Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

13th February 1926, Page: 234, Column: 1

The Colliery Fireman

By Professor W. H. McMillan, B.Sc., M.I.Min.E.

Concluded from page 219. Summary of lecture delivered at the Wigan Mining and Technical College.

Reduction of Accidents.

So far, I have dealt with the technical and practical qualifications of the mine fireman in relation to his duties, but there is still a third qualification necessary — namely, the personal — without which he cannot succeed. Indeed, it frequently happens that many firemen fail because they lack a proper appreciation of this, the human side of their work. They must be able to exercise a judicious authority over those for whose safety they are responsible, and success will depend very largely on the manner and tact with which this is accomplished.

To explain this more fully, perhaps you will allow me to digress for a few moments on the question of accidents.

Accidents, as you know, arise from a large variety of causes. Some are due to doing things which are clearly contraventions of the Coal Mines Act, some to a desire on the part of the men to save time and labour, and some to that fatal habit of procrastination. On the other hand, of course, a large number of accidents are due to causes over which neither the men, deputies nor management have any control whatever, for even while exercising the most careful supervision and strictly adhering to the rules, dangerous conditions often present themselves without the slightest warning.

If we take the year 1924, the Annual Report of the Chief Inspector of Mines shows that 1,201 persons were killed and 195,423 received injuries which disabled them for more than 3 days. In that year there were 1,230,200 persons employed, and of the 1,201 persons killed, 1,087 were below ground and 114 on the surface, and it can be estimated from the report that :—

607, or 50.6 per cent., were due to falls of ground.

232, or 19.3 per cent., to haulage.

124, or 10.3 per cent., to miscellaneous underground causes.

35, or 2.9 per cent., to explosions of firedamp or coal dust.

89, or 7.4 per cent,, to shaft accidents.

114, or 9.5 per cent., to accidents on the surface.

In other words just under 1 per 1,000 was killed and roughly 1 in every 6 employees received injuries which incapacitated them for over 3 days.

On a closer perusal of this table it will be observed that nearly 85 per cent. of the fatal accidents which occur come directly within the deputies' sphere of activity, and although it is a somewhat difficult matter to divide this under the headings of preventable and unpreventable, attempts have been made from time to time by Inspectors to estimate the number which could have been avoided. From observations which have been made by Inspectors of Mines in this country it would seem that approximately 30% of the deaths which Occur are due to neglect, breach of rules, or causes which could have been prevented by the exercise of greater care, and the remaining 70 per cent. to unavoidable causes. Of the injuries 50 per cent. can be avoided.

In this connection I would like to quote a paragraph from the recent Report of a Divisional Inspector of Mines. He states that:

"Generally speaking, the deputies, as a body, carry out their duties in a satisfactory manner, but there are exceptions, and from facts which occasionally come to light in connection with the investigation of accidents it would appear that some of them are lacking in initiative and foresight."

In the face of such statistics it is not too much to say that the avoidance of many of these accidents is largely a question of education and discipline, and it is to these that the fireman should direct special attention. We know, of course, that the introduction of systematic timbering has done much to reduce accidents from falls, but these are still much too high, and the best results can only be obtained from the rules by letting the men see the reasons for them, by a strict yet dignified supervision to ensure that the rules are carried out, and by the cultivation of a spirit of co-operation between the men and the deputies.

It is in human nature to take risks. It is contrary to human nature to do things efficiently under compulsion, but it is possible to attain the desired result by the cultivation of a spirit of friendly co-operation combined with systematic supervision and instruction, provided, of course, the fireman is a man of superior knowledge, experience, force of will and character. The fireman's success in this direction therefore depends on his ability to maintain proper discipline, not by compulsion or harshness, but by gaining the respect of, and working amicably with the men under his charge, and generally by maintaining a well balanced dignity both in and out of the mine. In other words, the best results will not be attained by insisting on things being done because rules and regulations require it, but by showing that it will be advantageous to the men themselves, and those dependent on them, both from the standpoints of safety and financial gain, to act on the advice given.

This is an ideal which I know many of you will take with the proverbial grain of salt. You all have probably cases in your mind now of men who cannot be "coaxed," and who will only do things under threat of dismissal or prosecution, but I venture to suggest that they are a small minority. Most men are amenable to discipline, properly administered, and when cases of extreme obstinacy arise it may be well, occasionally, to turn the critical lens on ourselves before threatening. After all, threatening is an admission of failure on the part of any official.

The Human Factor in Mine Accidents.

At this point you will perhaps allow me to draw your attention briefly to an aspect of this accident problem which may possibly have escaped your notice. I mean the Human Factor. I do so because I feel that when the men fully realise how much they themselves can do to prevent accidents, when every miner has had the facts brought to his notice that over 1,000 lives are lost annually — 35 per cent. to 40 per cent. of which can be saved — that approximately 200,000 are injured annually — 50 per cent. of which can be prevented — that the amount of compensation paid in the industry is 3 times greater to-day (approximately 4 million pounds) than it was ten years ago, he may confidently be expected to give his heartiest support and co-operation to a work that so vitally concerns himself, and those who are dependent on him at home. To my mind the solution of this great problem hangs largely on your shoulders.

