Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

27th March 1926, Page: 273, Column: 1

The Coal Report

Need for Conscientious Examination.

A document extending to some 300 pages, the Report of the Royal Commission on the Coal Industry bears ample evidence that the Commissioners conscientiously devoted themselves to a close scrutiny of the difficult problems presented in the course of the evidence. The Report has not been lightly written, nor should it be lightly considered. Any tendency to come to hasty conclusions would be fatal and is to be deprecated. It is not easy to get a true perspective by the mere reading of the suggestions offered and the proposals made. The whole of the text should be read and examined with all the care that the mind can bring to bear upon it. In the presentation of a summary or review a sense of difficulty and of diffidence is paramount. It is not even presumed that an accurate or satisfactory summary can be given, for the Report bristles with suggestions and ideas that would not readily occur to the ordinary mind, and the only commendable study is a study of the Report in full, with the determination so far as possible to arrive at conclusions tending to the amelioration of the prevailing unfortunate condition of the industry. The Report offers some hope that the industry will "again become a source of great economic strength to the nation," and perhaps this can most readily be assured by the fostering of the spirit of co-operation and goodwill. This is no time for recriminations nor for the harbouring of prejudices or that carping spirit which, owing to the inclusion of one unpalatable idea, can see no good in the presentation of the scheme as a whole. There is no unalloyed pleasure in life, and there can be none in industry. Duty therefore demands that the most shall be made of the best of things, and all should unite to the end that the greatest good shall be accomplished by all and for all. With a due sense of all that is involved, every reader of The Science and Art of Mining is urged to secure a copy of the Report. Already announcements have been made regarding the issue of a new edition at the price of 3d., by post 7½d. Upon these terms the Report should most certainly be available to all classes — officials and workmen. Meanwhile the examination of the document that follows is presented in the humble hope that all interested in the solution of the problem — and who is not ? — may be induced to obtain and then study most carefully, the Report for themselves and thus acquire a better understanding of the problem.

Importance of the Industry.

One-twelfth of the population of Great Britain is directly dependent on the coal mining industry, which indeed may be said to be the foundation of our whole industrial life. The annual value of its product approximates £250 millions, whilst it provides one-tenth of our exports in value and about four-fifths of them in volume. In 1800 the coal output was about ten million tons, and in the years following the expansion was rapid and almost uninterrupted, the climax of the industry's prosperity being reached in 1013, when the amount raised was 287 million tons and the exports totalled about 98 million tons.

Then came the disorganising influences of the war, and for some five years the industry was under Government control; by 1920 output had fallen to 230 million tons and exports had been cut down to 43¾ millions. Four years later the output was 267 1/8 million tons and exports 81¾ millions. Last year the figures were 244.42 and 68.97 millions respectively. Examination of the figures leads the Commission to the conclusion "that it is the export trade rather than the home trade that is the seat of our present troubles." It is shown that on the average the coal available for home consumption between 1909-13 was 175 million tons, for 1924 about 180 2/5 millions, and last year 170 4/5 millions.

Foreign Markets and Home Demand.

Our loss of markets in the countries that were our principal customers before the war was equivalent to 15 1/5 million tons, the most striking reductions being in the exports to Germany and Russia. The causes are examined, and it is shown that in the closing months of 1925 there was a noticeable recovery of trade. The depression in the export trade is part of a general depression affecting almost all European coal-producing countries, the excess of supply over demand being due to the impoverishment of customers, the development of new coalfields, and the use of substitutes. To a lesser extent we have felt the effect of foreign competition, especially that of Germany.

As regards the home demand, the consumption per head of population in 1909-13 was 88 cwt. ; in 1924 it was 83 cwt., and last year 78 cwt. When 1924 is compared with 1913 it is seen that for various home and domestic purposes the variations in the demand were not specially noteworthy under the greater number of heads, the most significant feature being the reduction in the amount of coal used for the manufacture of pig iron. In the iron and steel trade, as in shipbuilding and engineering, a great expansion to meet the demands of the war has been followed by a profound depression, and the Report indicates that it is only to the revival of the heavy industries that the coal mining industry can look for any substantial increase in the home demand for coal.

Duration of Supplies.

In an interesting chapter on the national coal resources reference is made to the Royal Commission appointed in 1866, whose report in 1871 estimated the reserves of the coal resources of the British Isles, in seams of 1 ft. in thickness and upwards, down to a depth of 4,000 ft., at 146,480 million tons, calculated, on the basis of the then annual production of 115 million tons, to last 1,273 years.

