2nd January 1926, Page: 186, Column: 1
Explosives In Mining
Some Hints on Use
By William Cullen, LL.D., M.INST.M.M.
Abstract of paper on "Some Notes on Explosives" reed at the
December meeting of the Past and Present Mining Students' Association
at the Wigan Mining and Technical College.
The object of the lecture is to minimise, as far as it is humanly
possible to do so, the number of accidents which take place in the
coal mines of the country. It is generally acknowledged that
many of these are preventable, and if common sense and intelligence
are exercised, it is probable that the number of accidents caused
directly or indirectly by explosives could be reduced by something
like 30 per cent. to 40 per cent. It is gratifying to note that
in the past few years there has been a very considerable decrease
in certain classes of accidents, owing to the "Safety First"
propaganda,
and to lectures of the present kind.
A few years ago, the missfires, which are very troublesome at
any time, were one per six hundred shots. To-day they are in
the neighbourhood of one per twelve hundred shots, which is a
distinct improvement, though even this is far too high.
The Lecturer, at this stage, mentioned that he proposed to
confine himself, so far as possible, to Permitted Explosives, because
that was the class with which they were most interested. He
then described, in considerable detail, the Home Office test for
licensing explosives for use in Coal Mines, and in describing the
difference between Permitted and Non-Permitted Explosives,
he emphasised the fact that for the former class, not only was
the temperature of the gases produced on detonation considerably
lower than in the Non-Permitted Class, but that the flame was
both smaller and of shorter duration. These facts were brought
out very clearly on the slides, which were shown on the screen.
One of them in particular indicated the great danger of firing
any Permitted Explosive without careful tamping, and this was
brought out very strikingly in the case of Samsonite No. 3. Without
tamping, 8 ozs. of this explosive produced quite a considerable
flame, but when tamped by clay, no record of flame whatever
was shown on the photographic plate.
The basis of practically all modern explosives is two bodies,
one nitro-glycerine, and the other nitrate of ammonia. Both of
these bodies, on detonation, are resolved completely into gaseous
products, and the difference between them, and other similar
bodies, which also can be completely gasified, is that they are in
a state of unstable equilibrium. In other words, the individual
atoms, or molecules, have a desire to re-arrange themselves in
their more stable form, and any slight cause, such as friction, or,
in practice, a detonator, brings about this state of affairs.
Nitro-glycerine has a very much greater mechanical effect
than nitrate of ammonia, owing to the greater heat produced,
and this indicates very clearly why nitro-glycerine explosives
are, on the whole, more suitable for metalliferous mines, and
nitrate of ammonia explosives more suitable for Coal Mines. Of
course, in practice, many explosives both for metal and coal mines
are an admixture of these two bodies, and this particular class
is exceedingly popular in America.
The Lectures next described, in considerable detail, the production
of nitrate of ammonia from nitrogen and hydrogen, and
showed how on detonation, after the water vapour had condensed,
there was actually an excess of 33 per cent. of oxygen in
the resulting gases.
Nitrate of ammonia was rather a curious body in many ways.
For instance, if heated at a moderate temperature it gave off
laughing gas (N2O) which was largely employed by the dentist,
and this indeed was the only source of supply. It was doubtful
to-day whether nitrate of ammonia by itself could be completely
detonated, but in association with bodies such as T.N.T., and
others which were not in themselves explosive, it formed the
basis of a large and important class of explosives. Nitrate of
ammonia weight for weight actually produced more gases on
detonation than nitro-glycerine, and this was a very important
point taken by itself. When all was said and done, however,
we did not yet know all we ought to know about this important
body, and there are certain occurrences, for instance the great
explosion of Oppan, which are still unexplained. The only advice
he could give to those who had to do with the handling of explosives
was to treat all, no matter what claims were made for them, as if
they were potentially dangerous. The explosive which one can
monkey with has not yet been discovered and possibly never
will be.
He proceeded next to compare the advantages and disadvantages
of nitrate of ammonia and nitro-glycerine explosives so far as coal
mining was concerned, pointing out that the perfect explosive
had not yet been discovered, and that advantages in one case
were balanced by disadvantages, but this applied to both classes.