General educational methods, such as lectures, talks, discussions on accidents, posters, slogans, etc., will all help enormously if a properly organised campaign embodying them is vigorously prosecuted, but there undoubtedly is a danger that their effect will be only temporary, and that a certain stage of improvement in accident prevention will be reached by such methods, beyond which no further progress can be made. A time will almost certainly come when such methods will be looked upon as commonplace, something to be expected and seen in the daily routine, and when this stage is reached it will be useless to expect that the conquests they made when first introduced will continue. New schemes and methods will have to be devised and the success of such schemes will depend on getting down to the individual. After all, we are apt to harp just a little too much on the word "careless," without investigating the state of mind which gave rise to an accident and making some attempt to correct it. We are inclined to jump to the conclusion that men who get hurt through their own fault do so wilfully, or, in other words, that they knew better, but deliberately went wrong. If this assumption were correct, then the Workmen's Compensation Act, which requires employers to pay for injuries, is grossly unfair. The law seems to admit, and rightly, I think, that men who get hurt are not responsible for their acts. In inquests in practically all cases of suicide do we not find the verdict given as "insane at the time," and can we not also say that some such verdict as "unguarded mind," "misguided mind, or diverted mind," may be equally applicable to a large majority or the preventable accidents which occur? We can all call cases to memory where the victim was hurried, where he wasn't given or didn't take time to think or where, in his hurry, he forgot to take some necessary step to avoid the risk. Then, again, there are cases where the victim was too slow, where he didn't react quickly enough to get out of the way of danger, or where he showed lack of judgment through confusion, ignorance or neglect. Or, again, might we not often find by a more careful analysis of some accidents that temperament, bodily health, worry over domestic matters, or other things not connected with his work have been the cause of the accident.

Different men have different "mental sets," and this being so it is obvious that stereotyped methods of dealing with accidents will not always prove successful. Several men may meet with injury in the same stall through "failure to set a prop," but although this may be the apparent cause of the accident, the real reason for the occurrence lies in that mental lapse which caused the men to fail. In one case it may have been because temporarily the prop was going to interfere with his freedom of action, in the second a suitable prop may not have been ready at hand, while in the third case some thought of domestic worry momentarily came uppermost in his mind. You see therefore that methods of accident prevention which assume that all men are alike, while they may produce good results generally, are limited in their scope, and this is precisely where the good fireman can make his influence felt, because of his individual knowledge of and close personal contact with the men.

We have seen in recent years how psychology is helping to overcome many industrial problems — how alterations of the conditions under which certain kinds of labour are carried on, how improvement in the lighting of factories, and how rhythm have not only increased the amount of work done, and wage-earning capacity of the men, but have also reduced the energy expended in performing this increased amount, and even in many cases raised the whole tone of a factory. If, instead of looking upon accidents as delinquencies, instead of basing the whole of our safety propaganda on the supposed necessity of scaring men into looking after themselves, we considered accidents as mental errors, is it not also possible that we would reach our desired goal, — namely, safer pits — much more quickly? This, however, is a very large subject, and one which is worthy of special treatment to the mining industry. Approaching the subject through this channel is undoubtedly full of difficulties, but that is not a sufficient reason for neglect to investigate it. Meantime, all I wish to do is to mention it and leave the thought with you, because it can only be dealt with by those who are in constant touch with the menthe colliery firemen.

I fully realise that in this address I have only dealt with the necessity for raising the educational status of the colliery fireman, and many of you may have concluded that I am an idealist. I have omitted entirely all reference to his practical duties, as these will no doubt receive more detailed attention in the lectures which are to follow, but I trust I have at least given some food for thought. If perhaps I have spoken somewhat plainly I trust you will forgive me taking this privilege, but being quite unbiased, I have probably a better claim to such privilege than if I were engaged on the practical side of the industry.

Midlands' Educational Efforts.

And now finally let me tell you in a few brief words what the Deputies' Association in the Midland Coalfield has done recently on the educational side of its activities.

Some years ago the office bearers of the National Association of Colliery Deputies, which I believe is a similar organisation to yours, and a branch of the British Federation, approached me, and pointed out that they felt their members were not so closely in touch with the rapid progress of Research and Investigation which was being made into various mining problems as they ought to be. They asked for the assistance and co-operation of the Mining Department of the University College, Nottingham, and after consultation with the Mining Advisory Committee which consists of the Agents of all the local Colliery Companies it was decided that the want could best be met by arranging for a series of 4 or 5 lectures during each winter session.

In order to ascertain whether such a scheme would prove successful so far as interest and attendance were concerned only one lecture was definitely fixed up as an experiment. This lecture on the subject of Mine Illumination did prove successful beyond our expectation. The attendance overtaxed our largest lecture theatre — over 450 — and deputies attended from a very wide area including Notts, Derbyshire, Warwickshire and South Yorkshire. The Association printed 3,000 copies of the lecture for distribution among its members, and the interest and enthusiasm created was such that two courses of four lectures each have since been given by the Staff of the Mining Department of the College, and a similar course is running during the present session. That the interest has not flagged in any way is shown by the fact that the average attendance of mine lectures is just over 400.

The lectures which have been given and printed are :— Mine Illumination, The Duties of a Colliery Deputy, Mine Gases, Timbering in Coal Mines, The Prevention of Colliery Explosions, Mining Explosives, Shot-firing in Mines, Prevention of Haulage Accidents, The Spontaneous Combustion of Coal. The course arranged for the present session is as follows :— Coal and Its Uses, Health and Safety in Mine Ventilation, Methods of Working Coal, Gas Testing Devices. It is interesting to note that Officers of the Association, Mines Inspectors and Agents of Colliery Companies, have acted as chairmen at these lectures. Another feature worth noting is that, in the present series, the deputies are now reaching out for information bearing on subjects outside the scope of their own particular duties.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
McMillan, William Hutchinson, Prof.      Whos Who Page



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
30 Jan 1926  The Colliery Fireman (The Science and Art of Mining)
13 Feb 1926  The Colliery Fireman (The Science and Art of Mining)

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print