The Royal Commission which reported in 1905 gave the available resources of proved coalfields as 100,914 million tons and of the unproved coalfields 39,484, representing a grand total of 140,398 million tons.

Dr. (now Sir Aubrey) Strahan, as Director of the Geological Survey, issued a report on the coal resources for the International Geological Congress of 1913. His figures are summarised as follows : — Actual reserves, 133,117; probable and possible reserves, 45,610. Total, 178,727 million tons.

Then Professor H. S. Jevons, in his work published in 1915 on "The British Coal Trade," arrived at the following results :— Actual reserves, 136,000 ; probable and possible reserves, 61,000. Total, 197,000 million tons.

Assuming that the present rate of output remains fairly constant, the present Commission concludes that the coal, that is the probable and possible reserves, should last about seven centuries, with a further extension if fresh means were found of utilising the small coal which is now so extensively wasted. The possibility that science may discover new sources of energy, replacing in greater or less degree the use of coal, is not overlooked.

Wasteful Method of Burning Coal.

Passing in review the problem of the utilisation of coal, the Commission notes that about four times as much coal is still burnt in this country in the raw state (either under boilers, in industrial furnaces, or in domestic grates and ranges) as is carbonised before being consumed. Assuming it would not be economical to carbonise all the coal before burning it, "there is no doubt that a large proportion of the 147 million tons of the coal at present burnt in a raw state is consumed in a very wasteful manner."

This involves, as indicated by a reference to the last report of the Abatement of Smoke Committee, the pollution of the atmosphere to the danger of health and damage to property, whilst the loss of potential fuel in the form of soot represents an annual and direct waste of £6 millions. The figure ascertained or estimated in Manchester that the increased cost of household washing alone on account of smoke is over £290,000 a year, admits of a rough calculation of the losses to the nation. To begin with, the three million tons of soot, as pointed out by the Commission, are equal in weight to nearly three days' output of all the collieries of Great Britain. In effect, the work of over a million men for three days every year is devoted to providing the soot which pollutes our atmosphere.

Low Temperature Carbonisation.

The imports of crude petroleum oil or its derivatives are colossal, exceeding 1,270 million gallons in 1924. A million tons of coal carbonised by suitable methods will produce some 15 million gallons of liquid fuels, and though the grades of oils may not correspond, by the treatment of the bulk of the coal now consumed in the raw state, the greater part at least of our present requirements of oil could be supplied from home sources instead of being imported from abroad.

Of the processes which are being investigated in this country, low temperature carbonisation has attracted most attention. Steady advance is being made, and there is a suggestion that the difficulties that have presented themselves are not insuperable technically, and evidence taken by the Commission gives them the impression "that we may be within measurable distance of a solution of both the technical and the commercial problems that arise." In the event of the successful pre-treatment of coal on technically sound and commercially profitable lines, advantages accruing would include a smokeless atmosphere, a great saving in maintaining cleanliness, improved health, a considerable supply of oil, a gain to mineowners and miners by the more profitable use of small and other low grade coal, whilst

If the total value of the constituents obtained, after deducting the cost of the process, showed a balance above the value of the raw coal, the wealth of the country would be increased to that extent."

Linking Up Industries.

The study of the utilisation of coal as presented by the Coal Commission is of more than passing interest. They recognise that it may be more economical in some cases to burn low grade coal to produce power at or near the pit, than to pay for the transport of such coal, or of a higher grade coal, to be used more scientifically elsewhere. The object to be aimed at is the most economical and efficient way of utilising the energy embodied in the coal, and they add that" The question is not the co-ordination, as is often supposed, of two industries — coal and electricity ; but of several — coal, electricity, gas, oil, chemical products, blast furnaces, coke ovens, etc. Two or more methods, dealing with two, three, or more of these, may be used simultaneously in combination, one feeding the other." Then again "It should be clearly recognised and constantly emphasised that the interests of the industries of mining, gas works, electricity stations, coke and by-product undertakings, and blast-furnaces are closely interlocked, and it is to the obvious interest of those who are engaged in them, whether employers or employed, that they should encourage whatever combinations are desirable in each particular case to promote their mutual prosperity."