Discussing the question of strength, he said this was an extremely
difficult subject, as it depended on three variables, which were
never the same in any explosive, notwithstanding the fact that
laboratory tests might bring them out absolutely identical.
Strength and reliability depend on three factors, viz., the volume
of gas produced, the temperature of that gas (in other words,
the number of calories released), and lastly, the rate at which these
gases were released. This latter is generally called velocity of
detonation, and it is probably the most important factor of all
in the question of strength, because it explains why a low velocity
explosive is more suitable for certain classes of mine work than a
higher velocity explosive.
For instance, black powder, which is in reality a mechanical
mixture of sulphur, charcoal, and salt petre, is a lower velocity
explosive, and would therefore be ideal for coal getting if it had
not some very serious disadvantages, which are well-known to all.
Proceeding, the Lecturer described how missfires are caused
in practice, and gave it as his considered opinion that one of the
most common reasons was, that the detonator was not tied to.
the cartridge by means of a piece of string. The hitching of the
electric wires round the neck of the primer cartridge was a dangerous
encouragement of missfires, and a practice which was to be
strongly deprecated. Most missfires were, in his opinion, caused
by the detonator getting separated from the cartridge through
a slight strain on the cable, or on the electric wires, and the detonator
and explosive were both blamed, when, as a matter of fact, they
were quite innocent. Then again, the so-called practice of inverse
initiation, that is, placing the detonator at the bottom of the hole,
instead of at the top of the primer cartridge, was also dangerous,
inasmuch as the insulation of the electric wires was apt to get
torn, which, in turn, would lead to a short circuit, so that no
current would pass to the electric detonator. Apart from this,
however, the practice was wrong from the mining point of view,
because the detonation was initiated at the point of maximum
resistance, which, of course, gave the explosive no chance at all.
A most interesting discussion ensued, which the Lecturer dealt
with, among which the following may be mentioned :— There
was a danger in tamping nitrate of ammonia explosives too hard,
as there seemed to he an indication that if this were done, it might
become somewhat insensitive to the effects of a detonator. There
was also just a suspicion that if a hole were considerably over-charged,
leaving the burden too light, that the production of
carbon monoxide might actually be increased. Of course, even
under the best circumstances, it was practically impossible to gauge
the actual charge required, because blasting was an art, and not
a science.
With regard to the cushioning effect, he had seen the results
of certain experiments which were carried out in the South Wales
coalfields, but they did not bring conviction to his mind.
Theoretically, there was something to be said for the practice,
but it certainly introduced dangers which were not taken sufficiently
into account. It was a fact that the' cartridge wrapper, which
generally consisted of paper, coated with paraffin wax, or similar
material, did, in reality, form an integral part of the explosive,
and as this was largely composed of carbonaceous matter, it followed
that a proportion of available oxygen was used up in burning
this paper wrapper, consequently, the amount of carbon monoxide
was increased. It Was not permissible to tear off the ends of the
cartridge wrapper, so as to reduce the amount of paper to be burnt,
and even though this were permissible, it would be exceedingly
dangerous, because nearly all explosives contain ingredients which
are soluble in water, and in a wet hole, the explosive would therefore
become useless in a very short time.
A number of questions dealt with "Hang-fire shots," and the
Lecturer gave It as his opinion that quite a number of these shots
might be caused by the detonator getting detached from the cartridge,
and when it was set off, it Ignited coal dust, which, In turn,
would smoulder, and gradually reach the cartridge. Of course,
in the case of electric detonators, it was a fact that if a current,
which was not strong enough, was passed through the detonator,
the physical nature of the priming mixture was altered, and it
might be possible to get a modified form of initiation, which
would be rather like a hang-fire shot. However, many of these
points were still very obscure, and they were very difficult to
imitate in practice.
One of the speakers pointed out that many years ago, in the
Scottish coalfield, they had deliberately employed a practice which
was practically the same as the cushioning practice, because the
explosive then available was found to be much too shattering in
its effect for the coal.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Cullen, William | | | |