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||