Research connected with coal may be divided broadly into (a) occurrence and constitution; (b) coal winning; (c) coal utilisation. The research work at present being undertaken is reviewed and the opinion is expressed that a Director of Research having high qualifications in physical and if possible, in engineering, science, should be appointed at an early date, and a research headquarters established, with heads of departments and adequate staffs to carry out the work appointed as the organisation develops. Responsibility for co-ordinating the work and preserving a proper balance between its various parts should be placed on the Department of Scientific and Industrial Research.

Structure of the Industry.

In the chapter on the structure of the industry, it is noted that its principal characteristic is its diversity, and "the only generalisation about it that is safe is that no generalisation is possible." The industry cannot be regarded as a collection of more or less uniform undertakings, employing so many men under conditions fairly similar, producing a single article, the costs of production and the price obtained varying little among them at any time. The productivity of each individual mine is due, not only to its physical characteristics, but to a combination of many factors, and the conclusion is that for only a few purposes is it possible to treat the industry as a whole. Averages may be useful, but they have to be used with much care.

Each of the units is productive only for a definite period. A mine is sunk, it is developed, it is worked out, and it is closed. This obsolescence and closing of mines is a normal feature of the industry, and indeed essential to its nature. A table given shows that the average age of the larger mines, employing 500 workpeople or more, is 51 years. One-third of the mines are under 30 years old. There are still in this country 57 mines, each employing an average of 855 workpeople, which are known to be more than a hundred years old.

Some of the mines are on a very small scale, and the Report says it is urged that the present economic difficulties are largely the result of small-scale production, and can only be effectively relieved if a considerable proportion of the existing mines are amalgamated to form large-scale enterprises. The Commissioners examine the question, and they seem to be agreed that the size of the undertakings usual in the industry is not economically the best, and that there are great advantages in large-scale production which are not now being realised. It would not appear that wholesale fusions or absorptions are to be effected, but there are a large number of cases in which such amalgamations are desirable, presuming they are effected with great care, and with intimate knowledge of the physical and financial considerations involved in each case.

Nationalisation and Royalties.

With regard to the proposal for nationalisation the Commissioners say they have seen no scheme that will withstand criticism, but they recognise "that there is substance in the demand which nationalisation is intended to meet — the demand for large changes in the organisation, and improvements in the efficiency of the industry, for an expansion of the miners' influence over the conditions that govern his working life. This legitimate demand we believe can be met without embarking upon an operation so vast and so hazardous."

After discussing the origin and character of royalties the report says that a system which vests the ownership of minerals under the surface in the owner of the surface means that the planning of the mines is influenced continually by surface boundaries and surface rights. "Many of the present defects of the industry are largely due to the fact that the mines have had to adapt themselves to surface ownership. It is found that, on the average, each mine has had to obtain leases from no fewer than five mineral owners. Nevertheless, the areas of coal worked from any particular pit have not necessarily been those areas which could most economically be worked from that pit, but those for which the mineowner has succeeded in obtaining leases." The discontent aroused by the system of privately-owned royalties has been duly considered, and it is also recognised that "the advantages of State ownership will be greatest in relation to the coal that is to be worked in the future. The lay-out of the present mines is in the main, decided. It cannot be radically changed. The State may sometimes be able to exercise a useful influence as mineral owners do now on occasion during the currency of the leases ; and still more when leases fall in for renewal; but otherwise its power of action will be limited."

Selling Agencies.

A chapter is devoted to the question of distribution. The distributive agencies connected with coal fall into four sections: the retail coal merchants, the factors and wholesale coal merchants, the exporters, and the selling agencies connected with particular collieries, or groups of collieries. Collieries normally sell their coal direct, to a consumer, a factor, a merchant, or a shipper, employing salaried salesmen, or, as they are called in certain districts, "fitters." In some cases, however, a formally separate but associated agency is established, to dispose of the output whether of a single colliery or of a group of collieries. The view is expressed that the co-operative organisation of selling, buying, power, transport, and technical skill, as seen in the Doncaster Collieries' Association, is a material improvement in efficiency and economy. Proceeding, the Commissioners say: "It is an example which we should like to see widely followed; nothing should be done to discourage the spread of similar co-operation elsewhere. On the other hand, an associated selling agency may appear to the miners to be a means of taking out of the wage ascertainment part of the proper proceeds; if a colliery replaces its own salaried salesman by an independent but associated selling agency which charges and makes a large profit on a commission of 6d. a ton, the district ascertainment will be the poorer by that profit."

