|
8th May 1926, Page: 330, Column: 2 Machinery At Coal FaceBy Sam Mavor. From paper on "The Applications of Machinery at the Coal Face" read at meeting on 8th April of the Institution of Electrical Engineers. It is impossible for anyone familiar with recent practice in mechanical coalmining and with its economic results, to be otherwise than optimistic as to the future of the industry if the colliery owners and the miners are left to settle their own affairs. In mining, as in every other industry, the problem of cost reduction is that of increasing individual output, but in mining this problem has special significance because labour accounts for 75 per cent. of the total cost of production, and because the higher this proportion the more effectively it can be attacked. At many collieries modern coal-producing machinery is even in these days of low prices earning profits that without it would he non-existent. The condition of unsettlement and the sense of insecurity of recent years and of the present day, have seriously retarded progress in the equipment of mines with machinery of production, and have thus accentuated the difficulties of the present situation. In England the proportion of machine-cut coal to the total output is, according to the latest Report of the Mines Department, 14 per cent., whereas in Scotland the proportion is 47 per cent. The geological conditions in Scotland are not more favourable to machine mining ; the difference is due partly to economic pressure compelling a reduction in cost of production, but largely to the permissibility of electricity at the coal face in most of the Scottish mines. In Scotland 93.25 per cent. of the coal-cutters in use are electric and 6.75 per cent. are compressed-air machines. Evolution of the Mechanical Coal-cutter. Soon after the middle of the eighteenth century the problem of providing the pick man with mechanical aid began to engage attention. The earliest form of coal-cutter was the "iron man," so called because the aim was to simulate the operation of a manually wielded pick. The "iron man" was a contrivance which held a miner's pick, to which a reciprocating motion was imparted by a system of levers, power being applied through crank handles by two or more men. Many variants of the "iron man" were devised but, so long as the machine depended on muscle power, little progress was possible. The first suggestion to discard the reciprocating pick in favour of continuously moving cutters was embodied in a patent of 1843 for a machine — the precursor of the disc coal-cutter — which was in effect a circular saw; but without adequate power to drive it such a machine could not succeed. It was not until after the middle of the nineteenth century, when compressed-air power became available for underground service, that development of the coal-cutter was possible. Compressed-air power was at first applied to energize the iron man, the pick of which operated by percussion at a point, but it was soon recognised that the new power might be utilised to greater advantage than by restricting it to delivery of blows by an individual pick. The sixth decade of the last century was marked by important steps in the evolution of the compressed-air coal-cutter ; and to the disc machine were added in 1853 the chain machine, and ten years later the bar machine; in both types the movement of the cutters was continuous. Since the period referred to, the development of power, strength and cutting capacity in coal-cutters has been progressive, but the principles that are applied with such effect in present-day coal-cutters were embodied in embryo in the early disc, chain and bar machines which were all originated in this country. A new era in the evolution of the coal-cutter was opened by the application in 1885 of electricity as the motive power. The first coal-cutter to be driven by an electric motor was a bar machine invented by James Blackburn, a Yorkshire colliery manager. As in the whole range of engineering the electric motor has had a beneficial influence on the design of every machine with which it has been associated — so with coal-cutters the application of the electric motor resulted in rapid advance in the development of these machines. The priceless advantage in the use of electricity, that the power can be easily and accurately measured, was quickly turned to account in coal-cutters and the power and strength of the machines were rapidly increased ; the application of the electric motor to the disc coal-cutter, and later to the chain machine, followed its successful use in the bar machine. Complete enclosure of the gearing of both disc and chain machines followed the adoption of the enclosed electric motor. The next notable advance was the application of the three-phase motor, and the credit for taking the first steps is due to Mr. Roslyn Holiday who, at Ackton Hall Collieries early in 1898, replaced the compressed-air motor of a disc coal-cutter by two 10-h.p. three-phase motors with wound rotors and slip-rings; later the slip-rings were removed and the rotor windings closed. In 1901 Mr. Holiday fitted three-phase motors, with wound rotors short-circuited, both to chain and to bar machines. The first coal-cutters to be put on the market with squirrel-cage rotors were probably the three-phase bar-type machines produced early in 1903. The compressed-air motors originally applied to the disc machine had single cylinders with reciprocating pistons. They were followed by twin cylinders side by side; this type was also applied to bar and chain machines and was in general use until the turbine was introduced. It still survives in some disc machines which continue to do good work where the undercut is not deep and the air supply is adequate. Later Development of the Coal-cutter. The electric motor importantly influenced the design of the coal-cutters with which it was incorporated; the possibility it introduced of developing large power in small dimensions resulted in the design of the whole machine being made more compact. For convenience in manufacture the overall dimensions of the d.c. and a.c. motors were made alike and with identical facings, so that either type of motor could be assembled in a coal-cutter; this interchangeability is an advantage to the user who may have occasion