The information collected as to costs of distribution is sufficient to show that "there do exist between producer and consumer substantial margins of profit or expenses, which might be narrowed to the advantage of one or other or both of them. It ought to be possible, either to reduce the price of coal to the consumer, or to raise it to the colliery."

The proposal was made by Mr. Shinwell, the former Secretary for Mines, that power should be given to municipalities to engage in the trade, in competition with the private merchants, and the Commissioners say the proposal might have useful results and they recommend that legislation should be passed to give effect to it.

They are strongly of opinion that the collieries would be well advised to establish Co-operative Selling Associations. The creation in the future of the larger undertakings which they envisage would make this easier. Selling Associations would play a useful part in organising the pools of railway wagons, and in the exporting districts they are especially needed. "Their function would be to maintain prices at a remunerative level in those foreign markets where the competition is not so much between British and foreign exporters, as among the British exporters themselves. If the industry succeeded in creating organisations for this purpose, it is possible that It could secure the co-operation of the existing German Kartell in an arrangement to prevent the prices of coal in neutral markets from again falling to unremunerative levels."

Factors in Production.

Following an examination of the factors governing the conveyance of coal, in which the advantages of the general use of 20-ton wagons are commented upon, some general observations on labour disputes are given setting forth the grievances of the miners as also the grievances of the employers, and the Commissioners do not appear to be convinced that the antagonisms and recriminations should all be accepted at their face value, and add, "We have reason to think that such mutual hostility as there is between the central bodies is not a true reflection of the spirit that prevails in the country at large."

The question of output is always an interesting one, and the interpretation of output statistics is not easy. As the Commissioners say: "The miner is only one factor in the production of coal; his output in any given time depends, not on himself alone, but on two other factors of at least equal importance and often of greater importance — the physical conditions of the mine and the efficiency of management." Then as regards the making of national comparisons, "the fact that the average yearly output for each person employed in mining is in Britain less than one-third of what it is in America and 50 per cent, more than it is in France or Belgium is no ground at all for thinking either that the British miner is personally less efficient than the American, or that he is personally more efficient than the Belgian or French one. Physical conditions and the organisation of mining in the various countries are not comparable."

There are differences of output at home. Per person employed in 1924 Scotland supplied 255 tons per annum, South Yorkshire 252 tons, Durham 210 tons, and Lancashire and Cheshire 186 tons. The smallest mines averaged 177 as against an average for nine large mines in South Yorkshire of 280 tons. Obviously, as indicated in the Report, such differences have little or nothing to do with the personal efficiency of the miners. They reflect differences in the age of the coalfields, in the capital equipment of the mines, and in other matters beyond the control of the individual workman. The danger of using yearly figures is illustrated in the table which shows for the period 1922-25 (a) the output in tons per head, and (b) the output in cwt. per man-shift worked:

More Off-hand Workers.

There has been a general tendency during the past twenty years to increase the proportion of "off-hand" workers to "face" workers, and the Report says: "For every 100 persons actually engaged at the coal face in 1905 there were 72 other persons working underground (that is to say, on the lines of communication between the face and the shaft), while there were 42 persons on the surface, making a total of 114 others for 100 at the face. In 1924, for every 100 workers at the face there were 95 others underground (in place of 72), and there were 50 on the surface (in place of 42), making a total of 145 others (in place of 114) to deal with the output of 100 persons at the face. In other words, the output of every 100 persons at the face has now to provide a living for 31 additional persons employed away from the face, either below ground or above ground."

Working Hours and Output.

The output per person at the face has declined. That seems to be accepted, and "it may probably be fairly put in the neighbourhood of 15 per cent., corresponding to an output per manshift at the face of about 53 cwt. in 1905 and about 45 cwt. in 1924." There have been two statutory restrictions of hours representing, other conditions being equal, a decrease of about 18 per cent, of working time at the face. The broad result of the investigation seems to be "that there has been no marked change in the personal efficiency or industry of the workers at the coal face, and that whatever change there has been has probably been a change in the direction of increasing their output per hour. This is a natural consequence of the decreased number of hours in the day."

Making the Best of Things.

No basis seems to be left for any general charge of "ca' canny" against the men directly concerned with output. At some collieries inspected, but which "cannot be taken as typical of all the collieries in the country," there appear from the Report to be cases "in which output is being hindered to some extent by such defects as shortage of tubs, bad roads, and insufficient mechanical haulage. There are also cases of antiquated equipment, though it is not clear that in all of these it would be worth while to install new equipment." The remedying of excessive underground travelling on foot, "by riding men in or by sinking additional shafts, should be undertaken wherever reasonably possible." The Commissioners conclude that "generally, there is nothing in the results of our inquiry to suggest that colliery managers as a whole are doing otherwise than making the best of their position." As to the increase in capital equipment including coal-cutters and conveyors, they "heard nowhere of opposition by the miners to the introduction of machinery." The older men may have a natural dislike to new-fangled notions, "but," it ls said, "generally speaking, if the manager seriously wishes to try machinery, he is able to do so."

Interest in Output.

Increasing physical difficulties are considered, and several causes have contributed to the increase of "off-hand" workers. There are additional safety regulations under the Act; the reductions of working hours in 1909 and again in 1919; additional work undertaken at many collieries in screening and washing coal; a fourth possibility is that the number of off-hand men below ground is in some cases at least excessive ("a legacy of war-time control when the numbers of men were remarkably increased"); the lines of communication between the face and the shaft may have become longer or more difficult to maintain. As to the last hypothesis, the investigations of the Commissioners have not allowed them to test it directly. Whatever the causes, the consequences are serious, and the suggestion of the Report seems to be "to give the off-hand men generally an interest in output, — either in the form of bonus on the output of the colliery or each part of it, or in some other form." The Report further indicates that the argument is strengthened that may be addressed to the men "for the withdrawal of objections, wherever they still exist, to the working of multiple shifts ; for the withdrawal in those few and limited cases, where they exist, of any practices or understandings leading to unnecessary restriction of output; for the reduction of voluntary absenteeism; and for the welcoming of any changes in methods of remuneration that may give to all workers an interest in the results of the colliery." Then again, "the argument is as strong or even stronger to those who manage the mines, that they should let no vested interests or old habits stand in the way of whatever reorganisation may hold the promise of greater efficiency."

The possibility of increasing output and the need for increasing output are discussed, and the Report says that what has been done in Germany should not be impossible here.

The Wages Problem.

Much attention is devoted to the wages question, and the conclusion is that the wages agreements of 1921 and 1924 embody two principles of essential value, both of which should be preserved. Other conclusions are arrived at regarding the satisfactory working of the agreements, t-he maintenance of a minimum wage, etc., and the introduction of a system of children's allowances irrespective of the level of wages, to raise materially the general level of comfort.

This chapter on wages should be read in full by all miners, as also that on hours. The conclusion arrived at regarding the latter is that, "while we do not recommend the State, of its own motion, to make any change of working hours or to endeavour to force upon the miners a longer working day than at present, this does not mean that if both employers and workmen were agreed in proposing a change, the State should refuse to accede to their joint request."

Mine Labour Recruiting.

The causes of lost time are considered, and though "there has been during recent years a progressive reduction in the rate of avoidable absenteeism," the Commissioners "consider that a serious effort should be made to reduce it further," and that "such an effort would be stimulated by the profit-sharing arrangements" recommended.

In the chapter on Recruiting and Personnel the consideration is recommended of practical steps for securing the transfer of unemployed miners from one district to another and for giving such miners the first chance of obtaining such colliery employment either in their own district or elsewhere, in preference to recruiting outside labour. At the same time it is recognised that the diversity of mining conditions makes a miner of one district less likely to be at home in another, and his transfer therefore more difficult than with almost any other class of workman.

In reference to the supervising and managing staff the Commissioners are deeply impressed "by the necessity of securing in this vital industry its full proportion of all the exceptional ability in the nation, and of men of broad views and imagination; we are not certain that this is likely to happen under the existing regulations. We recommend accordingly that the Mines Department should, at an early date, take the regulations into further consideration from this point of view. Upon the nature of the entrance into any occupation will depend the kind of men who eater; upon the kind of men who have to manage coal mines, more than upon any system that can be laid down for their management, will depend the prosperity of the industry, and the well-being and contentment of the miners."

Health and Safety.

The progress made in the last fifty years in matters concerning safety and health is reviewed, the most striking improvement being in the death-rate due to explosions and winding accidents, the rate from falls of ground, haulage accidents and miscellaneous accidents showing some decline, but a comparatively small one. The Report says that the high accident rate "makes the charge for Workmen's Compensation a heavy burden upon the industry, amounting to over £3,000,000 a year, or 3d. per ton of coal produced. It is obviously to the interest, as well as being the duty of the industry, to take all practicable measures to reduce the very heavy accident rate."