to change the system of power supply. Standardisation having been carried so far, it became obviously desirable that the compressed-air motor should be brought into conformity with the new general design of the coal-cutter ; this involved approximation of the compressed-air motor to the size and shape of the electric motors. The compressed-air motors designed for the purpose indicated were short-stroke, high-speed, single-acting motors of the 3- or 4-cylinder type actuating a crankshaft in the long axis of the coal-cutter. Motors of this type and form were made to be interchangeable with the electric motors in the coal-cutter structure. These air motors gave good service, but, owing to the necessary lightness and delicacy of their fast moving parts, they were not well suited to the rough usage and strenuous service to which they were subjected. Another important step in the evolution of the coal-cutter was marked by the advent of the so-called "air turbine" motor. The power is developed by the cumulative effect of the pressures in the spaces acting against the teeth of the opposite rotors and forcing them apart. It is essential that the teeth of the two rotors shall engage so closely that their lines of contact shall make practically airtight joints. The motor is extremely simple and robust, but it depends for its economical use of air upon a high order of precision in manufacture and upon accuracy of its adjustments. The invention remained dormant until the development of engineering practice enabled an American firm to produce a satisfactory motor. The suitability of this type of motor for incorporation in the coal-cutters that had been adapted to the electric motor was apparent. In the result reciprocating motors were soon superseded by turbines in all modern British coal-cutters, and the simple rotary motion, which has ousted reciprocating motion in so many spheres, scored another triumph. Its advantages for coal-cutters are decisive. In the case of motors to be used in coal-cutting machinery the dimensions of the motor are strictly limited by the conditions of service of the coal-cutter in which the motor is to be incorporated; the height especially is rigidly fixed, and this determines the maximum diameter of the armature or rotor. The work done by a coal-cutter is intermittent and may fluctuate violently from instant to instant, and the machine is liable to demand from its motor very large increases of power for brief periods, as when the cutters meet some obstacle, or when the overlying material collapses on the cutting member and jams or tends to jam it. The words "greatest possible horse-power" should therefore be interpreted to mean the greatest power that the motor will give without breaking down or ceasing to function, and should have no connection whatever with temperature-rise. Apart from the necessity for restricting the length of the machines, simplicity and robustness are so important in coal-cutter motors that in three-phase machines squirrel-cage rotors are generally used, although for disc machines, and in some cases for chain machines, wound rotors would have advantages. The stators of some machines are switched straight to the line, whilst others are wound for star-delta switching. The E.M.F. for which coal-cutters for service in this country are wound varies from 400 volts to 550 volts. The mean and the maximum powers required by the bar type are less than for the chain and disc types, the chain type is next in order, and the greatest mean and maximum powers are required by the disc machine. The cutting member of the bar machine is enabled to follow irregularities of contour in the plane of advance, and to accommodate itself to irregularities of the floor of a seam or of a band of dirt in which the cut may be made ; moreover, neither the resistance to rotation of the bar, nor the progress of the machine along the face, are affected by collapse of the coal or other material immediately behind the line of the cut. Owing to the large number of cutter picks of the bar machine, the comparatively small bits taken by each pick, and the immunity from liability by jamming of the cutter member, the power required by the bar machine varies less from the mean than in the other types. The cutting member of the chain machine consists of a rigid jib round which a "race" is formed to guide the chain that carries the cutters. The cutter picks of the chain machine are fewer in number, and individually they take a bigger bite than those of the bar machine. The cutting member of the disc machine presents a still larger area in the plane of the cut. As the disc machine is less amenable to manoeuvring than either of the other types, it must therefore overcome difficulties by frontal attack and must be endowed with great reserves of strength and power. The limits of the field of usefulness of coal-cutters cannot be defined with precision; they are elastic and have been widely extended by development of the capabilities of the machines. It may be said, however, that the respective types — bar, chain and disc — have comparative limitations imposed by the mining conditions. The following may be given as examples of mining conditions that impose limitations: Hardness of the material to be cut, presence of hard foreign bodies such as ironstone or pyrites at the holing position, friableness of the material under which the cut is made, the height from the floor at which the cut is required, undulations of a very hard floor, weakness of the roof of the seam, steepness of inclination of the seam, occurrence of faults or hitches in the seam, and so on. When it is considered that the cutting member of the disc machine — the disc — presents a large surface in the slot being cut and in the plane of advance of the machine; that the cutting member of the chain machine — the chain jib — presents a less surface, and that the bar machine presents only the bar, in effect a line, and that is entirely armed with cutters — the nature of some of the limitations of the respective machines may be understood. A factor that limits the application of all machines, but in different degrees, is the hardness of the material to be cut, or rather the effect of the material on the cutter picks.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||