The housing problem and welfare are other subjects considered, and bearing on the provision of pithead baths the Commissioners are "convinced that the effect upon the health and comfort of the miners, upon the well-being of their wives and families, and therefore upon the general contentedness of the population, would be so considerable as to make this a subject which should engage immediate and effective attention."

From Miner to Manager.

In the chapter on the Association of the Workers the appointment of pit committees receives consideration and the conclusion seems to be that "when the pit committees have come into being, the last excuse for the so-called 'lightning strikes' would disappear." The opportunities for the worker to obtain promotion are also commented upon, the evidence given showing that "over 50 per cent, of the present colliery managers started as working miners, and that practically all the deputies, firemen and examiners bad been working miners. This is no doubt partly due to the conditions which have to be fulfilled before a man can obtain a certificate of competency, but it shows that the industry offers considerable opportunity to the workman who is willing to qualify for positions of responsibility."

Meeting the Situation.

The chapter on Profits is followed by a review on the present situation and the following pointers appear in the suggestions for meeting it :—

"Before any sacrifices are asked from those engaged in the industry, it shall be definitely agreed between them that all practicable means for improving its organisation and increasing its efficiency should be adopted, as speedily as the circumstances in each case allow . . .

"The owners should discontinue charging the miners as a body with deliberate attempts to destroy the prosperity of the industry, in order to compel its nationalisation. It is possible that there may he a small number of individuals here and there who are animated by this idea, but we are convinced that the point is without substance.

"The owners should also cease to countenance accusations against the miners of restriction of output. Here again there may be sporadic cases, and when the rates of pay for new classes of work are under discussion, production may sometimes be purposely kept at a low level. But viewing the effect upon the industry as a whole, this point is quite unimportant.

"The miners on their part should cease to attach exaggerated weight to losses of output due to failures of the management to provide the colliers with proper supplies of tubs, rails, timber or other requisites. Such cases undoubtedly occur from time to time, and a proportion of them are due to inefficient management. In particular places and on particular occasions an appreciable loss may be caused, both to the colliery and to the workman. But the effect upon output in general, and upon wages, is very small.

"The mine-owners should not refuse to engage in discussions on a national footing with the Miners' Federation of Great Britain. All the principal industries of the country conduct negotiations between employers and employed on a national basis, and we can see no reason why the mining industry should be an exception. At the same time, the conditions imperatively require that there should be a large degree of flexibility in the wage rates of the different districts. The Miners' Federation should recognise this, without detriment to the broad policy that the general principles should be laid down nationally.

"As the first step accordingly, to the making of a new wage agreement, the Mining Association and the Miners' Federation should meet nationally. The procedure to be followed thereafter will depend upon the decisions then taken; it appears to us a reasonable course for the national conference to refer the question of minimum percentage and such other matters as they think appropriate to district associations to frame proposals. Those proposals would be submitted to the national conference for approval."

Summary of Findings and Recommendations.

The final chapter in the Report constitutes a summary of findings and recommendations, from which we quote as follows :—

The coal mining industry, for more than a century the foundation of the economic strength of the country, has come upon difficult times. This change of fortunes is the result of powerful economic forces. It is idle to attribute It either on the one hand to political unrest or restriction of output among the miners, or on the other hand to inefficiency in the day by day management of the mines.

At the same time we cannot agree with the view presented to us by the mine-owners that little can be done to improve the organisation of the industry, and that the only practicable course is to lengthen hours and to lower wages. In our view large changes are necessary in other directions, and large progress is possible. We agree that immediate measures are indispensable to deal with the immediate position, but the effort ought not to stop there.

The problem indeed is two-fold. It has a permanent aspect and a temporary aspect. We have proposals to make with regard to each. We will take first the permanent aspect.

The Need for Changes.

The industry is marked by great diversities. Among the existing collieries many date from an earlier time, and according to modern standards are badly planned. The defects are the result partly of the age of our coalfields, partly of the private and divided ownership of the minerals, with its effects on the lay-out of the mines, partly of other causes. Very many of the collieries are on too small a scale to be good units of production. A number are defective in equipment and some in management. On the other hand there are a large number of collieries which are admirably planned, equipped and managed.

The methods of utilising coal are unscientific. Four-fifths of the coal consumed in the country is burnt in a raw state; oil and valuable by-products are wasted and the atmosphere is polluted.

Research into the methods both of winning and of using coal is inadequate.

Mining, in many places, should be intimately associated with several other industries — with gas, electricity, smokeless fuel, oil, chemical products, blast furnaces and coke ovens. A beginning has been made towards this combination, but it is no more than a beginning.

The selling organisation and the methods of transport, are too costly, and do not secure the best financial results for the collieries, and therefore for the miners employed in them.

While the relations of employers and employed are generally better than sometimes appears on the surface, the organisation of the industry on its labour side calls for many improvements.

As a remedy for these defects the Miners' Federation propose the nationalisation of the mines. We do not recommend the adoption of this policy

We are not satisfied that the scheme proposed to us is workable, or that it offers a clear social gain. We perceive in it grave economic dangers, and we find no advantages that cannot be obtained as readily, or more readily in other ways.

We contemplate accordingly the continuance of the industry under private enterprise, but we make a number of proposals for its re-organisation,

Recommendations on Re-organisation.

1. Ownership of the Mineral. — The error which was made in times past, in allowing the ownership of the coal to fall into private hands, should be retrieved. The mineral should he acquired by the State-by purchase where it has a market value, by a declaration of State ownership in the case of unproved coal or coal at deep levels, which has now no market value. The coal of existing mines which are likely soon to cease working, and coal which is not now worked and is not likely to be developed in the future, should be excluded from the purchase. Safeguards should be adopted against excessive compensation claims. A Coal Commission should be appointed, under the authority of the Secretary for Mines, to acquire and administer the mineral property.

2. Amalgamations of Existing Mines. — The amalgamation of many of the present small units of production is both desirable and practicable. This may often be effected from within, but in many cases it will only take place if outside assistance is given. Any general measure of compulsory amalgamation, on arbitrary lines, would be mischievous; the action to be taken should be elastic and should enable each case to be treated individually. The State as mineral owner will be able to promote desirable amalgamations when granting new leases or renewing old ones. Legislation should provide for a compulsory transfer of interests under existing leases where desirable amalgamations are prevented by the dissent of some of the parties or their unreasonable claims. Existing leases would not otherwise be affected.

3. Combination of Industries. — A closer connection of mining with the allied industries should be promoted. Highly technical questions are involved, affecting a number of industries, and not electricity alone. The development of electrical supply under the new proposals of the Government should be closely co-ordinated with the generation of electricity at the mines. The heat, power and light requirements of the country should be under the constant and comprehensive survey of a body formed for the purpose. We propose for consideration the establishment of a National Fuel and Power Committee, with advisory powers, composed of representatives nominated by the Government from among the officials and other bodies concerned.

4. Research. — The existing provision for research should be largely extended by the industry with the support of the State. It is urgently necessary that new methods f or winning and utilising coal should be sought for, and should he found, if the prosperity of the industry is to be restored and a proper standard of wages and working conditions assured to the workers. If processes of low temperature carbonisation were perfected, great national advantages would ensue, particularly through the production of a smokeless fuel for domestic and industrial use, and the provision of large supplies of mineral oil from the country's own resources. The State should give financial support to use further experiments, on a commercial scale, which are necessary.

5. Distribution. — The industry as a whole has so far failed to realise the benefits to be obtained by a readiness to co-operate. Large financial advantages might ho gained by the formation, in particular, of co-operative selling agencies. They are specially needed in the export trade.

The Government should consider the establishment of an official system for the sampling and analysis of coal, with a view to encouraging selling on specification and guarantee, in both the home and foreign markets.

Local authorities should be empowered to engage in the retail sale of coal.

We propose measures to secure the adoption of larger mineral wagons on the railways, and a greater concentration of ownership of wagons. A Standing Joint Committee of the Ministry of Transport and the Mines Department should be formed to promote these measures.

6. Labour. — The relations between employers and employed are of fundamental importance, and- here also we are convinced that a number of changes are necessary.

(1) The principle on which the recent wage-agreements have been based is in our opinion sound, but amendments are needed in the method of ascertaining the proceeds of the industry for the fixing of wages. A large proportion of the coal is sold by the mines to associated industries, and the most important of these amendments relates to the prices at which these transfers are made.

(2) The standard length of the working day, which is now on the average 7½ hours underground, should remain unaltered. The optional re-distribution of hours within the present weekly total, over a week of five days instead of six, should be considered. The multiple shift systems should be extended.

(3) Joint pit committees should be established generally.

(4) The methods of payment of men not employed at the face should be revised where possible so as to give them a direct interest in output.

(5) The introduction of a family allowance system, either nationally or by districts, is desirable. Pooling schemes should be adopted to prevent married men with families being prejudiced in obtaining employment.

(6) Profit-sharing schemes, providing for the distribution to the workmen of shares in the undertakings, should be generally adopted in the industry, and should be made obligatory by statute.

(7) For all new collieries, a proper provision of houses for the workers should be a condition of the lease.

(8) The general establishment of pit-head baths is necessary. This should be undertaken by the existing Miners' Welfare Fund, which should be increased by a substantial contribution from royalties.

(9) When prosperity returns to the industry we consider that annual holidays with pay should be established,

The Immediate Problem.

To bring any of these measures of re-organisation into effect must need a period of months; to bring all of them into full operation must need years. The Miners' Federation folly recognise that, even if nationalisation were to he accepted, much time must elapse before the great changes it involves could be put into force and the effects be seen. Meantime the hard economic conditions of the moment remain to be faced.

The dominant fact is that, in the last quarter of 1925, if the subsidy be excluded, 73 per cent, of the coal was produced at a loss.

We express no opinion whether the grant of a subsidy last July was unavoidable or not, hut we think its continuance indefensible. The subsidy should stop at the end of its authorised term, and should never be repeated.

We cannot approve the proposal of the Mining Association, that the gap between costs and proceeds should be bridged by an increase of an hour in the working day, reductions in the miners wages, some economies in other costs, and a large diminution in railway rates to be effected by lowering the wages of railwaymen. In any case these proposals go beyond the need, for we do not concur in the low estimate of future coal prices on which they are based.

While the mine-owners presented a plan which is unacceptable, the Miners' Federation abstained from making any suggestion as to the means for meeting the immediate situation. The duty therefore devolves upon the Commission to formulate its own proposals.

If the present hours are to be retained, we think a revision of the "minimum percentage addition to standard rates of wages," fixed in 1924 at a time of temporary prosperity, is indispensable. A disaster is impending over the industry, and the immediate reduction of working costs that can be effected in this way, and in this way alone, is essential to save it. The minimum percentage is not a "minimum wage" in the usual sense of that term. The wages of the lowest paid men will be safeguarded by a continuance of the system of subsistence allowances. The reductions that we contemplate will still leave the mine-owners without adequate profits in any of the wage-agreement districts, and without any profits in most districts. If trade improves and prices rise, a profit will be earned. If prices do not rise, an adequate profit must he sought in the improved methods which should in any case he adopted.

Should the miners freely prefer some extension of hours with a less reduction of wages, Parliament would no doubt be prepared to authorise it. We trust, however, that this will not occur.

We consider that it is essential that there should be, as there always has been hitherto, considerable variation in the rates of wages in the several districts. But we are strongly of opinion that national wage agreements should continue. Such agreements are entered into in all the other British industries of importance.

We recommend that the representatives of the employers and employed should meet together, first nationally and then in the districts, in order to arrive at a settlement . . .

By a revision of the minimum percentage coal mining would be saved from an immediate collapse, but it seems inevitable that a number of collieries would still have to be closed. This may give rise to the necessity for a transfer of labour on a considerable scale. We recommend that the Government should be prepared in advance with such plans to assist it as are practicable, and should provide funds for the purpose . . .

The future depends primarily upon the leadership, and the general level of opinion, among the mine-owners and the miners of Great Britain. In laying down our charge, we would express our own firm conviction, that if the present difficulties be wisely handled, if the grievances of the one side and of the other be remedied, and a better spirit prevail in consequence between them, the mining industry, with the aid of science, will certainly recover, and even surpass, its former prosperity. It will again become a source of great economic strength to the nation.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Jevons, H. S., Prof.      
Shinwell, Emanuel (Manny)      Whos Who Page
Strahan, Aubrey, Sir    Director of the Geological Survey  



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
12 Sep 1925  The Coal Commissioners (The Science and Art of Mining)
26 Sep 1925  Coal Industry Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
10 Oct 1925  News and Notes (The Science and Art of Mining)
24 Oct 1925  Coal Inquiry (The Science and Art of Mining)
07 Nov 1925  Coal Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
21 Nov 1925  Coal Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
06 Dec 1925  Coal Commission (The Science and Art of Mining)
30 Jan 1926  News and Notes (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Mar 1926  News (The Science and Art of Mining)
27 Mar 1926  The Coal Report (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print